The prices were extremely reasonable, the food was amazing, and my steak was cooked exactly as ordered, the waitress was excellent, and the tavern itself was such a good vibe, 10/10 experience! read more

Mehhhh tried to return, but what a bummer. Got charged a mandatory $10 cover per person, even for coming in for dinner... I paid my $10, then spent 15 minutes trying unsuccessfully to flag down anyone to put in an order. Left with a lighter wallet and nothing to show for it after not being able to get anyone's attention the whole time. Bummer. read more

WORST "chicken chunks" EVER. Dry, tougher than shoe leather or a nail. $13.99 for 8 ounces of the worst, day old chicken breasts cut up into chunks and refried in seed oil GARBAGE you will ever eat. I do not recommend them. At all. Stick with regular wings. They should be ashamed of themselves. read more

So let me share the experience. It started with the waitress making a comment about beer choice... someone ordering Guinness in an Irish pub I guess is ridiculous. The wings were not cooked fully, but we couldn't tell anybody because the waitress would never come back to assist us. We had to flag her down to get another drink. When he finally got up to tell them, he was mocked for it but they did remove them from our bill. so thank you for that! The bartender had told my boyfriend that he couldn't cut it as a bartender there on a previous visit... Little did he know my boyfriend is a professional bartender trainer, and had been in the top three of the national bartending Olympics. Yes it actually exist. Oh and because of his bartending and food service experience, he knows food safety so arguing with him about raw chicken wings was entertaining. read more

Got the chicken BLT nachos and a chef salad. Both were delicious but the lettuce could have been colder/crispier. Jen/Leaha were gracious hosts and attentive even with a full bar of patrons. Give them a try sometime. read more

Great Pizzas and Wings. Normally take Pizza home but staff is good and atmosphere is unique. read more

Winner winner! Come for dinner! We've been here four times and they are consistently top notch. It's a perfect realization of a "pub" - public house. It's cozy and welcoming, lighting is on the lower side. Got a big, comfortable bar, dining area with high or low tops or booths. Part of it is set well away from the bar if you're with the little ones. Add a pool table, a reasonable amount of TVs, friendly folks and cheerful, attentive bartenders and waiters/waitresses, what more do you need? Oh, the food! To date have had BLT, homemade soup, ribs, Philly Cheese toasted sub, pretzel bites, and the fabulous fish and chips. Everything is way above average, even the fries and coleslaw are worth a mention. They actually have more than one brand of Malt Vinegar to dress your fish and chips. The BLT, which is one of my casual dining litmus tests, was superb. Cut in quarters, perfectly toasted bread & the bacon doneness exactly right. The ribs so tender and sliding off the bone with a sauce that does not overwhelm. There's Red Pepper Relish included on some items - or you can get a small side for 75 cents. I added this to my Philly cheese, boom! If you like to spice things up, don't miss this. O'Riley's is my 'supper club' as they open at 3 PM every day except Sunday (noon). Get in here. read more

See all

We are visiting and our hotel receptionist advised this was open late for a drink and food, so we stopped in. Our server Leila was young and did not know of any specials nor the prices of drinks - she said she was not old enough to pour drinks so she wasn't sure of much. We grabbed a whiskey sour and a coors light - the whiskey sour was literally ice. We ordered potato skins, onion straws, as well as a philly to go. Leila advised us the philly came with chips but once we got back to our room, their were none. I'm sure it's a local hot spot but it's not impressive at all. read more

See all

I didn't come in here expecting too much but was pleasantly surprised. Wings were good although they could have been hotter given it was their hottest sauce. I'd call it a solid medium heat level but very good. Place was comfortable and we will be back! Waitress was also the bar tender but she did a great job. It's worth a try if you're in the area. read more

Service was crazy SLOW! They were fairly busy, with a good crowd at the bar and a few tables occupied, but it was way too much for the SINGLE PERSON they had behind the bar AND waiting tables. Eventually, someone came out from the back a couple of times, but I don't think it really did much to lighten the load of the woman who was doing all the other front of house work. being from Philly, I was leery of trying the Texas Philly...melt, I think it was. It wasn't bad, but it wasn't great, either. I always enjoy getting Texas toast with my meal, but this really didn't stand out. My husband said the fish and chips were "nothing to write home about". He can't even remember whether they came with steak fries or regular french fries, and they only had a tiny splash of malt vinegar left for them. Really curious to know whether that poster for a pickle pizza was an April fools joke that was still hanging around, or not. Nice enough atmosphere for what it was, a pretty cozy place to chill, if you like the food. read more

There food taste wonderful , however you need to make sure to tell them you want your burgers done. I got home one time and it was raw in the middle read more

Call ahead The weekends are very popular! Stop up for good conversation, food & drinks (with the locals). During the week, call ahead. Closing time says 12+, but when I stopped at 10p on a Tuesday for a nightcap they were closing. read more

We were staying at the KOA for the weekend and wanted pizza and so this place showed up on the search. Not a lot in this town so we weren't expecting much and we're pleasantly surprised by how good it was. We went back the next night too! If in the area give it a try. read more

We love to eat here but boy can 1 bad server ruin it for you. I ordered a sandwich and it wasn't made correctly despite repeating my order at least 3 times (because I was questioning if the server was listening/understanding). I told her I was sorry but I couldn't eat it and would need it remade. She took it back and they dI'd a crappy job of scraping the ingredients off. You could still taste them. I couldn't even swallow the bite I took. I told the server, no apology and she didn't even offer to remake it or for me to order something else. i was so disappointed. read more

Great food. Seriously one of the best steaks ive eaten in a long time. Really great price and the flavor was there. It melted in my mouth and was to die for. Server was great as was the bartender. Cant ask for much more. Great drinks, great food,great service. Love the nostalgic feel,reminds me of home. read more

O'Riley's Tavern - New York Strip fit for a King - Bars Near Me - Brookville, Ohio

See all

The service is nice, food is always good with a wide variety on the menu. It can get crowded in the weekends but a nice spot for lunch or dinner on week nights if you don't want a crowd read more

Great service amazing food! Great atmosphere ! Family owed and very clean ! I ordered a pizza recently and it was hot and delicious

Love the appetizer sampler !! Small town and friendly place. Highly recommend! They also have specialty pizza

I have eaten here several times and after trying a handful of the menu items , I was most impressed with the breaded tenderloin. While it appears to be a prebreaded product , it is one of the better quality I have experienced. What really sets this sandwich apart is the bun ! It is Texas big... very soft and light , not heavy and over filling. The onion straws are also among the best. My trick for added flavor on the tenderloin is using the southwest sauce from the onion straws on my sandwich. read more

O'Riley's Tavern - Tenderloin with the best bun ! - Bars Near Me - Brookville, Ohio

See all

Great hand pattied burger. Impressed that the onion rings, fried pickles and other items are hand breaded. Clean inside.

This small-town bar and grill boasts the best wings in the area! We especially like their "sweet sriracha" sauce. Beyond the wonderful wings, they offer great burgers, and a very good pizza. Be sure to show your appreciation to the folks in the kitchen. read more

First time ever to the area, went with a coworker for supper around 700pm on 6/18. Ordered the chicken chunks, the Sweet Pepper Sriracha are awesome! The service was a little slow for only having about 12 people in there. Otherwise the food prices are fair and the food was good. read more

Ok so not going to win a James Beard award but as far as bar food goes, this place is bangin'! Wings are great. Subs have hot pepper relish.. so good. Definitely returning! read more

Friendly employees and a fun atmosphere top off the amazing food served here. Everything they served was delicious. The lights were recently replaced, so it's bright inside now. There are games to play and fun times to have. Even for kids, the place is great. read more

I really enjoyed the exterior of the building and the graphic on their sign. The inside of the bar has a very musty smell to it. Two gentlemen walked in and left because of it. Almost all of the light bulbs are burnt out over their booths. There was a huge cobweb connecting wall furnishings at our booth. This area of the bar seems neglected. The bartender was a pretty nice guy. There was a waitress hanging at the bar that seems miserable. Their burgers were good. It was pretty empty though. read more

Probably the worst cheeseburger I've ever had. The patty was uneven, the thicker part was undercooked. The bun was soggy. They use shredded lettuce and shredded cheddar cheese on their burgers, which I'm not a fan of. My burger was served with a half handful of bottom of the bag potato chips. And the spinach dip is disgusting. read more