Reservations are a must as this place is tiny. 10-11 seats at the bar, two booths that can seat 4-6 and four 2-tops. We went with a group of 10, so they pushed all the 2-tops together for us which was cozy but fine. The ingredients are fresh, the crust is thin, and the pizza is baked in a gas-fired oven which makes for a great tasting pie. But again, size is the issue as the last two of the five pizzas our group ordered came out about 10 minutes after the first three. Fortunately the extensive beer selection made the wait tolerable. Will I go back...absolutely, just not with a big group. Food: 5. Ambiance: 5 Beer selection: 5 Capacity: 3 read more

This is a great pizza place. We found it while driving around lost.the staff is friendly, the food amazingly fresh, and so.... It's homey....heart warming. We intend to go again. My daughter gave it four thumbs up (she uses her big toes) you can't get a better score from her. I highly recommend the Caesar salad and the holy trinity pizza. read more

Loved the pizza and had great service. Our server was cute too, so that was a plus. Highly recommend the pizza! Great atmosphere - check it out. read more

This place will shock you! Not much of a restaurant, but the pizza is to die for. I will be back (a lot).

Perfectly decent pizza. Nothing to write home about, but a respectable thin crust pizza. A warning: if you order takeout and they say it'll be 30 minutes, that could mean anything. I showed up in 25 minutes, and my pizza was already cold. read more

Hands down one of the best pizza I've ever had (I travel a lot, stateside and foreign). Absolutely love the staff. They always greet me with a smile and I've always received great service. I went there 3 times in 2 days for pizza, their spinach salad for both! I'll definitely check them out the next time I'm on St. Thomas. read more

My go to pizza place on STT. My kids love the spaghetti. Great staff and ambiance. If you looking for the best pie in Charlotte Amalie.

This place is sooo good!! The pizza is amazing. All homemade, and the people there are so nice and welcoming. I highly recommend this place!!! read more

The pizza here is amazing. My children ages 10-14 all loved every bite as did my wife and I. Definitely worth a visit.

Great place! Everyone is wonderful here the place is great for its hail casesr salad and its pizza. The wine is also great too. Bartender Eduardo and his staff make this whole experience great as well. He really knows how to make a good llng island ice tea. Went here the whole time we were down in st thomas read more

Pizza is the best we found in the USVI. Extensive beer and wine list. The staff were very friendly.

Probably the worst pizza I've ever had. We were starving. It was over an hour to have it delivered. It was late. Two pizzas cost $75. That's right $75!!!!!! It was burnt and cold. I feel really ripped off! read more

Pizza was great! Staff was friendly. I would recommend stopping if your looking for Pizza. Hurricane pizza was favorite I tried.

Pie whole is the best pizza on island. The beer selection is amazing and the apps are better than the sound. The spinach artichoke pizza app is so good. It's a must have on St Thomas. read more

Such an amazing place to eat! The artichoke dip is a meal in and of itself, and is wildly delicious. The pizza is amazing. One of the only places on the island where I could find an array of good beers to chose from. The interior is dark and small. The cook is known to wear Pizza socks from time to time, so be on the lookout. 8) read more

Probably my favorite spot for pizza on the island! Go hungry and you won't be disappointed! The brick oven pizza is thin and done well! You can sit inside or outside and I've only had great service there! Make sure to make a reservation during season bc this place has a reputation for being great! Enjoy! Mangia! read more

There's island time and there's island time. We waited 15 minutes for the menu. Then we ordered 2 pizzas. One was delivered in reasonable time. The server said the other pizza was "overlooked" but wouldn't take long to make. So now the two people with the first pizza are finished before the server returns. She says: I'm sorry to inform you that your pizza fell apart in the oven. Huh? How is that even possible? Attempt #3: pizza finally comes 75 minutes after we order and it's wrong. We ordered a plain pizza (not too complicated) and got one with pepperoni. One of our party is vegetarian so that doesn't work. Then they bring it back and offer it to us for the price of the plain--in other words, if we eat the pepperoni we don't want, we won't have to pay for the pepperoni! We would still have to pay for the pizza however. Attempt #4? Pizza was as ordered except it was dramatically undercooked, making almost chewy. Oh, and my water was never filled. At least the server was apologetic and very nice. The first pizza was correct and delicious, to be fair. But not good enough to warrant the abominable service. Total time at pizza place: 1:45. read more

make sure you make a reservation!! gets crowded real quick! probably the best beer selection on the island- people working there know their beer- feel free to ask for suggestion.. read more

Called in and placed a to go order. We walked in 15 minutes later and the pizza guy was on the phone for another 15 minutes before he fired up the oven and complained that he had to go and go to "fucking" work. He was given a dirty look by the manager and went to work on our pizzas. The pesto chicken pizza which was very dried and burnt and had no taste whatsoever. I would think that someone would taste for seasonings because it was absolutely bland. The other pizza the fungy peppy was good but also burnt on the bottom. We ordered a ceasars salad it was ok. We also ordered a cheese cake which was good and a brownie that was also good. So $65.00 later i was highly disappointed as was the rest of the people that ate it. According to the manager the bosses were in Arizona hopefully this was a fluke and someone is checking the food going out. So we threw away the pizzas and shared the salad and the desserts. Seriously smh because all of the yelpers out there love this place????? Never going back and i would highly not reccomend this pizza place. read more

The Pie Whole was recommended to my husband and I by the crew of the Verna Breeze, our sailboat charter stationed out of St. Thomas. After a week on a boat that served its own five star meals, we were encouraged to indulge our fancy at this little hole in the wall. Although the place is tiny in space (plenty of bar stools... but make a reservation OR get their early for a table), the flavors of the food and the selection of beer and liquor are huge. The pizza, baked in a traditional brick oven, was DELICIOUS and the Chip(otle) pasta was DIVINE. Unfortunately, in our daze of delight we forgot to order the mussels, which we were told by the crew are DELECTABLE. We were utterly amazed with our visit to the place... the food, ambiance, selection and staff amazed. Not to mention... the bathroom in the place is beautiful. read more

I love the $14 in 14 minutes lunch special. The pizza here is pretty good especially if you want a change of pace from the fast food fare. Where this place really shines though is their extensive collection of beer. I'm not talking Budweiser and Coors either (well they got those too), but imported beer from Belgium, England, Germany and even Scotland. They're also constantly adding new beer to their list. It's a very unique restaurant. read more

Tiny little place in French town with great pizza. Perfect for a late lunch. Also, they serve Coke. So tired of Pepsi.

One of our best meals on the island. Shared crab cakes, spinach salad and small pizza. Also had apple strudel and ice cream for dessert. Service was great. Just could have spaced bringing out the food better. We got everything pretty much at the same time. read more

We were staying on St. Thomas for vacation and craving pizza one night. We found this small restaurant on yelp. What we expected to be a your basic pizza joint was much much more. Our experience started with an extensive beer list. Next we enjoyed some out of this world mushroom and duck confit risotto and pesto breadsticks as an appetizer. For dinner we shared one of their thin crust, wood oven pizzas. We finished the meal with bailys cheesecake. Everything here is made fresh and delicious. Our server, Rebecca was very friendly and provided great service! I highly recommend this place!!! read more

Pie Whole has well presented, flavoursome food and wine at value for money prices. We normally avoid carbs and ordered plenty of salads, but also had to try the artichoke dip with jalapeño and were glad we did. We were also more than happy with the twisted Caesar with Spanish whitebait, in fact everything was delicious and the service was prompt and efficient. A pleasant experience we recommend.... read more

Recently spent a week in St. Thomas and had dinner here 3 times. This place is cozy, comfortable, with great service and even better food and drinks. Good Italian food and brick oven pizza along with a beer menu that can't be matched anywhere in the Virgin Islands if not the rest of the Caribbean. read more

I was recommended this place by a friend because of my big love of great beers, primarily belgian style ales and tripels. I was in St. Thomas for business and needed a place to grab dinner, and thought I would give it a shot. The place is small and intimate, and very busy, though I didn't wait hardly anything. Once I was in, I was served and taken care of extremely well and had a great time! The beer selection there is incredible. They had a huge selection of all types of beers, but my favorite belgian ales and even several I hadn't had before were on the menu. I had their special pizza of the night and a caprese salad which was also very delicious. Overall, if you are in St. Thomas and need a place to eat, and love beer and pizza, this is absolutely a place to go! read more

This place was sooooo good. Just thinking about that pizza makes my mouth water. That cheese pizza may have been the best cheese pizza i have ever had. I know it sounds plain, but it was anything but. SOO good! Prices definitely fair and a great beer list. Do yourself a favor and come here if you're in St. Thomas! read more

Best pizza I've ever had. Stromboli was also awesome. Rum punches are also super strong. Waiter was super cool.

Italiano salad was amazing! Great selection of beer. Pizza was delicious.

Loved it! This will be on our list every time we visit. The pizza is traditional Italian. Pastas and Stromboli were yummy. Large portions. Great wine. Can't go wrong! Make reservations if going at high traffic times. Loved the atmosphere and while we sat at a table the bar was full. It would be a great drop in spot if alone or as a couple. Enjoy! read more

Visited this restaurant after 4 months the last experience was a horrible one... looks like they have had a change in ownership and looks like it is moving back to good service and great food... my 2nd favorite pizza place on the island... actually the good tastes better than before my fav spinach dip was amazing better than before... read more

This pizza has to be the most amazing pizza I have ever had. I live in California and there is nothing but pizza places there, honestly it has to be the most incredible thing I've ever eaten. The Cesar dressing was incredible I have never had anything like that either. We had the chicken pesto and the meat lovers pizza and they both were outstanding. I highly recommend everyone to come here. read more

Oh, Yes! Awesome eats while in the Virgin Islands. I loved the "Chip". Well, everything my friends ordered was great. Eduardo was great to chit chat with while we waited for our food. Great place! read more

For those traveling to St Thomas don't miss this gem in the Caribbean. Very small place, so call ahead or come early to get a seat. My family of six came in at 11:15AM and we had to sit at the bar. No big deal, as the service was good and the pizza very good. The lunch menu features a combo of salad and personal pizza for $15. Seeing that I have not found anything cheap here on the island it was a deal. Check it out! read more

On our recent trip to the islands, we made a point to get a reservation for the Pie Whole, as we missed out on dining here before, due to a lack of space. It's a small place. And it smells like heaven. The aroma of pizza crust and garlic make your mouth water when you walk in. On recommendations from Yelp! our table ordered the spinach artichoke dip. The awesome thing about this is, it's on a pizza crust so you don't have the issue of dip-to-bread ratio that happens when you just have toast points to spread the dip on. It's perfect, and cheesy and delicious. I had the "Chip" pasta which is a great combination of flavors and textures. Get it. It's great! Several in our group ordered pizza and loved every bit of it. The beer selection is probably unmatched on St. Thomas. If someone has a better beer list on this island, I want to know where it is! Go to the Pie Whole. You will not regret it!! read more

Seriously the freshest food we had on the island! The salads are to die for and the pizza and atmosphere make you feel as if you're in NYC.

Once again I was slightly disappointed with the food on the island. I thought since I couldn't enjoy local island food, surely you can't mess up pizza, right? Well, it wasn't a complete disaster, but I had high hopes based on previous reviews. They were out of sausage. Good thing I'm cool with veggies. The crust did not have any flavor, and it was just a pizza. I've had better frozen pizza. I feel so bad writing this review because the people were very friendly so I gave them an extra star. Definitely not my worst food experience on the island, however. read more

Pie Whole - Veggie pizza - Pizza Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

We had a craving for pizza after being on our boat for a month and a half so when we got back to Charlotte Amalie we stopped into Pie Whole in Frenchtown. What a quaint little place with awesome service, knowledgable staff and great pies! One of the specials for the night was spinach artichoke dip with four cheeses and jalapeño's. We ordered this for our starter and I can honestly say that this was one of the most delectable things we have had in a long time. The creaminess, on a thin crispy crust and the bight of the fresh jalapeño all meshed perfectly together. We then had the Chi-town pizza for our main course. They also have an amazing beer selection to include a wide variety of Belgium and German beers. If your not sure what would suit your palate, just ask your server, they can tell you anything about the beer that you want to know! Also a great wine list! This gets 5 stars for service, food and ambiance! We will be back! read more

Pizza was pretty good but the calzone was too cheesy for me. I heard the pasta dishes are really good but I can not confirm or deny that. Great place for Italian food on Saint Thomas. read more