First time here and it was really good! I ordered the pepperoni, with hot honey-Mike's Sticky Fingers. I substituted the spicy sauce for regular sauce-it was delicious!!! I ate the entire thing! Service was good and ambiance was fair. We were there at noon and there wasn't a soul inside. So that is awkward and makes you wonder at the height of lunch time. They need music or something if it is empty. 4 stars because they charge you $1.06 for side of ranch and that is a bit ridiculous and want a tip. I don't know how you most people feel about that but I ordered at counter, got my own napkins, filled my own drink, and got up when my name was called to get food and cleared my table. No tip necessary-but feel guilty pushing no tip in front of them. read more

This place is a grade A shi*thole since it changed ownership. Soda machine is always broken, ice takes 15 minutes to get 1/4 cup... only to get flat soda from last week. The dine-in experience is like eating at the bathroom in Trainspotting. Fortunately - I still like the idea of pumping out my pizza with questionable ingredients in under 5 minutes! May or may not eat here again?... Probably will - but with more disgruntled complaints. read more

The pizza is acceptable in both taste and thin crust quality. Toppings and sauce are tasty, but not the best. The restaurant itself is neat and clean. The service I've had in restaurant is satisfactory. Usually I only order this pizza through Doordash for 2 reasons: because it's close to my home, this pizza is what I order when I want fast and inexpensive because I don't like the other popular pizza delivery places. I think this is better quality. Note: this is not my choice if eating out for specialty pizza or if I want an alcoholic beverage with my pizza. read more

Pie Five was a staple in our house that we frequented about every other week until we moved out of state. My son would go there more often, then we did as a family, because this was his favorite place to eat. Since we moved, the one thing he requests that we have to bring him back is Pie Five. This last time we ran into Dave, an owner, and he sent us home with uncooked pies for us to try that way. It worked splendidly. Just as crispy and delicious for our boy to enjoy! Talk about going above and beyond for loyal customers! We travel back 'home' at least every six months so we get our son his pies and Dave will help us out. Please support local owners that go above and beyond that also have fabulous food! read more

See all

I love Pie Five you guys. It's fast, the gluten free crust is really good, and you get to add most toppings free of charge, including fresh basil, most proteins, and endless veggies. I don't ever eat inside, I typically order online and have it delivered. But it's kinda fun to go in person and direct/watch your pie being put together, then disappear into the oven and come out hot and crispy! Don't forget to add the basil olive oil drizzle. read more

Food tasted great I had the $6.99 lunch special Thin crust two meat Pepperoni and sausage Small salad Server was nice and efficient Ambiance was cool Self serve drinks It was clean inside I enjoyed my lunch read more

Food was great and the service was excellent the workers are such kind people love this place

Wow... I have been a few times and have had to deal with the same awful woman who acts like she's the mean girl stuck in high school still. She's a blonde with shoulder length hair, in her 50s with full lips. She acts like she can just talk to her customers like they aren't worth her time. VERY rude and horrible attitude!! Clearly it's not just her having had a bad day since I ran into her multiple times now with the same attitude. Not returning and telling friends and family not to go to this location. read more

I have to say, i used to frequent this location a while back and love the size an taste of the pizzas. What the heck happened? The size is bigger and i know that, but the taste and look of the pies now just ain't what it used to be. The guy makin my pie was really nice and politely informed me that they were out of cheese and it would be awhile before they would have any. So i changed my order and went with feta cheese instead of mozzarella, which was a good idea cause it was better, i think. But goin back to this location again, well probably not. read more

Pie Five Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Keller, Texas

See all

The service and cleanliness were both below par. Upon entering we made our choices and when finished were told they had no personal pizzas or cinnamon sticks because their dough needed to rise three more hours. We promptly changed our order and proceeded to the checkout where we ordered one large and two children's drinks. We were given three large cups for the drinks. When I sat down at the dirty tables I noticed on the receipt that I was charged for three adult drinks. When I asked, the same employee told me they don't have kids drinks. She never said they were sorry or offered any compensation. There were only two employees on the premises, both under twenty. Besides all that, the pizza was terrible, having just a little cheese and sauce. Don't go! read more

female employee in store very was very aggressive and rude. Will not be returning. ever.

This is by far one of my favorite pizza spots. The general manager (D) is courteous, friendly and always asks how we are doing. She goes out of her way even for the little things. The place is very clean and the prices are fair. We've recommended this place to my in-laws and multiple friends. I think many could learn a few things on how she runs the store! read more

Will never order here again. Had a pickup order and the lack of quality and care was so disappointing. Pizza had the smallest portions of toppings and the salad greens were brown and wilted. For this price, the quality is severely lacking. read more

Pie Five Pizza - Pizza with disappointment - Pizza Near Me - Keller, Texas

Great concept. Too bad it has very unprofessional management with no businesse integrity. The pizza is over seasoned, chewey or raw dough with very hard dry toppings. Just aweful. read more

Daphne is amazing! I come all the time and order 4+ pizza's for my family and I and she always let me when there are some deals going on and always provides a wonderful experience! Good service is hard to find these days but it is always a pleasure being served by Daphne! read more

I've been coming to this location for at least 5 years. Through the years it's had its ups and downs. Everyone I know, knew it as the coldest place in town. The AC was always cranked to the coldest temp, and no one would eat inside. Possibly a business strategy? But that's not why I'm writing. Tonight my husband and I visited and had the most enjoyable time. We had been debating whether to have expensive Italian for our anniversary, or Pie Five. We decided on no frills at our old familiar place. We were greeted by 2 nice young men who were eager to help us. It was a short encounter, but it was obvious they worked as a team, and were the only ones working. They handled the customers perfectly and the pizza was great! When we left, I left something, and had to go back later. I arrived a few minutes before 9 pm, and the shop had already been cleaned by the guys and smelled really clean! I was greeted by the guys like we were old friends. (We're not yet), but We'll be going back again and again, because they created such a welcoming atmosphere, and great pizzas. I hope management recognizes the guys that worked evening of Jan. 30,2025. They really made our evening. read more

Not impressed being a first time visitor. Everything was fine until I politely went to inform the male working there on the line that their sweet tea was unsweetened. Don't let me fail to mention I poured my cup out & sampled BOTH tea urns. Instead of just fixing the issue he decided to argue with me that he had added " 2 pounds himself " to the tea and his best suggestion was to use sugar packs. At that point you can just let people complain to you all day I tried ‍ Can't say I would return here for the lack of customer service I experienced. Your job is really not that hard especially changing a damn tea urn. read more

Pie Five Pizza - two slices missing - Pizza Near Me - Keller, Texas

Being a vegan in this area only gets you so very far. This pizza place has vegan cheese and cauliflower crust. Awesome option when you want some fast comfort food read more

Great service, clean dining room& delicious pizza I always choose this location because of how great customer service they have read more

Very good!! Service was quick and the staff is friendly! Pizza was served quickly and it was tasty! read more

Pie Five Pizza - Who doesn't love pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Keller, Texas

Went in for take out. The first employed was great. I watched him make my pizzas and he seemed very knowledgeable. The next employee asked if I wanted everything on my pizzas. Yes. I ordered the Athenian for me and the High Five for my husband. The pizzas were great and the service was good. The uncomfortable thing is waiting for the pizza to finish while you stare at the employee. But it always tastes so good. read more

6 months ago, I would have said that this was the best Pie Five in the DFW area. I was always excited to go there. Great staff and always a great experience. The staff has been an issue for the past 1-2 months. It seems like there was a changing of the guard and this new group makes me not want to ever go back. I've gone weekly over this 2 month timeframe (poor experience each time) and tried to give some grace but the service this evening sent me over the edge. I hate to be a "Karen" but this staff has left me no choice :( This batch of incompetent employees have ruined the quality of the product and make every second I'm there a miserable experience. Whoever the manager is needs to take a long hard look in the mirror because they aren't hiring people with basic competence or entry level customer service skills. The staff they hired is terrible and immediate action needs to be taken. - Pizza dough poorly prepped - under cooked pizza - using wrong utensils while prepping pizza - don't follow directions - wildly rude and act like taking my order is an inconvenience read more

10" personal is closer to 9" $14 for a not even 10" cauliflower crust is just not worth it. Taste is ok but not amazing. This was our second time giving it a shot. The first time we ordered delivery for the whole family and were deeply disappointed with practically no cheese on all the pizzas. We had gluten free crust in that order and it tasted like cardboard. The regular thin crust in that order was dry and our group all agreed it was the worst pizza ever ordered out. Our second time the pizza builder did a better job because I went in person, but I would never trust them for delivery. Sad to say, but it's not a good experience! read more

Pie Five Pizza - Less than 10" pizza - Pizza Near Me - Keller, Texas

We have been going here for years. Unfortunately, they shrunk the size of the recently. Price increases are one thing but the double whammy of price plus shrinkage is not acceptable. We Will come back if you go back to the regular size. read more

I'm not going to change my rating, but I am slightly tempted to. I tried a salad (Greek) for the first time, and all I can think is, "What's the point (of the crust/bowl)?" It really wasn't a bowl, just a disc with the edges turned up slightly, but the worst part was it did nothing for the salad. It struck me as a bit stale, It was a little salty, but added nothing. Maybe if the salad was served with a side of tomato sauce, the crust might have been good for dunking, but not in my (Greek) salad dressing. The salad was OK, as in "3 star" OK, but I won't bother with a salad again, I'll be sticking with the pizza from now on. Bottom line: No more salad here for me! read more

Pie Five Pizza - Not impressed with the salad "bowl", seemed stale, tomato sauce (for dipping) would have helped. - Pizza Near Me - Keller, Texas

I come to this pie five once a month to get lunch for all of the crew. They've always been friendly and very helpful and the food is great and consistently good. I came back as I was running errands and don't even live by this location, but I am always pleased by the friendliness of the staff And how helpful they were. The cashier even made sure I got the special for the day today on my app I would definitely recommend this location. read more

Pie Five Pizza - Build Your Own Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Keller, Texas

Bbq chicken,bacon and pineapple not. Too sweet Mike sticky fingers not. Too sweet. Old salad with rotten tomatoes unacceptable. I order at 11am. Seriously!! You are not cutting cost of running a business. You're killing it. read more

This pie 5 keller texas location is always filthy. Every single table has crumbs or sticker residue on top. There's used napkins in the booth seat creases. It is like this every time. I saw the manager and she doesn't even look around at the dining area. I told a young blonde at the register and she wiped off 2 tables only. Can anyone say "BROOM?" Food is good but so are other places!!!! read more

I want to start by saying this review is not about the staff. They were so kind and doing the best they could, even though I could tell they were busy. I placed an app order to get the Mike's sticky finger pizza, but when my order was already completed I was told they were out of the hot honey. As that is the sole reason I wanted to try this pizza, I basically ended up with a plain pepperoni pizza with a little basil. I did not want to overwhelm the staff anymore or make a fuss while there was a line. so I just took the order. I also ordered the garlic butter breadsticks and when I opened them at home I saw they were completely plain. It looked like plain bread crust with absolutely nothing on it. I couldn't believe I wasted my money or rewards on any of this. Afterwards I wanted to make a complaint on the Pie Five website and tried to submit the review multiple times. It just kept reloading like it wouldn't allow me to submit at all. read more

Pie Five Pizza - Supposed to be Garlic Butter Stix - Pizza Near Me - Keller, Texas

See all

The employees were so wonderful during the huge rush they were having. The manager did a great job making the experience fun and was super sweet. The pizza was great and the store was super clean. Love love love this place and the hardworking employees! They all deserve a raise!! read more

Absolutely terrible. Customer service was awful. Restrooms were dirty. Would not recommend this location If I could rate no stars, I would. read more

We come to pie five a lot bc I can get the cauliflower crust and my kid only likes the traditional Softer crust. The catch is that kids pizza crust is hard as a rock/crispy and my kid hates it. So we've always requested kids bundle with traditional adult pizza split in half to make a kids pizza size. This typically is accepted. Today we were told this is not allowed anymore after asking someone in back. Bc of price for pizza/drink for kid at adult price and how much a child cannot eat. I won't be able to frequently visit anymore. We will have to go elsewhere. Price difference. $8 versus 12.99. With lots of wasted food. Big disappointment on customer service. read more

Awful! My daughter and I went there for the first (and last) time tonight. Walking in I asked if they could help us out with their ordering process bc we were new. No help or direction from the 8-10 employees just talking amongst themselves. Then my thincrust pizza had to be remade 3 times bc evidently there's a "prep" done to the crust that two employees didn't do? Then the same girl asked me four times if I wanted my dressing in the side. Yep....same answer all four times. Went to check out and yet another employee shows up saying my bill was $32.00. It was $18.00. She insisted it was $32.00 until a guy I assume was a manager brought up the correct amount. No, "I'm sorry", no, "We're training new people" NOTHING. Total waste of $20.00 and the food was horrible! Lost a Keller local. read more

VERY disappointed. We ordered thru DoorDash for delivery. Requested double chicken and there was barely any on the pizza at all. My husband's pepperoni and burger pizza had 1 slice of pepperoni Per slice of pizza. Total waste of money. Ordering from iFratelli next time! read more

I'm torn between giving Pie Five 3 or 4 stars. I think the pizza is good, and I love that you can add as many toppings as you want- and as much as you want. I also like that they offer cauliflower crust- but it's not completely low carb. The cauliflower crust still has 20g of carbs for half the pizza. Still a better option than the regular crust, but not as low carb as I would like. It's a good option for people who are gluten-free. I ordered a cauliflower crust pizza with pepperoni, onions, and black, green, and kalamata olives. Still had to add a little salt for more flavor. Overall, it's pretty good and I'm sure I'll be back at some point. read more

Pie Five Pizza - Cauliflower crust with pepperoni, onions, and lots of olives- pretty good! - Pizza Near Me - Keller, Texas

I love coming to Pie Five for more than the "pick you toppings" pizza. The high schooler working there warm this empty nesters hard. Something about watching the team work is compelling. And the pizza is awesome. Spread some kindness and give it a shot. read more

Was just got banned from this location. As soon as we walk in we hear the loud screeching noise of chairs being moved across concrete. The staff was doing this directly behind when you place the order, which made it hard to hear the person doing the order. The person taking the order was soft spoken and wearing a mask, which compounded with the chairs being dragged made it impossible to order. (As a side note one of us has a slight hearing impairment and is very sensitive to loud noises - trigger migraines - which amplified the situation) Due to having sensitive hearing, one of us said to the other "I have to get the f*** out of here, and left. This was not said to anyone that worked there. The other one stayed behind to complete the order. When attempting to check out the other person came back in and said I am ready to get the f*** out of here. Again not to the workers. At that time the individual that said they were the DM said if they don't stop dropping the f-bomb we were going to have to leave. Mind you the food was done and we were taking it to go) He then said the f-bomb was said to the people that worked there, which he did not. Also said the restaurant was full. It was not. There was one other adult couple on the other end waiting for food and another adult ordering while we were attempting to check out. The other people had left before anything was said and there was no one else eating since the same area they said there was. Please note, the area they claimed someone was sitting, was the same area they had been cleaning and dragging at least 10 plus chairs across the concrete. Would be hard to do that if that area was full of customers, right? We mentioned the noise was like nails on a chalkboard, and their response - "these are concrete floors, can't be helped." Well yes it can, you can pick up the chair and move it instead of dragging it. Never once did they ask what the problem was or what made him upset. Instead just got attitude. The DM also responded by saying we will clean how we want. Yes, that was from the DM! Then said he would ban us and if we came back he would call the cops and say we were trespassing. Never once did we raise our voice or curse directly to them. But they were banning us because one us was saying curse words to the other. What is most concerning, is the DM, which a GOOD DM would do, would ask what the problem was. He never did. He never wondered if potentially the person had a health condition and loud noises cause triggers. You know - there are people out there, that those loud noises would trigger fits of rage (autistic, cerebral palsy, etc.) None of that was taken into consideration as to why a person was upset. You know, I thought we were supposed to be living in a kinder more understanding world- apparently not. What is interesting is, we have been going there since the place opened years ago almost weekly. This new owner took over about 9 months ago. We have never seen any of the people working in there except one kid. And when we were in last week he was complaining to customers he was having a bad day and was upset he had already had to work over 6 hours that day. So yeah, about that. Needless to say we will never go to ANY Pie Five again if that is how they treat their customers. Both of us have worked in retail and food service for a number of years in our past lives. Plus, my father was also an executive at a national retailer for decades and dealt with difficult customers daily. The motto we all grew up with was the customer is always right, and if you have a challenge there are appropriate ways to deal with them. You are supposed to be inquisitive and ask about the concern as a leader. Not jump to conclusions, ban people and then threaten with the cops if they show up again. Their DM was the complete opposite and the antithesis of that. So if you want to support a place that does not care about their customers - have at this place! read more

Today was our first time trying the Keller location and we loved it! The staff was nice and helpful in creating our pizzas, and the ingredients and the inside of the restaurant looked very fresh and clean. We got 2 build your own pizzas and the cinnamon sticks were AMAZING! Will definitely be back :) read more

We enjoyed pizza tonight at this new location. The place was pretty dirty in the back half of the restaurant and super hot in the front half of the store. Not pleasant. We chose a dirty table to avoid the majority of the heat. My daughter liked the gluten free cheese pizza with ranch, my son enjoyed a meat and veggie pan pizza and I got a mixed pan. Most of the pan pizza was gooey and seemed underdone in the center, affecting the center half of the pizza. It still tasted good though. read more

See all

This pizza is similiar to Pizza Hut. I didnt go inside to get the food so I cant say much about the interior or the service, but parking was easy. I got half cheese half pepperoni personal pizza. The cheese tastes pretty good, crispy crust. Sauce and cheese were tasty, better than pizza huts. However, the pepperoni I felt was still too chewy and needed to be baked more. I prefer mine crispy though. So over all, id get the cheese pizza here, dont think I'll get pepperoni in the future though. read more