The quality of the pizza here is amazing, considering how far away from the Tri-state area the US VI are. It is thin crust and tasty. I would say the pizza is a little undercooked, and a little small, and the beer selection that everyone raves about it is very pricy ($8 for a half-pint when beer is 3 bucks elsewhere in the Caribbean), but considering the lack of high-quality other options in St. Thomas, I'd be happy to go back. read more

Really average wood fired pizza. Earns an extra star because the restaurant options on St. Thomas are truly dreadful. Tried two pies, the white pizza was the better of the two, the sausage mushroom was not appealing, sauce and sausage were to spicy. Both pies were in the oven a little too long. Decor/bar are fun, but this place would not survive on the mainland. read more

Great pizzas and great service! The artichoke appetizer and the ...I believe it was called the Crazy Earl was delicious. Very filling and great prices. The place is very small so make sure you call ahead or be prepared to wait to have a seat! read more

Small and quaint establishment but the food and ambience is fantastic. Fun place! We had the big meat pasta which I would highly suggest! The brownie dessert is good too! read more

Excellent thin crust pizza and large salads. Average prices for the island. The service was excellent. There is limited seating and you need a reservation for a booth so we sat at the bar. read more

Always delicious... It was especially great tonight. Consistently good good food. Thank you!

This is a great place. Friendly staff, great prices, great brick oven pizza. Definitely worth going if you are in French Town and need a quick bite. read more

Stopped a couple nights ago because the kids wanted pizza. So glad we did. The waiter was fantastic and the pizza was great. We had the meat livers and the crust was perfectly crisp, just like a brick oven pizza should be and the topping were high quality and plenty of them. We sat outside where it was warm and the waiter even brought me an extra beer on the house because it was hot and the had just taken a huge order right in front of use which made use wait a few extra minutes on our pizzas. We even went back for carry out 2 nights later. read more

Excellent pizza, pasta and salads. Small, very personal crowd. Often a wait, but worth it.

Best Pizza on island, that might mean you have to wait and drink a beer because everyone loves this place:) I've only been here 2 times and I can't wait to go back! read more

I am from Northern NJ and I am a pizza snob. Sadly the pizza here did not add up to the expectations. It is very thin crust, small for what I am used to, and small amount of toppings. They may have a wood fired oven, but does that mean you get "blackened" pizza like what we got? The interior is small with limited seating, dark with no view. If you like Belgian beer, they had a nice selection. If you like California Pizza Kitchen, you will like their pizza, sorry I don't. read more

Top notch beer selection and good pizza. Comfortable atmosphere, would recommend to anyone.

I took the advice of others and skipped the dominos delivery and opted to drive to pick up my take out pizza. $35 got me a dried out pizza (think burnt cheese on crackers) and 3 beers to go. The 3 beers are what gave them 2 stars. I defiantly will not be getting take out from them again. I would consider eating in. read more

Soooo good!!! Mussels, AMAZING! Pizza with house made sausage, EXCEPTIONAL! House made pasta with arugula, GREAT! Service, WONDERFUL! Lots of beers to choose from. I will not forget Pie Whole. You must experience it. read more

We had the Hurricane Earl pizza which was great. Huge beer selection, including Frenchtown Brewery. Ask for the homemade pepper oil for dipping the crust and the salted caramel cheesecake for dessert. Very friendly staff. read more

The service, food and drinks are awesome here. Try the spinach and artichoke dip, unique and very tasty. Brandon and Rusty are great hosts and bartenders. We went there twice in two days. Had the pizza and the pasta. Both are wonderful. read more

So being from Chicago I'm a little bias to pizza but this is by far one of the best restaurants on the island. More than reasonable prices. Awesome staff. Cool atmosphere. HIGHLY RECOMMEND. read more

I apologize for not having all the information, but I still wanted to review this great pizza stop. We were introduced to the Pie Whole and Brian the owner (or one of) by some new friends / locals last month during our annual trip to the island. This is a GREAT stop for some wonderful thin crust, slice of heaven. Almost as good as New Haven, CT Apizza! Brian has done a wonderful job and this small, but quaint restaurant with it's hand made brick oven, has become one of favorite eateries in all of St. Thomas! read more

Amazing pizza! Any pie with the homemade sausage will knock your socks off! The Belgian beer offering is outstanding !!!!! Staff will make you feel like you are at home. :) read more

Awesome pizza! We both agreed it was the best we've ever had. Went here 2x because we wanted to try the homemade pasta.. It was amazing! The place is super small so make reservations!! The wait is over an hr for walk ins! They also have a huge beer selection and the staff is super friendly! Def go!!! read more

Awesome place! Best selection of quality beers I seen on island. App was great followed by high quality artisan style pizza. Service was superb. Def be back:-) read more

Absolutely the best home made spinach and artichoke appetizer. Pizza was amazingly good. Eva, our hostess/waitress added so much to this visit. She loves the place and it shows. Great recommendations and personality. Make reservations as this small place fills up quick. read more

The pizza was the best I've ever had. Reservations are a must. The bartender and staff treated is like family. Great place.

We stopped here for lunch, very small but luckily not crowded at the time. The salads we ordered were good, but the pizzas we had were amazing. read more

Solid! Great pie, cool twist on a ceasar salad and a great beer selection. Quaint, affordable, tasty.

My family has been coming to St Thomas for years now (9+, visiting most years but not every) and know a lot about local restaurants and different places to explore. We came across Pie Whole a few years ago and were excited at the idea of good quality pizza on the island. In the past it's been a great but this experience has given credit to people talking about a decline in food and service over the last year or so. After traveling in yesterday afternoon we called for a takeout order at 730pm. While placing the order we found out that almost each one of our pizzas had to be modified because they didn't have all the ingredients. A pizza shop not having Italian sausage, their beer braised chicken, ham and others was pretty disappointing for a Saturday night. Waitress taking the order told us it'd take 45 min for the pickup - which on the island that's OK so we planned accordingly. We showed up 50 min after placing the order only to have the waitress say that it'd be another 30 minutes. They offered us a draft while we waited which was a local Saison. Beer was OK but they definitely have sub-par draft lines as the beer came out warm. Inside of the joint matched as well as I was building a sweat sitting at the bar. Food came out 1:25hr after the original call with no comp or discount of any kind on the order. Only thing keeping this from 1 star is the food which was fairly good (not as good as it has been before) but it'll be a while before we go back, assuming we ever do. Encourage them to focus on their service if they want recurring visitors to recommend them to other groups at the resorts. read more

This is the 2nd worst pizza I have ever eaten in my 50+ years. It is our first night in St. Thomas and due to the high stars we ordered pizza. I ordered a pepperoni pizza and a cheese lovers red. The cheese may have had some Parmesan sprinkled over it but there was no other cheese and no mozzarella and very little sauce with a burnt very thin crust. The pepperoni had a little more taste but not much. How on earth do people like this awful and tasteless expensive pizza? Eating Little Cesar's pizza in the states is like gourmet compared to this tasteless and topping less cardboard. read more

Love their Artichoke dip but the location is kind of small. If you're with a large group, order take out! A must go!!!

Went for the gluten free pizza which wasn't available at the time. Was told they are changing the ingredients and it is best to call 24 hours in advance so they can prepare it properly. Don't think that will be happening since I am not "celiac"but I do have some reactions to wheat. I couldn't imagine ordering it a day before hand unless it was for a party or something. Pizza was ok crust was a bit chewy or rubbery I guess you could say. Makes me wonder how the gluten free crust would have been. It was missing the snap of a nice thin crust pizza. I did eat the cold leftover veg pizza happily while waiting for my plane the next day though. It wasn't horrible but I've had much better. read more

I wasn't really expecting to go out for pizza while on St. Thomas, but after a couple of bad dining experiences my wife and I decided why not. this is a very good pizza restaurant, yeah there is better in NYC, but this is close. plus the beer selection is the best I saw on the Island. read more

Went there tonight while on vacation. We had a hard time getting there with the location provided on Yelp - the location was way off! Nonetheless we eventually stumbled on to the place with a regular map and what a place! We had the garlic cheese bread for appetizer and three different pizzas and four desserts. The Pizzas were thin crust and very tasty. The beer selection was to die for considering such a small place. Parking is a challenge, but keep driving around-the inconvenience is worth it. read more

Really good beer selection and really great pizza as well! Try the Spinach Artichoke pizza appetizer, it was incredible.

Found the Pie Whole on Yelp! and a few other sites. It is in the main Street area, but is open for dinner. Very small with a local feel. So, make a reservation. We had the artichoke dip sampler. it is a pizza with the artichoke dip and jalapenos. It was a special of the house and a nice size appetizer. We ordered the Calzone and a vegi-pizza. both were excellent and obviously hand-made. I would recommend this place with or without the kids. read more

Great Pizza and an amazing selection of beer. The artichoke dip is the best. Small place but cozy. One of my favorite places to eat on St. Thomas. read more

Awesome pizza and beer selection! Had the pleasure of meeting one of the owners who was very helpful and recommended some great beers for me and my wife. She also talked about the mission of the restaurant to create a restaurant that felt like a home and that mission is definitely being accomplished. Will be back on future vacations for sure. read more

Who would,of thought! Here we are in st thomas, the town of Charlotte amielle is not exactly the prettiest nor safest place in the world right next to it is an even darker looking town called french town. And what did we find, The Pie Whole, This place was awesome, they had a fear stone pizza oven, everything was made from scratch.... The drinks are strong and their beer selection was absolutely endless...and not a bunch of standard beers but an endless list of exotic brews. The spinach artichoke dip with xtra crab was great but it was not a dip,it was a pizza. After several really bad, very expensive meals here this place was very reasonably priced and great fresh homemade food..... Oh yeah I forgot all their pastas are made on site, no box pasta here. I highly recommend this place if you want a good pie for a fair price and that is saying a lot for st thomas And a side note, St. John is a,lot nicer than st thomas read more

Absolutely a must-go while in St. Thomas! Spinach and Artichoke dip, pasta, salads, pizza (everything we tried) was absolutely delicious. Service was fantastic and the waitress helped us plan our trip on the islands. read more

Delicious! Oh my goodness. I've always loved brick oven pizza so this place was a must. The garlic bread was amazing, very flavorful. Pizza came out wonderful! The service was spot on. Loved how small and quaint it was. Try to make a reservation because this is a poppin place. Max occupancy is less than 30 customers. read more

Despite being from Chicago, I loved the pizza great place to go to if your on the island

Great pub atmosphere. They have an amazing beer selection for St Thomas. They had La Chouffe - my husband's favorite and one he can't get in AZ. My brother and husband drank all of the La Chouffe in the bar! The pasta was delicious. Grant, the server, was funny and helpful. He bonded with my mother's boyfriend over boxers (the dog breed not fighters). Visit Frenchtown and go to Pie Hole. read more