Good pizza and friendly lady at the counter. It's a win if you're in the area and looking for pizza.

Workers were very rude to each other and workplace seem very unprofessional and dirty. Also, manager promised me a refund after my order was incorrect, I have called multiple times and am yet to be refunded. I have also heard him mocking me before he hangs up the phone. Never again! read more

Amazing little stop for lunch on the way to the Syracuse airport. Two slices for and a bottle of pop for $6.50 was a steal. If your are near here check it out. read more

New York Pizzeria - a slice of pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Canastota, New York

Been a customer for many years waited over an hour and a half for a pizza and I live down the street I called to ask where the pizza was. They said they were really busy. They never told me that when I called in the order. Then 20 minutes later after I called the driver called and said he was lost. Pizza was ice cold and wings paid $50 called back. The lady said we're busy. That's all she said to me. Kind of a smart,, way have to take business elsewhere. I've been in the business myself for over 40 years. Not the way to handle something read more

Wrong order. Always order the same thing sausage,mushrooms, onions-was given pepperoni instead of sausage . Crust was flat like it wasn't given time to rise. Chicken wings dark brown and super dry, read more

Welcome to NEW YORK it's a crime everyone can't give these folks a try. I drove 25 minutes on a 'what the heck ' journey. Would drive an hour. These folks nailed the crust had pizza and a calzone. read more

As for pizza in the area. This place is number 1 in my eyes. The crust is crispy, the sauce is divine and the topping portions are fantastic! I have gotten slices from there in the past. I love it. They are very similar to pizza I have had in Italy. My two only critiques is the pricing for combo deals. They are a bit high. However, I am willing to pay for quality. Also, when I asked for a side of ranch dressing I got a packet of kens. I don't know who their broadliner is, but if they order from sysco, I wish they just used sysco brand ranch and put it in portion cups. I am not a fan of packet dressing. But, to each their own. All in all, nothing to big to steer me away from ordering pizza at this authentic pizza spot. read more

Old, spoiled, overcooked wings swimming in sauce. And ice cold. We put them in the woodstove. Pizza was great, not wings. This is our 3rd time getting wings past expiration. Yuck!!! read more

New York Pizzeria - chicken wings and sauce - Pizza Near Me - Canastota, New York

Love this place ! Small town family owned pizzeria. They make one of the best pizzas in the CNY region. Wings are excellent too. They have really good pasta dishes as well as salads. If you're not in the mood for a pizza then they make killer subs too. Been a customer for years . read more

I love the pizza and products from this business but hate that I have to call them to get my double orders. Almost every time I order, if I get two orders of garlic Knotts or wings, they leave out the second order. It's shame because their food is amazing. I hope to see them fix this in the future read more

Screwed up our order tonight, overcharged us, and not doing anything to make up for it or refund us! Gave us an order of boneless wings with NO SAUCE over an 1 1/2hrs ago. After not splitting the wings correctly and charging us for a whole extra order we shouldn't have been charged for at all!! Then they offered to bring us just the sauce!! Umm no I want the wings made right!! Idiots!! Been waiting for it to be delivered for over an hour, called back they said it will be the LAST DELIVERY TONIGHT!! THANKS A FUCKING LOT ASSHOLES!! HOPE YOUR NEW YEARS IS SHITTY TOO WHILE OUR KIDS ARE WAITING TO EAT!! called the second time at 8pm (which is when they closed) because we still didn't get our food and the owner refused to get on the phone! this is how much they care about their customers! read more

I really love their pizza and garlic knots but their delivery service is awful. It took an hour and a half to get our (sadly cold) pizza last time and they forgot half the knots. This is the second time we were missing garlic knots from our order. If they had told me on the phone that they were short-staffed and it would be a long wait, I would GLADLY have driven into town and picked it up. My advice: order for pick up and avoid delivery at all costs. The pizza itself is great, but I will never order delivery again. read more

My go to place for late night after hours of working and cooking on the line all day. Love the white pizza and fast service. I've never had to wait too long. Keep up the good work. read more

I've been eating here sense I was young and still consistently eat here. Everything from the pizza to the calzones to the subs are amazing. The pizza is more on the greasy side. Okay. It's very greasy. Could be a bad thing for others but I love it. It tastes like the typical NYC high rated pizza, it's amazing. The subs are good but nothing to really comment on, just typical subs. If I could rate it more I would, absolutely amazing. read more

Pizza is fantastic New York style. The guy who throws the dough is fantastic. Right combination of sauce and toppings. Generous portions at a reasonable price. read more

Best pizza I've had since leaving NYC. It's. Definitely the absolute closes when it comes to taste and style. Just to bad i live in Syracuse. read more

Great pizza and even better prices! We were driving through on our way to the thruway and this place came up on Yelp! Staff was friendly and the pizza was piping hot when we picked it up! We had a large cheese and a large pepperoni which was $22 for both. The pepperoni was under the cheese so that was interesting. Overall very good, the reason for the 4 stars was there was too much cheese for my taste! But if you like that you will love this place! read more

Great New York style pizza and very affordable. Had 2 slices of meat lovers pizza and it filled this big guy up.

Excellent place if you're looking for a quick delicious bite and you can't beat the price. If this pizzeria was in my town, I'd be in every week read more

I normally don't eat pizza, so I went with a calzone. It was really good & huge! It lasted me 2 days. They cook it thoroughly & they use what tastes like fresh ingredients. I had the eggplant & ricotta which was very good.The staff is nice & polite. It's a really small place so it's better to take- out or have it delivered. If you do eat there, they have a tv. read more

I would give it less than 1 star if possible. Just purchased large cheese pizza and 30 wings for $35 and it has to be the worst ever. We ordered MILD wings - they were so coated with hot sauce they were not edible. The pizza was beyond bad. Very disappointing! read more