Pie Society is a really great spot to check out if you're just outside of San Antonio and looking for something a little different. One of my favorite things is that they offer pizza by the slice, depending on what they're serving that day -- and from what I understand, they always have pepperoni slices available, which is a plus. When you walk in, you can actually see them making the pizza from scratch, including hand-stretching the dough and tossing it in the air. It's a fun and unique touch that adds to the experience. They have a good amount of seating both inside and outside. Since this is Texas, outdoor seating can be a bit of a gamble weather-wise, but it's nice to have the option. Parking can be a little tricky, but when we went on a Sunday night, it wasn't bad at all. The service was great -- everyone was friendly, helpful, and very attentive, which made the visit even better. They also have a solid selection of alcohol and seasonal drinks, which pairs well with the pizza. For the kids, we grabbed a cookie, and it was very delicious -- definitely recommend it as a sweet treat after your meal. Overall, if you're in the area and want to try a place that's a bit out of the ordinary, I'd definitely recommend stopping by Pie Society and giving it a try. read more

Pie Society - Pizza Near Me - San Marcos, Texas

Tired of the quick pizza - PS is a great alternative. Need a hype evening dinner at Pie Society will fill your vibe. We love the Holy Grail and the Strawberry and Goat cheese salad!!!! Then stay at the Fatm!!!!! Stay at the Farm! VRBO- 2888351 airbnb.com/h/brokenroad #brokenroad #superhost #sanmarcostx #premierhostVBRO read more

See all

Pie Society is good place for slice of pizza. Similar to NY style. Great selection of options depending on what you are looking for. Prices are reasonable. The staff is very friendly and helpful. When in need of a good slice of pizza, check this place out. read more

Such great selections... pizza were all so worth it. We picked it up and was perfection. Tasty crust and cheese and all the toppings you'd love. read more

Way over priced, mediocre pie in a college town. Drinks weak as all get out and pricey too. Double shot makes a drink $12. Staff young, hipster and cool so that was good. Won't return. read more

Pizza SO GOOD, the review skips straight to the main course! With a pizza dough foundation only a legit craft baker could perfect! Firm and chewy, the perfect conveyance of explosive tasting toppings! The justice! House-Made Fennel Sausage, New York Pepperoni, Local Mushrooms, Red Onion & Ricotta! Shut the front door!!!! The fennel sausage is not for the light hearted!!! Amazing fennel accentuates the flavors, and the ricotta bombs balance it out. The 78-666! Italian Sausage, Pepperoni & Bacon! Holy Mother of Pizza! So simple yet so perfect. I find myself taking my time so I could enjoy each flavor. Super cool vibe, great service! It is a new "Must-Stop" location when I'm in town! read more

See all

I don't know where to start because I feel I could rave about this place for days. I noticed this place when I came to this strip mall for ramen. The parking is horrible in this small area and I had to park at the opposite end of the restaurant where I was going. But it was a lucky break because I had to walk past this restaurant and the smells wafting out immediately caught my attention. I took a mental note and told myself I'd be back to check it out. I didn't wait long because I came back the next day! One of the best decisions I've made recently. First let me say the customer service here is amazing. You're greeted walking in. I was met immediately to take my to go order. In the (about) 20 minutes while waiting, I kid you not, I was asked if I wanted water no less than 4 times! And the employees never stopped moving. Everyone was busy but very friendly. This place is obviously a well oiled machine. It's apparent it has to be because there was a crowd and a steady stream of people coming and going for pickup/to go orders. Also, they are making their own dough here! I was impressed watching one of the employees tossing the dough but then noticing they were making dough in the middle of the day; I didn't think I could be more impressed. But then I noticed they were also making their own sauce! I had to confirm what I was seeing so I asked the manager and he confirmed they do make their sauce and dough. And let me tell you, the final product shows all their hard work. There is not one thing the nitpick or say they can improve on. This is PIZZA. When you have a dream where you're having pizza, and it's just the most perfect TV type pizza you can imagine and you wake up thinking "pizza doesn't look and taste like that in real life!" THIS is the pizza you dreamed about. The crust, the toppings, the char....I can't even describe. It's perfect new york pizza. I got the Perry Mason. It's a familiar pizza to me because it's similar to a pizza I used to get from a place in downtown austin. But this one has hot honey. I wasn't ecstatic about that so I got it on the side. But boy oh boy did they teach me! My world opened after trying the savory pizza (gorgonzola sauce, prosciutto, spinach, pear and caramelized onion) with the hot and sweet honey. I didn't imagine I would like that but I'm so glad I learned something. I also got their goat cheese appetizer and again, they had to teach me about combos I never gave a chance. First let me say, this was an impressive appetizer. It came with a whole head of roasted garlic!!! It was such a beautiful sight to behold when I unwrapped the foil. There was also some pretty crostini, honey and marinara sauce. I kind of put the marinara to the side but my curiosity got the best of me and I'm grateful it did because the bite was so elevated! My meal from here was so satisfying, I wondered if it was possible for this meal to be better if I'd had it in restaurant or been able to eat it as soon as I got home instead of having to wait a little because I had an appointment. I'm going to definitely go back and dine in...for research purposes ofcourse. Someone has to do it, and I offer myself and my time. read more

See all

Woah! These pizzas are huge! And lucky for me they have Vegan pizzas!!! Yay! We came in on a weekend for dinner, and waited a bit longer than expected but in the end it was all good because the pizza was excellent! The location is tucked away but inside is large, well lit, and clean. There was plenty of sitting room for large parties. I took most of my pizza home, even the next day leftovers were amazing! If I come back to TOS part of Texas I will be back for sure! read more

See all

Great pizza and service. We went after the lunch rush so there was plenty of seating. The vibes are chill. read more

See all

Pizza was burnt and cold. We love Pie Society and this is our first bad experience but still there really is no excuse.

Always tasty food! Great bar selection. Good local beers. Nice craft soda selection. Good service. If you don't like loud, don't go on the weekends. If you don't mind it, go when you like! The pizza is always good. The roasted garlic and goat cheese appetizer is always a solid choice. read more

Offering a small, but excellent set of draft brews, this pizza joint may be one of our new faves in town. The goat cheese starter is delish, but maybe a little too hands on. Hand pressing the garlic makes it difficult share with someone you don't know too well. The calzone is excellent and I can't get enough of that red sauce. Only downside was the tea; tasted stale. But I guess that happens. read more

Pie Society - Spindle Tap Festbier, little too sweet to pair with the pie - Pizza Near Me - San Marcos, Texas

See all

Beginning with the service was great, the worker was nice and very courteous. As for the food, we ordered the Oath Calzone and the Custom Pie! It was AMAZING!!! The pizza was fresh, light, and extremely delicious! It was a New York styled pie, and was approved from my New Yorker Dad! Anyways, it was cheesy, and the marinara sauce was flavorful and not too sweet. The crust was crispy, airy, and had a crunchy texture. As for the Calzone... wow. The Calzone was filled with premium, meaty ingredients that made every bite savory and fantastic. The interior of the restaurant was unique, and had an urban vibe to it. It was just an overall amazing experience, and I hope everyone can enjoy Pie Society! read more

Pie Society - Build Your Own Cheese Pie with Fresh Jalapeños, Pepperoni, and Feta Cheese - Pizza Near Me - San Marcos, Texas

See all

So I came here to work an event. It's a cute little place in San Marcos and they are constantly making all the pizzas fresh and it was nice that they sell by the slice as well. You don't have to buy a whole pie. The people that work there super nice I spoke with the manager that I was gonna do the event and he was so nice and offered me and the other guy was working with each of a free slice of pizza so we can try them out. I got the holy Grail and it was delicious. My friend got a regular pepperoni which she said was very good too. We told management that they need to open this in Austin because I'm not gonna lie. It beat a lot of places here in Austin. So if you're out in San Marcos, stop here and get yourself some pizza. They also have a full bar if you wanna have drinks and they always have really good specials. read more

See all

Good day folks!! How Delish! Great slice of pizza! Great beer selection! $8 slice/pint combo! Perfect!!! Signature decor makes this place stand out as soon as you walk in. Upbeat energy from order taker - sealed the deal for an amazing experience!! Let Love Lead read more

Pie Society - Slice and pint combo - Pizza Near Me - San Marcos, Texas

See all

While shopping at the outlets, I was craving pizza and stumbled into Pie Society--and wow, what a find! From the moment I walked in, the staff made me feel welcome and offered great suggestions. We ordered two pizzas: a classic cheese and a loaded combination. The pizzas were massive, piled high with fresh toppings, and baked to perfection. Now, I usually skip cheese pizza, but this one completely won me over--the sauce had just the right tang, the cheese was gooey and flavorful, and the crust was that perfect balance: light, airy, and crisp without being too thick. The combination pizza was bold and hearty, every bite packed with flavor. To top it all off, I tried an Old Austin, and it was the perfect pairing--smooth, refreshing, and exactly what I needed. Between the friendly service, generous portions, and downright delicious food, Pie Society has officially earned a spot on my "must-return read more

See all

The pizza is so good. They have good deals with beer & a slice that everyone should check out!

Quirky college town pizza haunt that has seriously creative topping combinations. I've tried things I didn't think I would like and been won over. My college aged daughter introduced me to it and I've been back without her a few times so dad is a convert. Good food, laid back atmosphere and reasonable pricing. read more

Many options here. I ordered the Garden of Eden and subbed the feta with vegan cheese and gf crust. Outstanding. What I liked was I had the option to order a 12" . They also sold pizza by the slice. Salads and sandwiches also available. read more

Pie Society - Garden of Eden Pizza with vegan cheese and gf crust. - Pizza Near Me - San Marcos, Texas

10/10! We are in town for a youth basketball camp and craved pizza. This place is perfect!! If you drink, they have all options on tap, even Tupps from where we live in mckinney! Plenty of pizza options, from delicious pepperoni to completely customized like the San Martian. The line of fountain drinks is more custom and delicious too! Y'all DEF need to put this on the list to try! Everyone is super nice, music is fun and not too loud, annnd we got a chefs table view, perfect! Happy campers here!! read more

See all

I don't know how we forgot about Pie Society but I wanted a thin crust pizza and looked on Yelp. I saw that we had pizza here and loved it, so we came back. My family loved it. The pizzas are large! The toppings fresh! The service was great! And I recommended going for a slice inside with friends to my kids. If you have not tried it in a while like me, go check it out. read more

See all

Absolutely incredible. Flavors are spot on and the pizza was truly NY style. Great relaxed atmosphere and the prices were great for the portion sizes. I had a custom calzone and it was HUGE and sooo tasty! I also had the draft margarita and it was the perfect drink for the meal. Will definitely be returning! read more

After working a 12‑hour shift, my wife called Pie Society to place an order, only to be placed on hold for so long she had to hang up. When she called back, she was told her order was placed. But when she arrived, they couldn't locate it,... and it appears it was never placed. She then had to wait for them to place the order and make the order. We have always loved this place but this experience is a red flag, someone's dropping the ball. read more

Food is awesome, love their pizza. The service at times isn't the best but ambiance is really chill and nice. I would say though they are a bit pricey read more

Pie Society - Pizza Near Me - San Marcos, Texas

Not exactly sure what all the hype is about this place... had lots of recommendations to try it but when we arrived there was no sense in the ordering system. You basically crowd in front of the counter and whoever beats you to the register first gets to go. I stood in line for over 20 minutes, and then a large group came in and went in front of me. The people at the register said nothing, they knew I had been standing there and they went ahead and took the large groups order. I ordered two waters along with my pizza, when we went to get water. The water wasn't working. It was mixing with the syrup so I went back upfront and explained to them the water wasn't working and I purchased two sodas and they put 2 cups on the counter and charged me and didn't even say anything. The pizza was OK nothing spectacular and they charge for ranch as well. There's not enough seating and there was a really loud table which they did nothing about. They were screaming and yelling and standing on the chairs. I guess this is a college town experience but I definitely will not be back . read more

Great customer service! Especially Jace! Great attitude! Good and drinks were also great!

Great pizza! Orders are around 15-20 minutes on less busy times. Definitely try it

Pickup order. Balance of power was ordered . It was fine, nothing special and my opinion a little expensive . Also ordered the goat cheese that was okay. 3.5/5 read more

Pie society is very good when they have their pizza ready to eat. They are on time when the pizza is done . read more

Pie Society - Pizza Near Me - San Marcos, Texas

Let me preface my comments with I am a foodie and pretty good cook according to family and friends. I'm always looking for the best Pizza and Burgers. That said I'll start with the positives. Size of pie 18" was great for two and a half people, time to bake the pie was as expected, the crispy yet toothy dough was great, just how I like it too, but that's about all I got. The dough needed to be seasoned, the red sauce needed to be seasoned. There were huge globs of ricotta cheese and almost zero goat cheese. We added pepperoni and black olives. Now did we eat the pie absolutely and we will try again to see if our 1st experience was a fluke. read more

Good drinks and good pizza. I didn't realize that I could order a half of one type, along with a half of another pizza. Don't forget to check out their happy hours specials, one of which is a 16" pepperonI & cheese pizza discounted. They don't take reservations m even for large groups. We had 12 in our party, and had to chance it without reservations. We were fine because we ate early, otherwise you might want to go elsewhere. We'll be back! read more

Considering how much of my money goes to Pie Society by way of my Texas State Student, I had to give them a try for myself. I know for my child they go there partly out of convenience, but even college students have standards, especially when spending other people's money. Personally I was impressed enough that they have become our go to place for grabbing dinner when in town to see our child perform in the nearby performance hall. I appreciate that they have creative pizzas that they offer by the slice. My favorite is the Balance of Power with spinach, spicy sausage, crushed red pepper and Texas honey. Their toppings are fresh, the sauce is nicely seasoned, and the crust is thin but holds up to the toppings well. Their by the slice prices are reasonable. I also give them props for having Stubborn sodas on tap. The atmosphere is warm, bright, and open inside and also has tables set up outside. The restaurant and restrooms have been clean and in order everytime we've been. Staff have been friendly and service has been quick. read more

Pie Society - Balance of Power - Pizza Near Me - San Marcos, Texas

I enjoy their service, I enjoy their kindness... but all of their beers somehow taste like water???? Even ones that were in cans and draft? Not sure what the issue is with this place. read more

Always reliable and delicious! Garden of Eden is a favorite, grab a meatball sub and salad You won't be disappointed! read more

The food was made fresh. The pizza was delicious and filling. The ranch was great as well . The service was quick and easy. They have a full bar! You can see the area where the cooks make the food which is cool. The place is nicely lit and it's the perfect spot to go for a Friday night or on a Tuesday afternoon. I would recommend this pizza spot! read more

See all

Balance of Power. Yup, once you've had it , there is no going back. Pie Society is our favorite pizza place in the area. Piping hot, thin crust pizzas, cold beer, the best pink lemonade I have ever had and consistent good service. They are also very family and group friendly. We will be back! read more

Pie Society - Balance of Power(highly recommended). - Pizza Near Me - San Marcos, Texas

See all

What a gem of a find! The pizza was so full of toppings & the crust was nice and thin. Full of flavor. Definitely our new favorite place for pizza! read more

Possibly the best pizza EVAH! Ooey, gooey, cheesy and wonderful! You really gotta try some!

We drove down to San Marcos just to try the pie from Pie Society. We had the cheese slice, pepperoni slice and a few slices of the Balance of Power. The staples were fine, nothing remarkable. The Balance of Power was a delightful shocker. Well blended spice with local Texas honey to smooth it out. I'd eat here more if I were local, not sure I'll make the road trip again just for pizza. read more

Pie Society - Balance of Power slice - Pizza Near Me - San Marcos, Texas

Very delicious pizza. I've never received bad service nor anything below great pizza. It is one of the best pizza places in San Marcos. I got nothing negative to say about this place other than I wish they lived next to me. read more