In from out of town and came to this location two mornings in a row. Kept it simple with cold brew and an English breakfast tea. Also had a ham and cheese croissant. Everything was really good. Price seemed in line with what you'd expect. Atmosphere was very chill although it was just when they opened in the morning. Service was friendly and prompt. I could easily see this being a regular spot for me if I lived in the area. read more

Picky Barista - Cold brew. Ham and cheese croissant. Picture not taken at location. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

Quick cafe to grab a bit, coffee, catch up or get some work done. Bit busy but workable. Service was quick, PSL was yummy and creamy! The place is airy and bright even on dreary fall days. read more

Picky Barista - Pumpkin spice latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

Yummy hot cocoa. fast for how busy they were. It was creamy, sugary and delicious. Only allow laptops on certain days so check website if planning to work from here. read more

Picky Barista - Hot cocoa - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

Ordered matcha and they squeezed matcha out of a premade bottle... what a scam! Do not order

I decided to find a local café to work and grab a cup of solid latte. Decided to visit Picky Barista because I like a takeout I had a couple of weekends before. Unfortunately on a Thursday afternoon the place was packed. I was able to find a bar stool by a communal high table and decided to stay. It took a minute before I was served. I decided to order the seasonal special, Tiramisu latte with soy milk and two waffle cookies. Can I say it's one of the best lattes I've had of all time... The waffle cookies were alright. They were like sugar cookies baked on a waffle iron. Want impressed. Their cinnamon rolls & buns are worth trying. Loved them the last visit. Overall the place has a cool vibe and a good hangout place. Will need to find a time when it's less crowded to come back. read more

Picky Barista - Tiramisu soy latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

This is a popular and lively venue but also quiet enough to curl up with a book. The matcha was too mild for my taste. I liked hanging out here, regardless. It was good service. read more

Picky Barista - Hot oat milk matcha latte medium - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

Beautiful coffee shop with lots of natural light. Americano is standard. Pistachio latte (seasonal) is absolutely delicious. Not overly sweet. Staff is kind and answered all questions I had, and provided great recommendations. read more

Picky Barista - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The mornings are usually busy, any other time is decent. The coffee is good and the baristas are friendly.

Literally the worst cinnamon roll i have ever had. Two stars because the service and coffee are good but wow, how do you mess up a cinnamon roll read more

Picky Barista - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

No picture of my beverage but I ordered the ice pistachio latte. Absolutely loved it but be sure to shake all the sugar from the bottom so you can mix it well in. Super cute café, a lot of people were just hanging out there or working on their laptops. And I decided to take my coffee to go and stroll central Park. :) read more

Small and cozy cafe with the typical brick and plant decor. The coffee is pretty decent, but like more cafes around here it's a bit overpriced ($5.75 for a latte). The space is a bit too tiny to work comfortably in. Service is quick and there is wifi available. read more

Picky Barista - Menu - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

Still loving this place, a neighborhood fav, cool vibe, great coffee, delicious baked goods, very good avocado toast. Nice people working here, and they always try to keep the line movies. great coffees, only downside is small size. my little one loves the Nutella roll, it is big enough to share as well.. bring a book if you'd like to stay, they do not allow laptops (people used to stay all day, its understandable) if this place is too crowded, try to plant shed there's one on Columbus and 87 st and Amsterdam and 95 st. read more

The stars are only for the decor of this nook..it's small and intimate and most just seemed at ease as they drank their coffee/tea/beverage..NOW FOR THE SERVICE AS WELL AS MY MATCHA DRINK .....I so eagerly wanted to make this my "go to ". It's been here for sometime .This is around the corner from my apartment ..I got an iced matcha..This was by far the worst tasting matcha I ever had. It was not stirred; lumpy ..in which instantly takes away from any matcha experience. I still drank it and I was sick the whole day . This was the first beverage I drank and last.. The customer service was lack luster. They had signs about smiles and tipping ..;in which I love tipping ; (for a more than welcoming experience)..however the barista was not too friendly. They also seemed a bit unorganized.. it could have been just that day / moment .. BUT I HAVE TO SAY that Matcha , Is a NO go.. I literally had to drink pepto bismol (hours later) .I was sick the entire day ..Sighs...I did not enjoy my experience at all..however it's a pretty coffee bar.. read more

Met up with a friend here. Love the seating! The décor is also super hip. It was a bit hard to tell where to order. I didn't spot any gluten free pastries, so I just got a drip coffee. There's a little station where you can add your own sugar & lid. I didn't like the coffee lids... I ripped the plastic on mine trying to bend it back. They charge $.75 cents for a milk substitute. That personally feels a bit outdated to me. read more

Picky Barista - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This is a nice coffee shop right across the street from Trader Joe's. The vibe is perfect. Small enough for the people who like intimacy, but big enough for people to want to play with their phones a bit before leaving. There were a few people on their laptops, but not too many. The coffee was delicious. I had a turmeric latte and a cortado. I loved them both. read more

Nice baristas and appreciate the Wi-Fi, but the croissant was so doughy. Cold brew was fine. Place feels like it needs a little spring refresh. read more

Picky Barista - Egg cheese pesto & greens, added avo. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

Stopped by after a quick trip to Trader Joe's across the street. I didn't realize there was another location (to the nearby one on Broadway) -- I've never been to that one, but this one is bigger and has more seating. The cold brew I got was just ok, if a little lacking in flavor. Giving four stars, but would go for 3 if factoring in the price. read more

Picky Barista - the outside of a cafe - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

Both times take out and eat in the pastries were terrible. The scone was rock like. Only cafe in my neighborhood- terrible. A better pastry chef would be an improvement. read more

I had a mixed bag experience here. I went in on a Thursday afternoon and was shocked at how lax the barista waiting on me was. She definitely was moving like there wasn't a line behind me or as if I had no place to go. It was wild. The first part of my order, a pastry that once I bit into it found out it was still frozen, prompted me to go back in and ask for it to be reheated. I opted for the ham and cheese sandwich and a chocolate croissant, both lightly heated, and idk if it was because I was hungry or what, but they both tasted sensational. For that reason, and the coziness of the indoor space, I will be back. I would recommend that they get some rounded mesh cake covers for the pastries. Flys landing on food is not a necessity in 2023. Looking forward to returning. read more

Good coffee but a tad overpriced for the quality you get. Decent option in the area though given you don't have a lot of options available.

Went there to grab a cup of coffee and a little dessert. The barista was extremely rude and hostile towards me. She kept on shouting my order while she saw me handling a crying infant. She then screamed at me telling me that we don't deliver the drinks to the table. I didn't even ask her to but she shouted that across the cafe which lead all the patrons to feel uncomfortable. The coffee was ok But I will never come here again read more

Coffee was ok; iced vanilla latte was way too sweet and syrupy. I ordered an almond croissant that was as dense as a brick. No flakes, didn't taste any butter, sugar, or almond. read more

Picky Barista - Almond "croissant" - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

This place allows dogs not to clean, not sure if I should continue this establishment because they allow them to walk freely. I am reporting this. This is disrespectful. Dogs bite children all of the time. This is disrespectful to those who don't own dogs. I am rating them low because of this. I will not come back. The baristas are always GREAT, but the can't make coffee and regulate dogs in a room. read more

See all

Typically quite busy and hard to get seats. No laptops allowed on the weekends as well. Espresso is good but slightly on the more bitter side. Overall nice environment and good place to stop. Due to a lot of clientele typically has a line and a bit of a wait but worth it on the upper west side. read more

The space is adorable and the staff friendly; however, the coffee and pastries are not as good as they should be. The cold brew was more expansive than most places in the area... but the coffee wasn't any better. I also did not like the almond croissant (didn't even finish it). It was super dense, not flaky... basically not a croissant. read more

I love the vibe here. It's my favorite coffee shop in the neighborhood. But the no laptops policy on weekends sucks. There is literally nowhere else in the area to eat a pastry and immerse yourself in cool grown-up energy when you have a sitter for three hours on a Sunday and just want to write your novel and pretend you're a grad student again. What am I supposed to do, sit at Dunkin? Peaky B, please change your mind and let us relax on the weekends the only way we know how, by doing work on our computers. read more

Amazing ambiance. Friendly staff. Free wifi. Lots of people working on computers. Plenty of indoor seating and great drip coffee! read more

Picky Barista - people sitting at tables in a coffee shop - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

See all

After shopping at Trader Joe's, I popped over to Peaky Barista where I had the young woman surprise me with a drink!! It was amazing. It was an espresso based drink with notes of lavender. My friend ordered the raspberry lemonade. This lemonade definitely has tart aspects that drift away from the overly sweetened version found at any restaurant but if you don't mind the sour it's definitely worth it. read more

Picky Barista - Raspberry Lemonade and Surprise Drink - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

Lovely neighborhood spot. Much larger location than the Broadway one. Good coffee, ample seating indoors and out. Recommend the honey cookie as a little treat with your coffee. read more

See all

I popped in for a quick burek, because that's the food from my home country and I always want to try it out abroad. It was pretty good and I'll definitely be back when the burek cravings hit hahah read more

Picky Barista - Burek - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

The burek is really, and always ask for it warmed up, and the tea, coffee and other drinks are good as well. The location is super cute and nice, and the service is kind and helpful, and are very fast with making coffee and drinks:) read more

I love setting up shop here to work for a couple of hours. The place itself is a welcome addition to the neighborhood. What needs to be improved? The food. The pastries are no better than the corner store - 7/11, bodega variety. No flakiness, not a stench of butter, just bad. Reading the reviews, I see I'm not unique in the opinion. Everything else is first rate. read more

Hands down the worst pastry I've ever had. Ordered the almond croissant. Literally took a bite and spit it out immediately. Went back in and asked for a another pasty instead. Got a banana bread slice. Still lackluster. Coffee is average at best. Beautiful decor and good location. read more

Love this coffee shop! It's in my neighborhood so I always stop by and grab a pastry and a drink when I can. It''s usually pretty busy but the baristas are quick and friendly and there's normally plenty of space to sit. If it's a weekday I like to sit and do some work, if it's a weekend I'll catch up on reading or meet with a friend. Great coffee and I especially love their honey cookies read more

Great coffee and vibe. Theres always a table outside which is what I love. So happy they are here. :))

such a cute little coffee shop. we had the baklava, nutella roll and hot chocolate, everything was delicious :)

Love this place!!! I come here often and it's always a nice atmosphere, good service and yummy coffee. Plus they have spacious seating both indoor and outdoor. read more

I went in on a weekend with my laptop. I purchased $15 in food and drinks, tipped 15% and had been sitting doing work while enjoying my food and drink for 20 minutes. An employee came if we and told me I needed to put my computer away because they weren't allowed on weekends. I said "I paid $15 to purchase something and enjoy it here, I am a paying customer I should be able to do use my laptop- I'm not taking up extra space or bothering anyone". The employee told me I had to put it away. I ended up leaving and going to another cafe where I was able to purchase food and drink and do my work unbothered. Too bad they have this rule- I would have purchased more food and gone back again. I will not be back. I'm an adult, a paying customer- not a rowdy teen. read more

Nice vibe. Coffee and baklava are good. The staff are suuuuuuuper nice. It's a cute place. We need to support our local great cafes!

Over prized for the quality. Coffee is ok, baked goods are subpar. People who work there are snobby abs make you feel you are an annoyance. What a waste of money. read more