At first I wasn't sure about this place, I did not like Joseph approaches asking me about my credit card details without knowing my concerns about the design of my cake. Nevertheless I decided to place my order with them and the final result was beyond my expectations, I was so happy with my birthday cake, It looked exactly like the picture I sent them they also made it in less than 2 days which was an exception of the rule but they help me despite the time and I am grateful for that, I also like the staff working there, they were nice and helpful. I must be honest it wasn't cheap but it worth it believe me. read more

Thank you Ismel and the NYC Birthday Cakes team for making such an impressive cake. Inside and out the cake was perfect! read more

Nyc Birthday Cakes - Chocolate sponge, cream filling and buttercream frosting photo cake - Bakeries Near Me - Queens, New York

The cake I ordered for my mom's surprise birthday was by far the most gorgeous and most delicious cake I've ever had. These guys were a pleasure to deal with. I picked a cake from the website and placed the order. I called the day before just to make sure and was reassured that it was in process. The afternoon of the party, Wilson, the delivery person called to let me know that he had delivered it safe and sound. When they brought this thing of beauty out, everyone gasped! When we ate it, everyone asked for seconds! It was scrumptious! read more

Nyc Birthday Cakes - a woman taking a picture of a cake - Bakeries Near Me - Queens, New York

Paid over $150 for a cake that literally looked nothing like the reference photos I sent them. I asked for pastel and was given a neon-looking cake. It looked like they worked on the cake last minute and put very little effort into it. Also within the instructions for the cake, I added the writing that I wanted inside parentheses in order to emphasize the specific phrase and they added the parentheses into the cake.... read more

See all

If it was possible to give a less than one star review for this business I would. As silly as it sounds we wanted to celebrate the day we got our maltese with our closest friends. I saw the cakes on NYC Birthday Cakes website and ordered a cake with a custom maltese topper for our event. If you look at the attached photo On the left is the example of the cake topper we wanted. On the right is the cake we received. This is what we received for a near $400 cake. Outrageous. If I knew they were not capable of doing the job I would not have hired them to do so. Hopefully we can hire a real custom cake maker next time. read more

Nyc Birthday Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - Queens, New York

Ordered a cake for my partners surprise 30th Game of Thrones themed birthday party. The end result was better than I could have imagined. The ordering process was simple and the communication was spot on. The cake was absolutely delicious- white cake with raspberry filling! Thank you so much to the Cake Designer Joseph. read more

Nyc Birthday Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - Queens, New York

They were extremely late with the cake for my daughter's recent sweet sixteen. Had to call them and they said that it would be an hour before they got there. They were suppose to deliver it an hour before the party, which started at 7pm. They didn't arrive until 9pm. read more

Well this was a very aesthetically appealing and delicious cake for me to give up 5 stars. I had a custom cake made for my daughters 15th B DAY she loves make up so hint hint. I ordered a standing makeup bottle cake from them with a tasty caramel mousse filling to go with the vanilla cake. I really like how the details were put in exactly how i asked their manager Mike pays a lot of attention to details and it reflects in the product. Mike was professional enough to go over the cake with me before it was started, he gave me a call once he received a picture of what I needed.Overall this was great from start to finish on everything and even if you order for a certain number of people on the cake i noticed mine had 5 extra slices available. I recommend this service for special cakes considered the quality and attention I received. read more

Nyc Birthday Cakes - Cool cake tasted just as good as it looked. - Bakeries Near Me - Queens, New York

I took a chance with ordering a custom cake for my wife's 40th Birthday...The cake was beautiful and so delicious. It was delivered on time and the communication was easy and painless with the staff when i needed to make changes to my order. I will definitely recommend a friend and will also do more business down the line thank you NYC Birthday Cakes....! read more

This review is for a two tier cake order I placed in July. I placed the order about 2.5 weeks prior to my event. It started out well. Had a couple of conversations w/ the cake maker to explain what I wanted (it was simple--I wanted an all black fondant cake w/ nothing else on it.) I was told I could pick it up the day of the event. On the day of the event I went to pick up the cake and it was damaged--the box the cake was in had created a dent on the top of the cake. I panicked when I saw it at the store. They then had me wait until they called the maker and wait for him to drive there and fix the cake. This took about 40 mins (not too bad I guess), however I was then running late and had to deal with traffic on my way to the event --I was in a panic. I understand that these things happen but what I am pissed about is how the cake looked after all of this. It was poorly made--I could lit see streaks on the fondant (see the photos) and debris on the top of the cake. I wanted to cry. The fondant was wet. Like shiny and just wet looking. Now that only means that the cake maker does not know how to make or work w fondant bc that is a tell tale sign--wet, shiny fondant--even after refrigerating (please see photos). It did not look like fondant. Now the other thing is that there was cardboard debris on top of the cake where they had to fix from the box denting. Once again, please see photos. The cake was supposed to be the center piece of my party and it was just a disaster. I was so embarrassed that I spent so much money on my party and the cake to have it look so amateur. THE WORST PART was the customer service. OMG the cake maker/owner was BEYONDDDD nasty when I told him that there is debris embedded on the fondant and the fact that the fondant is wet andddd the fact that they let a box cave in on the cake and I had to wait of him to do a bang up job of fixing it. He got on bad with me and lit yelled "leave me alone" like a 2 year child. He took no responsibility. This was the scary part that someone can ruin a cake that is impt to your party and just not give a damn and tell you to leave and hang up the phone on you. I was bewildered that I had to deal with this level of nastiness in customer service! I would urge anyone who wants a professional looking cake and who wants to deal with reputable, professionals to AVOID this place. read more

See all

I ordered my mom's 60th Birthday cake from here because their pictures from the website was Amazing and they got good reviews...Well I gave 2 stars because the only thing good about the cake I ordered was the picture the decor around the cake was Horrible....they put the happy birthday lettering in pink as if it was a baby shower...I asked for chocolate decor..the taste of the cake was Horrendous!!! I paid $225 for the most disgusting tasting cake EVER!!! What a waste of money!!! Don't buy a cake from here...save your money and order a BJ's cake instead!! read more

Nyc Birthday Cakes - A 60th Birthday day celebration...photo of when she was 20 years old...horrible horrible tasting cake!! - Bakeries Near Me - Queens, New York

I ordered a custom cake for my husband's birthday. Vanilla cake, pineapple filling, with white buttercream frosting, and buttercream flowers. I also needed it delivered. I worked with Ismael on my order and he was fantastic. Super smooth transaction. The cake was delivered today by the friendliest man. And the cake!!! AMAZING! First off, it was perfect and beautiful to look at ... and the taste, YUM! My husband could not have been more pleased. You cannot go wrong with Nyc Birthday Cakes!!! read more

LOVED the cake NYC Birthday Cakes did for my son's party, I got nothing but compliments from our guests. It was much more $ than I anticipated but I really wanted a 2 tier cake and all the fondant bakeries I checked with we're in line with each other. I ordered the cake 1.5 weeks prior to my son's birthday, Joseph was very helpful in thinking through the details. Our bottom layer was red velvet with cream cheese while our top was vanilla with fudge. Both very moist. I recommend the red velvet and cream cheese over vanilla, way more tasty (in all fairness I was recommended the vanilla for the kids). See inspo and actual cake below! read more

Nyc Birthday Cakes - Cowboy cake (left was my inspiration, right is NYC Birthday Cake's execution). I think NYC Birthday Cakes is much better. - Bakeries Near Me - Queens, New York

See all

Beautiful cake for my Mom's 70th Birthday Party!!! The service was excellent and the cake was a hit at the party. Would definitely use this company again. read more

A HUGE thank you to this amazing bakery for a quick 24 hour turnaround time.. On a wedding cake!! They were SO flexible and basically agreed to make the cake look like any picture I sent them. It tasted amazing, and the guests couldn't stop commenting on how beautiful it was. Such nice people to work with! read more

Nyc Birthday Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - Queens, New York

I ordered a custom cake that came out very very well. It was yummy. I heard from everyone that it was so moist and delicious. The photo was beautiful. They could have wrote with a color that had better contrast because it was light... But that was something i could have told them. I told him choose whatever color he thought. I gave them five starts because it deserves it. I see some reviews about bad taste... But mine was amazing! read more

Nyc Birthday Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - Queens, New York

Joseph made my 7 year old's Super Mario themed birthday cake. I saw the picture on their website and emailed them, giving them very little specifics and just told them that I just want the cake to look like the picture (which is on their website). The cake Joseph made looked EXACTLY like the picture and everyone was delighted! Cake was delicious, Joseph was so easy and a pleasure to work with, and his price was very reasonable compared to the other places I called. I highly recommend this place. read more

I'll give them three stars because they took a last minute order (1 week & 1/2 prior) and I was told the cake was tasty. However if I am going to spend a good amount of money for a cake I expected it to be more like the image I shared and more clean. The center of my cakes design was dripping black into the red color. Not sure if I'd take the risk again. read more

The best cakes in the tristate area..... the finished product is flawless and the best cake i have ever tasted read more