Cancel

Open app

Search

Penny Lick Ice Cream

5.0 (1 review)
Closed • Closed

Order Penny Lick Ice Cream Takeout or Delivery

Penny Lick Ice Cream Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

More like Penny Lick Ice Cream

Recommended Reviews - Penny Lick Ice Cream

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Penny Lick Ice Cream

You might also consider

Pros & Cones - Ricotta Cream Cheese with Fig

Pros & Cones

4.3(24 reviews)
1.0 mi

I visited on a hot weekend afternoon. It's very cute inside with stuffies and greenery…read more Step up and checkout the flavors! Most are pretty standard, though there are different ones, like coconut blackberry. I got a taste of the pistachio, which was very good. The person scooping was here and there, but there's a bell in case you need any help.

Worst customer service I've experienced at "Influential Ice Cream"!…read more There's a reason this place was empty while Ralph's and Paleteria Fernandez had lines out the door. As a lifelong Westchester resident, my friends and I noticed this new ice cream shop after dinner and decided to check it out. As we walked by, an employee (a man wearing glasses) came outside and asked if we wanted to try some samples. At the time, the store was completely empty. Two of us went inside while the other three stayed outside. I mentioned, "My friends are just shy about trying new things." He immediately responded, "That's something r*tarded to say," and turned his back to me. Another employee then asked if I'd like to try a sample, but after being spoken to that way, I declined. My friend and I left without ordering and went to the ice cream shop down the street instead, where there was a line out the door. Customer service is what keeps people coming back, especially in Westchester. Everyone has bad days, but there's no excuse for speaking to a potential customer that way. I genuinely hope this employee learns to treat people with more respect, because no one should be made to feel unwelcome for simply walking into a business.

Photos
Pros & Cones - Modern and cozy atmosphere to enjoy your ice cream

Modern and cozy atmosphere to enjoy your ice cream

Pros & Cones - Interior is beautiful!

Interior is beautiful!

Pros & Cones - Inside

See all

Inside

Sal's Pizzeria

Sal's Pizzeria

4.1(510 reviews)
1.0 mi
•$

I live in Laguna Beach, CA and Mom lives in White Plains. Whenever I'm back East, Sal's is always a…read moremust and well worth a visit. The amazing white pie is nothing like we have back West, the friendly vibe, fast service and a classic pizza shop everyone should try. RIP SAL and thanks for your tasty legacy!

Tough to review just a quick stop by the slice. I heard Sal's outdoes everyone else in this part of…read moreWestchester, so I accompanied my pizza fiend - oops, friend - down to Mamaroneck to check them out. And this is a place worth checking out. Old-school vibe inside, not at all like the new-wave joints around. You can tell Sal's has been here for generations, which means they do it right. You walk in, there's a pizza counter to the left, a few tables to the right, some more in the back... and a hidden whole other room! So there will be room for you to enjoy your meal. This review is divided for now. My friend got cheese slices. They're big, thin, covered just right in cheese - win. Crust just the right toasty to hold the slice up. Classic NY pizza we got here - everyone in Fairfield County should visit. I peeked over at the other table and they had Sicilian slices that also look legit, if that's your thing. Plenty of cheese, soft crust, all that. Then there's my side. I had looked at the BBQ place next door and decided "nah, too contrived", so when I discovered the neat-looking slices on their platter were BBQ chicken, I went for them. Well, they actually didn't come out that hot. The thickness of the meat probably got in the way. Then there's the fact they were white slices (since BBQ sauce gets in the way of tomato sauce), but not hepped up with ricotta or other white cheese inside. I'd make those suggestions for improvement. There are also some other bizarre slices on offer - they're not afraid of variety! I'd steer clear of the salad pizza though. So based on just the one visit and everything I saw and tasted - 4 stars. I would want to get a whole pie next time for a fresh-baked experience, see how quickly that goes and if it's done just right. I doubt my review will drop, but it could rise up to 5. To be continued... ... So, I came back a second time with my friend. This time, I wasn't even feeling the pizza vibe, so I went with a meatball... wedge. Which is a sub if you're not from the area. Don't be scared by the name. It was tasty, but as I expected, just meatball, cheese, and some sauce. Actually a better balance of sauce to cheese than the pizzas, I thought. I was a little perturbed that our visiting friend's white slice is just pure ricotta, no white sauce below, no mozz on top. From my second experience, I'm keeping it at 4 stars.

Photos
Sal's Pizzeria
Sal's Pizzeria
Sal's Pizzeria

See all

Penny Lick Ice Cream - icecream - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...