Top notch pastry, delicious sweet and savory options, creative, well-balanced flavors and fillings and excellent vegetarian options...what's not to like? Did I mention the pleasant store environment and friendly, attentive service? Yeah, they gots! A neighborhood bakery that could seriously become a regular thing. Give them a try, and support this talented local shop! read more

This is a great establishment! You have a rustic downtown type of theme. The customer service is great. Every time I ordered anything it came out absolutely delicious. The only real I didn't give this 5 stars is because they seem to be closed a lot. Somehow every time I swing by they are closed. read more

What a hidden gem! I got a perfectly made, Raspberry Rhubarb 10" pie with a lattice top, coarse sugar on top. Wow. This was the best pie I've ever tasted. Blew Snohomish Pie Co out of the water. They also have mini pie options - I got the apple crumb - wow. Also got a loaf of fresh baked sourdough and will 100% be going back for more! A must try in Mount Vernon! read more

Pegasus Pie - Mini pie, handhelds, biscuits - oh my! - Bakeries Near Me - Mount Vernon, Washington

Super friendly service from Taylor who convinced me to try the tayberry (blackberry and cherry) hand pie, she said it was named after her. The pie was super flavorful, not too tart or too sweet, the pastry wasn't too thick either, just the perfect amount. Also got the toffee almond cookie with flaky sea salt, superb, chewy, crispy. However, I ate the rest later and found it to be too salty. Also got the cold brew and one of the lotus energy drinks, overall great offerings and super service. read more

Pegasus Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Mount Vernon, Washington

See all

Cute space with coffee shop vibes but with lots of pie! They have mini pies and hand pies in all flavors, cookies, and coffee. Nice place to sit with a coffee and snack or to carry out your favorite flavors. We tried blueberry peach and cherry hand pies which were as big as a slice of pie. The service was friendly and helpful. read more

See all

i'm not going to let an opportunity to try a new dessert/pastry shop pass me by. so i pulled over in the pouring rain and decided on a cherry hand pie to go so that it could become tonight's dessert. the shop is cute, with plenty of places to sit and lots of options, both savory and sweet. there's a self service water decanter and drinks and pastries to choose from ordering at the counter. i'm curious what the patronage is like in terms of locals vs visitors. for people passing through mt. vernon this will be another option in the downtown sector where they can take a load off and grab something to raise their waning blood sugar. thinking ahead a few months, they should be able to do a rocking business once the tulip festival rolls around. read more

Pegasus Pie - saturday afternoon selection - Bakeries Near Me - Mount Vernon, Washington

See all

Great and friendly service, and the marionberry hand pie was delish!!! Next time I'm in the area I'll be back! read more

Pegasus Pie - Marionberry hand pie - Bakeries Near Me - Mount Vernon, Washington

Great costumer service and even better pies. Stop on by if you are passing through right off the highway, easy off and easy on. read more

Pegasus Pie - Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Mount Vernon, Washington

Forgot to take pictures of the food before eating it because it was just so GOOD! I ordered a Caprese Panini and a Raspberry Rhubarb Hand Pie. The Caprese Panini was AMAZING. The cheese was smooth and very stretchy and the flavors were all there. The hand pie was so flaky that it stuck to my chapstick. You can tell the pies were made fresh. My friend and I decided to eat there because the ambiance felt as though you were sitting in a cozy cafe. The service was also very swift. Coming back here often with my friend!! (Picture was from my friend) read more

Pegasus Pie - Strawberry Rhubarb Hand Pie and Veggie Chili - Bakeries Near Me - Mount Vernon, Washington

Very excellent pie. We got it warmed up and ate it in the cafe with some ice cream -- it was sooo good. So simple but made really well. Wasn't very busy in on a weekday afternoon, we came after visiting the tulips. Soo worth a stop for some delicious pies. read more

Pegasus Pie - Marionberry pie with vanilla ice cream - Bakeries Near Me - Mount Vernon, Washington

I rarely write reviews, but this place was just way too good not to. This was the absolute best pastry place I've ever gone too. The hand pie pastry crust was amazing. You have to try the jalapeño cheddar biscuit. Also, delicious coffee! read more

We stopped by after seeing tulips. Located in downtown near the co-op is Pegasus Pie, a cute modern coffee and pie shop. They are currently have construction so there isn't much room to sit inside. We ordered a rhubarb pie and a toffee chocolate chip cookie. One review said it was better than Snohomish Pie Co. The crust and crunchy crumble does make me love this pie more too! I was surprised! But the contrast of soft filling with the flaky crust and crunchy topping was delicious! The cookie was a bit too sweet for me, I'd order a plain chocolate chip one in the future. Definitely worth a stop if you're in Mount Vernon! read more

See all

I love this place! I am a dasher for DoorDash, usually in Oak Harbor. I have had to be in Mount Vernon in the early mornings and discovered this gem...so cute! I stopped in this morning to sample the foods for myself. We ordered a cheesy potato pocket pie and a veggie quiche with our coffees. The food was as wonderful as the service. We will definitely be back! read more

See all

We wanted a good Marionberry Pie for Thanksgiving, I knew exactly where to go for that, I had tried a small Pegasus Pie earlier this year, so I went back in to see what I could find. I ordered a 9" pie and picked it up the next day. The price of the pie was a little shocking at first, but after considering the downtown Mount Vernon location, the quality of the pie, and that they most likely pay their employees a living wage, I gladly paid it. After telling my son how much the pie was he stated "it better be life changing". Well I am here to say that the Marionberry pie was a life changing experience, one of the best pies I've had since my grandmother passed away 20 years ago, and she made really good berry pies. The crust is soooo good, just perfect, and the consistency of the pie filling was spot on, and held up for days after without drying out. I was also impressed with the bakery back behind the scenes, I would have asked for a tour if the weren't so busy. Thank you Pegasus Pie, it's nice to see a successful business in downtown Mount Vernon. read more

Pegasus Pie - Marionberry Pie, absolute perfection! - Bakeries Near Me - Mount Vernon, Washington

Fantastic bakery with scones and hand pies in the AM, and savory pies, quiche, etc by lunchtime. Everything fresh, everything seasonal. And a great coffee bar/barista as well. You can even watch the bakers in the back doing their craft. read more

Excellent hand pies and on the weekends amazing biscuits and gravy. Favorite combo is jalapeño cheddar biscuit with mushroom gravy -- so good! Sometimes there isn't much in the pastry case and service at times can be a bit of a wait for hot items, but I hope as this place continues to grow in popularity those things will be resolved. Very cute and cozy stop for a Saturday morning breakfast. read more

Pegasus Pie - Historic and cozy feel - Bakeries Near Me - Mount Vernon, Washington

See all

I'm not sure if this is the normal size, but I was very disappointed and it wasn't even heated up read more

Pegasus Pie - This was a slice of quiche after tip it was $8.70 - Bakeries Near Me - Mount Vernon, Washington

Husband and I each got a slice of quiche, and a couple of mochas. The mochas were perfectly made, and the quiche was so tasty. We will be back to try the wonderful assortment they offer. read more

I must say the service, the layout of food and the smells are great. The prices are good too - even for the day old baked treasures. Yummy goodnesses! read more

Pies cookies where delicious will be back on our next visit - staff wonderful and a smile highly recommended

I purchased the best apple pie yesterday. The crust was perfect, the apples were crisp and plentiful. I also tried their marionberry pie last week and it was just as delicious. They do an excellent job combined with great service. Their sour dough bread was soft inside with a perfect crispy crust. read more

We were traveling from Seattle to visit friends in Lynden & stopped here for a bite to eat. I chose it because I just love pie & they have both savory and sweet ones. I chose a veggie hand pie while my husband got a veggie samosa one. They both were outstanding!! We liked that the pies were well filled with tasty vegetables and gravy. What really stands out about the pies here is the unbelievably flaky, buttery crust! It is almost like a croissant with the golden layers that easily flake off. These bakers know how to make pie crust ultra buttery. For dessert we shared a strawberry rhubarb hand pie which was the best I've ever eaten. I'm a baker myself & make a delicious all butter pie crust, but this was on a level above. We will make this a regular stop when we're in the area. read more

I purchased a small pie at the Anacortes Farmer's Mkt and was very disappointed in the lack of filling. The pie was mostly crust and very little fruit. The owner did not get back with me after 2 messages left for her. When I finally went into the store to talk to her she was completely unconcerned about my issue and had no interest in me as a customer. I left there very annoyed and will not go back or recommend this business. This is a beautiful store front in old downtown MV. It probably has some good product. But if the owner doesn't learn how to take criticism and treat customers with respect her business won't survive. read more

Pegasus Pie - The inside of the pie was less than half filling. - Bakeries Near Me - Mount Vernon, Washington

Best peanut butter Reese's cup cookie anywhere. I had mine fresh from the oven at the Anacortes Farmer's market. I will be visiting the Mt Vernon shop soon! read more

A great coffee shop and and bakery. Great place to come study or meet someone for coffee and a treat!

I called Pegasus Pie shortly after they closed on Pi Day. They were still cleaning up and said they would let me stop by to make a purchase. The owner was kind and the hand pies were delicious. I could not have had a better experience. I am a definite repeat customer. read more

This is a nice little place. When we were there a lot of people came in to look but left. Service was excellent, with a lot of help. We went mid-afternoon and they only had a little bit of savory pies, bought a hand pie to bring home. Then we split a mini pecan pie with coffee and ate it there. The crust on the pie was excellent, the pecan filling very good. They do now have soup and had 2 different ones available today. The cookies looked very good but pie was enough of an afternoon snack for us. It is a pleasant space with good service and excellent pies! Recommend you go to check it out and actually by a cookie or pie! read more

Best pies around. The crust is flake upon flake. The taste is irresistible, keeps you coming back for more. Coffee is fabulous. Avocado sour dough,balsamic,tomato feta is bomb. House made everything with high quality products. Did I mention the fresh baked potato bread. I can't give it enough credit to all the hand made special care items. You won't be disappointed. read more

We got all flavors of cookies, the brownie and a shaved ice. Cookies were superb! Brownie was a bit more on the dark/bittersweet side for my liking but my sister enjoyed it. The shaved ice was amazing! The shop is very cute to sit and enjoy your treats. read more

Cute little place with fabulous crust. The raspberry hand pie was delicious, and the peanut butter cookies were the best I've ever had. The staff was so friendly and sweet. The menu the day I was there was ovo-lacto vegetarian; I am not aware of they ever serve meat since the offerings do change. The highlight of my visit was the MEDITERRANIAN AVOCADO TOAST.... Oh my! I will go back just to have this alone! Great house-made bread (toasted) with avocado, sweet cherry tomatoes, fresh basil, feta cheese, and balsamic vinegar drizzled on top. It was so good. 4/5 stars is only because of the prices, which seem a bit on the high side. Example: the peanut butter cookies, albeit large, were $4 each. I hope this business does great and sticks around! read more

Just simply fantastic pies!! Try the Maple Burbon Pecan, triple berry, or raspberry/ruhbarb .....

We've been a few times, and everything has been delicious. Friendly staff, too. Good for takeout or a pleasant sitdown.

After a quick Google search and a need for a pie I found Pegasus pies. So I drove from Arlington to Mount Vernon to get a pie. As a specialty store I figured this would be the perfect place to buy one. Well, it turns out they don't have pies for sale. You have to order them in advance. A pie store with no pies. I admit I'm an old gen X guy so I expect pies in a pie store. Not unlike a liquor store having liquor, or a butcher having meat, Chinese restaurant having Chinese food etc. Maybe this is some pronoun thing where you can just identify as to what you want to be. "I'm a pie store". Sell pies? "Nope", but I identify as a pie store. Whatever, I'll buy something at Haggens. read more