Best bagel shop this side of the rockeys!! As a New Yorker I approve of this establishment ! Spicy everything is amazing highly recommend if you can handle the spice. All the classics done in a new creative way and the owner is awesome. read more

Let me start with Jack, the owner. Need I say more? Be prepared for a long winded schtick from the most extroverted man in existence. He'll be sure to guide you toward the choice he knows is best for you. My Asiago pesto bagel with a sausage patty, garden veggie cream cheese and roasted tomatoes was out of this world. The options are all artisanal and lavish. But you could also pair it down to a more traditional choice if you want to be boring. After spending much of his life indulging in bagels, my Jewish New Yorker boyfriend was pleasantly surprised and had nothing but great things to say about these bagels. They are slightly dense, but that is to be expected at this elevation. read more

Open Sesame - Asiago & Pesto bagel w/ garden veggie cream cheese and roasted tomatoes. - Bagels Near Me - Basalt, Colorado

A small spot in Willits serving excellent, creative bagels made by an intense but genuinely nice owner who clearly takes his craft seriously. The bagels are exactly what you want: classic crispy on the outside, light and chewy on the inside; and inventive flavors and unusual ingredients made in-house. It is a small place with just a few tables inside. In the summer, grab your bagel and go walk over to the nearby park to check out the water fountain show. Be prepared for the prices: $10+ for a bagel with cream cheese and $20 for their Lox version with all of the fixings. A craft bagel experience. read more

Open Sesame - Loxed and Loaded - Bagels Near Me - Basalt, Colorado

See all

I walked into this bagel shop expecting a quick, pleasant stop--but instead got a dose of attitude. The moment we came in, the man behind the counter threw what can only be described as a hissy fit about a dog being near the door. We had zero issue keeping the dog outside and were already handling it, but his reaction was completely over the top. From there, things didn't improve. He was rude, rolled his eyes multiple times, and kept huffing and acting irritated while we were simply trying to order. It made the whole experience uncomfortable and unwelcoming. Customer service clearly isn't a priority here. Plenty of other places to grab a bagel without being treated like an inconvenience--won't be coming back. read more

Absolutely love this place! Their bagel flavors are unique chewy with the perfect amount of crisp on the outside. I got the salmon bagel sandwich and it was delicious! read more

Open Sesame - Bagels Near Me - Basalt, Colorado

First time being in here and I wish I came sooner. Jack KNOWS his flavor combinations. This guy has such a passion for bread & flavormaxxing, and it shows. He suggested the Bacon, Cheddar, Jalapeño bagel with Blackberry Habanero cream cheese, which was out of this WORLD. Such a unique combo which I never would have concocted on my own. Sweet, savory, & spicy all in one. I'm not the biggest 'fruit cream cheese' fan, but this was incredible. When I inquired about nuts, he said "the only thing nuts is how delicious [your bagel] will be ... and the pesto". read more

See all

Another great experience at Open Sesame this morning. I cannot wait for them to open the new location in Willits. Their bagels are scrumptious, well toasted and even if I am not hungry I cannot stop eating them. I had a lox sesame seed bagel that had the traditional fixings (capers, red onion, tomato) plus crunchy cucumbers that gave it an extra oomph. My husband had one with bacon, lettuce, avocado that was fantastic too. Service was great and efficient. They are pricey but their ingredients are top notch and to me it's totally worth it. read more

Open Sesame - Lox bagel - Bagels Near Me - Basalt, Colorado

See all

The most beautiful bagel shop! Impressive bagel flavors, spreads, sandwiches, baked goods and sourdough bread. Excellent service. Immaculate. Vegan and GF options. read more

See all

We were visiting Basalt and looking for a solid breakfast joint. This one popped up and we gave it a shot. The breakfast bagel sandwich was decent but watch out for their crazy prices and hidden fees. The bagel sandwich alone was listed at $17+ but they add $2.50 if you choose a non standard bagel that they push on you without letting you know of the upcharge. They also say free house coffee which is a nice touch but watch out for the automatic service fee of 15% and a CC fee of 3%. So in the end we paid $71.98 for 3 bagel sandwiches and the owner said to us that we underpaid but that he will cover us this time. Haha. There are better options that will not break the bank. read more

Open Sesame - Receipt - Bagels Near Me - Basalt, Colorado

The cutest little bagel shop! The food here was amazing!!!! The service was great-- gave perfect recommendations. The ambiance was small but cute, and loved the family owned vibes with kids drawings on the walls. We will be back!!! read more

Bagel sandwiches to die for. Bagels that are great, and schmears to remember. I am dreaming of the lox sandwich with fresh heirloom tomatoes. The owner is cool too. read more

Second strike-meh. Attitude for days. First time in we got the bagel sandwich. Owner was distracted, music was loud, we got the wrong bagel. Fine, we ate it, tasty. My GF did ask for a receipt and that is when she saw the additional fees they add on, without you knowing and still have a tip screen. The coffee schtick is tiresome. Second time, bagel was alright, attitude and pricing insane. read more

The bagels are amazing!!! We had a great experience with the staff and the owner. The food is all meticulously prepared with, excellent, local ingredients and care. The shop is 20 minutes from our home but we will be visiting quite often. If we lived in a different State we would visit quite often!!!! Thank you Open Sesame!!! read more

An absolute treasure of a tiny place! Most fantastic amazing bagel sandwiches. Every single ingredient is of highest quality. The taste are amazing. There's a huge variety of bagel flavors and cream cheese that are original just to this place. The sandwich was reasonably price around $15 and it came with a free latte or a free cookie. I ended up getting an Americano with vanilla and lavender. Lovely, freshly made delicious coffee, espresso, fresh beans.. everyone would come here for a bagel or or a cookie because they're amazing but the coffee is also to die for. I also got the jalapeño egg bagel to have for later today. But everything cream cheese smear was delicious. I may just go back in and get a cookie NOW, I want to try everything! The owner is a lovely and the service is amazing. read more

See all

Freaking delicious. I'm a travel nurse so I don't have a ton of time to wait for food while I frantically try to accommodate my Aspen clients. Fast, efficient and friendly. Wait time is less than 5 minutes for a huge bagel and a generous amount of delicious cream cheese! Massive amounts of bagels and cream cheese to choose from so you won't be disappointed. My go to when I'm out in the area and FedEx that I need is right across the street. I wish I had taken a picture but I was so hungry! Also a really good music selection that helps me get back into work mode Food: 5/5 | Service: 5/5 | Atmosphere: can I work here for free bagels? read more

Amazing amazing amazing! Can't say enough about how delicious the food is here and how hilarious and incredible the owner was. We came expecting good food (which we got) and were thoroughly entertained as well. The menu items are cleverly named and creative. It's clear that the owner cares a lot about the quality of the food and coming up truly delicious and unique items. We had the lox bagel special and got a cookie along with it- which were both to die for. Don't skip this stop! read more

We loved Open Sesame (and Jack) so much we had it 3 times in 2 days! Highly recommend the rosemary salt bagels and incredible turkey sandwich. Everything was delicious! Great coffee too! read more

I have been supporting Open Sesame since it first opened in the design center. The new location in Willits is fabulous. The owner is frequently on site and is passionate about each customer's experience. The specialty bagels and cream cheese spreads are exceptional and my family and guests rave about them. Highly recommend supporting this local gem. read more

We stopped in to get a "quick bagel" on our drive to Aspen only to find a delight place full of personality and flavor. We liked it so much that we made sure to return on our drive out of town several days later. The owner, staff, (and even customers) were engaging and helpful. Which is important because this isn't a standard bagel shop. The flavors of bagels, sandwiches, and spreads are inspiring and Jack is always helpful in ensuring you get what is flavorful to you. Who knew that blackberry and smoked habanero cream cheese was so tasty? We will return on our next trip into the valley. read more

Great all around everything homemade and worth the trip from the bacon sausage and really unique cream cheese and bagel flavors!

Best bagel place I've ever eaten in my life! Amazing, creative bagel and cream cheese flavors. Owner and chef was so friendly and helpful. We'll be back soon! Get yourself in there. read more

We've really enjoyed going to Open Sesame in Basalt over the years, but unfortunately, this recent experience left a bad impression. We went in for two bagels and a coffee, and during checkout, the cashier told my wife she needed to leave a tip because she received a free coffee through their bagel promotion. While tipping is appreciated and often encouraged, it should never be demanded. Being pressured to tip -- especially for something advertised as free -- felt inappropriate and unprofessional. Tips should always be optional and based on service, not treated as an obligation. We hope the management addresses this with their staff, as it put a damper on an otherwise long-standing positive experience. read more

Quirky experience but honestly the best bagel I've ever had. Support this local business!

Amazing service the owner is a great guy! Amazing food will definitely be coming back.

Everything was great! The food was amazing and I was given an amazing recommendation, will be coming back again soon!

Best Bagel Sammy I've ever tasted. Enough said right? Well it's also worth mentioning that the service (assume it was the owners) was exceptional. Great service, great food, somewhat reasonable prices (it's the valley- everything is expensive), and oh yeah... amazing bagels. Good stuff. I ordered the BLT on a special bagel (sea salt, rosemary, and Asiago) with a fried egg. I don't even like bagels and I was just raving to my wife about this one (I reluctantly shared...). Location is weird but whatever... worth it. read more

amazing service, was very welcoming and gave great suggestions. Food was absolutely immaculate and blissful. Couldn't ask for more or anything better. read more

The food is INCREDIBLE! Super fresh and everything made in house. Lots of bagel, cream cheese, and pastry options. They do have gluten free bagels (which are delicious) and vegan cream cheese. The cookies are fantastic as are the pumpkin rolls and this one apple bacon Carmel pastry that I can't remember the name of. Service was fantastic too! read more

Fresh ingredients, genuinely friendly staff & top notch cookies & bagel sandwiches. So happy to have found them on our road trip. We may be back before our trip is over. THAT good!! read more

This place was one of the best bagels I've in a long time! The spreads and bagel flavors were so good and unique, and the service was phenomenal. The shop was super cute too and just a a quick bop off the main highway. read more

Incredible experience all around, gourmet cream cheeses and the people that work here are so amazing!! Would highly recommend if you need a good bagel sandwich!! read more

What a local treasure! My sister brought me here when I was visiting on 1/19/26 from Western NY. I've never experienced such a delectable combination of flavors and textures in a bagel sandwich. And EVERYTHING is hand made right there! The owner is on top of his craft in bringing rich authentic beauty to his offerings. I didn't know what to order from the multitude of options. His suggestion was spot on. He offers a free coffee with a specialty sandwich which blew my mind! I'm always happy to pay the price a small business asks for the wares because I know it is with careful consideration of their costs and what customers will pay. It's a delicate balance in order to stay in business! Please always patronize small businesses, without them we'd only have fast food or frozen bagels etc. I'm sharing this because as we were entering this bustling little shop whose bagels are well known throughout the valley, including very discerning restauranteurs, a customer was storming out irate that she should not only be given a free coffee with her naked bagel, but she shouldn't be charged for any butter. So if you happen to see a negative review here from a person that acted as I explained please do NOT take it out on this wonderful establishment! Instead go in and buy a bagel sandwich or two! That person was probably having a bad day and took it out in public on a very nice, generous, talented person and employer! Shameful, immature behavior! read more

Best French toast bagel with strawberries. Service was pretty good, faster than other bagel places. The ambiance was great in summer.

Open Sesame is a unique experience with gourmet bagels paired with curated and high quality ingredients. The Kiss my Hass sandwich on a Jalapeño- Asiago bagel is amazing. The rosemary malden sea salt bagel with truffle cream cheese or the blueberry habenaro cream cheese is also fantastic. The owner will take the time to help you match your tastes to the perfect foodie experience. Lots of interesting weekly specials. It's in a simple bagel shop but a really elevated - and quirky- hidden treasure. read more

Hey we have been coming here for six months and excited for them to open in Willits town center. The bagels are top notch, actual bagels, better than you get in major cities. Jack puts a ton of effort in designing his sandwiches and they are always perfectly balanced and tasteful. The cream cheeses and salads are innovative. This place is a true gem. Coffee is terrific too. read more

First time here and wow what a great impression! We were welcomed with a free latte and coffee. The service is top notch and friendly. Great way to start the morning! Our bagels sandwiches were delish! read more

This bagel shop was delicious! We are from Texas and saw this place on google and wanted to give it a try on our way out of town...don't hesitate to stop, everything we got was delicious! The owner was very sweet and funny! read more

Open Sesame - Asiago bagels with bacon, egg, tomato and cheese and the other has chive and scallion spread (I couldn't wait to take a bite ) - Bagels Near Me - Basalt, Colorado

See all

After camping with friends, we stumbled into this local bagel spot--tired, hungry, and a little confused by the menu. Right away, the owner (or maybe just the friendliest staff member ever) greeted us with a warm smile and made us feel completely at home. He was incredibly helpful as we tried to figure out what to order, offering recommendations and even sharing a few laughs with us. read more

During a recent stay in Carbondale we picked up bagels for family at Open Sesame in Basalt. Wow! Amazing fresh bagels and the best selection of creative and yummy cream cheese spreads. So good we had to stop on our way back home to pick up enough to get us through the week. Free latte or coffee with bagel order. Don't miss the place when you're in Basalt. Owner is working the orders and super friendly and happy. Outdoor and indoor seating available if you want to sit and enjoy. read more

The French toast bagel with strawberry cream cheese was recommended and I would say it was an amazing bagel. I also tried their onion something bagel. Got 2 free lattes and I was so impressed. Good quality bagels in a small town of Basalt. Good find for sure read more