We have loved every Extreme pizza experience in Caldwell! Great service, attentive owners/…read moremanagement, awesome options and we can even get good vegan and gf options! Food is always delish & we love the fun Indian Creek atmosphere.

I've been going here for a few years and the pizza is always amazing…read more We have dined in and the atmosphere is fun. Not great for big parties but it works for our family of 5. We order to go a lot and eat it at the Indian creek plaza. It works great because you get a text when your pizza is ready. Service is pretty quick. Usually 20-30 mins but lunch and dinner are busy times. I will pre order by the app or calling in. I have eaten the pizzas, salads, sandwiches and the Indian creek bread. I wish I grabbed more pics of our food. The kids tend to grab it to eat as I'm setting it out.

This place is a gem. The service, drinks and food are all amazing. We had both the white and red…read moresangria and also their meat pizza. We didn't have wine this time because it was a very hot day when we were there. We highly recommend this place.

Opened late. Way…read moreunderstaffed - they had one woman running the entire restaurant, front and back of house. Apparently someone called in sick, but what the hell?? Very limited menu. Only a few pizzas, two sandwiches and a cheese board. Food took FOREVER to come out. Cheese board was good.

The food's always good. I haven't been disappointed every time I've been there. They have some wild…read morepizzas like enchiladas, kind ofof surprising. They're always good with their service. They're fast good pizza does take a minute though but always good. The main dining room is kinda loud, but the bar area is nice and cozy..

We finally stopped by today to try the yummy pizza smell that fills our car as we drive by. Love…read morethe decorations and the ambiance. The salad bar was very clean and fresh. The staff was also very friendly. Can't wait to try more of their food. The pizza was perfectly cooked. We will definitely be stopping by again.

We've only had the one in Caldwell. Dine in or delivery…read morethey always have Polite service, and good food for the price!

The gentleman was very polite that delivered the pizza delivery was hot and made good time. I…read moreappreciate having good food and great service. Thank you!!!

I love this pizza place. Good for big groups. We usually get the salad bars and a bunch of pizzas…read more The service is fast and the food is hot and fresh. I haven't gotten pics yet but next time I will. The salad bars are stocked, good for kids because they have some arcade games, and the parents can sit for a few mins. Bring change, the cashier does give change though.

This is definitely a unique spot in Caldwell, but unfortunately the overall experience was…read moredisappointing. The dining area has some seating, although the layout feels a little awkward. The cleanliness also left a lot to be desired--the dining room and bathroom were not very clean, and the bathroom was low on toilet paper and completely out of soap. The biggest issue was the wait time. We waited over an hour for just two pizzas, while several tables that arrived after us received their food first. We eventually had to go to the counter ourselves to check on the order. It seemed like a high volume of takeout orders was causing major delays for dine-in customers. There were also problems with the soda fountain, leaving only Country Time lemonade and water available. Unfortunately, even the water had a strange flavor, so we avoided drinking it. The pizza itself was decent and had a nice crunchy crust, but the service and cleanliness issues outweighed the positives for us.

Great food and friendly service!! If anything is ever missing from your order or something is…read moreincorrect (doesn't happen often) they're quick to make it right. Had a great interaction with Donald today... super nice person. I totally forgot to add pepperoncinis to my salad order and he happily gave some to my husband in a to go cup to bring home. Thanks for the pepperoncinis my guy :) So happy our favorite pizza finally made it to Idaho!!

I've had several experiences since my previous review. Several of the pikes peak pizza now come…read morewith about 10%-20% of the toppings it used to:(no exaggeration, it could be less). The quality and consistency is not there and I have become disappointed with Mountain Mikes Pizza. I will now give my business to Westside Pizza. At least I know it will be Consistent

Poppi's Pizza is a great "take & bake" pizza spot in Middleton…read more We went there on a Tuesday and the place was hopping. Even with several customers, the awesome staff were friendly and fast at getting our order out. My cheeseburger pizza was phenomenal with a delicious sauce and a generous amount of toppings. My wife had a bbq chicken pizza that she raved about. This is a great spot for exceptional pizza and it will definitely be on our favorites list.

The pizza are made fresh and then you bring them home to bake. The quality of ingredients are…read morealways fresh and they put alot of them on the pizzas. Hands down great pizza!!!

What a delightful find! My mom recently moved to Nampa so I'm exploring restaurants in totally new…read moreneighborhoods. The Rustic Oven in Middleton is in the corner of a strip mall next to a very clean, organized Idaho Yourh Ranch. But back to the food... They specialize in sandwiches--hot and cold--and baked goods. Since my time with my mom is special, I go a little extra each time. So we started with a Nutella roll. Holy heck. It was amazing. Kinda like the best chocolate chip cookie you've ever eaten. I got one to-go for my daughter too. My mom ate half of her pastrami sandwich so she could have another treat! She picked out a Huckleberry cream cheese pasty. So good, but so rich. I enjoyed my roast beef hot recommended by the delightful hostess, Avah. Her pride in their many offerings was evident. We took home the rest of our sandwiches. But right when she got home, my mom wanted the rest of her pastrami. I know she was full but it was that good that she had to finish it while it was still fresh. That's quite a testimonial. The Rustic Oven will be our new go-to place! PS: In Yelp, it's mistakenly described as a food truck. Avah explained that they used to offer pizza via a food truck, but that was years ago.

The food at the cafe is good, yet the owner lacks business sense. The cafe is unorganized and very…read morecramped. Orders are made, but stay sitting on the back counter as the cashier is too busy to bring them out resulting in customers waiting up to 20 minutes to get their food. This place has a lot of potential, but needs a manager who can add efficiency and organization to the business. In terms of the food, the sandwiches are drenched in mayo/mustard mix and the sugar cookies are dry and crumbly. I hope this place can turn it around!

The wine maker in his entire staff is so friendly and is eager to make your stay a pleasurable one…read more Kindred is probably my favorite Winery because it is the best of both the boutique feel, family farm, and pretty darn good Wines at reasonable prices.

A little torn on this review. Small winery and tasting room that gets an A for effort…read more The good first. Friendly, knowledgeable staff and delicious homemade pizzas. Oh, and the wine. Unique variates with some traditional ones. Tasty for sure. The bad. Uncomfortable folding chairs and the flies. It was a constant battle to keep them off of our food and out of the wine glasses. The fans help circulate the air but they didn't help deter the pesty bugs. Not sure if i'd return.

Our favorite pizza place!! We always order for parties and get togethers. Tanya is so sweet and all…read morethe staff is so helpful---plus we love the pizza!

Marco's is great. It's become my family's go-to for our pizza nights. The pizzas are full of…read moreflavor, and the staff is always friendly. I recommend the hot honey pepperoni!