Nick's Tomato Pie

Apizza Regionale was our girls night choice for our get together. My friends have never been, it's…read morebeen forever since I had their food (I've done takeout only). When we got there and added our name to the list, we didn't have to wait long to be seated. It was quite cozy inside and they have an outdoor patio as well. My friends ordered a drink they saw their Instagram which was the Cucumber Watermelon Sangria. They both loved it, I opted for water since I drank a bit this weekend already lol. We ordered appetizers and individual pizzas. I'm a sucker for a brussels sprouts appetizer and had to try theirs. This will be a repeat order, all the flavors balance each other so well(sweet, salty, and that mustard glaze yum). My friends enjoyed this as well. My friend's ordered the zucchini fritte and they enjoyed that. I ordered my favorite, tried and true The Calabrian (I love hot honey on anything lol). My friends ordered the Garlic & Broccolini (which would be my second choice). They both enjoyed their pizzas, my friend and I shared a sliced with each other. I like the garlic and broccolini as well, I enjoy a white sauce based pizza at times(I love broccoli on pizza, huge garlic person lol). They ordered dessert and coffee, and they both loved the pistachio crème brûlée. Overall it was a great evening with friends, delicious food and atmosphere. The service was friendly from when we arrived to the end. I'll add it to my date night list for my husband and I.

I really wanted to like Apizza Regionale more than I did…read more We started with the meatballs, which were incredibly small and unfortunately very dry. The sauce, however, was very good and easily the best part of the dish. The Porkstore arancini was also disappointing. They lacked flavor, and the portion size was surprisingly small. I would have much preferred one traditional, full-sized arancini because even combined, I'm not sure everything on the plate amounted to one. The pizza was good and ultimately the saving grace of the meal, but it wasn't anything that blew me away. For the price, I expected a higher level of quality, particularly when it came to the ingredients. I've had considerably better pizza made with better ingredients for roughly the same price elsewhere, even if admittedly not in Syracuse. The restaurant itself is very attractive and has a great atmosphere, but the food simply didn't justify the price for me. I left feeling like much of Apizza Regionale's appeal comes from the lack of serious competition for this particular style of restaurant in Syracuse rather than the food standing out on its own. Overall, it just wasn't for me, and I don't see myself returning.

Brussel sprouts

See all

Get the Chocolate Budino - heavenly!!!

East of Chicago Pizza - Syracuse

3.9(40 reviews)

2.6 mi

Certified professionals

Locally owned & operated

This is like the second review I did tonight about this pizza. Second slice was even tastier than…read morethe first somehow.

I have mixed reviewes for them as I have a few issues along with decent customer service. I ordered…read morea pizza and wings for delivery and it took almost 2 hours to get it and I ended up refusing the delivery at as it was sitting around for 1.5 hours before it was delivered. Tried them again after that with pickup, that one was ok then th elast time I ordered from them, there was hair in my pizza. Havent gone back since and wont.

Large 14" Just Cheese Pan Pizza

14" Double Stacked Pepperoni Pizza

See all

14" Large Tower Pizza

Di Lauros Bakery & Pizza

4.6(56 reviews)

1.0 mi

Stopped into Di Lauros today to try the pizza. We were greeted as soon as we walked in the door and…read morepromptly waited on. I ordered a slice of the cheese pizza ($2.70) and was very surprised at how good this was! They also had loads of Breads and pastries available but didn't try any of those. Definitely will return !!

I have got to add this review. While it's true, most of DiLauro's bread is tasteless and so not…read morelike the Italian breads of Italy or New York, their tomato pie is to die for. I've been all over the world following my passion for pizza. While the tomato pie is not truly a pizza (it has no cheese) it holds a special place in the sauce on crust world. A lot of Italian bakeries in the NYC area back in the day would have a sheet of tomato pie with squares available for customers to buy to go along with their canoli, biscotti, or sfogliatelle. DiLauro's has captured that memory & that flavor. So surprisingly good, mainly because their sauce is the sauce of the tomato gods; words alone cannot describe how ridiculously good it is. It needs to be experienced. Thick, zesty, memorable.

See all

Diluna varieties

Mario & Salvo's

3.9(170 reviews)

4.4 mi

I don't know how I haven't reviewed Mario & Salvo's yet, they are absolutely the best pizza in…read moreSyracuse and I will not change my mind on that. Here are some recommendations of what to order: -Classic cheese slice - so good, never fails -In a garlic mood? Try the broccoli garlic slice -Looking for something unique? Get the Grandma's slice, it's a special dough and is delicious! I usually see it on Fridays, and just tried a new version of it with Pepperoni and WOW I didn't think it could get any better but it did! -Don't want pizza? Check out the calzones, they're delicious -Pro tip: add a garlic knot, because why knot?!

I'm on a pizza mission while visiting Cuse heard this place has pretty good pizza. Which it it is…read moreand they will accommodate what you want to create. Wish they had lunch specials or a pizza and soda combos available(especially around lunch hours). Paid 22$ for large half cheese half white pizza with broccoli & mushroom. Not the best pizza in my life but Def enjoyed and would recommend.

See all

Tazza

4.4(20 reviews)

1.8 mi

Excellent pizza and wings. Great service and clean surroundings. I will return and highly recommend…read moreTazza!

Because of its location, I get to Tazza infrequently. Tonight I stopped for a quick bite and have…read moretwo slices of pizza: bbq chicken and chickens bacon-ranch. I was underwhelmed. Both slices were bland and that was very disappointing. Those are two pizzas that should be full of flavor and they were not. Guess it is time to check out the new pizza place on Westcott when I'm in that area and need a slice. In terms of service, it was fast. I sat outside at the picnic tables to eat and that was a nice change of pace. Now if only the slices had tasted better.

Boneless chicken

See all

Toss & Fire Wood-Fired Pizza

4.4(253 reviews)

6.5 mi

Another flawless pizza from Toss & Fire. Ordered a Small…read moreDetroit Pizza with just cheese topped with marinara. 5/5 Stars, thank you T&F.

This place is great!…read more We had flown in and were searching for a place to grab lunch. They make 4 styles of pizza, all under one roof: wood-fired, New York, New Haven, and Detroit. If you can't tolerate gluten, their cauliflower crust is awesome. If you can tolerate gluten, then you can appreciate the differences in how their four styles are prepared. It was happy hour when we arrived, so I decided to get a slice of Nee Haven. I believe it was a slice of White Brocolli Apizza. Super thin crust that gives off that satisfying crisp when you bite it, yet is soft when you chew. Very yum. My wife opted for the Cheeky Monkey on cauliflower crust. Their meatballs have bread crumbs, so we subbed in their over roasted chicken for the meatballs. Their cauliflower crust is also incredibly thin and slightly cheesy. Their roasted chicken was extremely juicy. The staff were very friendly and efficient. Seating inside was clean and bright. You can also sit outside. This is definitely a great place to frequent.

3 Little Pigs Pizza Four the Love of Cheese Pizza Tessa's Veggie Pizza

Believe or not , gluten Tessa's Veggie Pizza - 10x8 Gluten-Free Detroit Style Pizza.. sooo delish!?love it!!

See all

Cheese pizza slice

Gianni’s Pizza And Wings

4.6(5 reviews)

1.2 mi

To preface, I had this for delivery. Food was cold on arrival…read more Overall it was mediocre pizza.

In a town where there is no shortage of terrific pizza, add Gianne's to the list of yet another…read moreterrific pizza joint! Ordering off their website, I got a large cheese pizza with mushrooms and spinach. 20 minutes later I show up and the pizza was good to go. I like my pizza a little crispy so I ordered it that way. Everything was terrific. The mushrooms and spinach were fresh. There was plenty of fresh mozzarella cheese too. Though there's no such thing as "too much cheese" on a pizza, this was the perfect amount. The topper is the sauce and the crust. Both of them excellent!

See all

Large Cheese Pizza

Pavone's Pizza

3.8(115 reviews)

4.2 mi

Great pizza! great service! great people! super in expensive! will definitely be back again!read more

I wish there were more than five stars. Let me tell you about how it is the best pizza I have ever…read moreordered, eaten, and given to the staff. Everyone who took the order were fantastic. The order was hot, the crossed fantastic, and I ordered an antipasto which was huge and big enough for four. I live in Watertown, New York and I was in the hospital and I wanted to thank the staff of the floor that I was on on seven a. My roommate and I ordered the sheet pizza and we were lucky enough to get a couple of pieces, and then donated the rest to the staff both day and night. They went ballistic! They loved it. I hope you have new fans, but I know when I'm back in Syracuse, you have one in me.

Inside

Large Buffalo Chicken - $23.95

See all

Pizza Friday!!!

Pump Pizza Pub

4.3(56 reviews)

4.1 mi

Was in here today and the staff was wonderful the pizza delicious. I was only in there for a pick…read moreup ordered and she made me feel so welcomed!

The service was poor, the food was overhyped and tasteless and there were only a couple of people…read moreeating and drinking at the bar. I don't know how this place stays in business. I would not go back here.

Nice bar setup with lots of beers on tap!

Calzone

See all

Shrimp scampi pizza

Francesca's Pizza & Italian Kitchen

3.7(232 reviews)

4.3 mi

I've never had a bad experience here whether it be food, service, or cost. Check out the vodka…read moresauce pizza, it's the only one that I will get now!

I came for the Monday Chicken Riggies special. 2 orders of chicken Riggies and 4 garlic knots,…read more$21.99. I got it to go. All ordering is done at the counter whether dine in or take out. This was for a dinner with friends so I ordered 2 specials, especially since I needed some mild, some medium and some spiced hot. My mistake was going around lunchtime. I was getting hungry watching everyone eat and the food smelled wonderful. They were very efficient taking the order and I waited maybe 10-15 minutes...... which was good as they were busy. As soon as the server brought my order I asked her for a plate and silverware so I could eat some right away. It was hot, just a little spicy, full of sauce and a nice amount of chicken. It was delicious and I'll definitely be returning for this special.

Mozzarella sticks

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

9 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

S G.

8 years ago

Since the recent reopening the pizza has been amazing. The variety during lunch is great and the new speciality pizzas that have been on the line are delicious. This is a go to lunch stop if you work in the area. If you are looking for a late night slice after the bars close this is the place, they are open late ! Unlike some of the previous reviews regarding staff I have never had any issues with the customer service here. The staff is welcoming , nice and always accommodating to their customer's requests . Glad to have you back on the pizza scene in downtown Syracuse. read more

james a.

12 years ago

Im giving them 4 stars instead of 5 only because they don't have Tomato Pie available on a consistent basis - which is my favorite. Having said that, I go here at least once or twice a week not just because I work across the street. Because their pizza is simply the best. Alright, I'll give them 5 stars. :) read more

udeh w.

5 years ago

I love their pizza and delivery service don't waste time keep the good work guys and I can't wait for your Christmas bonus already

Raymond L.

8 years ago

Very nice people and a great late night option for pizza! was greeted with friendly staff and would recommend to a friend.

Ann P.

12 years ago

Almost missed this place ... Happy we found it! Great place to stop in with kids after a visit to the MOST.

Maggie D.

15 years ago

Nick's is great for the late night pizza and surprisingly just as good at 3pm as it is at 3 am

Tammy M.

4 years ago

Delicious pizza. Open late night and single slices available. Great after a night out.

Chad G.

529

11 years ago

where the fuck is my pizza? lets fucking go damn it

Michael J.

246

129

14 years ago

Delicious

Nick's Tomato Pie - pizza - Updated October 2026

People who viewed Nick's Tomato Pie also viewed

Pump Pizza Pub

4.3

(56 reviews)

Was in here today and the staff was wonderful the pizza delicious. I was only in there for a pick…read moreup ordered and she made me feel so welcomed!

Original Italian Pizza

3.5

(24 reviews)

Pop in grab a slice! Quick & affordable with friendly staff…read more BIG slices Garlic knots - yum! Picnic bench outside (summer months) Indoor booths available Cooler on site with soda options Variety of tasty treats

The vodka pizza is delicious. Boxing is solid. Could work on better cutting for pizza. I was to…read moretear mine up. Sharper cutlery is all I would suggest for business otherwise it's a good place to order pizza from :3

Amore Pizza & More

4.8

(25 reviews)

Back in like 2008, I remember seeing this building on 57 and it was just a plain looking building…read more The only sign they had was a single black and white banner that said "Pizza". I was pretty new to adult life, good food, and pizza outside my small home town, but I remember betting it all on finding a hidden gem in this random place that nobody should think to go to. I was still forming my roots in Syracuse and wanted them to be interesting. Anyway, I'm pretty sure that was at least one restaurant ago. I noticed the name Amore coming up a lot on online discussion for great pizza, and when I finally looked it up, I was excited to realize it was my old favorite no-name pizzeria. We started with a pepperoni/garlic halvsie pizza and some Extra Hot Wings. For Extra Hot, the wings were kinda spicy. Great tasting sauce and great wings though. Not top tier, but better than average. The pizza though, that's top tier. Soft, thin, greasy, crispy, not too much of any of those things. Favorite pizzas are hard in a place like this, but this name always comes up now. Next time we ordered, we were feeling the Bang Bang Chicken pizza. It's not something you see on every menu, and the way it was notated on their menu inside made it seem like a point of pride for them. This pizza had all the same great qualities as the original, but the chicken and sauce took it a completely different direction. The sauce was right on par with good bang bang sauce, but their regular pizzas are so good I wouldn't deviate from them again. One thing that struck me funny was that they limit only their Phillys and nothing else from 11 - 3. I'd be interested to know why that is. I thought maybe it was just a lunch price, but I placed my order shortly after 3:00 and ordering a cheesesteak just wasn't in the stars. We scrambled and decided on Chicken Wing Dip and Loaded Fries. The wing dip was exactly the same dish 4 different people bring to every potluck and Super Bowl party, just equal parts cream cheese, buffalo sauce and chicken. When we ordered the loaded fries, we were thinking nacho cheese, but these had full on cheddar and bacon. We had them with ranch and sour cream, but between that and the wing dip, it was a lot. Doesn't matter. All is forgiven if they keep churning out those pizzas exactly the way we had them. These pizzas alone will keep me coming back.

I have been hearing a lot of good things about this place and I was in the area. So, when in…read moreRome... My order was their special of medium pizza and 10 wings. I opted for pepperoni topping and medium traditional wings (an additional price). I also prefer less sauce, so I ordered my pizza with less. On a Thursday afternoon around 130pm, it was only a 20 minute wait. So no complaints there. First off, the appearance, in my opinion, looked like a basic pizza. Almost looked undercooked if I didn't see the steam coming off it. So, at that point, I was expecting something very subpar. However, it was very good. It is a pretty thin pizza, so dont expect anything too thick. Amount of sauce was perfect, cheese was good and pepperoni had good flavor. One of my favorite parts of a pizza is the crust and that is where I got a little disappointed. Its fluffy with a slight crunch (which is perfect), but there wasnt much flavor to it. Now onto the wings. I kind of expect wings to not be crispy anywhere I go and this place was no different. The upside to it, the flavor of the medium was very good. However, it almost tasted like a mild sauce. The wing itself was very juicy and tender. Nothing special, but they were enjoyable with a slice of pizza. The parking lot is very small, so if you have a larger vehicle, maneuvering may be cumbersome. It is just a row of spots and 1 lane to drive along their building. Just something to consider if youre going at a busy time. The woman working was very nice and attentive to when I walked in. She was in the middle of moving boxes and came right up. So good customer service. I did have to call because on their app I was unable to select between boneless and traditional wings. But, they do have an easy to use app. Overall, I gave this 4 stars due to pizza not really standing out and wings not being crispy. I enjoyed it, but I dont think I would specifically seek this place out for my pizza and wing fix. I would not mind trying other things on their menu.

Mario & Salvo's

3.9

(170 reviews)

Stingers Pizza Pub

3.4

(66 reviews)

After writing my review had to go back for the fish sandwich, my favorite fish sandwich in Syracuse!read more

Friendly service. You order at counter then they give you a number in a stick to put on your table…read more Country music Pizza is good, otherwise I'd say a notch about your typical pubfare; burgers are pretty good. Daily specials Fountain + bottle drinks and good selection of beer both bottles and draft.

Robbie T's Pizza

4.7

(133 reviews)

Biggest calzone anywhere, high-quality ingredients: mozzarella, ricotta, garlic butter on top…read more Can't beat the taste or the price.

I feel like I'm jumping on the bandwagon with this one, but a certain local Facebook group has been…read moreraving about Robbie T's for quite some time. I now have my own back to back experiences to share, so let's go! #1 -we stopped by 15 minutes before closing mid-week. Robby had shut down the ovens early because it was a crazy "yellow sky" crappy air quality day, and business was off. No problem, watcha got? A couple of leftover slices? Sold! We hit a picnic table outside; a minute or two later, Robby comes out and comps us a few more slices that were unsold. Love it! #2 -we ordered a calzone a few days later. Yes, it is crazy big, and delicious. Wings were just as they should be: crispy, and drenched in Frank's Red Hot. Prices are shockingly reasonable (shhh!) that it's worth the trip from F/M to Jamesville on a regular basis. My friend lives for their cheeseburger-we'll put that on the list down the orad.

Gino & Joe's Pizza

3.3

(42 reviews)

I miss certain style of pizza here in Central NY - however I finally found a place that makes a…read moreSicilian style pizza at Gino & Joe's on Route 31. The pizza is round, not square like traditional Sicilian pizza but the taste and quality were there.

Gino & Joe's has a couple of locations but I like this one the best. Great pizza but their calzones…read moreare world class. Most of the time enough for two meals. Always look forward to that second day. The lady behind the counter can give you a hard New York stare but she's actually very patient and kind.

Due Passi

3.9

(7 reviews)

Ordered 2 pizzas. Cheese and bbq chicken. Both were equally delicious with complex flavors. Tomato…read moreand cucumber salad was perfect side! Fed 2 with half left over.

We love their pizza! We get it take out or we go & eat at the bar at least once a month as we are…read morelocals. The staff is always so friendly & accommodating! Highly recommend!

Kostas Pizza House & Restaurant

4.8

(76 reviews)