The best pizza in New York State and great customer service! I would recommend the All the Way…read morePizza, but their Pepperoni and cheese is amazing also.

Decided to take a ride to Pizza King when visiting our son at Alfred State. We walked in and were…read moregreeted and placed our order We got a large pie/half pepperoni and a chicken quesadilla. I was surprised how quiet the area was . Cute town. The quesadilla was very good and the pizza was good (a little oily from the cheese) I should have asked to have the crust done a little more on the well done side, but that was my fault. We took it to day and ate it outside in the garden area across the street. Price was fair.

Prices have gone way up, but portions and quality have gone down…read more I'm not spending $21 on a small average tasting piece of lasagna then paying like $4 to add a basic side salad on. This is sad because we used to drive over an hour to go there. We heard from someone at the bar at another local place that they think the reason why L'Italia changed so much is because it has different owners now. Our last visit it was a chilly rainy windy day and it was uncomfortably cold in their dining room. The music was also too loud. The straw that broke the camel's back was seeing the smaller menu with higher prices. We chose to go elsewhere.

Love our L'Italia! Always my go-to when back home visiting. Owners are spunky, motivated…read moreyoungsters on the move, who genuinely care about their customers and business. The team works seamlessly together for a very satisfying dining experience, always love their youthful smiles and friendly vibe! I'm a sucker for the same dish, usually, Pasta Chicago (sub tortellini), but have also enjoyed the burger. Tiramisu is my default dessert! Experimented with the pizza too, def a solid choice! Go here! Say hi!

We've been eating here since they opened and we love it! Their pizza and wings are so consistently…read moregood. The service is friendly! The garlic parm wings with the homemade blue cheese is my go to!

This is St. Patrick's Day and Eric has a Rueben Calzone today as one of his Monday specials. I…read moreordered ahead and arrived about 5:15. My order was just coming out of the oven so perfect timing. They included a delicious "thousand island" homemade sauce whose flavor absolutely complemented the tasty sandwich. Normally, Eric features either a meatball sub or a beef on wick. Having now tried both you better order ahead of time as he sells out every Monday.

Geez, did this pizza hit the spot or what?!?! Walked over…read moreafter a long day of skiing and was greeted by the owner himself. Sit at the bar and had a beer as I watched them hand toss my pizza, along with it cooking in a brick pizza oven right in front of my eyes. Have to say they are some of the friendliest staff I've met. And that pizza was to die for!!!! Literally had to unbutton my ski pants the next day. lol Soooo worth it though. Thanks guys, your Columbus, Ohio friend. See you next year.

Love the thin crust on the pizza. For 3 pizzas, 3 orders of wings and a salad, the wait time was an…read morehour and half. The pizza was good but it took awhile until we can pick it up. There aren't too many choices on pizza in this town.

Beer was great! We were happily impressed and then halfway through we realized they didn't make any…read moreof it and that this is actually a taproom. Regardless, was fine!

This place is worth a visit! We had the homemade pretzel and Margherita pizza. It was delicious…read more The crust is so amazing and the sauce is perfect. Our bartender was friendly and service was quick!

Pizza was delicious, but on a Barstool scale maybe in their-high 6's. Great that they deliver,…read moreexcept the driver never made it and we had to pick up. Things happen, but this small town pizza shop brings great quality pizza to the area and it will keep me coming back!

Pizza was solid. Ordered with no issue and got it pretty quick. Your typical pizza stop ambiance…read more Would definitely recommend

We traveled the 25 minutes from home to Alfred to try Duke's Main Street Pizza, because my wife was…read morein the mood for some "good" pizza. None of the local places really fit that description. We ordered the Xtra large Deluxe pizza along with 12 extra crispy, medium wings. The pizza arrived about 20 minutes later and I must say, the crust was tasty and had just the right texture.The sauce was excellent and the toppings were just the right amount with making the pizza, soggy. The wings were also pretty good, not quite as crispy as we like but they were good. The college students that worked there were all very polite and went out of their way to make us Senior citizens, feel at home. One plus is they have fountain drinks and bottle soft drinks. This pizza was definitely worth the ride and we had enough left over for another meal. We will definitely be going back.

wow, I'm from NYC area and this place is a disaster even by those standards. It's a shame because…read morethere is not much in the area.

Hole in the wall! Let me start with that. Super friendly staff and cozy interior. We ordered a…read morecouple things... cheese pizza, pepperoni, meat lovers, some garlic bread, and a cookie. The cookie was killer! Garlic bread was good but nothing crazy. The meat lovers and pepperoni pizza were amazing, they use the good pepperoni cups which always get bonus points. Cheese pizza alone was ok. Would definitely recommend to all!

I ordered chicken fingers & fries to go. The service was fast we ordered and picked up our food…read more The ambiance is a great space and big parties are definitely welcomed. If you're in the ellicottville area come check out this pizza spot.

Amazing restaurant near Dexter's! I ordered the chicken alfredo with a side salad. The salad had…read morenice moist lettuce and a great helping of ranch with it. The alfredo had a nice balance of seasoning in it, and they put in a LOT of chicken. My dad got the tortellini dinner. The price for both of us was $33. Would definitely eat here again! My advice: They Take A Little Long, so if you don't have patience, then I recommend doing takeout/delivery.

Love stopping in for a slice of the Sicilian pizza and chicken tenders! If the weather allows…read moresitting outside is really nice. Definitely an establishment I will return to.