We ordered the Alcatraz pizza to go on a Friday night to watch college football and could not be happier with what we got. The employee that took my order on the phone made sure he knew exactly what we wanted with modifications. The pizza was done in about 20 minutes from the time we ordered. The staff was very friendly and met all our needs when we picked up the pizza. And the pizza!!! Let me tell you it was delicious. Cooked perfectly with an even distribution of sauce, cheese, and toppings. We are here in the area for two weeks and are already talking about getting another pizza from Pier 49! read more

We ordered the Tourist jumbo size pizza to go a couple of weeks ago i paid over $40 for a pizza to go that tasted horrible. Hardly any sauce, very little cheese salty and on top of that another shrinkflation product of today" s market. The salt was overpowering and the crust barely cooked. Regardless, we have been coming here for years...not anymore. Pizza now tastes the same everywhere you go. Time to buy my own brick oven and do the cooking myself. read more

Charged full price $55 for 2 pizzas and never was offered the free breadsticks valued at $9. Unfriendly owner. read more

I placed an order through DoorDash... And they've already refunded me for the issue. However, I did want to call and follow up with the store and let them know what happened or at least get their perspective on things since DoorDash is saying that it wasn't their fault that my order was wrong... I ordered a cheese pizza as the base with toppings. What I received was a half cheese plain pizza and then half of my pizza with the toppings I requested. That's not what I paid for. I called and asked to speak to a manager, however, was told there was no one there, except the person who made my order. I tried to explain to him what happened and he became belligerent and would not let me get in word in edgewise. He took it from a minor "hey heads up you got it wrong" to a near shouting match on the phone. I had to point blank Tell him he was talking over me and not listening to what I had to say. I've got my DoorDash order in front of me. I've got the receipt in front of me and I've got a photo of the actual food, Which I'm posting here. If Roberto hadn't been so absolutely rude on the phone there wouldn't be a review tonight. This would've been maybe a two minute call and it would've been over with. I had my money back. However his attitude and having escalated it for no reason because he couldn't emotionally deal with someone calling in to give him a heads up on an issue? I won't be wasting my money there again... read more

See all

My wife and I visited Pier 49 Pizza on February 14 for Valentine's Day. The restaurant was very slow -- just one family finishing up and one other couple who had ordered -- so we expected a smooth and pleasant experience. We ordered the large pizza and breadsticks special for $19.99 and asked the manager how big the salad was to see if one would be enough for both of us. He told us it would only feed one person, so we ordered two. Our bill came out to $40 -- nearly $20 just for salads, which felt excessive. The menu listed the salad as having lettuce, cheese, olives, and mushrooms. We specifically asked for no mushrooms. When the salads arrived, there were no mushrooms -- but there were onions, which were not listed on the menu. We let the server know we didn't want onions, and she politely said she would take care of it. The manager then came over and began arguing with us, insisting we hadn't asked for no onions -- even though onions weren't listed as an ingredient in the first place. The manager was very unprofessional and rude in how he handled the situation. Instead of simply correcting the mistake, he chose to argue with us. He eventually remade the salad, which ended up being large enough to feed two people -- meaning we never needed to order two salads in the first place. When we asked for extra ranch because the small amount provided wasn't enough for both the pizza and salads, the manager said we would be charged for it. Being charged for extra condiments after everything else felt unreasonable. The food itself was fine, but the customer service -- especially from the manager -- was disappointing. Unfortunately, the overall experience left a bad impression on what was supposed to be a nice Valentine's dinner. read more

I ordered a pepperoni pizza and some cheese sticks. The pizza was actually very good. A little small but it was good. The cheese sticks were also good. I would order lunch from here again! read more

Came in from out of town. Ordered pick up. Arrived 30 minutes later to find our order had not even been started. Had to wait another 30 minutes as we were not the only people who called in and then had to wait for their order to be started. The pizza was nothing special. It tasted like what you get at a convenience store. Definitely not worth the price or the wait. read more

We stopped by Pier 49 at about 4pm. There was absolutely no other customers in the restaurant. Some of the tables were still dirty and the booth seats needed some stuffing - it felt like there were giant gaps in stuffing. The food itself was good. They are decently sized pizzas. read more

We ordered pizzas for our office today for a 12:00 delivery. They showed up at 1:13. We had to call to see that was up. A nice little call to say we are running over an hour late or when we called be honest and say we forgot about your order we will get it in right now. The pizza was decent tasting but anyone makes a decent pizza. You gotta set yourself apart. read more

Best customer service experience I've had, pricey but worth the money, got great suggestions and feels right coming back with a picky family. Nicce yummy pizzas read more

Great fast service and the pizza is so good! They literally make it fresh when you order but they are fast! I think we weren't even sitting for 15 min and the food came out! The best sourdough crust. Some of my favorite pizza for sure. The restaurant was clean and comfortable. read more

See all

This was a pleasant surprise and very good tasting pizza. The service was friendly, and the pizza came out quick and was brought to our table. The server which was also the cashier was very attentive and nice. We ordered two pizzas. The sauce tasted great, and this was reasonably priced. read more

See all

Love their pizza!!! it's right by my nail salon Galaxy Nails every time I go get my nails nails done I get a pizza!!!

So insanely over priced for the smallest pizzas.. be prepared to wait an hour for one to actually get your food. Don't waste your money and just get some Little Caesars. They absolutely need to lower the prices. read more

Just Okay. Staff was cordial, but not friendly. Seemed maybe other things were more important. I was a little disappointed by the styrofoam plates and plastic forks. We arrived at 11:30 and zero customers were here. We had our food on our table by 11:45. read more

Pier 49 Pizza - Garlic festival and pineapple and ham. - Italian Near Me - Murray, Utah

I placed an order with Pier 49 Murray via Slice Life (online ordering partner) for about a 7:30 PM pickup, and I requested some alterations to the pizza, namely swapping sauce bases, due to my sensitive system not handling tomato-based sauces well after 6:00 PM. When I got home, I found that the order was not correct, and they used the tomato sauce, despite the system charging me extra for the sauce substitution. I called up the location, and I was given to the manager to talk about the issue. I was told "sorry, but you did not say in the comments 'no tomato sauce', so we don't see things, so it is best to call in an order instead of ordering online." This left me unable to eat with my family, and extremely disappointed in the level of service. Their website reads: Your Satisfaction is Guaranteed! At Pier 49 Pizza, we have only one goal - to help you Fall in Love with Pizza Again! We do it by offering more Specialty Pizzas, more Specialty Sauces, a wider variety of ingredients, and by hiring the best people we can find. We guarantee your experience will be a great one. In fact if you don't absolutely love your meal, or if your experience with Pier 49 is anything less than satisfactory, we promise to make it right, whatever it takes. The staff did nothing to work with me to come up with some way to make this right. I am not satisfied, and if I could leave a "0 star" review, I would. This has given no reason to use this pizza place again. If you are like me and have special dietary needs, if you are going to visit Pier 49 for a take out order, I suggest that you NOT use the online ordering system since this is apparently unable to fulfill order requests and the establishment's staff will NOT honor their guarantee of satisfaction. read more

Nice ambience. Pizza was ok, the crust did not taste like what I would call or think of as San Francisco sourdough pizza. Maybe it's because I'm from the bay and have higher standards for my carbs lol Service was absolutely terrible. I can deal with subpar pizza if the employees were nice. He was just generally upset and seemed inconvenienced by our presences. Asking for ranch was like asking a Mickey Ds employee for another sacred sauce cup or ketchup packet. It is a little pricey but the dinner for 2 was $19 and that's not too bad all things considered. You should try it once and decide for yourself but we probably won't be back with so many other better choices around the area. read more

See all

I'm updating a review that was made last year, we didn't come back since we had a very bad customer service, but today under the circumstances we decided to have dinner there, customer service experience was awesome, the guy who took care of our order also made great recommendations, I was so pleased with the interaction. We did have the special for 4, what is a jumbo pizza , cheesy breadsticks and a cinnamon dessert. For was very good We enjoyed it read more

See all

The food was mediocre and service wasn't the best. We got there and they seemed annoyed even though we got there an hour before close. The ambiance was ok but they started turning off the lights and tvs as we were wearing super awkward! read more

First time, but definitely not the last time we'll order from Pier 49. We ordered the 'Something for Everyone' pizza, and it was great. The crust was soft with a crunchy shell that was just right, done, but not over baked and hard. The toppings were all exactly as described on their website. Best of all was the service! Our pizza was delivered 10 minutes before the stated time, and they included plates and napkins, which was definitely an unexpected plus as we are staying in a hotel for the night. This will be our go to pizza when we're in town! read more

I would never eat and/or never will eat from this place. I'm appalled that a place like this exists. There was one table sat In the entire building, and still, my order wasn't edible. read more

We order from Pier 49 often for takeout and it's always hot, delicious, and on time. This is our fave place for takeout pizza.

Just in town visiting and thought I would try this pizza place since it was close to my hotel. I ordered the Nob Hill Pizza and a order of Cheese Bread. Both came out really tasty! Customer service was fine, no complaints there. The gentleman behind the counter was very helpful and nice. The environment in the restaurant seems a little dated, but I think it adds to the effect of it feeling like a mom n pop type restaurant. Would recommend anyone to try this place! read more

Pizza was absolutely amazing good! Ranch was good. Bread sticks were meh! I would definitely come back for pizza !

Vibrance is nice but nothing special. I tried 2 personal pizzas & it tasted good but kinda expensive for the size. Service was alright. When I dropped by here, they had some kind of board game idk what it really was but overall, it's not bad. Pizza is good. read more

Pier 49 Pizza - Italian Near Me - Murray, Utah

Slow slow slow slow slow....did I say it was slow? I understand that it's hard to get help these days but that does not excuse the LACK OF CUSTOMER SERVICE. Over priced. Do not recommend. read more

The gluten free pizza was decent. The service was lacking and it took forever for our food to come out. It seemed like a bunch of high school kids working here that don't know what customer service is. The kid that brought out our food didn't say a single word, just put the pizza down and walked away. There wasn't any music playing and it just seemed dead in there. Definitely won't be coming back. read more

Had previously been a big fan of Pier 49 for both the pizza and the service. Now, however, the service is so bad that we won't be back. They screwed up our order--didn't even start it despite confirming that it was ready--and then refused to do anything to help solve the problem. And the staff was rude, condescending, and snobby the whole time. Disappointed that they've gone so down hill in the last year and a half. read more

Really good pizza, breadsticks where good as well. Service was very friendly staff and prompt. Also, pizza was ready quickly.

Not bad pizza, but definitely not good. Did not taste at all like sourdough I have had in the past. No flavor at all, I almost never use salt and I had to use a lot (they didn't give us Parmesan cheese). Threw away the leftovers, which was a first. read more

We went for dinner tonight we were concerned because it was 6 in the evening and this place was empty. We ordered a medium Nob Hill pizza. They make them on a sourdough crust. It was pretty good on a scale of 1-10 maybe a 7. Somewhat pricy($16.99) in my opinion. I would recommend trying at least once, but I doubt we'll be back. We're just visiting the area. read more

Pier 49 Pizza - Menu - Italian Near Me - Murray, Utah

See all

Ordered a Bay bridge pizza which is a veggie pizza with no cheese and it came covered in cheese. Food tastes good but when you can't get a simple order right, there's no excuse. read more

Yummy pizza! The booth seats were a little soft and you sank down a little but after a few minutes it was comfortable enough and bonus points for serving Pepsi products read more

Pier 49 Pizza - Alcatraz pizza - Italian Near Me - Murray, Utah

See all

Shitty service, one day they deliver, the very next they don't.. only the Slice app will deliver this and even that is spotty with this place.. Either deliver or don't, you make good pizza, let us have it.. read more

Service was awful. We ordered our food for dine in and we're the only customers in there sat down and waited for our food. The girl working and who took our order just sat behind the counter on her phone. After a while another couple came in and ordered food and sat down within 10 minutes they were brought their food. So after about 40 minutes we ask the girl who took our order what the status was on our food and she asked what we ordered, after telling her she turns around and grabs our food that was boxed up sitting for who knows how long, then ask for ranch and she throws it across the counter. No apology or anything. It's unfortunate because the food is good(when it's not sitting in a box for no reason) but the customer service is severely lacking. read more

Great service, especially in the snow and busy weekend events in the area! P.S. the pizza was great!!!

I love this place! I've been coming here for awhile now everyone is always super friendly! It's a very clean and relaxed place to eat. They make sure to get your food out asap which is great, plus you can see it's fresh out of the oven. I recently found out I can no longer eat gluten and my heart broke thinking I could no longer enjoy my favorite pizza place! I JUST FOUND OUT THEY HAVE A GLUTEN FREE MENU! You better believe I went the next day! read more

Pier 49 Pizza - Delicious gluten free tourist. My favorite! - Italian Near Me - Murray, Utah

We bought the 49er and the embarcadero pizzas. They were pretty good. The restaurant had a fun decor but felt dead. Not much life to this place'. Worth trying out though. I should have added some tomato to my pizza. read more

Pier 49 Pizza - The 49er pizza - Italian Near Me - Murray, Utah

See all

I have been here a few times now. Its close to home & convenient. I call ahead for pick-up & its no muss no fuss. I absolutely am addicted to the "garlic festival" pizza and I have them add shrimp! Sooooo yummy!!! One star deduction for the employees. They clearly would rather be anywhere else than there. Customer service & a smile are lacking but its a pizza joint, I go for the tasty pizza not the entertainment! read more

Great pizza, great service, very clean place I recommend 100%, I love it the Alcatraz is my favorite, pesto and chicken too, the Spanish Alfredo, they all taste great, love it. read more