Don't listen to the haters. There is an absurd level of hate pointed toward The Bronx. This is due to movies and the unfair view that The Bronx is populated exclusively by stupid, uneducated ghetto people. That is simply not the case. The Bronx is home to some of the city's best universities/colleges and the highest percentage of park land in the 5 boroughs.
Orchard Beach is part of Pelham Bay Park, which is NYC's largest park. The beach is nestled in a corner of the park that is fairly distant from the Subway. Anyone with half a brain and experience living in NYC knows that proximity to the subway is the kiss of death for cleanliness and peacefulness. It is for this reason that the beach is exponentially cleaner than Coney Island or Brighton Beach could ever hope to be. Swap the mix of Russian and Latina girls being hounded/scoped by creepy ghetto dudes for mostly Latina's being given the same treatment, the vibe is similar to Coney Island. FYI, this beach is surrounded by middle-class neighborhoods, the only exception being nearby Co-Op City which is a little sketchy, but not nearly as sketchy as say, Flatbush. The closest residential area is City Island, which is a very safe area.
The biggest downfall of this beach is that it is not an ocean beach, but on Eastchester Bay, an inlet of the Long Island Sound, which is an extension of the Atlantic Ocean. The distance from the Ocean means its waters are quite still and waves are not to be seen. This also creates a murkiness to the water that some find unpleasant, but on a less crowded day or when the tides are just right, the water can actually be quite a bit warmer and cleaner than the ocean beaches in the city.
I am a Manhattan resident who hates Brooklyn beaches. I think they're gross and dirty and I don't like the shack-like atmosphere of the businesses surrounding the boardwalks. I find it depressing to see the projects and homeless people around the beach. Orchard Beach has none of that. As I live on the Upper East Side, I find that it takes me longer to get to Coney Island than Orchard Beach with the train/bike route I recommend. In fact, if you're a sporty person, like me, taking the 6 with your bike makes the trip an adventure, a workout and a zen experience that you cannot have going to any other city beach. Riding your bike is actually faster than taking the bus and allows you to explore the hiking biking trails surrounding the beach when you get there. In fact, you can even find some secluded spots along the rocky shores of the trails if you want to have total peace and tranquility. I've even seen people skinnydipping in the waters off the trails - it's that secluded, despite being in New York City!
Basically, if you're looking for an easy trip where you just don't move your body and you just want to get a tan, I think you should go to a tanning salon. But if you want to truly get back to nature, bike from the 6 to the beach, have an adventure, soak up the sun as your reward and feel like you've traveled far from the city without leaving it, go to Orchard Beach. You can even end your day by heading over to City Island and have a bite to eat at one of its (admittedly mediocre) seafood restaurants. Just don't go on a Saturday during the summer - you'll be sorry. Take off work on Tuesday and have an adventure.
Orchard Beach is one of New York's best kept secrets. It stays that way because people don't know what to expect. Pelham Bay Park is not funded the way Central Park is and the experience is very different but it's equally beautiful in a natural, much less developed way. Orchard Beach is also much less developed than Coney Island beach, but that is exactly what makes it so much better. read more