In a nutshell, this is in my opinion the BEST Indian restaurant in the United States. Yes, this is a loaded statement and is of course based on the experience of only trying about 150 Indian restaurants in the US.
That said, here's also a disclaimer: If you are looking for the chicken tikka masala and tandoori chicken that's brought to you on a hot plate for the lunch buffet; sorry, this place isn't for you. If you are looking for a fancy place that does some tricks to create so called 'fusion Indian' or makes the food 'look' good by using geometric tricks in a fancy place that charges you $20 a drink; sorry, this isn't for you either.
We were in Seattle and of the 5 of us, 3 had dietary restrictions so it was extremely important for us to find a place that could accommodate the 3 and get their bellies filled up. The other two (one of which was myself) can and will eat just about anything. Google recommended Nirmal's and I think this is probably the first time where I thank Google from the bottom of my heart for showing me Nirmal's as an option.
For the Indians, to put in context, the 5 of us consisted of 2 Maharashtrans raised mostly in the Bangalore area, one North Indian who has lived here for most of their life, one Kutchi who grew up in Bombay but has been here for about 20 years (but has a very open palette for an Indian) and myself who grew up in Tokyo, lived in Poona for about 5 years and have been here for about 20. That should set the stage for where I am coming from this review.
As you enter the restaurant, you could smell the amazing aroma of various dishes even through my KN95 mask. I was hungry before entering the space. Now, I could eat a horse.
We were seated promptly and our table (like others) already had glasses of water on the table that were a few degrees cooler than room temperature. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. I didn't have to request my water without ice and it was already there.
They were somewhat busy (about a third of the space was full) so it took a little time for the server to stop by to take our orders but when he did, what impressed us all was his knowledge of the food items. No, he wasn't an Indian. He was a young Black gentleman who had this amazing smile and was so friendly. He knew what he was talking about when he recommended the vada pav to us and Vada Pav we did order. Also ordered the misal.
Vada Pav was delivered and OMG, this did NOT come with the Hawaiian sweet buns that other joints serve vada pav with. It seemed the pav came straight from India (and if I didn't know I was sitting in a restaurant in the US, I would've thought I'm actually in India). That's how fresh and right on the pav was. The red chutney which you find with a traditional vada pav in Maharashtra looked and tasted just the way it should. The vada, spiced the right way having an amazing flavor hit the spot. All of us back in India.
The misal; hmmmm hmmmm hmmmm. Fresh, spicy and as I remember it from Nasik when I had it the first time.
We were already in heaven. They set up a very high bar and the taste buds in our mouths were waiting to be tantalized with even more deliciousness. They were not disappointed.
We ordered Saoji Chicken Rassa, Nizami Goat Curry, Bharwan Simla Mirch and Paneer Makhan Masala.
This was the first time I was tasting the Rassa but from the feedback from my Maharashtran friend, this was the actual Rassa exactly how he has had it in India. As a first timer, I thought this dish was outstanding. The chicken was cooked perfectly. The flavor of the gravy was AMAZING. I could leave the chicken and finish the gravy on its own.
The goat. You know, you usually flavor the meat with other flavors (bbq, masala, gravy, etc.)? In this case, the gravy got flavored by the goat and the goat was so succulent. It melted in your mouth. You could taste the subtle fat of the goat (FYI: Goat is a very lean meat but to be able to taste even the slight fat from it in my opinion shows the skill level of the chef cooking it) along with the spices. Nothing was too spicy or less spicy. It was just right.
I had a tasting of the gravy of the Bharwan Simla Mirch which held its own ground. I think it was a cashew and tomato based gravy so it was on the sweeter side. Although not my kind of flavor, I still liked it because of the freshness it had in it.
I was way too full to try the paneer and really really wanted to try the baby coconut ice cream that I heard of so it was either the paneer or the ice cream. You can guess what I went for and boy am I glad I did.
I am a registered fan of chocolate ice cream. The baby coconut ice cream made me flip overnight; this ice cream is AWESOME. The ever so subtle flavor of baby coconut put together with the amazing look of the ice cream (it was not 100% set. Every so slighlty melted with a shiny top) made this the best way to end the meal.
Nothing felt oily or heavy. Flavors were really like India (some may argue with m read more