If I could rate it six stars I would because of the amazing service we received from Lauren. From the moment it was realized that we wanted to eat a slice while we waited for our Hot Honey/goat cheese/pepperoni to go , she escorted us to the restaurant side and had our order in within moments. We would have to wait for the individual slices of pepperoni with Jalapeños, so she brought out their mashed potato/bacon/scallions slice and the seasonal street corn style slice with cilantro (both freaking delicious) as a treat. The pizza, thin, crisp and just the right amount of chewiness. Bravo Otto on your hire of Lauren (so hard to find someone who goes above and beyond the call of duty) and on pizza well done! You have been a staple for Maine and you will be a staple for this foodie as well read more

See all

Purchase a couple of pizzas this week and when we got the pizzas home and opened the boxes, one looked great, the other absolutely burned to a crisp. I don't know how in the world they could have sent it out the door. I want to like Otto in Yarmouth, but they keep tripping over themselves. The service is rough. The mistakes are often. I'm sorry, but for the price of premier pizza, they should be better. Whoever manages this store does his/her employees no favors. I will not go back and I'll share this story as often as I can. read more

Hot honey, cup & char pepperoni, and goat cheese? Yes, please! In my opinion, this one's the best, but give them all a try and judge for yourself. When in Yarmouth, this place is a must-try! read more

Hunting a place for a quick lunch as we traveled I295 heading from Maine to Massachusetts, Otto was a perfect stop. Easy off and easy on at exit 15. We were on the early side of lunch so parking was easy. We ordered a small meatball, ricotta and basil pizza and sat at the bar in the adjoining room. Nice, new, clean appearance to the room. Our server was very friendly and efficient. Pizza was perfectly cooked and the toppings were just right...not too little, not too much. A small pizza was plenty for the two of us. Clean, good restrooms. Great stop! read more

See all

Some of the best pizza I've ever had. They consistently show quality and care and that is speaking for all the locations I've been to in this state. Keep up the great work. The value you get for your money is priceless. Unfortunately dining room was closed in Yarmouth. read more

Great Otto location! Ordered delivery on a Friday night and it came within 30min. The pizza was fantastic. They have one of the best gluten free pizzas in Maine. read more

OTTO offers a clean, trendy eating experience with local beers on tap. The staff during my visit was incredibly friendly and the service was quick. I decided to go with the Margherita pie - which turned out to be a great decision. The pie featured an ultra-thin base that was browned nicely by the oven. The fresh, juicy tomatoes were well distributed and did not slide when eating slices. The crisp exterior on the thin crust added a great crunch. The fresh basil ribbons and the spicy herb blend added to the cheese carried a ton of flavor. There are many other pizza options available at OTTO, including gluten-free and vegan options. I will definitely be returning so that I can work my way through the rest of the pizza menu. read more

See all

Fresh made pizza was good, however pizza by the slice was a little old. Caesar salad was good and wait staff was kind and helpful.

Traveling to Maine for the first time, we are looking for something to eat for lunch after landing at the airport and on our way to the LL Bean Store. As we were driving, we saw the sign and decided to stop in. I wasn't familiar with the place, but was up for trying something new. People we saw were friendly. When we first went in, there was a counter where you could order to-go or pick up an order. But we were looking to dine in. The dining area has about 10 tables as well as a bar. It wasn't busy but we arrived around 1:30 and ordered shortly after. Took about 15 minutes for a pepperoni pizza. It was hot and more of a thin crust, brick oven style. Really liked the taste. They have a variety of unique combinations, like potato bacon. Price seemed a little steep for a 12-inch pepperoni pizza at $15.50, so I wouldn't be looking to do this pizza for a group. But overall, I was happy that I found this place to try during my first visit to Maine. read more

Too tight pants girl smile,OK.Food,value,price?No way.And we got sick.Not recommended.

Great stop to get pizza while driving out of Portland! Fresh and fast, Otto has one of my favorite pizzas

I'm so disappointed in this location. Our pizza was cooked to annihilation and not edible at all, it was like chewing a rubber tire. It is disgraceful that they have a worker who thinks sending a pizza like this out the door is acceptable at all. No one should ever have to contact them about a pizza this terrible. It was also an hour late so to say it's disappointing when it arrived and we were starving is an understatement (it was the middle of the day on a random Tuesday! 2pm was expected time done. Was finished at 3:15!) They also never responded to my complaint and request for refund which now makes the company and not only the worker terrible. At the VERY least I deserve a refund for my $30 inedible pizza. read more

OTTO - Could break in half like a chip - Pizza Near Me - Yarmouth, Maine

Though they were slammed with orders on Halloween, the staff of OTTO made two delicious pizzas - each crust was perfectly cooked (and we all liked the 'new' crust recipe). The mushroom, manchego, herb pizza was a hit with all three generations, and the Sriracha chicken with avocado was almost finished as well. I appreciate being able to have an easy dinner that allows us to focus upon our family and the holiday rather than being too busy cooking a meal on such a hectic day. Thank you! read more

Pizza is good. Especially Mashed Potato Bacon Scallion. Service and care for customer is non-existent. Ordered three small pizzas. For $55 none the less !!!!! The girl answering the phone kept putting me on hold in middle of taking my order and I just knew she was not paying attention. I clarified with her on what I wanted. My wife goes and picks up pizza and they sent home one that I did not order leaving out one I wanted. It was an expensive pizza for a small as it is and a 30 minute drive each way so no, I'm not driving all the way back because YOU screwed up and didn't care enough about your customer to listen to the order and get it right. Said manager would call me because I asked for a refund on the missing pizza. ( the wrong one they sent was a pizza i do not like at all otherwise I would just have grumpily eaten it). Manager NEVER gave the courtesy of a single call back. I called them again the next day. Was told AGAIN manager would call me. Yeah that NEVER happened. Will NEVER buy another Ottos product ever again. Extremely piss poor to not even call your customer back after they gave you money for a product that YOU got wrong. Clearly don't care. At all. Pizza itself is good for most part when they get it right however they are awful thin and light on toppings. Especially for a company that is one of the most expensive small pizzas in the entire region. Do yourself a favor and find somewhere else. Look at my reviews. I'm not a complainer and generally only post when it's positive. This place....yeah.....start caring about your customers or you won't have any. read more

My wife and I have always enjoyed the pizza from Otto's but have never visited this location. The pizza here did not disappoint.... great crisp crust with delicious and unique toppings. Superb! This space is peculiar and confusing if you have never been before. If you enter from the side street it is hard to tell you are even in the right place. Once inside, you are greeted by a large sign for Andy's which is a corner store that also serves food which is the front of the establishment; a sign for Moxie groceries and another sign for the Gorham Savings Bank Community Board Room?! All of this was inside a room about the size of my living room. After dinner, we exited through the front and saw the Ottos kitchen area which made things a bit clearer, but still a weird set up. The service was a very friendly but a little strange. The young man asked us if we wanted plates or if we were "just going to eat it off the pan"? After returning with the requested plates, he asked us if we wanted silverware and napkins. Seriously, I have never been asked if I wanted utensils and a plate before. How hard is it to just set the table? The pizza more than made up for the quirkiness! read more

OTTO - Fantastic jalapeño, bacon and ricotta pizza! My wife's squash and cranberry pizza is in the background. - Pizza Near Me - Yarmouth, Maine

We love Otto! Whenever we are in Maine and we want pizza, it's Otto or nothing. Particularly love their veggie options (margarita, butternut squash, spinach, mushroom and cauliflower - all of them really) but there's a chicken one that we also love. read more

Oh my god I love Otto, but I hadn't had it in about 5 years, since I was going to grad school in Portland (one of my professors used to order it for us on the last day of classes and got me hooked). I was so happy to see that the Yarmouth location delivered to Freeport, where I was staying, and happily ordered a mashed potato pizza, which, if I'm being honest, is the penultimate mashed potato pizza. Other places may have theirs, but Otto will always be the best mashed potato pizza ever to me. We also got the spicy pulled pork, pepperoni, bacon, and sausage pizza which was (yes, spicy) but really good. Delivery time was decent and the delivery girl was cheerful and pleasant when she got to us. read more

The Yarmouth, Maine location always the crispest fresh lettuce and sweet red onions in the garden salad and the best GF crust locally. I enjoy the simple, red sauce and generous toppings. Delivery is fast, friendly and convenient. I always pick up or have it delivered. read more

Otto is unbearably hot, making it an inhumane place to dine. The oppressive heat made the entire experience horrible. Requiring employees to work under these conditions is despicable and down right illegal. I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone looking for a meal. read more

If I could rate them 0 stars I would. Horrible service. Took almost 25 minutes to get our pizza even though there was a group that walked in 10 minutes after us and they got their pizza within 2 minutes of sitting down. We get the first order and the large pepperoni pizza was wrong, they give us a cheese pizza and the waiter/ bartender stared at us like we were still going to eat it or something. So then after sending back the cheese pizza and while waiting another 25 minutes another group walks in and seemed to order a cheese pizza. This establishment took our cheese pizza that we sent back and brought it back out and gave it to another group. So at this point I've watched 2 Seperated groups get served their pizza while we were sitting there with half our group eating and the other half of our group staring into the other peoples pizzas watching them enjoy their food with their groups. One person from our group ordered the chicken ceaser, the salad was super dry, we couldn't get any dressing because There was 1 bartender doing all of the tables in the dining room. So after waiting 50 minutes for a pepperoni pizza we decided to take the pizza to go because the rest of our group was finished eating.. I Will not be coming back and genuinely really like Otto's pizza, but this is the WORST Otto's Experience I've EVER been apart of. You might as well go to Romeo's If you want good service or if you really like Otto's pizza please go to any other establishment but this one. The fact that we paid full price for this kind of service is absolutely disappointing to say the least read more

Delivery was fast, ordered a small pepperoni pizza. It's a decent tasting pizza, not a lot of sauce used which I enjoy, the crust was also tasty. New to the area so I am not a connoisseur of pizza places around here but I imagine there are other places where you can get a better bang for your buck. I just cannot justify spending $18 for the size and quality of that pie again. read more

Great pizza selections and friendly staff. Recommend you try Otto's. The online ordering is easy to use and order was ready when promised.

Great portion size for two people. Three slices each of the small pizza. Delicious crispy crust and yummy sausage toppings.

*Usually Order from the Otto's in Yarmouth!* I am 110% a pizza snob. Growing up in Jersey City where pizzerias are on every corner (no joke) has led me to be this way. I'm used to New York style pizza and the Italian brick oven personal sized pizzas. I didn't expect much when I moved to Portland regarding pizza. It's simple to do, but so easy to mess up. Everyone ranted and raved about Otto's pizza. Considering it's a chain restaurant, I had extremely low expectations, but I still wanted to try it. Boy was I caught by surprise. I'm a carnivore - love meat, but I decided to go the eggplant, ricotta, basil route and holy cannoli - it was delicious. The sauce, the cheese, the texture - my taste buds were knocked for a loop. They didn't see it coming. I liked it so much that I finished half of a large pie on my own. What can I say, I like to keep my taste buds happy. I absolutely recommend Otto's. It's definitely a "must-try". It can get a little pricey after awhile, but I like to order it as a nice treat here and there. If you're in town, stop by and grab a slice - or just finish half a pie on your own :) read more

OTTO - Eggplant, Ricotta, Basil nom nom nom :) - Pizza Near Me - Yarmouth, Maine

See all

Located in the rear of what's left of Handy Andy's is Otto's Pizza. Usual and unusual pizzas like mashed potato, bacon and scallion. Thin dough pizza cooked in a gas oven. Chewy texture with crispy crust. Dollops of tangy pizza sauce make each bite unique. read more

OTTO - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Yarmouth, Maine

Everyone else in the family says it was great. Giving it 2 stars instead of 1 for that reason. But they put vegan cheese on my pizza when I ordered online and did not check the vegan cheese option. As a cheese hater, vegan or not, that's a dealbreaker. So for me, I won't be going back. It's quite easy to follow instructions. They did not. Simple as that. (Also, several employees had their masks off in the building, so clearly health & safety are not of paramount importance here) read more

My husband, toddler and I were driving through Yarmouth and stopped to get their amazing pizza. I was so enthralled in the food that I forgot my cel there. The wonderful staff got in touch with my mom somehow and let us know. We were already an hour away so it was an impossible situation for us to turn back with a toddler. Their delivery driver Ava, offered to send it to our home in Boston on her day off. Sure enough early the next day we got the tracking number. We are so thankful. THANK YOU AVA! ps- their ranch sauce is amazing. read more

Consistent on every level everytime we place an order. Very friendly and courteous staff, order is always correct, delivery on time, delivery person is always friendly and kind no matter if it's rain or sunshine. Food is as perfect as it can get with always using fresh ingredients. Nice to have an establishment you can count on. Thanks for being there! read more

We ordered 8 pizzas ... all amazingly good! Your team does a tremendous job. They totally nailed it on this order in all aspects. They are cheerful, helpful, and went out of their way to get it right. Just awesome! read more

The pizza choices are unusual here (butternut squash with ricotta and cranberry, chicken with roasted pears, etc.). Alright, we're game. We tried the mashed potato, bacon and scallion and it was really good. Crust was great. Caesar salad is a mix of romaine and kale with way too much kale. Servers are on the young and inexperienced side. Friendly, but not very professional. Our server got part of our order wrong and rather than just correct it he told us that he brought us what we ordered. Um, actually, no. We did not order what you brought because of a food allergy. Not worth arguing over so we ate the dish and picked out the offending item. But that's not how you respond to an error in an order. Outdoor patio is nice. On the whole, a good experience. read more

I eat at Ottos pizza often the pizza here is Quit delicious everytime I come there there is a girl name Chantelle is very efficient when she serves. her tables and bar .Always there when she is needed. Smart girl she is great customers love that girl. You ot promote her she is a great server I've been a server for a life time and she deserves a promotion .Linda Gastonguay 207-837-5478 read more

We love Otto! Great service, high-quality food, and interesting menu items! Ordering through the website is easy. Estimated delivery times are accurate except when they wind up showing up EARLIER than expected. We were particularly impressed this most recent time with the "staff favorites" pizza specials - SO GOOD! Keep them! read more

As always, Otto's pizzas are the best! Perfectly cooked and just the right amount of toppings. It's the only pizza that I actually eat all the crust because it's not too hard or thick. So happy we have Otto in Yarmouth! read more

Love the meatballs. My grand absolutely loves the pizza.

When moving up to Massachusetts from one of the best cities for Pizza in the world, I was a little worried that I wouldn't be able to find any decent Pizzeria. I was so wrong. I first discovered OTTO's in Portland, Maine! When I found out they were opening a branch in Newburyport, I was thrilled! There's nothing better than a double-dough, 4meat Pizza. It just covers all the food groups and the crust is to die for! I highly recommend accompanying a few slices with a nice refreshing salad from OTTO's. It doesn't get much better... I can truly say "Life is good!" read more

Our Pizzas & Salad were fresh and delicious! Enjoyed some of their fun, unique flavor options, as well as the traditional ones. read more

OTTO - Butternut Squash, Ricotta & Cranberry Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Yarmouth, Maine

See all

Solid delivery. Timely with text alerts giving status. Pizza always arrives hot. As for the product, it's good thin crust with flavorful toppings. A very solid option and a 4 stars. read more

OTTO's is definitely a staple in our home. I do wish I could find really good classic NY style pizza in Portland but OTTO for sure makes a great crispy crust and is very creative with their toppings. Personally I find the pizzas are a little hit or miss but once you find your favorites you'll probably keep going back like me. Hits: -Ricotta with bacon and jalapeño -Four cheese -Eggplant, basil and ricotta -Chicken, pear and fontina Basically anything with their ricotta topping is great as far as I'm concerned. Misses: -Mashed potato (I get that it's a fun thing, it just doesn't do it for me) -Tortellini suffers the same fate -Mango-habanero chicken and pineapple salsa (I think this one suffers the same fate that other reviewers have touched on with some of the pizzas. If you put too much on they lose their finesse and just become sloppy slabs of pizza but also being skimpy with the toppings can lead to a somewhat bland pizza) I will echo what other reviewers have also said that the actual experience at this location is not my favorite. The building is pretty confusing because it shares a space with another restaurant but there are really no signs that I could find making this clear. So you walk into the front door under the sign for OTTO's and you are actually entering a different restaurant. Additionally the staff there does some a little inexperienced/unprofessional. But then again it's a chain pizza place which is a common way for teenagers to get into the work space and I'm not going there expecting five star service. read more

Online ordering was so easy and detailed about pick up time. Staff were friendly and quality great. Thank you!! read more

Great place for pizza, I find them to be consistently good from the butternut squash, cranberry and ricotta to the best pepperoni in town. I give them five stars! read more