I rarely leave reviews , in fact, this may be my first one, but this experience was so negative that I feel compelled to share it. I ordered two sandwiches through the DoorDash app for pickup. The app clearly stated that the sandwiches came with chips and potato salad, which is why I chose that option instead of ordering a different special. When I arrived at the restaurant, I still had to wait in line before reaching the cashier. When I finally got to the counter, she handed me my sandwiches and then told me that I had ordered chips and potato salad but had not paid for them. I calmly explained that the app showed those items as included with the sandwich. Instead of resolving the situation professionally, she told me she needed to call the owner. She then had me step aside while she helped three other customers, leaving me waiting awkwardly off to the side. When the owner finally called her back, she spoke to him loudly (almost argumentatively) about me being there and "claiming" the sandwiches came with chips and potato salad. It was embarrassing because other customers could clearly hear what was happening. Ultimately, I was told the owner said the sandwiches did not come with those sides. At that point, I just took my sandwiches and left. The entire situation felt uncomfortable and unnecessary. If there was a mix-up with the app, that isn't the customer's fault. Good customer service would have been to honor what was displayed in the app and clarify the issue internally afterward. Instead, I left feeling frustrated and embarrassed. Unfortunately, this was one of the worst restaurant experiences I've had. read more

It says this location is closed, but I ordered food delivery from here today at work and the Cuban sandwich was fantastic! The best Cuban I've had outside of Miami. Delicious read more

First timers here. Tried the Cuban. Good quality meat. Fresh bread. Friendly staff. Restaurant has an old time feel in the heart of University Park. read more

New York Sub - Cuban sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Dallas, Texas

Saw this reviewed online. Delicious! Veggies very fresh. We ordered 1/2 sandwiches which was plenty. Bread was soft and almost like sweet Hawaiian bread but not too sweet. read more

New York Sub - Texas Club - Sandwiches Near Me - Dallas, Texas

See all

....... READ THIS REVIEW ...... D Magazine best subs in Dallas for a good reason! I've been eating them since 1974. Meats cooked in back - fresh and awesome. Many specials on the board too. Incredible secret recipe oil-vinegar sauce is their claim to fame as well. No other place comes close!!!! This is what a sub shop should be. GO! Family owned - support your local business! read more

Honestly a really amazing sandwich. It feels like an authentic ran down New York joint and I absolutely love it. I don't know how I missed this place every time I've driven by it but I will certainly be back. The only issue I'd have is it's pretty expensive for a sandwich shop, but judging strictly off of the sandwiches it's delicious. read more

New York Sub - Rueben - Sandwiches Near Me - Dallas, Texas

You need a good quality lunch option? You found the right place! Upon entering, you take a small jump back in time to slower times with arcade games and ice cream parlor style seating that is clean and well maintained. I had heard multiple people rave about New York Sub and frequently responded with "can a sandwich really be THAT good?" And IT IS! I have tried The Italian, Every Stop On The New York Subway, and Turkey Pastrami Reuben. Each sandwich had distinct flavors and notably fresh ingredients. They also have a bbq company connected to them that always has amazing aromas coming from the meat smoker and they sell some of their items in the restaurant. I will highlight, this is a "no BS" type environment where the staff will make sure your order is taken and everything is correct, but don't expect a chatty bunch (not rude, but very to the point). GO CHECK THEM OUT! read more

Wow! These subs are so good. Only get the Whole sandwich off you haven't eaten for a couple days lol. That thing is massive! Hubby got the Texas sub and devoured it and I got the half plain turkey and it's the least plain turkey sub I've ever had! Meaning it's mouth watering and so worth the wait. The line can get pretty hectic. The employees are swamped with in store and online to-go orders but they have a well oiled system you can tell. Nice and hard working. Worth the visit! read more

See all

Hands down the best sandwich I've ever had. I had the Texas Sub and the Chicago dog. I took it to go but literally had to call them and let them know how good it was. Phenomenal read more

Super fresh ingredients, soft bread with that perfect chew, and portions that actually fill you up. The flavors are bold without being overdone, and the staff is friendly and quick. Whether you're grabbing lunch or a late bite, it hits every time. Definitely one of the best sandwich spots around! read more

Decided to head over for lunch today after seeing rave reviews. I was about 12 minutes away but didn't have too much time so decided to call ahead and place my order. When I arrived there wasn't much parking but luckily I was in and out so I just pulled into the neighboring 711. The place has a very unpretentious feel. Very welcoming to all. I am glad I ordered ahead because my lunch hour seemed to be going by pretty fast. Staff was friendly. I had ordered the Italian Beef with peppers and a mango flavored tea by a company called Joe Tea. This came out to 21$ which is a little pricy compared to the other Italian Beefs I've had recently. The sandwich I had was very big in size and definitely had amazing flavor. From the first bite you know this place cares about the quality of their food. It was phenomenal. The heat from the peppers was a little delayed. The bread was very nice and held together well after I poured some au jus over it. Very nice place with a great tasting Italian Beef sandwich. The tea paired very well and was very much needed after the heat from peppers started to come on. read more

See all

I would give this place 3.5/5 but rounded up. I ordered the pizza sub and the roast beef sub. The roast beef sub was good, but the beef wasn't rare, its was more med well. But I'm glad I found a place with the style of roast beef that I like. I just hope if I try it again, it's the right temperature. Also, the sub roll was strangely sweet. Not terrible but just not the kind of sub roll I'm used to. The pizza sub was good, exactly what it sounds like. I'd definitely try and come back, just hoping the roast beef is cooked better. read more

See all

My review may be a little biased because my work pay for the catering here so I spent no money myself. The meal that they got came with sandwich, cookies, and chips . I got the roast beef with pretzel bun and chocolate chip cookie. The cookie and sub really good. Normally I don't order subs but I could see my self coming back here on my own dime. read more

Great traditional sandwich. Friendly staff with good service. Clean and quick. Would go back for sure

UPDATED REVIEW 8-17-24 I had been a fan of this place, drove a long way hoping to enjoy the pastrami sub yesterday, but the meat simply didn't taste good and was fatty. It was one of those surprises you don't like -- especially when you believe you finally found a sandwich with the best pastrami in the area. Pastrami is difficult to prepare. If a restaurant cuts back on the quality of the meat and the steps to prepare it once on site, it loses alot of taste. I don't want to judge New York Sub based on one new experience -- especially given the tasty sandwiches in previous years. It was as though ownership changed hands. Whether or not that's the case, I hope the owner will see the more critical reviews as an opportunity to learn how to improve, at least in my case, starting with the pastrami. read more

I ordered from this place a couple times on food delivery apps and the food is very fresh and amazing. Although, I'm wondering why they removed gluten free bread option from the menu?! Please, please add it back!!! I can't get a gluten free sub anywhere! I'm so sad. read more

This place is so great, from the food to the ppl. Tucked away on a side street across from SMU, if you don't know about it, you could miss it. The owners have so much passion for bringing the best quality food at a price that can compete. It does give off like a sidewalk store in a big city and the stuff for kids is great. They give back to the community all the time. They also run a bbq bulk meats name and do catering I believe. Please give them a shot and you will be hooked. read more

Loved this place for a long time but its popularity has sunk it. The sandwiches are good but the service sucks and the prices are now ridiculous. Since I had nothing to do for 30 mins while I waited on my $18 sandwich, I thought I'd warn you: if you didn't order online, you better not walk in here hungry. Oh...looks like they got my order wrong too! read more

They should call it the Beverly Hills Subway. While I know they are located in Highland Park, I grew up three blocks from them, so I get it, but I went in today, ordered a half sub, she thought I asked for a whole sub, $26. I said I only ordered a half, well that is $18. Mind you, no drink, no chips, no cookie, that is absolute lunacy. I went at 1, there was one other person in there. This is a sinking ship. The owner is obviously insipid and doesn't care. You have been warned. read more

Ordered a Rueben with No Cheese. I had a 15 minute wait. This sandwich was super salty and had oregano on it. That's fine for a sub or Hoagie but Rueben? ? They put the sandwich on a toasted sub roll without asking did I want bread or a roll. Honestly I've never had this type of sandwich presented on a roll. No adequate parking either. Will not be going again or Doordashing this place. BTW Rueben was $15.00 with no chips or side offered. These people cannot be from NYC period! read more

New York Sub makes wonderful sandwiches. My favorite is their "Reuben" - big mouthfuls of messy deliciousness of hot pastrami, sauerkraut, pickles, and, Russian dressing inside a toasted white bun! Welcoming and efficient is the service. Fun and family-friendly is the atmosphere. Busy it is at lunchtime and always on weekends. Familiar are the faces for most ordering are repeat customers! CHEERS! read more

New York Sub - Love It Here! (12/05/20) - Sandwiches Near Me - Dallas, Texas

See all

love this place! the sandwiches always deliver. gotta get the extra oil and vinegar. gives the vibes of a true NY deli. read more

See all

I was in between meetings and wanted to find a quick lunch. Searched sandwiches near me and this place came up. I'm SO HAPPY I tried it. I ordered the turkey Reuben and WOW......the sandwich was so good! Easily one of the best sandwiches I've ever had. Comes with Turkey Pastrami, Sauerkraut, Homemade Pickles, Italian Oregano and Russian dressing. Everything about the flavors were perfect together. The sauerkraut could be a bit more tangy, but the pickles made up for that. I was going to order it without pickles, but I'm so glad I didn't. They were absolutely delicious. The Sprinkle of Oregano worked so well to add a perfect pop of flavor. The bread......the BREAADDD! It was a perfect texture of toasted pillowy goodness. The half size was more than enough. They are not stingy AT ALL with their delicious meat. I had leftovers that I happily ate the next day. I honestly cannot wait to get back and try another sandwich. Great service and food! What more could you ask for? read more

New York Sub - Best turkey Reuben ever!! - Sandwiches Near Me - Dallas, Texas

Drove here to get lunch before work and they couldn't be bothered to post accurate hours. Closed at 11 am with a sign saying they close at 3:30. Thanks for failing at the very basic level of running a restaurant read more

From the bread, to the meat, to the toppings...this is the best sub sandwich that I have had in Dallas. It is not even close. The service is always great. They get busy, but I still have never had a bad experience. read more

Service is HORRIBLE when I went up to the counter 2 Latina women were there. I said "Hey how's it going" and they just looked at me like "what you want". Not even a smile or a hey back. You think they'll be nice since at the moment it isn't busy. Honestly ruined the whole mood for the food. When I said "well let me know when the food is ready" both of them didn't even looked at me or said anything. You want customers to love your restaurant have great customer service Edit: spelling error read more

New York Sub - Photo after this happened. - Sandwiches Near Me - Dallas, Texas

Food was good service was great. Employees were knowledgeable about products. They customized my food per my request

Always amazing sandwiches with quality ingredients. They don't skimp on anything, and the dipping sauce is great

Excellent little sub shop with authentic NY style sandwiches. I had the Reuben and it was gigantic and delicious. Loaded with pastrami and topped with sauerkraut, pickle pieces and 1000 island dressing, it is excellent. read more

Food was gas and the restaurant has aura. 5 stars. If I went to SMU, I'd be here all the time!

Great food, fantastic specials and Andrew the owner is a solid dude. I've been getting the same sub for 35+ years.

By far one of the best Subs I've had. This place was the true meaning of eat fresh! Can't wait to try there chilli cheese dog! read more

New York Sub - Texas Sub - Sandwiches Near Me - Dallas, Texas

The best subs I've ever eaten! The sandwiches are so flavorful; each ingredient is excellent and very high quality meats and cheeses! You can eat in also! read more

We were on that side of town in search of a good sandwich and we were not disappointed. They are still social distancing so when we pulled up the line looked to be out the door but that was only because the set up was for you to order at the door and not physically come in to building. Wifey had the Italian Sandwich and she was very pleased with the freshness of the ingredients on the sandwich and the portion. I had the regular sized Ruben and it was great. The Pastrami was the show stopper and I could just have eaten the meat by itself. Looking forward to going back and trying other sandwiches. read more

New York Sub - Ruben - Sandwiches Near Me - Dallas, Texas

This is a keeper. Sean and I stopped by to see the mural and fell in love with the sandwiches, charm, and owners. The outsides: The mural is pretty awesome and so is the story behind it. The story is that the original mural was painted (early 70s) in exchange for subs. The current mural includes the owners Andrew, Edi, their dogs, and some employees. The innards: beautiful place..clean and trendy. The bathroom....spectacularly clean. There are remnants of the previous buildings written on the walls (ghost signs). Its a great place to relax and hang out. There are t.vs to check out the game. The food: I had a half turkey and cheese sub on wheat. The bread was ah mazing! Andrew made my sub and he walked me through my choices (great guy) and I ended up with the best little sub. They have a plethora of sandwich sides..I was not interested...just get in my belly sub! Sean ordered a half pepperoni sub on white. The pepperoni was 1000 times better than what comes on pizza (he said it). It was melted in the oven and get this it was so good Sean offered me a bite! I think he needed someone to attest to how delicious this sandwich was! I don't even like pizza sandwiches...and I am getting one of those next time! The toppings were fresh and plentiful. The price was in line with other sandwich shops. The customer service was a 10 plus. read more

See all

This place is SO good! I came on a weekday afternoon and they made my sandwich so quickly and all the girls working there were so kind! I got the Reuben after looking at some pictures online and it was one of the best I've had! Really amazing and the bread was excellent quality. My only critique is that I wish the sauerkraut had a little more "zing" but still an awesome sub. read more

New York Sub - 26. Reuben - Sandwiches Near Me - Dallas, Texas

See all

Waiting for my over priced sandwich for 30 minutes and it had no taste I could have had a better sandwich at Subway..

Okay this place is good, it's good. You would rarely if ever have a bad word about this place. Whatever sandwich you get could be good to very good. What is lacking is some crunchie texture bread. Bread is fresh and soft But I would smash this joint any day all day, if your a sandwich pro this is not next level, but close read more

I've been following New York Sub on Facebook for well over a year now. I just never seem to get the chance to go. I finally was able to free up some time and head to New York Sub for my lunch break. It did not disappoint! Meat was fresh, the bread was simple and just right. If you want a fresh sub, this is the place. HOWEVER...parking is a pain! Very few spaces in front. Tow signs everywhere so you have to luck out and get something in front or if your lucky, off street parking. So this definitely isn't somewhere to go if you don't have much time to spare. read more

See all

We were so excited after reading the yelp reviews BUT what a disappointing $32 expenditure for me and wifey. It was far too much breading and lettuce. It was just ok. And for $32 not so much. We'll return to Subway. read more