Over the weekend I made my at least 5th order here. Every time it is very predictable no matter…read morewhat I get., excellent!!! They have to put a lot of thought and love into everything that they put out. Home of the best Sloppy Joes!! From sandwiches to salad to iced tea and desserts I highly recommend this place. I had to take the time to leave a review this time because I felt it was very overdue. The gobbler sandwich is yummy, The Godfadda, The Gossip Girl, I also have had an egg salad with layer of tuna salad Sloppy Joe-that is amazing! The Cobb salad is also a fave. My friends rave about all the sandwiches they have tried. They are very friendly behind the counter and the order takers are fast and efficient. It gets crowded but moves fast.

Sandwiches are really fresh and tasty. The gobbler can be a little skimpy on turkey but still…read moredelicious. The sloppy Joe's are great and don't forget the chili basil bowtie salad. My go-to is the make your own salad with chunks of turkey. They don't skimp on the protein or your choice of veggies and the salad is huge!

Taylor ham egg and cheese is very good. Top 5 in Jersey…read more The prices though on some items is head scratching. Got a children's cup of meatballs that had 2 meatballs in it and cost $14. Comes with crayons but no bread to dip in the ton of sauce. What kid is slurping straight up sauce? How in the world is it the same price as a hot pastrami sandwich???? Also got up charged for asking to split half ham and half turkey on sloppy Joe instead of just turkey. Which I wasn't told about. $14 is not a children's meal price tag. Its not even an appetizer price. Had a great feeling about this spot but spending over $50 on a Taylor ham sandwich with a hash brown 1 sloppy Joe 2 meatballs And a pickle Is reason to never be back. I'm actually insulted.

Congratulations Pascarella Brothers for being named the best breakfast sandwich in New Jersey!read more

Amazing sandwich spot in Livingston! I had the tuna sandwich…read moreand it was absolutely delicious,super fresh, perfectly seasoned, and really satisfying. The service was also fast, friendly, and welcoming. What I love most is the variety on the menu. There are so many different options to choose from, whether you're into cold subs, hot sandwiches, salads, or something in between. It's the kind of place where you want to try something new every time you go. Definitely recommend if you're in the area and looking for a solid, high-quality sandwich shop. I'll be back for sure!

This place has become absolutely ridiculous. Imagine placing your order ahead of time and still…read morewaiting more than 20 minutes to get your food. What's the point of ordering in advance? Anthony, if you read this, you seriously need to check what's happening at this location. You either need to replace some of these employees or take their phones away, because they seem far more interested in being on their phones than preparing customers' orders. And don't even get me started on the customer service. It's practically nonexistent. There is no sense of urgency, no accountability, and no respect for people's time. Customers shouldn't have to stand around watching employees ignore them while orders pile up. I've known the history of Tony Boys Sandwiches and Anthony for years, which makes it even more frustrating to watch this location decline. It's hard to believe this is the standard that's now being accepted. Poor management, unprofessional employees, constant mistakes, and a complete lack of accountability are driving loyal customers away. A successful business depends on discipline, customer service, and competent staff--not employees who seem more interested in their phones than doing their jobs. Anthony, if you care about your reputation, it's time to clean house and restore the standards that built this business. This location needs a complete reset. .

Very impressed! I always pass by this place but finally ventured in the other day and ordered a…read morechicken parmesan sandwich and an italian sub. The sandwiches were packed with fresh ingredients and the bread was nice and soft. I enjoyed the sauce on the chicken parm sandwich, it was a flavorful mix of spices and a little sweet. The woman working at the counter was also so kind/happy! I'll definitely be back

This little local spot is a gem. Family owned. Small, worn in a good way. Counter seating…read more All made here. Super reasonable pricing. Very friendly staff and management. I had an eggplant sandwich on a roll. This was a long roll and could have easily fed two. What a great little spot!

Food was delicious service was great roast beef was nice and rare I will be back soonread more

!! Holy Cannoli this place is the Real Freakin Deal over here people. I mean everywhere you look is…read moresome kind of super special deliciousness just waiting to jump in your cart. Incredible Italian Pastas, Homemade Sauces, Amazing Baked Goods, Imported Pantry Items, Prepared Foods for days, Fresh Seafood, Delicious Assortment of Rice Balls, Glorious Meats, WOW!!  they gonna have to kick me outta here cause I ain't Never leaving on my own, LOL!! Wait, I didn't even mention the Sandwich Counter Yet. My thoughts must be popping outta my head, along with my eyeballs. What a great selection of loaded combination subs to choose from off of their menu board. I went with the #9 Italian Supreme Sub: Mortadella, Golfetta Salami, Sharp Provolone, Hot Cherry Peppers, on Fresh Baked Brooklyn Style Bread and it was beyond my expectations and explanations. Yeah it was THAT Delicious. Service here is very friendly and helpful especially if they see you're looking for something with that confused look on your face. For me it's not really confusion, that's just how I look when I get hungry. Hello? That's like all the freakin time LOL!! Come And Get Your Munch On!!

The most delicious fried chicken I have ever had.Namkeen flavor is amazing.10/10 100%read more

We came here twice during our visit to NJ/NYC. Everything we ordered was delicious! We got the…read moreTikkaville sandwich (delicious, the sauce complimented the sandwich well), the Tikkaville melt (very cheesy), the Nashville chicken sandwich (medium spice was pretty spicy but a good level for me as someone who can handle spice decently well; loved how crispy this sandwich was), the spicy maple chicken (yummy and quite sweet - I liked this as an additional item but not my main), and the masala fries (well-spiced). The restaurant gets quite busy so we did have to wait maybe 15-20 minutes for our food, but we were informed of that when we ordered. This is a good spot for a casual meal or grab and go, as there is limited seating within the restaurant. I would love to come again!

Ok can you tell me where the six stars button is because five stars is not enough! I can not rave…read moreabout this place more. I walk in and I am immediately greeted by Teresa herself. Staff was so helpful and friendly. I asked for some suggestions and they were spot on. The interior is nicely decorated. Now the real reason we came. The food is amazing!!!!! I got the drunken chicken parm with a side of their fresh pasta, it's better than you can imagine. This is a must go to spot.

First time-Quick service. The chicken parm two foot sub was delicious. The price is right. Friendly…read morestaff. Second time- waited 45 minutes for the cheesesteak sub special. I think the hidden gem has been discovered. Seemed short staffed. More people needed up front.

You know those days when you're on your lunch break and realize you still have to go food shopping?…read moreToday was that day. Hungry and very short on time, I ordered the turkey and brie sandwich from the Chatham Sandwich Shop. My order was ready for pickup in less than ten minutes. The sandwich was melt-in-your-mouth amazing--the kind of lunch that makes you stop after the first bite and think, "Oh, that's good." There's something comforting about places that do simple things exceptionally well. The Chatham Sandwich Shop is one of those classic sandwich shops that doesn't need to try too hard. Good food, quick service, and exactly what I needed on a busy workday. Five stars. I'll be back--probably the next time I ignore my grocery list.

So I ordered from here cause they had a pretty good reviews on yelp, itv says they've been around…read morefor 40+ years and they were running a pretty cool Bogo deal on Uber eats so I got the turkey club. Sometimes I like to throw random instructions in there like toast bread, melt the cheese and make the fries well done and surprisingly this shop hit on all points. The bread was fresh and so was the turkey, and the fries were well done to perfection and they had that golden crisp to them. The shop itself looks nice inside and my food was ready for pickup as soon as I arrived. If you are in the mood for a good sandwich then I recommend this spot will be going there again stars.