Paul Evans just catered a traditional New England clambake in the community room of my condominium for 60 people. They were amazing, and friends who are in the catering business who attended the party could not believe what a great job they did. From set up to final clean up Paul Evans was flawless. They never let our guests have a dirty or empty plate in front of them, and all the food was fresh, hot and delicious! Although the meal was pricy, everyone agreed that the quality of the food and service justified the price. read more

new ownership since 2020 I'm sorry to say this .. save yourself some trouble go elsewhere anywhere it was actually embarrassing to serve that quality of food read more

Getting some food for our SEADER from Paul . His menus are always a cut above without being so different ! Easy to work with and get just what you need rather than a menu filled with things your not going to use. I love that the fruit platter is deconstructed So I get to use my platters yet filled with decorated pieces to make it look special I would have given 5 stars but the delivery charge is high considering that it's a limited distance- so we'll pick up read more

ordered food for Passover for the last day of Passover. had to throw away the entire order. food had spoiled and there was mold growing on the potato kuggel. chicken was so dry I couldn't cut it. the gefilte fish was like rubber. I called to complain and the owner said he never had any complaints like this. didn't apologize but said he wouldn't charge me but he had already run my card and I didn't get reimbursed. I stopped payment on my card. they are new owners . would never have happened with the original owners. read more

Another great experience with Paul Evans/Tibbles. We actually used them twice in a two-week span; once for an engagement party and then for a 70th birthday party. The engagement party was buffet style (no staff) and then birthday party was passed appetizers and dessert (3 staff). For both, the food was great, and there was plenty of it. We were all truly blown away by the birthday party and the professionalism and attitudes of the team working. They did a great job of setting everything up, interacting with the guests, and then cleaning up. It was really wonderful! Thanks again Paul Evans Catering for a couple of great events! read more

We selected Paul Evans to cater our rehearsal dinner at my house on Long Island on September 5th 2015 after seeing the great variety of food that they provided and after going in for a tasting. The quality of the food and service as phenomenal and we really enjoyed working with Paul leading up to the event. Paul was very understanding of our budget and logistical questions and assisted us in every way possible. On the day of we were blown away with the quality of service (we already knew the food was going to be awesome an dirt definitely did not disappoint). The staff arrived well in advance of the start of the event and was ready to go once we finished the rehearsal in my backyard. Everyone loved the passed hourdervs outside were amazing and the sit down meal was everything we could have hoped it to be. The setup of the tables and rentals were exactly what we envisioned and the meal ran like a five star restaurant. After the meal, the staff returned the house looking exactly as it was before the event. In summary when hiring Paul Evans 'a.k.a. Tibbles' you are not hiring a caterer, but instead you are turning your event space into a five star restaurant with extreme attention to detail, friendly staff, and al all around amazing time! read more

I could not have been happier with the great food and service. I had a small Christmas dinner with duck, filet, grilled vegetables and mashed potatoes. Everything was perfect!!! I will be using Paul Evans from now on! read more

Our Halloween party this past Saturday, catered by Paul Evans/Tbls of Island Park, was wonderful. This is about the 4th or 5th time we have used them, and as usual, they did not disappoint. The staff they provided (Liz and Trish the Servers, Donato the Bartender, and Matt the Chef) arrived at 6:00 for set up of our party, which started at 8:00 pm. They took over my kitchen and went to work. The result was wonderful, from the delicious and creative food, to the creative buffet table set up, to the terrific Bar Tending, to the attentive and professional service! My kitchen was cleaner when they left than when they first arrived! The party was a resounding success, and we can't wait for our next event with Paul Evans Caterers. read more

We hired Paul Evans to cater my cousin's birthday party. Rachel worked with us to create the perfect menu, with delicious options, fairly priced. The food was fabulous,;presentation lovely; on-time delivery with no glitches. This was a fussy family crowd--very sophisticated palates--and everyone gave the food enthusiastic, rave reviews. Couldn't have been happier. read more

We catered a Fathers Day BBQ dinner from Paul Evans and the food was absolutely delicious!! If you have not tried them yet, you definitely should!! I highly recommend them!!! read more

I asked Paul Evans to cater my friend's baby shower this past weekend. I chose the "English Tea Party" package, and it was a huge hit. Many of the guests commented on the variety and quality of the food. Portions were generous, and the price was reasonable. Communication before the event was prompt and smooth. The food was delivered right on time. I couldn't have asked for a better experience. Thank you for helping make the shower a success! read more

Paul Evans was recommended to me by a few people who lives in the area. We were throwing a Housewarming party/birthday celebration for about 70 adults and 25 kids. We decided to do pass hors d'oeuvres and a kids station with chicken fingers, mac and cheese and mini hot dogs. My guests cannot stop raving about the food and the staffs. They came about a hour before to set up and change into their uniforms and set up the bar area. I didnt have to worry about anything and I will def use them again for my next party!! The price was reasonable for the selection of food and amount of people. They left me with a ton of desserts that was leftover. Some food was left but not much- the guests couldnt stop eating!! Amazing and professionals at what they do! read more

We use Paul Evans for all our corporate events. They are extremely professional and always on time. The food is incredible. Kevin is awesome. Evan is a genius when it comes to building a menu. Our holiday party this year was awesome due to Paul Evans great menu! read more

Catered a BBQ package for my daughters graduation party. Kevin and his crew did a great job. The food was spot and everyone enjoyed their meal. The burgers, chicken were tasty and the grilled shrimp app was a hit. Crew was professional and the event was effortless. read more

Paul, please allow me to gush a bit about you, the food and your staff. EVERYTHING was just outstanding. You are the consummate professional and are obviously superior at providing your customers with an unforgettably excellent experience. We and our guests were thrilled with the delicious food and presentation. Your staff is magnificent: helpful, knowledgeable, exceedingly efficient and delightfully nice. The weather was perfect, as was the joyous confluence of family and friends celebrating our daughter's upcoming wedding. Your culinary skill and masterful management of this happy affair made it that more magical. If you are looking for the BEST---THIS is your caterer!!!!!!! read more

We used them last week for a rehearsal dinner for 100, on the beach. They were BAD. #1. Menu was steak, chicken, and salmon; they forgot to bring salmon, Mgr said "nothing could be done about it", I drove to Citarella (BH) and purchased 4 lbs of organic salmon to satisfy those guests who required fish. #2. I received a call, email, and pics from Town Parks Dept re: improper waste disposal, and other violations of MY beach permit by their actions. #3. I call Evan (principal) to discuss these issues and he screams at me telling me that he knows there was no trash and this was our fault for not taking leftovers (what an asshole), I indicate a willingness to assist the Town in revoking their license and explain my true feelings prior to terminating call. I receive call from Evan (principal) seemingly accepting responsibility for all mistakes and seeking to satisfy all, I explain that the damage is done and I don't know how to fix the matter. STAY AWAY!!!! read more

Catered 4 parties over the past 18 months with them. 50 to 75 people at each event. Great food, great presentation, great service. Was pleased to later hear that 3 of my guests then used them for their business party events! Love the buffet main dish finger food! read more

Having just moved into a nice new house, we wanted to have a really glam housewarming party that we planned to fall on Memorial Day weekend. The attire was dress to the 9's cocktail attire, we had a St. Tropez style house music Dj, full bar and bartender and hired Paul Evans for the catering. We requested that everything be butler pass style, and have a high end presentation. Let me just say that they were AMAZING! They sent a chef and two servers that wore cute little tuxedos. The staff was soooo nice and so accommodating to everything. They set up in a room not included in the party and did all the plating and kept a nice clean kitchen while cooking. The presentation was so nice and they were VERY good at timing and at making enough rounds with the food. We had a variety of appetizers, then we had mini passed meals. of duck, lamb and crab sliders, followed by a variety of desserts. They also set up a dip station that was really cute. All of our guests are still raving about the food and have told us the food was what really made the party! Also I have to mention the for one of the appetizers they did a noddle dish served in the cutest mini Chinese take out boxes and for dessert they served a chocolate orange martini in martini glasses, that looked so elegant! We are just really please and highly recommend them. They are also really reasonable in pricing in comparison to say Elegant Affairs who we also looked at. We plan on using them again for sure! read more

Small office party catered by Paul Evans. Food was very good. Staff was attentive. Very easy to plan. They supplied the food, bartender and servers. We planned an outdoor party but the weather did not cooperate and we had to move indoors to a much smaller place and they made it work. read more

We have used Paul Evans over the years for many different and have never been disappointed. The food and service is consistently excellent. Our guests have often raved about the food and have opted to call Paul Evans for their own parties. read more