Friday nite fish fry to go was really good. I had walleye and waffle fries. Partner had blue gill…read moreand wedges. Both came with tartar sauce, Cole slaw, roll, butter and mine had lemon wedges. Both were large servings and both were delicious. They also have cod and shrimp. Called the order in and didn't have a long wait time. Order was all ready to go when I got there. You must try and see for yourself why Tracy and the Nickel deserve high praises.

Love it here! Good food and great people! You will feel right at home. Don't miss the walleye on…read moreFriday!

It is a nice lil place for the middle of no where the staff is amazing the food is amazing my steak…read morewas more rare the medium rare but it's good I would recommend this place to friends and family if they was come here from out of town.... I love going to small towns and find the unique restaurants and eat there and give reviews I give them 5 stars bc this small down find is pretty good and the staff is very friendly and I would eat here again the trip from Texas to Wisconsin has been a good trip and of all the place I have ate this is is 5 stars to me.... Thanks for the great meal on my way home to Texas!

Food was good. Waitress was nice. The charge n the bill to have it prepared to go was appalling and…read morewill either be a reason to never return or to deduct it from the bill via the tip. So, in essence it's not a proper charge for the customer and not fair to the waitress, because it's the owners/managements choice to charge it.

Have been here several times and really need to Get a review…read moreput together and get people out to enjoy this restaurant!! Pick a meal and you will be happy! Yum! And Tonya as our server was awesome! And you can have a conversation and enjoy the atmosphere!

Great food and service. Burgers, BLT, chicken sandwich fries and onion rings were all very good…read more Bartender was very friendly and attentive to our needs.

This is my mom's favorite Wisconsin supper club. She raves about it constantly so I finally…read morechecked it out. Loved sitting at the bar so much that we ordered dinner there. They have big leather swivel chairs that are actually comfy. The bar was very lively on a weekday at 4 pm. Watermelon mojito was one of the best I've ever had , followed it up with a great espresso martini. Ordered the fried clams appetizer which was good but many pieces were so small and thin that they seemed pure batter and no clam. The escargo was covered in a mexi-cheese blend that I found strange at first but tastes delicious- just more like Wisconsin escargo then French . They came with delicious crispy bread bites that we soaked up all the extra cheese and juices. Broccoli cheddar soup was the best I've ever had and absolutely loved the steak medallions with onions and dude of sauce . Steak was perfectly cooked. I loved this place and can't wait to come back

This was the second time we travelled up to Portage for Cimaroli's. Since we were last here they…read moreadded a whole new modern building with large windows which makes for a bright dining experience. The original bar is in the old darker section - more traditional for a supper club.. We stopped there for some old fashions before dinner - they were solid. Service was very good. We ordered our meals after some tough decision making after snacking on their very tasty warm rolls. I tried their special of crabbed stuff shrimp. Five large shrimp that were very good with a baked potato on the side. My wife got the encrusted salmon and was surprised that it was encrusted in a bread crumb cheese mixture. She really enjoyed it. Our friends got the chicken with pasta and the walleye - two thumbs up. We decided to try their ice cream drinks for dessert. One pink squirrel and one brandy Alexander. Both were good but we have had better and bigger versions at other supper clubs. Prices were typical for a supper club - not cheap.

amazing food with hair and a fingernail inside my food. I would recommend Arnold, who so gratefully…read morecursed me out and took a bite of my food. clearly a great experience

We were staying in the area before graduation at UW-Madison and needed some late night eats on a…read moreFriday around 9pm. A group of six of us walked in, sat ourself, and I asked a bartender if the kitchen was open. There were two guys behind the bar. They looked at each other and gave a nod. The younger guy said yes, but we are out of the fish fry. No problem for us. We were served by the younger guy and he was friendly, attentive, and didn't treat us as second class as most of our group took water while I had a couple beers. It was pretty quiet when we arrived. We tried a couple apps, and a few different burgers and fried shrimp. Having read about the steak burger, we had high expectations but it fell a bit flat. Others mentioned a sauce, but there wasn't any in ours. The burger with bacon and jalapeño was a banger though! Onion rings and fries were excellent. The curds were good, but I've had better. When it came time to close the check, our server met me as I jumped off my stool. I don't know his name, but gave him a 25% tip. Wish he worked at my place! For the Dells, the price is very reasonable in my opinion. As we were leaving things were lighting up, and getting loud. I got the impression the kitchen was closing even though they say they are open late as the older guy was grumbling about only having two people working. As an owner of a cocktail bar I get that things happen, but I don't like my employees getting upset about it. The younger guy kept his cool - even if he was hoping for more. I do plan to go back for another service and ask about the sauce on the steak burger. Felt weird to talk about it before getting it the way I assume they serve it. Our son is staying for grad school so we have an excuse to try again!

The pizza is really good, bartenders were all super friendly and they have great happy hour pricing…read moreon the Bloody Marys which were tasty!

Pulled up and 2 dumpsters were overflowing in the parking lot. 1 of the 2 bartenders were on…read moredrugs, could not even pour a beer for a customer. Bottle of beer $5.33, rail mixer $6.33 - seems high for the location. It was scary, did not bother to order food - so left.

Wow! We had a delicious meal--everything from the bread, soup, salad to the entrees were…read moreoutstanding. The fish and shrimp had light breading and was fried in clean oil. I love that the chef checked in with us mid-way through the meal. Don't hesitate to check out Crystal's!

DELISH! We went on a girl's trip and this place was recommended to us by our airbnb host. It was…read morewonderful! Great drinks in the bar, followed by a tasty dinner. They were able to accommodate a big group of wild women very well! The ribs, baked potato, carrot cake and old fashioned were perfect for me!

soooo yummmy omg i love this place ill eat here everydayyyyy. like its delicious omg omg omgread more

I'm not posting this for the owner to respond to it and say they'll fix it and don't. I'm writing…read morethis to future customers to prepare them for the service they're getting. First off there was literally two tables filled in the whole restaurant and it said sit yourself so we did, in the hall of fame part, well the room closest to the bar but still in that little doorway . We were the only ones in that part but they saw us come in, made eye contact but never said hi how're y'all or Anything. So I let it slide. After I want to say 15 minutes of sitting down with nobody coming to the table, I personally had to go up to the bar And tell the lady , we needed to get our drinks ordered. She then said okay I will be over in a second. She came to take our order yet no menus, so we had to wait for that as well. After we got a alcoholic beverage and a coke with lemon, and water with lemon, she comes back with drinks , no lemon. At that point we said forget it. Then after 20 minutes of her not coming back, I had to go up AGAIN just to find out she was sitting there talking to her coworker . I said uhm we've been ready to order and you haven't came back and she used the excuse she was waiting for bar orders which doesn't make much sense because while you were talking and waiting, you could've gotten our orders in. We order and I ordered the beef brisket or whatever it was and she asked if I wanted the glaze and the BBQ and I was like well if I can I'll do the glaze on the side and she said ok that will work. Then the other two in my party ordered burgers. Waited about 25/30 minutes for food. When she came with the food she finally introduced herself as Kristen. Now the brisket was amazing hands down. However, one of the burgers were made medium rare and also the egg was runny. Then I thought about it. KRISTEN NEVER ASKED HOW SHE WANTED HER EGG OR BURGER. Careless mistake. I wouldn't have been mad if that was all but also on this sandwich, they forgot the tomato and lettuce and the sauce that goes on it. Come to find out they put the sauce in between the two patties and it's a very small amount so you couldn't even taste it . The other burger was also wrong because they didn't put cheese or the right bun on it. Very disappointed for the price of the food y'all charge. Portions and quality is unacceptable. Service is ridiculous. Customers please be aware. You'll probably have to sit at the bar just for good service because that's were the attention was since that's where they stayed posted. You guys need to do more than just "relay the message to staff" you need to fix the broken service. Also she didn't check on the table the whole time after that and I had to go up there again for the check. Took so long to come get it, I payed thru the dumb QR code and left. It seems like all the bad reviews, the owner is trying to justify the fact that the staff can't do their job. That's not something you do, you have to TAKE RESPONSIBILITY. Take action. Make this restaurant better. Not a good first impression for someone visiting the state, won't be back, even if I was in state. This experience was three years ago * hope they've improved. Would still never go back