I have not written a review in a longggg time, so since this is the place i ate at this weekend I must review it. Groupon and the delicious looking wings brought me to this place. Ordered the wings. They were alright. They looked alot better in the picture. I had the mexican grilled chicken sandwich with the waffle fries and it was delicious. The chicken tasted fresh off the grill and the bread for the sandwich was really good too. Service was fast no complaints there. Only reason why im giving it 3 stars is that the bill came out to $30 (before groupon) and it only included a dozen of wings and 2 sandwiches with fries. I think that it's kinda steep for that kind of place. read more

We had a groupon and they would not let us use it even though we used it on a day we were supposed to be able to use it. It was a waste of my time and gas. read more

The best thing I can say about this off off Broadway pub is that they have all you can eat ribs and the ribs are very tasty-first round was half slab followed 1/4 slabs hinting they did not want us to eat more-ribs were great smoky fall of the bone type...there seems to be a nice local following with small bands as teh place is pretty small-bar in front "restaurant" in back-not a destination place but f you are by the zoo and looking for grub, pop in! read more

We had high hopes for this small bar like pub. The smell inside alone should have been a warning, as it smelled like a urinal cake. The food was meh, bland and nothing special. Will not be back. read more

Good ole Groupon. We went here during a Hawks v. Bruins championship game. When we got there, I was confused what these people were doing with Groupon. It was a pretty divey dive bar. The front of the building seems like the original structure with a dining room edition on the back. Just like other reviews, the lights were pretty dim back there. The front was bright and welcoming, but full from the Hawks game. We unfortunately sat in the back next to the trashiest people EVER! Don't get me wrong, I LOVE dive bars. While confused, I was pretty excited to be here. The group next to us were all older 20s, and they were the type of people that thought that they were so interesting, EVERYONE needed to hear their conversation which included one loud mad trying to convince the two girls to kiss THE ENTIRE TIME! And their various drunk driving experiences. Why is this relevant, you ask? Because for me (and I think others?) a big part of the dive experience is people watching. These people were so irritating I wanted to run away screaming. Also, we got there around 9:30 pm and there were children there while their guardians drank beer! I would think it's a little late for children to be allowed in a bar? These kids were next to the crazy obscene people, so... great environment for them. Anyway, the waitress was really nice, but frequently absent. I will put that off to the Hawks and the annoying people next to us. Our food was standard bar fare. Nothing special, but pretty cheap. They have some amazing specials that we weren't allowed to get with our Groupon. If I were to go again, I would indulge in their awesome specials and sit in the front. read more

I am giving Off-Broadway another star simply because of the wings. We were there over the weekend and the wings continue to be some of the best that I have had since moving to the Chicago area. They are a good size and the sauce is traditional wing sauce. They don't add BBQ or any other thinsgs to make it their own "special" thing. It is just simple wing sauce. read more

A friend had a groupon.. (what a wonderful thing) She called when she got there and told me looked like a neighborhood bar do I want to meet someplace else.. We talked and decided no unsafe place in Brookfield and we would give it a try. Glad we did.. Didn't look like pic on the web page but Got in and even a seat in back where it was warmer. We both decided on the fish fry. Very good but a bit greasy but just what it says.. FISH FRY. It has a great taste and i don't find many places I like their slaw but this place it was good. I would go again if in the area.. it is kind of stuck back in a resident area so you would be surprised of the place.. Small but great food and service was good too.. Glad to have said I been there. The fish fry was 9;95 a person came with fries, slaw. My coke was 2.50.. total bill was 29.00 for two people. try it you will like it read more

Having move in just down the street and easy walking distance from Off Broadway, I was excited to try them out. It was a let down. So I tried them again. Same thing. 3rd time? Didn't help. Like an idiot, I even gave them a fourth try. The wings are a dry sauce and really are good, but they charge extra for dipping sauce, carrots and celery. What is that? Or put a notice that your about to be charged for everything besides the wings and the basket they come in. The service is also really slow and two notches above "rude". I'm really trying to like this place, the outside area is really nice and it's great because dogs are welcome. I know this place has a lot of regulars and above average bar food so I'm going with a three, but as far as going back? I'm not in a hurry. read more

Thanks to GroupOn Chicago for helping me find this place. It's a great neighborhood bar. Delicious food, great drinks, friendly service. I'll definitely be going back. read more

we came here during the brookfield spring fling and heard this band, i think called "redmonds"? a really good trio. sang janis joplin and johnny cash stuff. i want to say that one of them is a part owner or has some connection to the bar. this place has a real nice local flavor to it. they had a decent sized restaurant that was in the back. i would like to go back and eat sometime. read more

pretty good food. service is lacking. It's down the street from my house, which is really nice - i'll give it a few more tries.

This is a cute little neighborhood pub. They have tables on the inside and outside in front of the building. That said, there's a bit of improvements with the menu if they want people to come back. Got to the pub as people were outside eating and a group of locals came out to enjoy the nighttime air. Met my friend there and we decided to eat inside. We were the only two in the back room. People were along the side playing games on the slot machines and in the front drinking. Neither of us ordered alcohol, so I can't really comment on their selection. We both ordered Bleu Cheese Burgers with fries. Mine came out the wrong temp (med. well instead of med. rare), so we had to wait a bit for both of us to eat. The buns were good and there was plenty of cheese on the burgers. The meat and condiments were lackluster. The meat was not seasoned, and the only condiments were some pickles and a pepper. I was hoping for more like onions or lettuce or even a piece of tomato. The fries were good and crispy. And there was a good amount of meat in the burger. I just wanted more. The server kept my iced tea flowing and mostly let us enjoy our private dining room so we could chat and catch up. I'm not sure if I'll go back and try a different menu item. read more

Came here with my family during the summertime. This place is a really fun little neighborhood type of pub. It's food is pretty delicious and well-priced. During the summer-time there is outdoor seating, and you can bring your dog : ) I love that. So many times I've passed it and seen people sitting there, obviously %100 serene, simply enjoying a beer, the sunshine, and the company of their friends and dog : ) What more could a person want? read more

Came back again for a birthday celebration, and experienced more mediocrity. This time I had the lovely experience of dining in the back room. I wish someone told me we should bring a flashlight. We were the first ones seated for the evening and thought they forgot to turn the lights on. When we asked, the waitress explained that this was as bright as it was going to get because the lights were broken. It sounded like they had been out for a while, and there was no urgency to fix them. The apps were pretty typical and nothing extraordinary. The pizza burger was decent, but not sure why they make it with grilled onions. Once again, the only thing that stood out was their beer selection. read more

Five star on food - the place was decent. Had the hot wings (split with someone) which were amazing and then had the Buffalo Burger, wow!!! It was awesome, huge, spicy, fries were great... I was stuffed! Great meal, kinda simple on the atmosphere & dark. Felt like a place where the same guys hang out for afternoon beers every day. read more

I'm a fan. Cool, neighborhood location. Solid beer list. Good food and fair prices.

Great food in a great neighborhood meeting joint! Service is always friendly and fast. Outstanding wings and fish. Not much atmosphere but that's why you can come as you are and be comfortable here. read more

We get takeout from here all the time! We have lived here for close to 20 years and we love the staff and the food has never disappointed us. It is a great local bar but having kids we normally do not go in. read more

One of my favorite places to go for lunch in the Brookfield area. Great food, decent beer selection, and several Tvs to watch whatever you'd like. Small town feel to it which I enjoy. Highly recommend this place as an alternative to Buffalo Wild Wings. read more

I've been in Brookfield over 12 years and I'm kicking myself for not trying this place sooner. The cheeseburger and chicken sandwich were both incredibly delicious. The service was excellent. The beer was cold. Will definitely go back! read more

Well......this place very bad service and over priced food who pays for horrible food bad quality. We ordered Garlic bread and it had mold on it and the lady waitress didn't want to take it back we had to ask 4 times finally got a new one the cheese for the fries came out cold and tasted like old cheese don't eat it fries were the only thing that you can't mess up the wings are bad Buffalo Wild Wings is way better and they have 65 cent wings and better quality and service. I ordered some pop came out flat so I changed it for a tea and that tasted like a Chicago sewer so I had to walk to the cvs and buy my own drinks. The pizza we ate tasted like plastic sucked too. Please take my advice stay away from this place don't not waist your money or time. read more

Best fish fry is the area. Place can get packed but Worth the wait. We usually only go during Lent for the fish fry but again it's definitely worth the wait. read more

Great place. Very welcoming place, great wings, great service. I always enjoy OBP. People are fun, bartenders are good and the beer is cold. Great place for a Guiness. read more

My family and I have been customers here for years. The wings are great and the pizza is good. However, after some recent experiences, I'm fed up. The past two times we attempted to order pizzas we were unable to. First, we tried ordering an 18" pizza last weekend and were told we'd have to wait an hour and a half because they are only equipped to cook two pizzas at a time or something like that. Which, while frustrating, is still a bit understandable. Tonight, however, was mindboggling. We called to order a pizza and were told that they weren't cooking pizzas today because it was too hot in their kitchen. I can't even begin to comprehend this from a business standpoint, especially since today marked the return of football season and I'd imagine they would probably move a decent number of pizzas. Anyway, after these experiences, we're moving on and seeking a new go-to pizzaria. Maybe one that actually wants to earn money. read more

Never again... It truly is who you know there. The server was rude.. No cheese on the tortilla soup... never again..

Whats not to love? Have you seen their weekly specials?? Great place for a casual, inexpensive dinner or lunch. Total dive though! Don't expect anything fancy, it is Brookfield after all! If you want fancy, Lagrange is a stones throw away. It almost feels like you're in rural Wisconsin in the wintertime. Lots of local regulars frequent the place. Pizza is really good, so are the wings. The salads aren't bad either, I like the chopped salad. The burgers aren't the best thing on the menu though...Need to some salt and pepper or seasonings in the meat. They do occasionally have free pizza at happy hour. It was a nice little surprise the last time I went because I am pregnant and was STARVING!! They also have free popcorn! I really enjoy their outdoor patio in the summer time. We live a few blocks away and walk over with our well behaved dog. They allow the dog on the patio as long as it does not go inside and even bring out a little bowl of water! :) The staff is always pretty nice if you aren't a snob, (again, its Brookfield...) read more

Well, I live in the neighborhood and since the new owners took over the place, the quality hasn't been the same. I used a Groupon coupon. They were unwilling to substitute a salad dressing for one that came with the regular item, also the boneless wings as an appetizer were good except the "mild" sauce was way too HOT and vinegary and spicy. I've been there in the past but will seriously consider another place the next time around when I dine out. read more

Have been going here for years mainly on Wednesday for the wing special. The wings are good, but the owner is cheap. There's a charge for the celery and carrots that are brought out with the wings. Although the servers don't inform you. Most recently they started charging for refills on soda. read more

I really like the fish fry good prices nice service great wings lil pricey but great! Great beer selection....will definitely be going back for their fish fry on Friday's or Wednesdays read more

I really enjoyed the atmosphere of Off Broadway. I really felt at home there on a weekday night. The food was good and exactly what I would expect. I look forward to warmer weather and being able to walk to Off Broadway. read more

Very dissappointed! I ordered some take-out this past Friday and was truly dissappointed in the food I received. First, they forgot to give me the soup that went with my order, so we had to go back and pick it up. I should have let them keep it because it was too saltly and all I could taste was celery. The wings we ordered were dry (both orders) and the chicken parmesan was terrible. I'm not sure what happened, but the food wasn't like this before. I was really looking forward to some good comfort food....and I was let down! Don't think I'll be ordering from here again... read more

We ordered a large order of wings to go, instead of the usual BWW. They were much better, and meatier too. They have a good selection on the menu and we will order from here now when we want wings. It is also great, because they are local to us so it's nice to be able to support surrounding small businesses. read more

I've had fish and chips many places, but for a small neighborhood bar it's outstanding! 5 pieces of fried cod and crispy chips for $11.95. I'd drive out of the city for this to get my fix on. MAM read more

Food and service are good. However, they post a "No Gun" sticker on their front door. I will return when they welcome law abiding concealed-carry customers in the store. I don't want to leave my gun, which I carry for work reasons, in the car just to get a burger or meal at Off Broadway Pub. read more

I purchased a Groupon because this place is close to home and my husband and I are always up to finding new places with good food- and this is what we found. We walked in and I was a bit concerned that the food quality would not be the greatest and boy were we surprised! It is definitely a "locals" place but our server quickly made us feel very welcome. She was quite attentive and friendly. We wach had a sandwich and both were tasty and we will definitely come back for more! read more

We moved in right around the corner and were really hoping this would become "our" neighborhood spot (a bar you can walk to? yes please!) But were quickly dissapointed. So far we've been there three times. First we went on a week night for a couple of beers and some wings. We sat inside as it was a little chilly. Took a while for the server to come around, but it's kind of a small divey place so no big deal. She was pleasant enough, but a little rough around the edges (again, we chocked this up to "oh well, it's a dive bar, not an applebees"). We ordered wings and soon found out that if you wanted anything other than the traditional sauce you had to pay extra, like enough extra that it made the wings pretty pricey. We figured, well, they're "award winning" so let's try it! They were...at best, "meh", and I'm really not picky about wings. Just so so, kinda greasy and not a lot of meat. BBQ sauce was kind of bland. The next time we went was during the stanley cup game when the hawks won. Now, it was crazy-town in there, and we totally anticipated waiting longer for service...when it did come (2 hours after sitting down) it was grumpy at best. We waited another HOUR for wings. Cut to paying the bill...they charged us $3.00 for the ranch & celery sticks.....huh?! Not extra mind you..just the little cup and 4 sticks that came with the wings in the basket. I asked the server and she got very snippy and said "well you didn't say you DIDNT want that" Ok....whatever. 3 hours for food and you charge us for the celery sticks (not on the menu btw). We tried again for a third time in the summer, we saw a groupon for 50% off food items and decided to give it one last try. We sat out on the patio and had some dinner, wings, and a few beers. Service was luke warm, but we were OK with it. When the bill came, we told the waitress we had a groupon for the food portion, she brought the bill and we gave her the groupon (I think it was like 20% off of food items or something like that) and gave her cash for the reminder of the bill plus a 20% tip. When I handed her the cash, I told her we were all set (i.e don't need any change, the rest is for tip), and she said "Don't leave, I need to go type in the code on this groupon to make sure you aren't giving me a fake one". I swear, if my husband wasn't there I would never have believed she actually said that. Really a shame they have such a great location in brookfield. Maybe the staff will change soon and we can try it yet again. read more

This was my first time here and I was so disappointed!! I came before going out to the movies. I had a long wait to be seated. I saw everyone pretty much with the wings and heard they were so good. When they arrived, they looked good..small but good. When I bit into the first one, I noticed that the bones were crushed inside..YUCK! I had my grandson with me who loves bar b qued chicken wings (this was one reason for coming). I tried the second one thinking that one messed up wing was an accident to serve to a customer, but the 3 that I tried were ALL like this! I couldn't let him eat them. I informed my waitress and she said she couldn't do anything about it even though she saw the condition and all the bone pieces. I asked to speak to the manager/owner who came over to me with a real attitude problem. He said he was sorry and refused to take them off the bill or allow me to come back for a replacement. I couldn't believe he made me pay for the wings, even though I left the majority (I saw that they were broken up also) on my plate. I would NEVER go back there or recommend this place to anyone...not even a DOG!!!!! read more