The bread was awful. Maybe it's my fault because I didn't want it toasted but the first sandwich I ordered was not just dry, it tasted like it was a few hours from turning moldy. Just wrong. They remade it with a good attitude, and the bread was so dry it just crumbled apart and was dry enough to choke on. I ate half with no bread. Two stars for ok service and a decent amount of meat. I forgot to add mozzarella and when I asked to add it, I was told my sandwich "was already on the other side" er, it's 6 steps and the cheese is right there. The guy on the other side did it but wow. The ambience was fine. Clean space. Since the place has pickle in the name I expected at least a small side spear like most other delis or a variety of pickles for sale. Neither of those things is true. Just odd. 1 sandwich 1 single serving of chips and a 12 oz drink was almost 18 dollars. I will never go back. read more

Driven by here a few times since moving to NWA. Decided to try it today for lunch. Underwhelmed is an understatement. Not a big eater but the meat to bread ratio is wild and not in a good way. Also a small smear of avocado for $1.49 outrageous. Maybe I ordered the wrong thing but a turkey sandwich should be the standard. Maybe I would come back to try pizza. read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Half of a half turkey bacon with "added avocado" - Salad Near Me - Rogers, Arkansas

Im the baker in a prominent steak house in Bentonville. Three times we've ordered sandwiches for our crew, three times its been a joke. The bread is actually ok, the portions are less than Subway. Do you employees give a damn? Maybe an ounce of meat and cheese. It's not even distributed evenly on the bread. Pathetic if I'm being generous. I'd fire everyone if I was the KM. Do better!!!!! read more

Great spot for sandwiches! Quick service, nice and clean inside, and a great spot for lunch.

Oh my goodness. Order the chicken salad sandwich with lettuce, tomatoes and onions. Delicious! read more

This place is SOLID! From the customer service given by Shay, to the quality of the fresh ingredients I have to say I was very impressed. The place is really clean, the staff is very helpful and patient (newbies here so we had all of the questions lol) I was expect to eat only half on my sandwich but so glad I went ahead and ordered the whole thing, because I ate the entire thing! Definitely giving this place another visit. read more

See all

Food was eh and service was worse. The girl at the sandwich counter looked like she couldn't care less about being there. Had to restate our entire order for 3 people once we got to the cashier at the end of the line. My BLTC was mostly lettuce and very sad and disappointing. The rest of the food wasn't bad but don't think I would come back here anytime soon. It's called Picklemans Gourmet Cafe but not much gourmet about it read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - BLTC - Salad Near Me - Rogers, Arkansas

Very disappointed. Their pickles are verry small like Gherkins and yet they charge you money for each pickle you order. Will not be going back. I can go to other restaurants and pickles for free on the side read more

My grandson ( very picky eater) just said this is the best pizza ever! Square cut, less crust!

If you're looking for an expensive sandwich with no flavor, this is it! Over $30 for my husband and I to get a sandwich meal. Jersey mikes is better, jimmy John's is better, even subway. Not impressed. read more

I like Pickleman's. Great soup and sandwich combos! Can be noisy but a solid lunch place.

Beware. They will charge you more than the prices on the menu board. Ask for a receipt and check it. The menu board says soup is $5.99 but looked at my receipt and was charged $6.99. Soup was cold. Had to ask them to warm it for me. My husband had already finished his meal by the time they warmed my soup and gave it back to me. read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - 12 oz soup says 5.99 but rings up for 6.99. - Salad Near Me - Rogers, Arkansas

See all

Food was good. Small portions compared to most sub sandwiches. Service was average for today. The location was nice and quiet. The high prices will not compete with similar experiences read more

Was craving a sandwich but was talked into pizza when we arrived. It was way better than expected. 12" is a perfect size for two people, we even had left overs. Daughter liked the side of Mac and cheese too but it seems pretty pricey for the size. Add one drink and it was about $25 for dinner. Super friendly, fast service in a clean atmosphere. I will definitely be back to try their sandwiches. read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Sausage/pepperoni 12" pizza - Salad Near Me - Rogers, Arkansas

See all

We've driven by this place several times but finally stopped in to check it out. Glad we tried it, and here is our overall review with pros and cons: Pros: - Mayo has great flavor, makes for a very tasty sandwich - the staff was nice (unlike most of the reviews here) and followed all of our instructions on how we wanted our meal prepared - pizza was thin crust and crispy. We ended up taking several pieces home because I couldn't eat it all - cookies were good, chocolate and chewy - like a slightly more delicious version of a Subway cookie - staff were wearing masks for pandemic considerations which was nice Cons: - the sandwich was pretty small for the price - smaller than what you'd get at a place like Firehouse or Jersey Mike's at the same price - not a ton of difference in flavor - everything was extra: a drink was an additional $2.59 (a little steep & not even a combo), pickles are not included with the sandwich btw - one of the staff members wipes his nose with the same gloved hand he was prepping the sandwiches with - normally wouldn't be a big deal but with pandemic it matters a little more Overall I'm glad we went, we had a nice meal - both the pizza and sandwich were tasty with a nice cookie finish. Nothing extraordinary, but not as cringe as some other reviews. read more

See all

This place is absolutely amazing. The food was delicious and the staff was so nice! I highly recommend the Mac n cheese bowls. The pickles are the best definitely get a whole one. The strawberry lemonade was fantastic as well. I will definitely be coming back here!!! read more

Fast and friendly service with quality ingredients. Not processed. I would recommend for a lunch visit more than a dinner.

Very good sandwiches. Good quality meats and fresh veggies. Quick service and polite. Clean atmosphere and clean restaurant.

What a rip off! This place deserves to go out of business. I ordered a chicken salad sandwich and when I got home it was nothing more than a lettuce sandwich with a smear of chicken salad. At the most there were 3 tablespoons of chicken salad, for $8! I could buy a whole chicken with money leftover for that price. Will never go here again. It's simply a form of theft. read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Salad Near Me - Rogers, Arkansas

Oscar, Alice, and Kim were so nice! Employees are a 10! Food was also really good as well!

Strawberry lemonade is amazing! I have been to the location in Springdale and it was by far a better experience. Sandwiches at the Rogers location did not live up to the hype that I told my wife about after visiting the Springdale location. Service was okay. read more

Well first visit. Place smells amazing when you walk in. I ordered a meatball sub and half a pickle. The pickle was delicious, crisp and flavorful it won't disappoint. The meatball sandwich somewhat disappointingly. First off they put it through the oven and then wrap it in paper. I was not thrilled to have to pick the paper as it torn from my sandwich. Secondly, the meatballs were tasty but in general there was not enough marinara or tomato to balance out the sandwich. Probably would not order again. But my friend ordered a pizza and I had order envy. I had a piece of her pizza and it was delicious. I would order the pizza again and again. The pizza made me happy read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Meatball sandwich - Salad Near Me - Rogers, Arkansas

See all

Love this place - will come back next time I'm in town. I experienced wonderful service from the entire team. They were warm, helpful and efficient. And just a good local feeling - saying hi to customers by name as they walked in the door. So refreshing! My sandwich was toasted perfection. Great lunch - better service. Love it! Well done. read more

Awesome place awesome service but the price was way too expensive for a sandwich.. Also the portion was not very filling either but I would recommend this place the food was good but the price point is definitely too expensive for what it is. read more

We went to this restaurant in the mid afternoon. They weren't very busy but they had a steady stream of customers. We had a pepperoni pizza and a veggie sandwich with tomato bisque soup and a cookie. All the food was very good. It's mostly a self service restaurant. Restaurant was clean. Very polite staff. Food came out pretty quick. read more

My husband and I came here twice in three days! It is soooo good. The sandwiches are definitely the best. Their pizza is decent and their salads are super good too. The vibe inside is cute and updated. The first time we came, the staff was not super friendly or helpful, but the second day the staff was really friendly and helpful so it's a little touch and go with he service you will get, but the food was the same both days. It did take a little longer than I thought it should, but then again, the food was really good! read more

I love pickle man's pizza but yesterday I met the sweetest employee ever named Tony! She made our experience amazing!

I was craving a sandwich after just finishing up a walk on the trail nearby with my kids. I needed something convenient and quick. I placed an order online and luckily our food was prepared and ready quickly. I believe at the time they were only doing curbside orders (possibly delivery, not sure), so I pulled up and parked out front. There were other people parked out front as well. No one came to my car, but I called the number that was on the door and they brought my food out to me. Their sandwiches are a typical sub place, where you can order one of the ones off the menu or build your own. I usually build my own. We all enjoyed our sandwiches that day! read more

We have driven past this strip mall so many times but never stopped. We finally wondered what they had at Pickleman's and stopped in. Since then we have stopped 3 more times and will be back again. #9 Beef Sandwich is the best! Being from the Chicago area, it's the closest beef we have found down here! Today tho.......BEST BEEF SANDWICH EVER!!!!!!! Very clean and friendly Staff. Thank you!!!!! read more

Best Sandwich Ever!!!! The Cuban sandwich hits the spot. Highly recommend. Excellent place to have lunch. Staff was friendly and very helpful. read more

Rating on a scale of 1 to 10 for flavor would have to be 7.9, with the added information of cost and size my rating must drop to 6.5. (Large pizza was the size of everyone else's medium) price was $15.32. For being a sandwich shop... not bad. Well played pickle man. read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Pizza box - Salad Near Me - Rogers, Arkansas

The Roger's location is the best! It's always fast, friendly, fresh, and clean. Best cookies ever!

Always a good choice!! Great fresh sandwiches, salads and pizza's + friendly staff and consistently great food! We have made Pickleman's part of our go-to carry out rotation. And don't skip the cookie - they are hard to resist after you try them read more

Going to give 5 stars because you can really see where they are doing there best to be a quality place to eat. Food was very tasty ( sandwiches are small ) salads are huge . Got overcharged for my lunch one day but I'm sure it was an accident. Waits are a bit long , but they sandwiches are hand made so it's worth it. Been in town 6 days and eaten here twice. Great place read more

Pizza and sandwiches! The staff was good and place clean. Our first time and the kids loved the pepperoni pizza. One thing that was different and good was they give you some ranch sauce or rather you buy it and it goes really well with the pizza! Hope to actually try their subs next time read more

Took the family in to try on a Sunday afternoon. Tried the Italian Club. I thought it was very good. Came out toasted and just like I ordered. Restaurant was clean and service was good. Be sure and try the chocolate chip cookies. read more

I love the barbecue Buffalo pizza! It's a unique find that strikes a great balance between savory, sweet, and tangy. A wonderful option if you are a fan of blue cheese. We typically order delivery through their website and they really beat Uber eats, door dash, etc. Food is always prepared fast and delivered fast. It's a quaint little lunch or dinner spot and everyone is always very nice. One of our top picks in Rogers. read more

Obviously it's a franchise store. But I have been here several times there is almost always plenty of employees working today I counted eight! I really enjoy the number 15 buffalo chicken sandwich and the gluten-free pepperoni is my kids favorite. I definitely recommend this place read more

You just can't go wrong great selection great food fast service and they're Dickson st location saves lives

Great deli for soup, sandwiches and pizza. On our first visit I was intrigued by the Italian beef sandwich. As a Chicago native I was skeptical. The meat was the real deal. Served on a lovely toasted ciabatta style roll and served with au jus it was excellent. My son snagged an Italian deli meat sandwich and we ended up sharing--his sandwich was also excellent. A few days later I went back and had pizza. Although a little pricey, the ingredients were good quality and the crust very thin. Can't wait to go back when the weather cools to try the soup offerings. The atmosphere is neat. We love Pickleman's!!!! read more