After seeing this huge calzone on FB reels we decided we had to try it since we were only 10 minutes away. The owner of #NewYorkBestPizzaArlington was so nice and makes a delicious GIANT CALZONE! 4 of us barely ate 1/3rd. Just check out this video. If you are ever in Arlington I highly recommend giving them a try. https://www.instagram.com/reel/DajAZXHp-gS/?igsh=MWtkMHUybm1kZTNhYQ== #pizza #calzone #giantcalzone read more

Amazing food and great people working there Best pizza I've had in the Arlington area will definitely be back !!! read more

New York's Best Pizza - Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Texas

Me and my friend would come to the restaurant every once in a while, just to get the Philly! It is by far the best sandwich I've ever had, here in the Arlington area! read more

New York's Best Pizza - Philly Cheesesteak - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Texas

After many efforts to find good pizza in Arlington, finally found New York Best Pizza which is better than the rest. Not NY great but above average. No frills atmosphere. Fair prices. Does NOT offer alcohol despite claims on Yelp that they do read more

Place was busy but doesn't excuse shit service. Not only that the pizza was horrible. Ordered a meat lovers and they drenched it in sausage! I think I could have bought a frozen pizza and it would have been better. The calzone was good though Place seemed filthy, too read more

Pretty good, it's tasty and has a nice zing to it. Not bad. Not the best, but not bad at all

Wow! I ordered from here last week for a work event. We got 3 of the Giant Pizzas one cheese, one pepperoni and one pepperoni and veggies. The veggies were very expensive to add coming in at $8 per veggie and there didn't seem to be that much of some of the toppings. But.. the pizza was SO good. I'm from western NY and can easily say this is the best pizza I've had in Texas. The giant pizzas had 8 slices each and were insanely large. Next time I would ask for it to be cut in squares because almost no one finished a slice. I placed the order the day before on the phone and they were ready early the next day and they called to let me know. For the size of the pizzas the boxes held up surprisingly well! I will definitely be back again read more

See all

Cheesy and didn't skimp on toppings! Crust is not bad! Ordered in the store and took about 10 mins! read more

New York's Best Pizza - a hand holding a slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Texas

No pics. I ordered a large half cheese, half veggie with hamburger, and an order of wings. My lady and I wanted to try a new pizza spot, so we turned to Yelp for suggestions. This is how we ended up at this location. Long story short, the food was horrible. The wings were dry and hard, and the pizza lacked sauce and flavor. The only thing I could taste was the bell peppers. I have had plenty of New York style pizza this place, isn't it. Staff: A Parking: A Price: B- Food quality: F read more

well without a doubt this is our favorite pizza place. Im the brown on top well done pizza guy. The owner is nice and quick to remember us , they are so quick to make our pizza experience as good possible. The best part about this place is the leftovers if any the next day from the toaster oven. Havent tried the pasta yet but if as good as their pizza im sure it will be awesome . read more

I've been coming here for years, I love the pizza, prices, and size. Service is always good, restaurant is always clean. Would definitely recommend! read more

The food is always good always fresh. They are always nice whether you call your order in or drive over and order.

Luv luv this place. Delicious foldable pizza, great quality. Chicken parm delicious, as is the philly. Can't go wrong with this place. Small dining area, but most people do take out. read more

My son and his friends frequent this restaurant often as the food portions are generous, good, and it's close to their campus. He and I went recently to order some take out dinner for the family and I also had a great experience. My wife really liked the Philly cheesesteak and my son got another couple of huge calzones. I saw they had some other Italian dishes on the menu and ordered the Chicken Murphy (a chicken and pasta dish with a spicy, creamy pink sauce with jalapeños). The owner took our order and commented that he enjoys having some non-pizza / basic options on the menu. The Murphy was really good and we'll be back again. read more

Pretty great stop. We originally came to the area for Chinese, but found this nice little spot and decided to try it. The prices are unbeatable, 3 large crispy pizza rolls with a drink for under $4, c'mon!! For my meal I ordered the chicken parm sandwich. It was ginormous and filled to the brim with cheese chicken and sauce. I also ordered a side of Alfredo sauce to dip it in. It was so good! Don't let this place pass you by when you're driving round, it's in a smaller part of town but worth the drive out for sure. read more

This is just a late night pizza at the best. Cheese and sauce taste pretty decent but the crust it's just not good. It wasn't horrible but it's definitely not NY style crust at all. read more

New York's Best Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Texas

Bring an east coaster originally and happen to be in dallas from htx I have been missing NY style pizza. Found this place on yelp, they exceeded the expectation! The pizza was sooooo good me and my sister finished a medium and I typically never eat more than 2 slices. Omg I would drive back just for the pizza! And the guy taking orders at the front was super awesome! read more

New York's Best Pizza - a cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Texas

We came thanks to Other yelp reviews! The dishes are scrumptious simply phenomenal- Philly Cheese Steak sandwich and bf ordered the Baked Ziti. The breads are freshly made - warm and crispy. Wow We will be back for other dishes. Only complaint? They don't have non- sugar drinks or soda not even unsweetened ice tea. Management please offer sparkling water bottles or unsweetened tea. Not all that t us like sugar water drinks. Thanks! Also, good to know - BYOB read more

New York's Best Pizza - To go box - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Texas

One of the kids looking for a wings place...did not want to go to a corporate place and chose this place as it was highly reviewed. Mistake...had no ice for drinks...service seemed like it was a bother...food...eh. If you're looking for good food...would not recommend. If you're looking for food...it meets that criteria. read more

This is the place to come if you want a traditional New York style pie. The classic cheese is my favorite, but I have tried them all. They also have a wide selection of appetizers and great Italian dishes. The cheese steak sandwich is also a great choice, if your not in the mood for pizza. Give it a shot and you will not regret it. read more

New York's Best Pizza - Me following some awesome pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Texas

I LOVE their chicken Alfredo ! Their sauce chefs kiss! Their lemon chicken is also immaculate, and their pizza is the !

I wanna start off by saying this is a great place for awesome tasting pies with great ingredients at a reasonable price. The pies and calzones are just tasteful and hott when you pick up. The calzones are made from the pizza crust but are flattened in some way that just makes sense. It's good and it doesn't take away from the taste. You just definitely try this place for sure read more

Kids favorite pizza. Good simple service can't ask for anything else. Great pizza all around,great price as well

Nice fresh Stromboli with good ingredients and sized right for several people to eat on. Great courteous servers. Got an order to go. Plastic ware was terribly cheap and didn't cut the Stromboli. Got a cannoli and I could t eat it. Tasted terrible, I think the grease was old or is used for other things but had a bad taste that kinda lingered/ Not a bad experience but wasn't someplace I'm dying to go back to. I would recommend giving it a try. Especially to support local small businesses. read more

New York's Best Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Texas

This place is so legit. The pizza is great. I got cheese and I wish the cheese was a little gooier other then that it was pretty perfect. Nice dough/crust and slightly rich tomato sauce. The cheese steak was perfect as it was. Basic but decent salad. Honestly one of the better conolis I've had. A touch too much vanilla to it for me but still yummy. And this place is pretty cheap! read more

I thought the service was personable and friendly. Made suggestions on menu options. This was my first time eating here. It's small, limited seating, and the food was tasty. I would def come back when in the area. I found them through Yelp app and glad I had time. The marinara sauce was delicious, went well with my Stromboli. Highly recommend for a casual lunch or dinner out, or take out which was very busy. read more

Trust those Pizza joints that are unassuming and tucked away in strip center corners. I did with this one and it paid off. Nice big slices of pizza with a good tasting crust. There are a few different "lunch" specials they offer which are very well priced. We did pizza slices, calzone and a chicken parm sandwich. The real winner of lunch was the appetizer we ordered. Three pepperoni pizza rolls. I know these rolls are common things and almost always good. These rolls were cream of the crop though. The dough was slightly crispy on top and the "fillings" were seasoned perfectly. What blew me away though was the bottom portions of each roll. It was this super crispy flavor disc of everything that oozed out of the rolls and just came together to perfection on the bottom of the pan. It's kinda like when you get a fresh cinnamon roll and all the butter and sugar has formed together to bake underneath. Man o man ... Any way, those pizza rolls are big enough for a meal by themselves. Excellent!! read more

New York's Best Pizza - Pepperoni pizza rolls. (Came with a drink). Lunch special for $3.95, well worth it. - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Texas

See all

The pizza rolls are perfect for any group function & they are very delicious I will definitely recommend this place out read more

I remember the first time I had a Philly Cheese Steak here it was beyond what I could've asked for. It was soo good! The bread was perfect! If you know anything about a Philly then you know the bread is important too!! Bottom line, you can't go wrong here! Enjoy! read more

New York's Best Pizza - Philly Cheese Steak - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Texas

If I could do zero stars I would. Horrible customer service. Ordered online didn't fulfill order and wouldn't offer delivery .

Omg sogood The wings are so good i had to eat sum then hide em so my bf doesnt get any the pizza is good and the ranch is soooo good . Will be back read more

Ordered pizza tonight and didn't feel like getting the usual Domino's or Pizza Hut. This pizza place wasn't too far away so I decided to try something new. We ordered an XL pizza for $17.95, 8 wings for $6.95, and a slice of tiramisu. Our total came to $33. Delivery is always expensive to me but what can ya do. I swallowed my pride and temptation to reason about how I could make a meal in the time it would take to deliver and placed the order. Our order arrived in an hour and the woman who delivered was very sweet. Our food was hot although it could have been hotter. But I didn't mind too much because I do understand that it's cold outside. Taste wise I was expecting more from the reviews. I have had New York style pizza before and frequented two excellent pizza places when I lived in Chicago and while the pizza did satisfy us, I wouldn't say it was the best pizza I have ever had. Portions are good though. The pizza was a good size and the slices were huge. The buffalo wings were decent and on the larger side. Tiramisu was good, true to tiramisu recipes. Bottom line though, if we are in the mood for something different, we'd order again. read more

New York's Best Pizza - Half pepperoni half supreme mmmm! - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Texas

See all

This was, hands down, the absolute worst pizza I've ever had. The chicken tasted like a cut up frozen chicken patty, pepperoni was paper thin, cheese tasted cheap/low-quality. So bad even my baby wouldn't eat it. Definitely regret driving across town for this. read more

I can't say enough about this place as their Stromboli is the best! The filling is stuffed to the brim inside and sauce is good. We have not tried their pizza but heard it can compare to Brooklyn. read more

Despite what others say, who is probably only used to pizza from dominos, Pizza Hut, or papa johns, which these place have ok pizza but definitely is not great pizza. This place is pretty good after I try it. I'm from New York and it's pretty close to New York pizza. The layout is like New York pizzeria, small and tight, but New York don't have a lot of space like we do, so they do give me a New York feel(just like home). As for the chucky cheese comment, I think you can only compare little ceasar to chucky cheese. I order a special made baked ziti pizza and it was great, it's not exactly the same taste but it have a distinctive taste that is good on its own. I'm definitely coming back for more. read more

New York's Best Pizza - Great tasting baked ziti pizza, special ordered, thanks - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Texas

Simplest and cleanest tasting pizza ever! This place has such uncomplicated flavors, it's incredible. Tried the veggie pizza this time around and I could taste the freshest ingredients. For once I thought I was actually building health. Oh and DONT FORGET their deserts! Tiramisu cake was the bomb! Great texture, lightly sweet and slightly chilled. Perfect! read more

New York's Best Pizza - 14" veggie pizza($12.95 I think). Super delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Texas

Had the Alfredo pizza and it was SO yum! Literally was like eating a bowl of pasta on a giant breadstick. Don't consider having it if you're on a diet, unless it's your cheat day! If it is, then have yourself a whole one, lol! Quaint little place. Will definitely come again! read more

New York's Best Pizza - Alfredo pizza - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Texas

I've been coming here for a while for their take out pizza --- it's the only place I know of on the east side where you can get pizza by the slice, and their lunch special is a great deal. Today for the first time I ate in, and I was pleasantly surprised. The salad was good, and NOT iceberg lettuce, thank you, and the baked ziti was really very good. All good value for money, large portions (I had plenty to take home!), and their dinner rolls are wonderful. My only con is the TV --- small dining room, loud TV, I found it unpleasant, but different strokes and all that. read more

So my family and I ordered 2 slices of pepperoni pizza, a chicken parm sandwich, and a kids stuffed shells. It cost less than $20 to feed 4 of us until we were stuffed. Pizza was great! My aunt is from Pennsylvania and thought this was the best pizza she's had in the 3 years she's lived here. She even went back for another slice. It does take a little while for your order to come out if you get more than a slice of pizza, but it's well worth a wait. Everything came out popping hot and delicious. I highly recommend it all! read more

This place is awesome! 25 bucks and I got a giant philly cheese steak, stuffed shells, a Stromboli, and an order of pepperoni wheels and all of it is fantastic! Inside was super clean too, nice staff! read more