Best pizza in the area!! Other menu items are also…read moredelicious. This is an absolute family favorite and you won't be disappointed.

Moved up here from Chicago a year ago and haven't found good pizza until today. Finally!!!! Pizza…read morewas AMAZING. Service was great. Definitely worth the thirty minute drive. I will be back

Awesome stop for the whole fam. Spicy, sweet, savory, all the bases. Plus they have VEGAN options…read moreincluding non dairy cheese, tradition red sauce and the traditional crust are also vegan. Service is fast and easy. Chill vibe with good tunes. They used to turn this place into a dance party at nights but I don't know if they still do it.

The concept is good. Pick what you want and they make it. Not too many seats but what was there was…read moreclean. The pizza was decent but the dough was a bit tough to bite through.

Delicious as always, and even though they were crazy busy last night we didn't wait long at all. I…read morehad pan fried walleye and a French onion soup, they were both fantastic with my Moscow mule. Never had a bad meal here and the ambiance and wait/bar staff are warm and welcoming.

While staying at a cabin on vacation, we were craving pizza and decided to give this spot a try. A…read morelocal mentioned the crust might be soggy, but that definitely wasn't our experience. The pizza was delicious with a crunchy, sturdy crust that held up perfectly. The wings were also really tasty and hit the spot. Service was friendly and prompt, which made the meal even better. If we're ever back in the area, we'd happily come here again.

So the beer here is on the better side of average -- perfectly serviceable but not necessarily…read morestandout representations of their respective styles. As a rule, I tend to rate breweries and brewpubs first and foremost on the the quality of their beer. On that basis a 3.5 star rating would be appropriate. But the ambience and atmosphere here is so inviting and comfortable that it shows just how much these elements can bring to the hospitality experience. That said, I'd rather drink great beer in a barn than terrible beer in a Vanderbilt mansion. But honestly I would come here just to hang out and play board games even if I weren't drinking the beer Speaking of which, a crucial part of that ambiance is NO SCREENS. I'm not averse to catching a college ball game on a Saturday afternoon at a corner pub, but this isn't the place for that. Any uproarious excitement from the clientele will instead be on account of a competitive game of Uno.

Nice surprise while i was out for an out of area Harley ride, great little local place, they are a…read morenano brewery so lots of different rotating types of beers.... I didnt try any beers on tap that i disliked! Pizza looks amazing, heard lots of compliments on it! Located in the small town of Coloma so the patrons are pretty much very nice locals. I'll be back!

Service is great!! Small local bar but didn't make us feel out of place! Daily specials and lots of…read morebar food options.

Great pizza, burgers and fish fry. Classic. Always friendly with great service. Not the largest…read moreplace but very well run.

Oh my goodness--I truly felt like I was back in Italy while dining at Mike's! My husband and I…read morefirst met Mike when he was part owner of Mama Mia's on the square in Baraboo, and now he's opened his own restaurant as the sole owner. Mike immigrated here legally from Albania and became a U.S. citizen, and you can taste the pride he puts into every dish--everything is homemade, even the pasta. I had the spicy chicken arrabbiata with Alfredo sauce, and it was absolutely delicious. The homemade garlic knots were mouthwatering, and the salads were fresh and crisp. My friend ordered the shrimp pasta and loved it. I also brought home two pizzas for my family, and they said it was the best pizza they've ever had! The service was excellent, and the restaurant itself is spacious with a great bar area. From now on, Mike's Italian Restaurant will be our go-to spot whenever we're in Baraboo. If you're in the area, give Mike a try--you won't be disappointed!

This was our favorite restaurant we visited during our vacation! The food was amazing and the…read moreservice was above and beyond. We had delicious garlic bread and I got the spaghetti limon special which was great. Everything tasted homemade and fresh and it was a very kid friendly place. Our server Cody was so kind to our daughter.

We were in town after spending time on a local lake and needed to find some grub. Not a ton of…read moreoptions but, OPG topped the list. Everyone enjoyed their burgers: Mushroom & Swiss, Pizza Burger, and a pair of bacon cheeseburgers. Fries, onion rings and cheese curds were on point as well. For a Saturday afternoon we enjoyed the ambiance. Soccer on all but one television and lots of helpful folks making sure we were taken care of. We'll be back, for sure.

Food was good, but the service was sweet. Very much a small town gathering spot which made a for a…read morefun time!

The pizzas were great. Garlic bread too thick and very dry. Italian beef sandwich and calzones…read moredidn't have much meat or fillings. Disappointing lunch for all the hype this place gets.

Food is always excellent here! The margarita pizza is a must! Get extra marinara because it's so…read moregood for dipping. Calzones are great along with pasta! Garlic bread is large and not the best. Only bummer they don't offer any milk or drinks for kids.

We stopped there today on a Sunday after visiting the awesome Shamba Safari outside Neshkoro. The…read morefood was spectacular and plentiful! The gyro plate my daughter in law ordered had the best gyro meat I have EVER tasted. She ate her fill and still had enough for another meal. My chicken tenders were huge and so good. The serving staff/bartenders were super friendly, busy, and very accommodating. The prices were very reasonable. I can't wait to go there again! Plus, there is a candy and ice cream store next door for dessert!

Gyro is amazing. Wings are best in Montello for sure. I have not had the burger but see a lot of…read morepeople order them. Bartenders are always welcoming and quick with refills.