I have hiked Old Rag for many years now at least once or twice a year, often more. It is my favorite east coast trail by far. I hiked the trail with a party of friends for the 4th time this year on Friday after Thanksgiving. The weather was near perfect and our party found ourselves sharing the trail with the largest crowd I have ever experienced. The Park Service lot completely filled around 0930. This allows the person who owns the adjacent pasture to open a gate and park cars for $10.00 each - The Park Service also charges $10.00 so the only real negative is for those of us who have an annual or lifetime pass, which of course, the little neighbor lady who collects $10.00 does not accept - but despite this slight disadvantage she is providing a great service since there is no other option for parking within miles of the trail. I lead with this because some of the reviewers on this site have indicated that she is ripping folks off (or words to that effect) - when that is absolutely not the case since she doesn't raise the ante from the park normal fee. . In any case thank her for the service she provides, (even if her attitude is not entirely pleasant on the day in question as was the case when I was there Friday!) So word to the wise, if you are an annual / lifetime pass holder and you want to save $10.00 get to the parking area early during the prime weather / days of the week
The other negative which is repeatedly mentioned in these reviews is the large crowds on good weather days, (especially holidays and weekends) and the lines that sometimes form at a few of the slots. Of my 20 plus times on the trail I have experienced this only a few times and yes it is something of a negative but I can report that the crowds have always been uniformly polite and friendly and I have seen friendships initiated in the waiting periods as well as at the most popular rest stops and on the summit. Of the many hundreds of hikers I have walked with I have seen very little litter and virtually no rude or inconsiderate behaviour (a few smokers and one person walking with a music player blaring is all that comes to mind). Conversely I have only had a few completely solitary walks, always on bad weather days. So the bottom line on the crowds is the same as the parking - if you want to avoid the lines at scramble slots then get in early and you will be ok - and if you are training for an ultra or otherwise running the trail definitely get an early start on good weather days - if not then just relax and enjoy the company and people watching.
Most of the reviews do a great job in describing the trail and provide good advice on shoes, water, snacks, lunch, etc. The only things I can add is to recommend that if you are prone to sweat a lot on warm days then bring a couple of hand towel size sweat rags to wipe your face. . When I forget this I am miserable with the unpleasant side effects of profuse sweating...
One last point - be aware that if there is an emergency on the trail and the ranger is not on station at the parking area (they leave in the early afternoon most days and are absent entirely on low traffic days) there is an emergency phone box on the side of the shack at the gate. Open the box and you find a red phone which automatically rings the ranger station at the park. If, for example, you need the chains opened to drive up the fire road for any reason the key may have to come down from Big Meadows, which even via the fire road will take some time.
It is a great family outing - just be patient and help one another, start early take plenty of food and water and take plenty of photos to enjoy later. I have seen a few 4 year olds walk the entire trail with only a few assists at some scramble points and many, many fit men and women in their 70s enjoy the trail
As you will read in every reviewers post here, Old Rag is a unique trail, a challenging, non-trivial walk in the woods with great views at scenic overlooks and many seasonal delights (wildflowers, mountain laurel blooming, bear, deer, hawks, ravens and bobcats are sighted, spectacular rock formations, unusual lichen growth, etc), Additionally the drive out 211, through Sperryville and down through Nethers Rd is wonderfully scenic. Tlhere are just no real negatives if you are in good health and ambulatory - then satisfaction is pretty much guaranteed. read more