First time to Nick's pizza. We placed an order for picked. Large Hawaiian pizza, Buffalo cheese curds, and pepperoni rolls. The order was ready a few minutes early and come out ready to eat. Our favorite was the rolls for sure. Lots of pepperoni and soft texture on the inside. The pizza was decent but could have used more pineapple and toppings. Cheese curds were a good surprise with spice. Small mom and pop shop with friendly service read more

See all

Good crust good toppings good pizza. Service was quick and courteous. I did not eat inside.

I just got a Pepperoni pizza here it was pretty solid i would definetly come back. Only reason i didn't give 5 stars is because the pizza was very thin and wasn't filling especially for the price. Still very good tho. read more

Shady Business. Ordered pizzas from here last week. Apparently they have an answering service that takes the orders for them at times. You are not made aware of that. When I arrived for my pizzas order was wrong. Woman at front counter forced my 16 yr old son to pay for them evn though he explained that wasn't the right order. She kept showing him the receipt and said "This is what you ordered. This is what you ordered. Take the pizzas". I called for the past week trying to get a hold of owner George who was supposed to take care of our problem. It's been two weeks and I have not been allowed to speak to George directly about the incident. Shady as hell read more

The quality vs price on this place is crazy. I've had better pizza, but at a far higher price point. Their service is always great too. This is a go-to for our family. read more

Bad quality, bad customer service, no accountability for dirty/contaminated/stale food/virus or bacteria infested food. I ordered a chicken bacon ranch XL. When I arrived for pickup, they were just making my pizza when I arrived. If you want a waste of time, money, and the contents of your biles to be exited from your stomach, go to Nicks Pizza. I attempted to eat this dirty contaminated virus or bacteria infested food three times, every time almost like clockwork it came out the other end. The pizza seemed a little undercooked when I started to eat it. The shop had flies flying around, and the kitchen looked absolutely filthy from the front counter. The cook had filth all over him. They said they only cooked the pizza for 10 minutes, to come back in 10. I called back explaining the situation to them, and they blame me for getting sick after eating their pizza. I asked the manager if I could speak to the owner, she said he wasn't available. I asked to give them another chance by offering a pizza either a cost or half off, to my surprise, they said no. They don't stand behind anything, including their food and customers. Skip this place, it's lost everything that made it what it was before Nick and Tom sold it. read more

Went in shortly after 8:00 for a pizza and they said they were closing. The two women who worked there just sat at the table talking. Hours were til 9:00. Just an fyi! Guess they don't need business. read more

Best pizza in Pittsburgh, and they have an original gem that is a first for me, the Doughboy. Basically a pizza/taco/panini, they tasted great. We had the Deluxe Steak pizza and Italian Doughboy and Philly steak Doughboy. All home runs and will definitely get again. Pete was very helpful and brought out the food very fast and hot. Again, best pizza in Pittsburgh. It's a must try. read more

See all

Ordered Earl's Sausage Pizza to support the #greatamericantakeout What a find! The pizza was really good. This was delivered to me and came piping hot . Crust - passed the stand test. The crust had a slight chew which I really like Sauce - neither acidic or sweet. They advertise that this particular pie offers a spicy version. I could not tell but it was very good. A great partner to the toppings. Toppings - lotsa cheese and sausage was awesome. The peppers rings added the final compliment. A really good pie - I will order again. Support your local restaurants and delivery workers especially when the product is awesome like this pie. read more

Nick’s Pizza - Earl's Pizza!!! #GreatAmericanTakeout - Pizza Near Me - Castle Shannon, Pennsylvania

We really enjoyed there Lent specials menu. We tried almost everything on the menu. The fish hoagie is HUGE and well worth the price. The macaroni and cheese was one of my favorite sides hands down. read more

We had pizza and wings delivered. The pizza was hot, very good, delivered on time, and was great the next day for lunch!!! The wings were flavorful and meaty. We will order from Nick's again in the near future. The Slice Ap was easy and convenient to use. read more

Nick’s Pizza - Nick's Pizza, 1/2 Pepperoni and Onion, 1/2 Mushroom and Basil and Nick's Hot Buffalo Chicken Wings. - Pizza Near Me - Castle Shannon, Pennsylvania

Decided to try Nick's because a friend suggested and we could not get thru to either of our favorite places on the phon. So many people doing take out or delivery on a Friday night. It is easy to order online. Really nice to be able to order online, wish more pizza shops did this! We arrive at the time the pizza was to be ready and they said five more minutes and they would bring it to the car. Sure enough in 5 minutes the pizza was delivered. The pizza was good but the crust was a little limpy..soft. We order half plain and half with 2 toppings/items and the pizza came with one item on each side..Oh Well. We also had wings which were AOK but the side of dipping sauce that was to come with was missing. read more

Fast service on a terrible weather Saturday night. Very good pizza half pepperoni and half cheese. The family all agreed we will order from them again read more

I've never had cauliflower crust that tasted so yummy before. Hubby couldn't even really tell it was cauliflower. That's saying a lot, as he hates cauliflower. Oh and the regular crust pizza is good too. Hubs also likes the wings. read more

Pizzas was quite good when it arrived, two hours after we ordered them. I get it - Friday evenings are busy. We expected a wait. The Slice app predicted a one hour wait but our pizzas ended up being delivered a full two hours after we ordered them. Would not recommend this place, at least not on a Friday. read more

The menu online features a picture of a pizza cooked in real pizza oven. Nope not a true story. They use a conveyor belt oven, so the pizza is either burned to a crisp or soggy. Mine arrived soggy. PSHhhh I'm not a fan of those nasty, fake ovens. Those ovens are cheap and the food cooked in them is disgusting. Pizza places that use them should include a warning on their menus so folks like me don't get ripped off & duped by their false advertising. I'll pass on Nicks conveyor belt soggy pizza. It's nasty. Blech. I want a refund & to not be insulted by businesses who take short cuts as mediocrity is what they stand on. I can't support a business that doesn't take pride in how their food tastes & looks. Am I the only person on the planet who doesn't want to settle for mediocrity? More on that later, for now I gotta run my easy bake oven pizza is done. Now those easy bake oven people know how to pizza with a 40 watt light bulb even. And it's way, way better than anyone who opts for those bullshit conveyor belt ovens. That's whats up. I didn't say anything about the salad - the pic speaks for itself, read more

See all

New owners took over, the pizza is very good. We got an extra large during the holidays and it was huge! It tastes fresh- that's the best way I can describe it. Ordering again tonight! read more

Good pizza. The subs are good too. They don't deserve a low rating for their food but they need to hire one more delivery driver. Delivery takes way too long with only one car running around. read more

It was the first time ordering from Nick's. I like it when you can order and pay directly on yelp, which was available for Nick's. The typical pizza, wings, and salad selections were available. I got a 6 sliced pizza with large slices. The pizza crust was softer and a big hit! The buffalo chicken on the salad was plentiful with fresh salad ingredients. The delivery was on time and friendly. I will definitely order from Nick's again. read more

I wouldn't even give a one star had better pizza from gestation steak hoagie was horrible everything was not good didn't even bother to complain to them because if you give customers food like that you shouldn't be in business wast of 80 dollars. Guess im looking for a better pizza place in south hills read more

nick's has been around a long time, through a few owners, but it's always remained great food! they deliver too! & they deliver quickly. they have a little of everything, which means there's something for everyone! apps, wings, burgers, salads, pizza, hoagies, even dessert! & it's ALL delicious! there are different kinds of pizza too. know that if you get a sicilian cut, you get 2 square pieces of pizza. our last order, for just the 2 of us, lol!, was-an order of fries with cheese & bacon, a whole supreme steak hoagie, a dozen garlic parmesan wings, & 2(so 4) slices of sicilian pizza with pepperoni & hot sausage. we ate until we could eat no more! even still, there was enough food for dinner the next night! lol! yes, stop in or call. they make us that happy! read more

Nick's Pizza is amazing delicious pizza and great staff! I had the 9 inch lunch combo and the nick Rolls. Everything fresh! So so good! Highly Recommend if your in the area. read more

See all

Decided to branch out and try other pizzerias in the area, esp those that deliver. We just tried a plain pizza (my daughters standard) and a calzone. The calzone was really outstanding. The dough was heavily seasoned and the interior was loaded with filling, not as much cheese. Only request would be a little more sauce accompaniment. Will definitely order again. read more

Never even tried the food i order one large pizza after and a calzone after worn at 5pm and it dint show up untill after 7pm and i asked what took so long and the delivery driver started giving me attitude and so i walked away and he started coming into my house n told him to f off, it made the the people i live with very upset at me for this interaction and we dint even get any food i wish i could review the food butt the staff their (phone people that lie on the time and the delivery people) and it was a friday and they might have been busy butt just say that over the phone or tell me your not taking orders rn were to busy dont say its gonna be 30 minutes and make me wait over 2 hours read more

Terrible service and very disrespectful. I ordered a delivery through Slice. I chose contactless delivery because I was on a zoom conference and wouldn't be able to answer the door. So an hour after ordering I check the app and it says any minute it should be delivered. 20 minutes later, still no delivery so I contact customer service and they reach out to the restaurant. The delivery person says they dropped it off but they described the wrong house. I told the restaurant this and they begin to tell me that I'm wrong and they won't give a refund or redeliver the pizza. I wasn't even upset until they started to take that approach. Manager wouldn't even speak to me on the phone and instead told me to hang up because they had "wasted too much time talking to me". Really bizarre and will definitely never be ordering from here again. read more

We ordered a salad, Italian hoagie, meatball hoagie, and mild wings tonite. Everything was delicious!! We were told our order would be delivered in 35 - 45 minutes, but it arrived in 25. Thank you Nick's for the great service and a delicious meal!!! Dawn Castle Shannon read more

Spent $36.80 on soggy Conveyor belt Pizza and 6 breaded wing dings that they advertise online as 12 jumbo whole wings. What a joke. The wings also come breaded and the breading sucks up all the sauce. Also this was advertised online as a $31 deal. I even picked it up myself and still don't know where the extra four dollars comes in as I was charged an additional dollar for the pepperoni on the conveyor belt Pizza also each slice only has one piece of pepperoni per slice. False advertising and crappy food won't be back don't recommend. read more

Love Nick's!! Just moved to Castle Shannon in the last year and this is our go to pizza place! Great service and even better pizza! Haven't had many things off the menu except for pizza but I highly recommend!! read more

I've lived in the area for for 30 years and Nick's was always a go to when I was growing up. It fell off a bit, but with them reopening I thought I'd give them another go. I have to say, I'm glad Nick's is back to its 90's glory. Easy online ordering and a very friendly staff made picking up the pizza 20 minutes after ordering a breeze. The pizza was well cooked, the cheese was high quality, and the sauce and crust were spot on. Really glad to another another locally owned, quality pizza shop in the neighborhood. Congrats on the grand reopening! read more

We ordered from here because our usual choice stopped delivering. Am I glad we did!!!!! It was excellent!!!!! We ordered a whole veggie hoagie that was so stuffed with veggies and cheese!!! It made the other place's hoagies look like 2 saltines with a lettuce leaf between them!!!! The buffalo chicken salad was sooooo wonderful!!!! The chicken wasn't breaded ( which I was over the moon happy about!) and there was enough sauce on the chicken and the perfect amount of cheese and veggies. The burger was huge and the pizza with extra cheese was superb! Nick's is now our number 1 place for pizza, hoagies and salads!!!!! read more

My son in law ordered pizza, wings and Italian hoagie. The pizza was delicious and still Very Hot when we got home 10 min away! The hot garlic parmesan wings were bomb! All the food met our expectations and we will be ordering again in the future! read more

Went there for the first time last night. Dined in as we don't like take out or delivery. Just a few tables but more than adequate for the two of us. Super busy Friday night. Phone ringing off the hook but Ava never missed a beat. Answered every call, waited on walk ins and ran for food-always with a smile. I was impressed with the delicious pizza and hoagie but even more impressed with the way the staff worked under pressure. We will definitely be back!! read more

We saw that Nick's had recently opened and thought we would give it a try. The pizza is really good and we will definitely be back. We only got pizza so can't say anything about the rest of the menu. But, I will say that the price is right too. Much better prices and special deals than many of the other shops around. read more

Established way back in 1979, Nick's has certainly been a permanent part of Mount Lebanon's dining landscape, and is likely the preferred purveyor of pizza for area residents. An appropriate analogy would be Brookline's Fiori's or Dormont's Campiti's. Recently, Kay and I decided to sit down and try Nick's pie for ourselves after traveling past it a dozen times while running errands. An oddity among its competitors, a Nick's crust is somewhat thin like you'd find in a Big Apple sidewalk special. A crisp exterior hides a somewhat plush interior. A fruity sauce, a freshly-grated mozzarella/provolone (?) blend, fatty bacon bits, and savory black olives finished off what was a tidy, tasty platter of goodness. The Meatball hoagie fell a tad short with its somewhat dry meatballs, the fine sauce and cheese salvaging the sandwich. The white-walled interiors are as sparse as the seating, but don't allow that to keep you away. Nick's is quietly serving up some quality pizzas in a modest storefont in a sleepy suburb. It's time the secret fell out of the attic. read more

Friendly, fast, and great service!!!! Pizza and Meatball hoagie were both great. I was a little apprehensive about going here from the look of the building, but i was pleasantly surprised. From the warm welcome upon entering, to the great tasting food. Everything was perfect and I will be returning. read more

Pizza was great and exactly how I remember it from a decade plus ago. Hoagie and salad left something to be desired. Going to just stick to pizza from Nick's and will be happy down the road. read more

Old-times feel, but they have awesome hoagies, great pizza, and very good italian food. They do deliver, and pretty much anything on the menu is able to be ordered for delivery. The drinks are by the can or by the 2-liter. In-store, you place the order and they'll either hand it to you at the counter or bring it out to you. There is very limited seating. You can call in your order and pick it up, too. Definitely would recommend. read more

I've driven by this place many times. I've heard friends say it was ok. I decided to give it a chance. It was one of the worst pizzas I've ever had. First of all, the pie had almost no real flavor. The dough, sauce, cheese...even the pepperoni was bland. I put some hot sauce on it strictly to add flavor. On top of it, I got so sick. Who knew a small pizza could cause so much internal chaos. My stomach was in knots for hours. It gave me terrible gas, but then the E. coli like symptoms had me doubling over. I have had better pizza at Little Caesars. In a competitive pizza city like this one, I will never try this place again. When you have Fiori's, Betos, Mineos, Slice on Broadway...there's no reason to subject yourself to this. read more

Sure wish we had tried Nick's sooner!! Truthfully what turned me off was the restaurant adjacent to them which had THE worst Chinese food I ever ate. Sorry Nick's, better late than never! Helpful staff via phone. Arrived inside and felt like I stepped back into the late 1980's with complete old green refrigerator- reminds you of being in your nana's kitchen! Got the thin crust large one topping (pepperoni) pizza and small salad to go. Really enjoyed both! Likely to be our go-to pizza order in the area, which we've been looking for! read more

See all

This place is the bomb. Great hoagies. Great pie. Fair prices. Cheap delivery. I have had a LOT of pgh pizza over the years, and this is a solid non-chain joint. The sandwiches are fantastic. Probably skip the wings or anything fried, to be honest though. Cheesebread is fantastic. It's WELL worth a try folks. read more