Very good brick oven 'za. If you like a crunchy crust, it's advisable to specify your pie to be made extra crispy. Service is warm & friendly. We ate here twice in one week. More reasonably priced than other restaurants on the island- just $19 for a large pizza. read more

The pizza here is definitely not to Hip on the pasta. Great atmosphere and love the outside dining. Service was fantastic and friendly. This is a come back too place! Yelp directions are wrong they are right next to Bella Blu. read more

Pie Whole - Pizza Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

Great pizza, friendly staff. Always a go to place when we are on the island. Love that they have expanded which provides both more indoor and outdoor seating. read more

Good spot, yummy pizza. Nice servers and staff, they have a renovation going on excited to see it all finished

I'm sorry for the 3 stars guys. The meathead just isn't what it used to be. It changed and I'm bummed. The beer was cold and the service was awesome. Place is usually rather full so thats good. The caprese salad and the spinach dip are awesome. The pizza is almost universally excellent. Part of the reason I lowered my review to 3 stars is because yelp rewards people with elite badges you give bad reviews. I have to meet my quota. It's not easy because I know it's bad for business. The bottom line is people should know that yelp isn't as democratic as it seems. Low posting and too many 4 and 5 star reviews pushes your rank down and they don't have as much "weight" so I'm sorry you got the 3 star. Business looks good so you aren't getting hurt. I wish you all the best. read more

The have the best pizza around. We came here four times while we were on vacation.Very clean and always busy which is a good thing you know the pizza is awesome. read more

Pie Whole: make sure to update your phone number on your site! We tried to order 12 pizzas for our wedding party but could not get in touch. Having recently opened again under new management, Pie Whole is still trying to figure out where they stand. Most of their beer collection was unavailable, but we stuck to our old favorite: Bud Light. Kind of amazing with pizza! The cesar salad is served with two slices of tasty flatbread. Unfortunately, the salad has a bit too much dressing for my liking. The pizza, however, is delicious. Somewhere between thin crust and bar style, the pepperoni is delifghtfully greasy and has a solid crust to sauce to cheese ratio. Cheers to that! read more

We just got home from an amazing vacation in St. Thomas and we stile have the amazing taste of the Pie Hole pizza in out mouths!!! This was the first place our friends took us to for dinner and I insisted to go back one more time before we leave! The food is AMAZING the bartenders are super nice and helpful and they have a varied selection of beer . They stay open later than most of the restaurants there and they are also open for lunch in the middle of the week so don't miss out on this one if you get to be in St. Thomas read more

This place is awesome...probably my favorite on St. Thomas anyway. Where else can one get pizza, homemade pasta and a great selection of Belgian beer. Went in with my girl the first night not knowing anyone and was treated good. Went in the next night with our local friends and the free samples were flowing. They even busted out the private stash which wasn't currently on the list. If ever in Frenchtown I highly recommend stopping here. Really cozy environment with friendly staff and I'll say it again...BELGIAN BEER! read more

Good fresh food and fast service at reasonable price when not busy.More like local pizza place with one of the fresh New York style pizza I ever had. read more

See all

Dang, this place is GOOD. The only edible and enjoyable meal we had in VI was at Pie Whole. We walked in early and grabbed a seat at the bar. Reservations are highly recommended. Small place. Maybe 4 tables and 8 seats at the bar. They have an extensive beer list and amazing menu. We had the spinach and artichoke dip that shocked my pants right off. Not your traditional chips and dip, but almost like a pizza with spinach and artichoke dip. AMAZING. Pizza was also fantastic. They use a wood oven (without the wood) to get a similar taste to a real wood burning oven. The small size came out to about 13 inches which was more than enough to share. Crust is thin and crunchy. Service was great and the bartender was knowledgeable on the beers. They offered to call a cab for us which we thought was so nice. We were going to ask but they offered first. That's what I call great service. Highly recommend. MUST make a reservation. read more

I was completely shocked to find such a great place on the island. This place not only has great food but also an amazing selection of beers. In fact, the pesto and garlic breadsticks and other appetizers we had including the spinach and artichoke dip would have been enough to get us through the night. I really enjoyed my time here with my friends and I will definitely go back. If you are around Frenchtown then do yourself a favor and at least drop in for a beer and some apps! read more

A no nonsense pizza place. Thin crust pies. Made to order. Ingredients are quality. Reasonable prices.

Great pizza and pasta. Very friendly server who kindly called a cab for us when we asked for the best spot to catch one.

Have you ever been to a little hole in the wall pub in Chicago that has the BEST pizza you have ever had in your life, but the place only seats 20 people, so you have to get in there early or make a reservation? That's THIS place! Get there! NOW! We ran into a guy in the grocery store who had just moved back to the Chicago area before we left and he recommended a few places for us to go to... This was one of them and we want to go back every week, like forever! . We got seated faster than we originally expected because a few people were leaving the bar (yay)! They had 3 different kinds of cider, so I was pretty excited! We sat next to the perfect people because we ordered everything they had... Not because we're stalkers, I swear! The boy doesn't eat salad unless it's a really good ceasar. This couple just finished a good looking one, so we looked it up. It was the Twisted Ceasar Salad with Balsamic and Flat Bread with Roasted Garlic and Crispy Panchetta... Yea, you try NOT to order THAT! It was amazing! When it came out, I swear, the two of us fought to inhale it! The balsamic added the perfect touch to their homemade dressing. The panchetta added just the right amount of saltiness. And the flat bread that was baked in their brick over was to die for! We saved half of it for leftovers! The roasted garlic was sweet and nutty. So then that couple's pizza came out... It smelled all meaty and smokey. When we asked what it was they said it was the special and the couple next to them had ordered it (lol)! We ask our bartender and she said it was the Desperado (and has had various other names) with homemade thinly cut crispy pork belly (brined for 3 weeks), sweet Italian sausage, Spanish chorizo and San Marzano tomato sauce. Yes, we ordered it... It was sweet from the tomatoes & sausage and salty & smokey from the chorizo & pork belly. It was heaven in our mouths! We had 3 pieces left over to take back with the flat bread! Lunch the next day was fabulous! While we were waiting for our salad we saw a guy in the back making handmade pasta... He was wearing (kid you not!) black & white striped pants, hoop earrings, and had a long grey bear... He was a pirate, no joke! We asked our bartender and she said oh that's the owner, Crazy Earl. HA! He came out to talk to us as the boy is a former chef and was interested in the homemade pork belly. Crazy Earl is awesome! The atmosphere in this place is great! The service was awesome! I would recommend that you come visit the island just to eat here! No, seriously! read more

My husband and I go to pie whole every time we visit St.Thomas. The food is consistently great and the staff is very friendly. My husband was a big fan of the beer from the brewery upstairs. The caprese salad was a great starter and the pizza was incredible! We will definitely be coming back! read more

Love this place! They make you feel right at home. It's a little "hole" in the wall but that's what makes it so perfect. I will say I can imagine if it was crowded that you might need a sweatband. The service was quick and friendly and the food was delicious. We had the caprese salad, spinach dip and the cheese lovers with pepperoni and red sauce and I would highly recommend both(total for 2 people $49). The red sauce is so flavorful and I haven't had a sauce like that since I was in Italy. Another good thing is that the pizza is not greasy at all. If you're coming from a hotel and don't know how to get back, the bartender will call you a cab to be there in about 5 mins-super helpful. The next time I'm in St. Thomas I will be sure to stop in for a meal. read more

Pie Whole - Spinach dip and caprese salad - Pizza Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

Excellent food! We had eggplant parmesan and pizza and Calamari. The sauce was excellent and I am picky about my sauce. Everyone in our party of 7 raved about their pizzas. They had a wide variety to choose from. The bar has the biggest selection of beer, even having a home town favorite! Nick was our waiter and he was great to chat with (yay Newark!) And just pleasant to deal with! We made reservations but i don't think they are needed. The parking is iffy but not that hard to find. We will definitely go again before we return home. read more

We had an amazing evening at Pie Whole in Frenchtown! Donatello was a terrific bartender. The drinks were on point and the food was exceptional. This was our favorite evening on St. Thomas. We highly recommend Pie Whole. read more

Pie Whole - Pizza Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

I don't write a lot of reviews but this place deserves a great one. The pizza is legit from scratch and baked in a brick oven -- really good pizza. The salads were awesome. And the service was great. Highly recommend supporting a business like this. read more

Pizza was just okay, IMHO. Service friendly and fine. That said, it's super pricey. $25+ for a 14 inch pie? I'm from NYC and this is as expensive, if not more so than any place near me. Can't recommend for that reason. read more

Liz, Bentley, Tyler and the chef were phenomenal to say the least! Fantastic atmosphere and amazing food. Seriously stop in and check it out, you won't be disappointed. Bring them your fresh catch and the chef will prepare it in an out of this world fashion. read more

A really awesome beer menu, unfortunately about 75% of the beers on the menu are out. (Really, no joke, only about 25% of the menu beers are available). Still was able to easily find a couple great Belgian beers to go with my pizza. The Caesar salad and pizza was also pretty excellent. I would totally recommend The Pie Whole, but just know, when you get the impressive beer menu. The beers with the dots next to them are not really available, and you'll find those dots next to most of the beers. read more

Ridiculous, 1 hour wait, and then entrees came out piecemeal. Don't waste your time. read more

The Pie Whole is a must-visit place if you are spending any time in St. Thomas. Well known by the locals, they feature unique hand made wood-fired pizzas and a fantastic beer selection in a pub-type atmosphere. We had the mussels appetizer which was excellent! I highly recommend making reservations in advance. At 8:30 PM in a Thursday night, there was not an empty seat in the house. read more

We had the Chitown and Spanish Town pizzas. Both were very good. However, the highlights of the dinner were the appetizers. Both the artichoke dip and the sea scallop apps were GREAT. The beer list is extensive as well. One of the better lists I've seen. read more

This place is awesome! I ordered The chip pasta its creamy, soft, delicious, and savory. The beers are from amazing selection as well. The brewery is upstairs so you can imagine the rest. I defiantly recommend this place as a tourist. You can just take the safari from downtown and try their famous pizza. The staff very friendly and music is hype. Full bar and cool inside. read more

Excellent pizza and the service was great. Spirited waitress added to the atmosphere. Very accommodative to food needs too. Will be back!

Pie Whole is located in the Frenchtown section of Charlotte Amalie on St. Thomas. We recently stopped at this cozy pizzeria for lunch and tried the $14 pizza/salad combo. Both salad's (ceasar and house) were quite good. Everything we ate was made on site, including the personal pizzas. The regular crust was very tasty, but the whole wheat was lacking something. Perhaps some sesame would add to it's flavor. If I was to return to St. Thomas, I'd revisit this establishment. read more

Pie Whole - Pizza Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

We stumbled across this small pizza restaurant while walking through Frenchtown and figured we'd give it a try, and we are so glad we did. The staff was very friendly, they treated us like neighbors. The pizza was amazing. Probably one of the best pizzas I've ever had. We did a create your own style pizza. Definitely eat here! read more

Our pizza was sooo good!! The day we went (I've only been once) it took a long time to get our food, even by island standards, but it was worth it. We will definitely be back for more delicious pizza! read more

Amazing brick oven thin crust pizza. This place is super tiny and sometimes there is no seating, but totally worth the wait. Try the spinach dip appetizer that is served on their pizza dough....you will be thinking about it forever after eating it! read more

One star for the pizza. We paid $18 for their horrible olive pasta. Basically they boiled the spaghetti, and mixed with olive oil and pepper. No flavor at all. And they charged $2 for each shrimp. Not even mention the spaghetti was hard chewing. Anyway, if you like basic pizza, you could go. read more

This has to be the best pizza on the island. Great lunch special: personal pizza and a salad for $15. The salad was amazing with chicken and balsamic drizzle. Very impressive. Gonna eat lunch here more often. read more

Pie Whole - Pepperoni personal pizza. More than enough for lunch. - Pizza Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

Keep in mind, this is a review on the restaurants merits with it's beer list in mind. Probably the best food I've had at a location with some of my favorite beer. The pizza is a little on the pricey side, but at least tasty. read more

Pie Whole - Pizza Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

Loved it ! So glad our waitress frm the Marriott recommended this place. Very small inside so make a reservation if you can. Or you might get stuck eating at the bar. Spinach artichoke: not the typical dip. So glad we were told to order it. Beer: oodles to choose from. Menu describes each. read more

This place will shock you! Not much of a restaurant, but the pizza is to die for. I will be back (a lot).

Perfectly decent pizza. Nothing to write home about, but a respectable thin crust pizza. A warning: if you order takeout and they say it'll be 30 minutes, that could mean anything. I showed up in 25 minutes, and my pizza was already cold. read more

Hands down one of the best pizza I've ever had (I travel a lot, stateside and foreign). Absolutely love the staff. They always greet me with a smile and I've always received great service. I went there 3 times in 2 days for pizza, their spinach salad for both! I'll definitely check them out the next time I'm on St. Thomas. read more

Food is very good but service was mediocre, they seem OK with couples but with out group of six they were "sorry" all the time for the wait. read more

Pie Whole - Pizza Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands