What I like about this place this word is located, the shopping opportunities that exist around it, and how clean and well maintained this particular ice cream store is. It definitely has an old-time feel with very nice people working there. The quality of the product is very good. read more

A long time favorite.... Absolutely great location for foot traffic. Great menu, product, and service. As I wait for my wife, lots of customers Sometimes, she will opt for frozen yogurt over pie.... read more

Old Mill Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pigeon Forge, Tennessee

Coffee Sho across street was closed. Luckily there's coffe here besides ice cream! Got a large 16oz. It's the only size available read more

See all

Great shop in a cute area. I wanted to try the banana but it was frozen solid for some reason. 3 servers working but very slow was my only issue. I think it was due to so many customers ordering milk shakes and they went the extra mile in making them. My second choice was very good. read more

Old Mill Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pigeon Forge, Tennessee

Delicious homemade ice cream! Located in the Old Mill area close to Pigeon Forge, it's perfect for stopping after a long day of activities, but getting away from the crowds. They have a nice variety of flavors, some classics and also some more unique like cheesecake. I ordered a scoop of Whiskey River and Cookie Monster. Both were very good! Whiskey River has caramel, walnuts, and chocolate pieces in vanilla ice cream. Cookie Monster is vanilla with oreo and cookie dough pieces. They both had a wonderfully creamy flavor and filled with many ingredients so you tasted them with each bite. Reasonable priced for a touristy area too. read more

Old Mill Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pigeon Forge, Tennessee

So I didn't realize that old Mill had a bunch of different shops along with two food places. We saw this and figured we'd check it out. My daughter and I both got pumpkin cheesecake and it was extremely soft it was very cold outside but it melted super quickly And as she hands it to us it's dripping down our hands. The taste was all right it wasn't amazing read more

Old Mill Creamery - Pumpkin cheesecake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pigeon Forge, Tennessee

Absolutely delicious ice cream and treats. Staff was so friendly and warm. Portions are generous!!!! I would come back read more

Old Mill Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pigeon Forge, Tennessee

Delicious ice cream and some nice places to sit and enjoy it. The kids scoop size is appreciated too. Nice people and good ice cream - what more can you ask for? read more

Our friends raved about this place, and that's why we wound up here at 8:45 - 15 minutes before closing. All the flavors looked good, on the wall and in the freezer. There was a line, and I was hesitant to ask for a sample. But the three young ladies were sweet and patient. I decided on a scoop of Cookies & Cream and Vanilla Bean in a waffle cup. The cones looked too messy on a warm night. Husband had the banana pudding. He said it tasted like the pudding, but better! Mine was good, too. So good that I know we'll be back. We sat outside on a bench in front of the store. We watched them put up the closed sign. And we watched large families come and look disappointed. The young ladies opened up the store for them, but at 9:05, with a long line inside, they put up the sign again. They wanted to clean up and go home on a Saturday night. But the few that got in were so appreciative. As I said before, and it bears repeating, this was our first time here. It won't be our last. read more

See all

Came here on Saturday, during the afternoon. We were exploring the town, and it was so hot. We couldn't resist having a nice cup of ice cream. They offer lots of flavors. I dont think i have ever seen banana flavor of ice cream, so i wanted to have a taste of strawberry-banana. It was quite good, actually. However, we got a cup with 2 scoops. Coffee and strawberry flavors. Coffee didn't have a strong taste of coffee/caffeine. It was already getting to melt while she was doing the scoop. On the other hand, strawberry was good. Had a good texture. The store seems like very busy; always had a line. Outside had lots of seating area. So, if you wanna have a quick rest with some ice cream to cool down, you should try this place :) read more

Old Mill Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pigeon Forge, Tennessee

Delish! Good ice cream and went back twice! Yummy flavors and we were happy. Loved the special flavors.

Whiskey Ribbon and Butter Pecan - best flavors! We decided to have dessert first here while waiting for our table across the street at the Old Mill Restaurant. Ordered kid's sized cones and they were very generous with the portion size! read more

Wonderful location, good service and terrific ice cream place - what more could you ask from a place on a lovely sunny afternoon. Hubby got a one scoop of black cherry, and I received a 2-scoop cup of coffee topped with coconut ice creams. I was in heaven with the coconut pieces in the ice cream that I intentionally lingered over it. The coffee flavor was also very good and I enjoyed it very much. This is a must stop for everyone!! read more

We stopped in at Old Mill Creamery during our first visit to PF. The shop is located in a cute area surrounded by other shops, sitting area outside and lawn games. There is a large selection of flavors and the ice cream is so delicious. They were so helpful and allowed us to sample so that we could decide between flavors...there were so many good choices!!! I sampled the coconut and the peanut butter. Such a hard decision but peanut butter won and it did not disappoint!! My husband got two scoops - coffee and butter pecan. Can't wait to visit next time we are in the area. I'm definitely having the coconut!!! read more

Old Mill Creamery - Coffee and butter pecan. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pigeon Forge, Tennessee

See all

Where can you get good ice cream in Pigeon Forge? Try looking here. The Old Mill creamery is across the street from the Old Mill and restaurant. Inside you can sample the flavor offerings. I wasn't overly hungry but decided to try the bear paw ice cream made with chocolate and caramel. I got the kids' size bowl since I wasn't overly hungry from my lunch. Got tons of napkins because it started melting right away before I even left the place. Outside there are porch chairs to sit in and take in the scenery. Needless to say this ice cream was so good but yet not overfilling. The chocolate and caramel were not overwhelming and I must say I enjoyed this little treat. Definitely worth a visit if you are visiting the Old Mill shoppes. read more

See all

There is nothing like fresh homemade creamer ice cream. Plain vanilla is all you need to taste the beautiful effort put into the food

Mixed feelings here. Decided to come here because they had really unique flavors. I sampled a couple of them (banana pudding and oatmeal cream pie) but wasn't terribly impressed. I ended up getting a pralines and cream in a sugar cone that was just average. Prices were very reasonable. We had a negative interaction with the manager, who overruled her staff and charged us for tap water in an unkind way, making us feel terrible and like they're just focused on money. I wouldn't go back. read more

My experience was good.I got the 3 scoop in a cup. I got Cookie Monster,Oat mill cream pie and brown butter black walnut. I loved the cookie monster and the brown butter black walnut but the oat mill cream pie didn't taste like anything and was bitter in the end. the brown butter black walnut was really good but I felt the the walnuts were stale. read more

Old Mill Creamery - Front store - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pigeon Forge, Tennessee

See all

Cute ice cream shop in a cute little market space. I e cream was very tasty and full of fillings.

Let me start by saying that I really don't even like ice cream. The kids eat it all the time and I don't even get anything for myself because it's just not my fave. However, I made an exception for this place, once I realized they make their own ice cream. I got a sample of the "Oatmill Cream Pie" and it was DELICIOUS. My kids got "Play Doh" and I don't even know what it was made of (lol), but it was SO good. We got a cup with three scoops and asked for an extra cup to split it up. We sat out on their picnic tables in this cute little area. It was really nice. Highly recommend, even if you aren't an ice cream lover. read more

We ate it so fast so it wouldn't melt, so I didn't get pictures. Best ice cream! I had coconut and it was full of pieces of flaked coconut. Very smooth and creamy. My husband had strawberry and you could see pieces chopped up in it. Prices are super great-very inexpensive. Staff was very friendly and inside was very clean. Don't miss this hidden gem! read more

Fantastic ice cream at a reasonable price. Ice cream was made from scratch and included a ton of variety. The sundae options were a bit lacking but overall you can't go wrong stopping here. read more

Five stars because I really appreciate the high level of friendliness and the welcoming atmosphere that I felt as soon as I walked in the door. I came in with my 2 year old niece and one of the employees was so kind to her. She interacted with her, tried to get her to dance, and made sure to say goodbye to her. I also saw how friendly they were with other customers. They make a real customer service effort here. The ice cream is good, typical ice cream. I tried the coffee ice cream on a cookie. I only wanted ice cream on one cookie so they gave me the other cookie packaged. The cookies are huge and also really good alone. I recommend taking them up on the offer to warm up the cookie. I know it seems weird to warm up a cookie that you will put ice cream on; however, it would soften the cookie & make it easier to eat with a spoon along with the ice cream. read more

Old Mill Creamery - Cookie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pigeon Forge, Tennessee

Such yummy ice cream, and lots of outdoor seating available! My husband and I really enjoyed our treats, and the staff was really friendly. Highly recommend! read more

Old Mill Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pigeon Forge, Tennessee

Friendly service, staff actually helped me pick out what I wanted since I love PB and I wanted something with texture as well. They also have slushies which is what my 9 year old chose, they also have coffee which would be about amazing right now. Outdoor seating is available as well. read more

Old Mill Creamery - Cookie dough Ice cream with peanut butter syrup - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pigeon Forge, Tennessee

4 Thumbs way up... A hot day needs to include some delicious ice cream. It wasnt until the near last day PF we happened to find this area. It's really cool. A small village with restaurants and stores - all pretty much part of Old Mill. Anyway - we had their banana pie ice cream - and it was out of this world...they literally bake a pie and crush it in with vanilla ice cream. We also had chocolate - a boring pick by my daughter and vanilla - creamy but still boring. Score a table outside and enjoy some under the umbrella... It wasnt busy when we got there but did pick up when we left. Staff was friendly and you can sample their flavors. Prices were not very expensive and a small is big enough for two. ENJOY! read more

Sorry, just not that impressed with this ice cream. I got cookie dough flavor and the cookie dough tasted like a stale cookie. I tasted the orange cream which was pretty good, maybe I should've gotten that. The woman who served us was very kind and personable! Also, note that the waffle cones are not homemade. Homemade cones do a lot in my opinion! read more

Nice homemade ice cream. The Whiskey ribbon is a treat with bites of caramel and walnuts. I loved the dark chocolate raspberry as well. Not bad prices and a good selection. But every scoop seemed very runny and a bit melted, only complaint. Over all yummy fun! read more

Old Mill Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pigeon Forge, Tennessee

The ice cream was DELICIOUS! I got two different scoops in the waffle bowl! My server was very helpful with helping select flavors and taste different flavors so I could decide what I wanted. Store is cute and quaint.... Wish it was bigger, but was BERY IMPRESSED with how fast I was served. read more

Ice cream is great! Service wasn't. The 3 teenage girls working at time of visit tonight, clearly didn't want to be.

This is one of the best ice creams I've ever had. It was so smooth and creamy (hence the name), but resisted to melt at the same time. The girl who scooped mine was rude when I asked for a sample, and got ice cream all over the side of the cone. Other than that, it was very delightful. read more

Old Mill Creamery - Cookie Monster on top and Oatmill Cream Pie on bottom - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pigeon Forge, Tennessee

The basil cider is where it's at! I love that they carry a handful of ciders along with their wines. You can sample both as well. Love one? Take it home in a growler at a very reasonable cost! Many places make you buy the growers and then pay to fill. Not this place! Get both at a low cost! (About $10) which you cant beat! If you're staying in the area, once you drink it, bring it back in and fill it up for a couple bucks off! read more

Old Mill Creamery - a chalkboard with a message on it - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pigeon Forge, Tennessee

We came here in the afternoon for some ice cream. This area is commonly crowded, with other shops and restaurants enjoined, but we were able to get a parking spot in the lot across the street. There was only one other party there when we entered and the employees were all wearing masks. The flavor selection was good and the ice cream even better. I liked how the mint flavor was white and not green, not adding any artificial colors. The cookie monster, which was blue, was a hit with my youngest. I had the Snickers flavor and enjoyed it. The ice cream was fairly priced for a tourist area and add-ons (cones and sprinkles) were also reasonable. read more

I was impressed with the ice cream and spotted at which the ice cream was served. We ordered a vanilla milkshake, whiskey ribbon milkshake, and a vanilla cone. Two girls were in the front when I came in and when I started ordering, one girl immediately started making the food. Awesome customer service!!! Also, this is the first time ever my daughter completely finished her ice cream cone. Usually it's about a quarter gone before she chucks it. read more

Old Mill Creamery - Vanilla cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pigeon Forge, Tennessee

This was a nice little ice cream shop that I could take my two small dogs to. I bought them both a kiddie size cup of vanilla for $2, just the perfect size. We went outside to the patio and I hooked their leashes on the chair rungs that I sat on we didn't have to worry about messing anything up. It was great! read more

We have been coming here for years. We always recommend to family and friends. Love their ice cream. Typically, the portions are very generous. Today, however, the portions were about half of what you normally get. Very disappointing and the staff was not very friendly. We will try again and hope things are back to normal. read more

My mom specifically asked me to take her there so that she could get coconut ice cream and when we get there they have decided to not make that flavor right now so she was incredibly disappointed and got what they said would be the closest thing to it and she said it was just OK. Keep in mind that I've been hearing about about this coconut ice cream now for a year ... My biggest complaint with them is that they do not have any vegan ice cream. One in three people are lactose intolerant so it boggles my mind at this point in time why every ice cream place doesn't have vegan ice cream and candidly nobody should be eating dairy in its current state, it's not healthy. I will say their employees were very friendly and very helpful as best they could be. The store was clean and welcoming. We were just very disappointed that the coconut wasn't available and they didn't have vegan. read more

Old Mill Creamery is a country themed ice cream ice cream shop in the Old Mill Square. Of course the place is country themed. It does have some unusual ice creme flavors including Oatmeal Pie, Banana Pudding, Brown Butter Black Walnut made with real bourbon!), Whiskey Cream; Almond Tart. I wanted to try the Creamery because I tried the vanilla ice cream at the Old Mill Restaurant the day before and it was excellent. Cold Mill Creamery did not disappoint! I tried a cup of the Wedding Cake: a rich vanilla with chunks of white cake of frosting! Delicious! 12 year old enjoyed the Sprinkles flavor (yes, tons of sprinkles!). My 14 year old nixed the iced cream in favor of a homemade oatmeal pie! I would not say the staff was the most enthusiastic but they gave us plenty of samples and were polite. There are many dessert places in Pidgeon Forge but I would definitely give Old Mill Creamery a try! read more

See all

Delicious ice cream! It's very creamy and flavorful. The oat mill cookie ice cream was so unique and definitely worth trying! We couldn't believe how reasonable the prices are. Highly recommend! read more

Old Mill Creamery - Old Mill Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pigeon Forge, Tennessee

Fantastic Ice-Cream! This review is after my 5th or so visit to this little shop when either waiting for a table at the Old Mill, or after a meal and walking the strip. There isn't really much to say since in a lot of ways ice-cream is just ice-cream, and to be honest, most shops all have the same generic flavors. The Old Mill Creamery falls into that mostly generic category for me. I guess if I was really pressed to pick out something special about them I might be able to conclude that the their ice-cream is somewhat creamier than others, but in reality the only thing that is really "unique" about them is the location and the Old Mill namesake. For what its worth I'll definitely be back next time I'm getting lunch or dinner at the Old Mill, and like I said in my opening line, it really is fantastic ice-cream, but aside from already being there its not really a place that I'd go out of my way for. read more