It's slim pickings out in this area when looking for food. My husband did some digging around on Yelp and found this place. When we walked in, we were like "oh Lord , what did we just walk into". Waitress told us to sit anywhere - we picked a booth. Menu was pretty big with a wide variety of sauces for wings, tons of pizza toppings for pizzas, burgers, salads etc. My hubs got wings dry. Wings were lightly dredged in the perfect seasoning and were deliciously crisp. I got the 1/4 lb burger and it tasted like a White Castle, with a slight hint of onion. Side of slaw was delicious. Fries were also very good. Stepson had the taco Mac n cheese and he loved it. oh and the waitress was great! We will be back! read more

Meh. Not fresh. But then again... it's a pub. Ive had worse... Ive had much better. Staff is great. Appetizers are from a bag. Ramen barria was ok. Wings were garbage. Mac and cheese was mediocre. It's a solid 3 for this area. A 2 in any city. The pub does look much nicer than it used to, but the food needs to be better. In response to a disrespectful response on google; Meh, not fresh. But then again... it's a pub. Ive had worse... Ive had much better. Staff is great. Appetizers from a bag. Ramen barria was ok. Wings were garbage. Mac and cheese was mediocre. It's a solid 3 for this area. A 2 in any city. Also, the owner can't take criticism. I live three miles away. Your wings ARE trash. "Much better people"? Nice bud. Won't be back to try the rest of your 'fresh from the bag' crap. Do better. Go take notes from the Canaserega soup and coffee company. Learn a thing or two. Do you really think that your wings are on par with the best in the southern tier? If you were to place in the top 3 in a contest, I would buy $2000 worth of your wings just to put my money where my mouth is. They are not good. Dry, un-original, run of the mill, deep fried trash. Just because you sell a lot of garbage doesn't mean that it's not garbage. read more

Had to stop in to see how they fixed it up. Great cold beer and wings. A must stop when I visit Alfred. I remember it from years ago. Nice, cozy spot. read more

I think I have just witnessed the worst thing I've ever seen at a restaurant. We were sitting there waiting for our food and this sweet elderly couple walks in the door out of the rain with big smiles on their face for date night. The restaurant is empty...They ask for a table for 2...The young lady says we can seat you upstairs..Both of these sweet souls struggled to walk and had cane's. They see all the empty seats and ask "Can we just sit there" NO SORRY THATS FOR TABLES OF 3 OR MORE!!! This possy of young waitresses was completely rude and disrespectful to this sweet old couple...I will never step foot in the door ever again..And as they struggled to make they're way back to their car... Woman in tears...I heard her say the same thing...WHY WHY Do we not respect the elderly...Let alone customer service 101...Absolutely Terrible and ruined their night. read more

I would have given 5 stars. Food was great! Had pb&j wings and they were amazing! But staff seemed confused and lost about who was waiting on what tables. read more

Old Mill - Amazing pb&j wings - American Near Me - Alfred Station, New York

Easily the worst place I've ever eaten at. Avoid the Mac and cheese it's just noodles with dried up cheese. Waited over 3 hours to do apps dinner and desert. Over an hour between each meal. Spent 4 hours in the place and waiter only came to our table 3 times. The beer bucket wasn't served in a bucket but instead beer bottles on the table that sat warm the whole night instead of on ice. Waiter never came to check on us it got to the point I had to get up and get myself as well as another table waters cause we had waited over 45 minutes to get a water refill. Worst service ever and even worse food. Unclean as well. Couldn't even eat without swatting away flies. read more

My son wanted to go here for wings and said he'd been there with friends and they were good. So, we figured why not... we pulled in to the parking lot and I was definitely hesitant... anyway, we went in, we're greeted and seated. Sat down and she quickly took our drink order and then food order. We ordered one app and entrees. Our food came out. My husband was happy with his burger and fries, my son of course liked his wings and my salad was okay. The appetizer never came out, and the server was extremely apologetic and gave my son a voucher for a future visit, which I thought was very nice. The price is right and portion sizes are good. Later in the day, my husband realized he left his credit card there. We went in the next day and picked it up. She knew exactly where it was and he was happy to have it. read more

See all

Nice interior upgrade, food is good and most of the times I was there the service was good but I think there is one young waitress who doesn't enjoy her job and the customer suffers. read more

Place is filthy inside and out. Staff seemed confused about how to seat people. We took a table upstairs and quickly found that the condiment tray had ants crawling on the ketchup on our table. We moved to another table because our server disappeared. When she returned she was irritated stating " Did you get permission to move" We should have left then. When our food came the French fried were burned, the hamburger rolls were stale and the server rushed us with the check because her shift was over in 10 minutes. The worst place I've ever been. It appears that this is an owner and staff very new to the restaurant business. read more

Wings, beer, mixed drinks and sports on TV - what's not to love? They even welcomed a Rams fan deep in Bills territory - great time!

HUGE selection of drinks, there is something for everyone. I've had the wings a few times and they are my favorite--Crispy on the outside but still juicy on the inside. They also have tons of options for sauces, some for the more adventurous, but lots of classic options too. The owner has really cleaned the place up and expanded the menu. Staff is very friendly and quick. read more

Great food for a great cost! Vegetarian options were great! The sampler plate is definitely worth it!

I've eaten at the Old Mill multiple times. Food is delicious, drinks are made to perfection, and the service was fast and efficient. The place does get very busy, but I do believe that they take reservationOver the last two years, since I've discovered the Old Mill, the owner has done an immense amount of renovations and the place looks great! You should definitely try out their fish fry's or their wings (Cajun ranch and mill steak seasoning) read more

Amazing food! So many wing sauces to choose from, and their steak dinners are to die for. You are made at home in their cozy dining room or upstairs arcade. They have the best rewards program to keep you coming back and an amazing,friendly staff! read more

Old Mill - A steak dinner with baked Mac and cheese - American Near Me - Alfred Station, New York

This place is such a joke. They had phone or mobile orders or something going on and they were out of stuff that people were ordering and then trying to substitute for side salads even though the order had been paid for? We've gone here twice. First time, there was a guy and girl bartender, the girl couldn't make drinks and we were just not satisfied. Last time we went, we wanted to get some drinks and then get food, we walked in and the same girl immediately took her time talking to customers as we just walked in and sat at the bar. We waited at least 10-15min before being asked what we'd like. I asked for a seltzer of some sort, simple. My boyfriend asked for a *WHISKEY* sour We watch as she proceeds to chit chat and make the drink with vodka, maybe sour mix, and garnished with a lime?? We asked did you make this with vodka? And she proceeded with a nasty snarky little girl attitude that she indeed made a whiskey sour with vodka...my boyfriend literally couldn't handle it and walked out. While I tried to pay for my drink and leave the rest of the staff just stood there dumbfounded as I asked multiple times how much is this so I can just go. read more

Noah, The owner of the Old Mill is great. He's got a great attitude and very knowledgeable and friendly. The Ol Mill has a very good atmosphere and the decor is perfect. The beer selection was great and the bar can make every mix drink possible. I am recommending you stop by grab a beer and a pie. This place is very clean and my food was perfectly cooked, very tasty and served hot. I will be returning very soon! read more

Not worth the time to even go. It took 10 minutes to get seated then while getting sat down the waitress decided to take someone else's order. Then we get sat down at the table, we never even opened the menus and she asked what we wanted to drink. I have never been here so I didn't even know what they had for drinks. We ordered cokes which were completely watered down then proceeded to sit there for another 25 minutes waiting for her to come back. My boyfriend and I watched her come out of the kitchen 4 different times and look at our table then she would walk somewhere else. read more

A nice selection of food on their menu, relaxing environment, and good beer selection. Delicious wings and the Old Mill Spice is really tasty. Our server Cassie was really friendly and attentive. We will definitely be back! read more

Waitress was ehh.They were out of everything on the menu even though we called ahead and asked if they would be able to accommodate our large group. The food we were able to order still got messed up some how. And if you're not a local, prepare to be stared down intensely by drunken hillbillies and hipsters. Enough said. read more

Nice country tavern, our food was excellent , Philly cheese and 1/2 pound cheese burgers, perfect. Beer and wine at reasonable prices and our waitress Brittany did a excellent job. Can't wait to go back! read more

I was pleasantly surprised when we arrived and were told the kitchen was closed but the fryers were still going. We ordered Cajun ranch wings and peanut butter and jelly wings. OMG they were amazing !! the PBJ is subtle not overly sauced which made them perfect. I love trying new things so of course we did the mango habanero vodka shots and WOW it was exactly what I wanted. Bam Hot the service was great and a special shout out to the owner and Kayleigh or server / bartender. Thanks for a great night. read more

Stopped here on our way to Cooperstown. Other reviews were spot on. Had lunch - fantastic portions and delicious!

Came in here on my way through. Nothing too big or fancy, but they did have pretty good drinks for not too expensive at all, and they do have some pretty cracking jalapeno poppers, so that was a plus for me. They had a much wider range of items to choose from (chicken tenders, pizza logs, chicken wings, etc...), and I heard from the locals that the wings here are the best in town, so sounds like they have enough so you dont feel like you're eating the same stuff over and over read more

Mostly locals. Felt like I got weird looks from regulars and jerked around by the bartender cause I wasn't a regular. Asked for a dirty martini and he laughed.. My mistake I guess. Beer selection was good, and they've got darts and pool--there's a plus. Definitely a hoot to checkout but not a place I would regular. Maybe when I'm 60 and decide to move out to the sticks, buy a farm and a 12gauge, but by then this place will be long gone. read more

What can I say? It's just a relaxed time. If you don't want to wait 10-20 mins for service and you don't want a bunch of kids pushing past you, come here. read more