The pizzas were great. Garlic bread too thick and very dry. Italian beef sandwich and calzones didn't have much meat or fillings. Disappointing lunch for all the hype this place gets. read more

Food is always excellent here! The margarita pizza is a must! Get extra marinara because it's so good for dipping. Calzones are great along with pasta! Garlic bread is large and not the best. Only bummer they don't offer any milk or drinks for kids. read more

I ordered a pizza for delivery to evergreen campsites. I called to make sure they delivered to the campsite. I was told yes on the phone. The driver sat at the gate and turned around. After I called they came back to the gate with a cold soggy pizza. I would never order carry out again. The pizza was soggy and disgusting. read more

We've been ordering for years and residents. Ordered 2 kid chicken Alfredo, an adult chicken Alfredo, and a chicken Alfredo add spinach. Order arrived timely. However no garlic bread, which is included...called and was told it's a courtesy and they were out. read more

In the past the food and service has been great. But I ordered delivery tonight and I was given a salad instead of the lasagna I ordered. I called the store and they said the driver made a mistake and that he would be bringing my correct order back to me and exchanging it for the incorrect order I received. By the time the driver came back and I ate, the lasagne was barely lukewarm. I am/was a frequent customer but I'll be avoiding Christiano's at least for the near future. read more

Nice place to eat , good service good food ! Enjoy the lunch specials in Wautoma , wishing the one in Appleton was open at lunch time !

The best pizza joint in the area. Garlic bread and pizza is huge an well worth the money.

OUTSTANDING! We love Christiano's Pizza! We're from Racine, Wisconsin for 50+ years... known for different kinds of kringles, pizzas and lots more...Since we've moved here we've tried quite a few different so-called "pizza" places . . .they just don't compare to Christiano's Pizza... We love our pizza if it's done right...Christiano's Pizza does just that...Delivered fast right to the front door...HOT... We will continue to have Christiano's Pizza ...The best ... from Don and Marion of Don's COMPUTER Services, Repairs, Sales . . . 920 787 9100 read more

In these times of restaurants consistently looking for help, it was crazy good to walk in and see multiple servers and a ton of cooks. We each ordered a medium pizza a piece cuz who doesn't love left over pizza. We ordered the gourmet, marqarita and shrimp made to order. Delicious pizzas that come out fast and hot. Great service too. And of course, loved the left overs. read more

I came here while visiting some friends, and was very pleasantly surprised! My friend had actually ordered a pizza to go from work, but we called shortly thereafter passing through town and wanting to go to dinner. Staff took our friend's pizza and changed it from to-go to dine-in. Our service was great and everyone at the restaurant was super nice. The place was very spacious and had some really neat decorations. I shared a veggie pizza with the third friend, and it was delicious. A pretty standard beer selection, but we all found something to drink. If you're in the area, I highly recommend stopping here for some pizza! They do have other Italian food options... but pizza is my favorite! read more

See all

Delivery driver left order outside the door in the middle of winter. No knock, no doorbell, and no phone call. When I called the restaurant I was told to look outside- really? Sure enough it was sitting there in the freezing cold! Never again Christianos - totally unacceptable! read more

Food was great! Everything tasted amazingly delicious!!! The service is always great!! The lighting could be a little brighter but the ambiance is pretty perfect!! read more

Christianos Pizza - Meatball appetizer - Pizza Near Me - Wautoma, Wisconsin

So.... The cheesy bread sticks, weren't very cheesy and the bread chewy. Tasted ok, but missed somehow. The thin crust pizza was severely lacking in quantity. Seems like it should have been more. The place is LOUD. Echos everywhere and with radio and telephone on LOUD. Plus patrons with noisy kids. On top of that, the pizza " chef" fount it funny to drop something very heavy and loud, probably a wooden pallet. He and the other "servers " peaked around the corner to see if they got a rise out of anyone. VERY CHILDISH. The decor is nice buy to many hard surfaces to reflect sound. read more

In the past we have found the food to be very good. This past trip the pizza was cardboard, hoping this was a one time thing. They are very busy and well thought of so I think this was a one time thing. read more

My boyfriend literally told me the pizza was not very good here, I decided to get delivery anyways ( all the way to wild rose!) they didn't bring my drink I ordered with the pizza and honestly he was right, the pizza was awful. I cant pin point exactly what it was but it did not taste good. It's hard for me not to like pizza bc it's so simple but man, I was definitely disappointed. Maybe one day I'll try something else & my review will be retracted but until then... pizza sucks read more

Real ingredients and flavorful! Generous portions and wonderful family. A wonderful experience.

I have been a long time customer of Christianos. I usually get the same 2 things every time for myself for years. Today I ordered delivery. I gave specific instructions including what decor I have in my yard ( I am literally the only one with Halloween stuff out). I watched the driver pass by, then turn around and come back. Then as I was starting to eat I remembered that I had ordered a 2 liter of coke, double check my electronic receipt its on there so I call, he brings it back in a few minutes, thank you. I finish eating and open my salad, no dressing, Ok I have dressing at home no need to call. I always get the tomato basil pesto, today I think I had noodles in a water sauce with pesto in it. I have noticed their food has slowly been declining for years which is sad. There is no consistency between the cooks. Sometimes the pasta is drenched in oil, sometimes is so creamy I can't stir it. For an almost 35$ pasta delivered on the other side of town they really should be doing better. read more

A good pizza. Not the best I have had by far but a good thin crust pizza. If I'm rolling through again and hungry for pizza I might stop, but I don't think I will drive 35 minutes for it again. Price is fair, service was good. read more

Delicious food and adorable inside! Love this place! Pizza was great and service was fast and friendly!

Christiano's pizza, pasta, and garlic bread are the best, reasonably priced and always hot and fresh!

We ordered to go pizza and cheese bread and couldn't wait to get back to our lodge to start eating. Fantastic taste, generous toppings, friendly staff, great pricing! A must! read more

I have no idea what they changed in the sauce recipe l, but, it has gone from being delicious to being mediocre (do not order it again]. Over the past 3-5 years it has gone from favorable to becoming bland. Expansion at the cost of quality? Twice does not mean a third chance. read more

We stopped in for a quick lunch and I as surprised to see they now have wine on the menu. My sister suggested splitting a pannini. We chose the chicken and artichoke. The sandwich arrived and it was huge! Do glad we decided to split it. We also each tried a cup of the daily soup, the roasted red pepper. The sandwich and the soup were both delicious and well made. Service was prompt and friendly. Do glad Wautoma has this as a go to. read more

Christianos Pizza - Roasted red pepper soup - Pizza Near Me - Wautoma, Wisconsin

We stopped in for lunch today since we were in Wautoma. I had never been in the restaurant and upon entry, you are met by the hostess. I noticed that even though the building is old, the interior was newer (it had that small town feel to it) and it was clean. We ordered a Italian sausage and a meatball sandwich to go. I was told the wait would be 15 minutes and it was just that. The reason for the 15 minute wait was because of other "to go" orders ahead of us. My wife had the meatball sandwich which she said was excellent and on a fantastic 3" x 6" very fresh Italian bread roll. It was a bit messy but in a very good way. I had the Italian sausage which was a 3" x 6" patty which fit nicely on the roll. There was a fair amount of Italian sauce, but it had no onions or cheese, which was disappointing as that would have really made the sandwich even more memorable. Even without those items, it was fantastic. I wish the clerk would have asked I wanted the extras as I would have said yes...definitely. We sat outside and could not happen but notice that Cristiano's had a lot of people coming and going. They also had 5 delivery vehicles in the parking lot, so they must really have a huge fan club. We will stop in again when in town for dinner. Thanks again for a great lunch. read more

Christianos Pizza - Carry out counter area. - Pizza Near Me - Wautoma, Wisconsin

See all

Really reliably great pizza. The cheesy breadsticks and garlic bread are delicious basics. The Dad's Special is one of our go-to's. Hard to go wrong here. The staff is great and so is the food. read more

A bit pricey for the pizza size and amount of toppings. Good for date night. Due to price, would recommend frozen pizza or different pizza joint for a family. Always clean facility and friendly staff. read more

A must for pizza, always look forward to it. Highly recommend the meat lovers thin crust!

Good every time! And they deliver. We have dined in and ordered delivery multiple times. The food is consistently great and fast. Most of their pizzas come on a thin crust, except for a few of their specialty pizzas. A few of our favorite non-pizza menu items are the mozzarella bread and the chicken avocado salad (which comes with a large piece of garlic bread). Their dining room is family friendly. It offers beer and wine, I don't believe they have any hard alcohol. They also sell bags of Collectivo coffee by the register. Delivery is fast. They usually tell us 45-60 minutes and show up well before that. Some areas have a delivery charge, so just make sure to ask. If you are looking for a family friendly restaurant in Wautoma, this is your place! read more

This place was awesome! I'm from out of town but was here on business. Fresh handmade pasta, fresh herbs, and vegetables. You get so much food for your money and everything tastes amazing! Unfortunately the meatballs had pork in them so I ordered the Chicken Milano and it was divine! Servers were super nice and the food was prompt with enough left over for dinner. Highly recommend this place is a gem. read more

Fast takeout. Pizza wasn't good or bad, just pizza. Salads are great. So is the calzone! Plenty of bench seating inside. Friendly staff (sometimes too friendly because the girls on break hang out on the take out parking talking to their boyfriends). One of our go-to places in town read more

Excruciating. That is the word to sum up my experience. I ordered carry out and they actually forgot about my pizza. Not the friendliest bunch of employees as I walked in I got a stare down by the kids behind the counter and I witnessed one messing with his head after taking his helmet off and not wash his hands. I had to look away because I didn't even want to know if he actually touched anything. In any event to sum it up the pizza took 15 minutes longer than I was quoted, they use canned mushrooms as they were waxy , pizza was burned on one side and soggy on the middle. Totally not impressed. read more

A-MAZING pizza! I would have to agree and say that it may be the best in the state. They deliver a good distance as well and the staff is super friendly. I would recommend Christiano's anytime...family time, out with friends or date night! *I do wish they had a liquor license so that I could enjoy a beer with such delectable pizza! read more

Great for deliveries! Meatballs are deeeeelish! Overall the food is very good, but when it comes to deliveries my child can't get the kids alfredo delivered. That to me is B.S. What's the difference when I'm already ordering 2 other meals and pizza?!? Very disappointed in the restaurants policy. So heads up for people with small hungry children, because in the delivery world they don't matter. 's for good food for poor policies. 's for kindness over the phone. read more

Perfect little gem in a small town! No matter what you get here, it's always amazing. Their Alfredo with homemade noodles and sauce make for a great dish. They also make great salads, if you're in need of something healthy. Their portions never leave you wanting more, and the service is great! read more

The delivery was timely. Pizzas were small. For what you got it was not worth the price. Order 2 medium pizzas and 2 orders of cheese bread stick to feed 3 adults and 2 little kids. There was barely enough food to feed 2 adults. read more

We have ordered takeout many times. The food is delicious--especially the Alfredo pasta.

Who would have thought a little Wisconsin town would have a fabulous Italian restaurant? The marinara sauce with the meatball appetizer was seasoned perfectly. Huge portion of lasagna and a flavorful sauce on the grilled salmon. Each dinner meal came with a huge plank of toasted garlic bread. Everything was absolutely delicious! read more

Christianos Pizza - Lasagna and garlic bread also came with a salad...tomato/basil vinegrette to die for! All was yummy! - Pizza Near Me - Wautoma, Wisconsin

See all

The Chicken Avocado Salad was great. I asked for it without corn and rotini which was perfect. In and out within an hour. read more

Christianos Pizza - Walnut salad with beets and grilled chicken. Excellent on a cold day for lunch - Pizza Near Me - Wautoma, Wisconsin

See all

Originally went for pizza, but ended up with dinner. Very pleased. Sauces were bright and light without a lot of acidity. Pasta was done to perfection. Meatballs with the spaghetti were real - not loaded with fillers. Enjoyed dinner so much that we took two pizzas home. Pizza warmed up next day as if it just came out of the kitchen. It was definitely worth our 45 minute drive. read more

The service was awesome from the time we walked in the door, until we walked out (full and satisfied). They will do half and half with their specialty pizzas and the size and price are great. The only downside is that they do NOT have a changing table in the bathroom. read more