I've been to most of the wineries along the trail, with the exception of those closer to Rochester. Overall the trail is wonderfully diverse and eclectic with a mix of traditional wines and more unique offerings that set our local trail apart from the rest.
The best overall winery is Niagara Landing. They have the most generous tastings (6 pours for $3) and affordable prices, and they excel in a variety of wines so even people with different tastes from me are bound to find something they like. Other favorites include Honeymoon Trail, Black Willow and Spring Lake, but all wineries are worth a visit. Here's my favorite individual wines along the trail:
Dry white: Chateau Niagara's 2013 Gewürztraminer
Semi dry white: Chateau Niagara's semi-dry Riesling
Semi sweet white: Niagara Landing's Rosebud White
Sweet white: Honeymoon Trail's Diamond
Dry blush or rosé: Long Cliff's Platinum Rosé
Semi dry blush or rosé: the search continues...
Semi sweet blush or rosé: Honeymoon Trail's Pink Diamond
Sweet blush or rosé: Niagara Landing's Rosebud Rosé
Dry red: Black Willow's Trilogy Red
Sweet red: Black Willow's Black Widow Berry, Niagara Landing's Rosebud Red
Fruit wine: Marjum Manor's Blue Beryl, but it's sold out (possibly returning 2017)
Sparkling wine: Schultz' Mon Cheri
Dessert wine: Niagara Landing's Almond Dream, fave wine AND dessert
Also, I recommend Niagara Landing's Rosebud Cranberry to pair with your Thanksgiving Turkey (it's re-branded Spirit of Christmas) and Rosebud Gold with its pineapple flavor to pair with your Easter Ham. Rosebud Red is my go to for prime rib instead of a dry red.
I also recommend the Black Willow meads, especially Odin's Nectar. read more