Amazing pizza!!! So good, from crust to sauce and generous toppings. The huge size was fun, but hard to eat gracefully. The crew from cashier, to kitchen were fast, fun and professional. We don't live in AZ so I am bummed we don't have this place at home. We took it to go, but we were grateful for the ample seating and entertaining screens while we waited. The air conditioning was a life saver and they didn't skimp. If you want great pizza, this is the place; the proverbial hidden gem. read more

The pizza slice was HUGE. I've lived next to this place for over 2 years, never stopped by, but it's definitely a whole in a wall, and i will be returning. I think it's better than Mamas pizza down the street! The boyfriend and i got a beer and a slice, ate in, and it was amazing. The service, the quickness, the music. It was a wonderful experience. WILL BE BACK! Would've taken a picture of my slice but i ate too many bites to share it now. read more

I've loved this place forever, they support local youth sports and I appreciate places that give back to kids! The service has always been amazing for me, prices are unbeatable for the slice and drink combo, great salads, and huge portions. First time back in a while and it was perfect! And the arcade games are fun while you wait. read more

So this pizzeria hosts a poker tournament every Monday and Wednesday evening and I've been stopping in a little early to enjoy a slice and a beer before I play. I have to say their slices are straight out of NYC. Closest I've gotten in Tucson to that authentic New York slice. The slice is as big as your head and it's crispy while still folding into that perfect airplane for consumption. This last time I had the meatball sub which comes with a bag of chips. Fire! 4 meatballs and melt cheese on crispy bread. Perfect fuel to see some hands and win this tournament! read more

New York Pizza - Meatball sub - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

Play to win. Win to play. Great service great pizza. Will definitely be back. Best pizza on the eastside

The advertised price is not the real price you get on the phone. If you order over the phone my total was a little over 48.00 with tax, however on grub hub and the website the total should be 45.65. My total came to 50.10 for the 24" Meat pizza. That's 9.5% surcharge. After I called they told me they charged me 2.65 for the pizza box and 3% extra for using my card. That's 19% fees including tax and 9.5% extra fees. This is a classic bait and switch. They told me to eat at the restaurant and bring cash when I complained, that's not good customer service. It's misleading. The place has a really cool vibe inside. read more

New York Pizza - The actual charge it should be! - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

So far, it's our favorite NYish pizza in town! Love the crust and the cheese is the great kind that doesn't turn into rubber when it cools down (common at other places), which is a plus for me as I'm a slower eater. Garlic bread I'd say is a little smaller than average, but still good. Pizza is always perfectly cooked and staff is always friendly. read more

New York Pizza - 1/2 order of cheese bread (I was a little sad that we got the bottom of the loaf) - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

See all

Best pizza in Tucson and all the people who work here are really nice , ordered to go but could wait we had to have a slice before driving home read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

See all

I visit about once every two weeks and have my usual cheese slice and drink. I like the establishment, but my main complaint is the inconsistency. Sometimes you get a wonderfully prepared slice and then another time it's light on cheese and sauce which more often than not is then over cooked. One time I took it back and was met with a stare. Not again, but I still go back regardless. read more

I found a pizza I liked and was going there for awhile. The last time I called to order the price was beyond what I will pay, so my good thing was spoiled. read more

Pizza is really good. They have a great lunch special of a slice and a drink for $5.50. The slice is huge. Staff is always friendly. Tyrone and Josh took care of us today! Was lucky enough to win a free large cheese pizza on Facebook. Give it a try if you haven't yet. read more

it was my first time here and I am so glad I came in. the service was exceptional and food was great! I will definitely be back!

We have been looking for a good pizza place and we found it! My husband and friend from NY love the pizza. We got the classic cheese and another pepperoni. The sauce was great, not sweet. The pizza was amazing and it was done on time for pick up. Definitely will be back!! read more

It ain't New York but it's damn good pizza. Crispy crust, no oily cheese, just enough tomato sauce. Fresh and searingly hot out of the oven, folded in half for speed eating, it is delicious. Super clean tables, floors, and condiment bottles. Really really terrific counter staff. Take the kids, take the soccer team, there's a claw machine! read more

See all

Highly recommend New York pizza! Food was great. Service was excellent! Garlic bread is amazing! read more

New York Pizza - Garlic Bread - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

See all

My favorite place for pizza on the east side! Friendly, welcoming staff, family atmosphere and delicious pizza!!

This is a hidden gem on the east side, you will never get let down on lunch specials.

Great place for pizza on the East Side of Tucson!! Great food and friendly staff, my family and I enjoy this place very much!!

Perfect as usual. Grab a family size tonight. Half pepperoni. Well done. Perfect crust sauce is delicious. Cheese ratio on point. Get in there abd get some! The service is great! The interior has been redone and looks awesome! Giant tvs! Games and more! read more

New York Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

See all

This place is really good as they make a proper NY pizza. The slices are huge and really stay true to the NY style. They have awesome daily lunch specials. The staff there are really nice and it's just great to have a local Tucson spot that serves good pizza. Def recommend this place especially for individual pizza slices that's affordable and tastes good. read more

New York Pizza - slice - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

See all

It's been around for 49 years, but I just recently heard of it. It's your basic old school pizza shop that has a certain charm to it. The lobby has video games and pinball and the space is wide open. Unfortunately, the pizza only gets 3 stars but I'd give it 4 stars for everything else. First, the good. It's not a fancy place by any means, but it's clean, lots of seating, easy parking, and really friendly staff. I got a slice with 2 toppings and a soda for $8.39 which is reasonable. Unfortunately, the pizza is hit and miss. The cheese and sauce are uninspiring. The cheese didn't have any kind of pull to it and kind of separates on itself. I got sausage and pepperoni and the sausage is little crumbles which I love. The toppings really helped make the slice better. I found when I got to the edges/crust you could really taste the difference without toppings, tho. Would I go there again? If I were in the area and wanted a cheap lunch I think I would. Would I drive out of my way to go there? Probably not. read more

New York Pizza - 2-topping slice with a soda, $8.39. December 2024. - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

Greeted when we came in. Helped with choosing food. He showed us sizing of pizza. It tastes great. We will be back . They have thrifty ice cream. read more

Amazing pizza, relaxing environment & nice staff. Reminds me of when I came as a kid & they still have the games!

Some of the very best pizza in town. Great service, friendly staff, quick turnaround for that tasty pizza. read more

New York Pizza - Delicious pepperoni pizza and a nice Amberbock in a frosty mug. Does it get any better? - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

Well, well, well, I guess I had the spoiled urban palette for proper N.Y. Style pizza, maybe having come from San Diego after almost 30 years, to this Tucson food desert. Up the hill from me was Bronx Pizza, established 1997. Back when they used to use actual NYC tap water for their dough... Fast forward to month six of living on the East Side of Tucson. I had tired of the crappy, soulless chain, doughy drivel of the likes of MOD Pizza, Serial Grillers, Papa Murphy's, Pizza (H)Butt, etc. That is sadly all that I can get within a 15 minute drive out here on the perimeters. So, I found this spot on some Reddit forum, for good New York style pizza in Tucson and more or less east. The majority of members had voted for Empire Pizza, Upper Crust, Time Market, et al. But this odd east side spot for "NY Pizza" came up in a couple mentions. So my mom and I tried it out today. This was by far the WORST PIZZA I have tasted or experienced since I was in Fresno for work training in the summer of 2008. I found that place also on the internets, and in a desert too, but it was also in California, and they used freakin' CANNED MUSHROOMS on my pizza! I cried and I thought of growing up poor in Michigan with canned mushrooms. And I thought of school lunch pizzas in grade school, and how that pizza was not much better. So, who the hell stoops to a cost-cutting/taste killing low of putting CANNED MUSHROOMS ON A PIZZA??? (Inquiring minds and taste buds want to know..) We got a half pepperoni pizza and other half "mushrooms" and pepperoni. We were served a greasy, soggy, undercooked piece of shite, complete with what tasted like processed pre-grated cheese and a super bland (most likely from a can) red sauce, and add the horror of CANNED MUSHROOMS!!! I wanted to throw the goddamned thing out the car window on the way home. To add, even cooking it another five minutes under the broiler, while sopping up the grease with several paper towels, and picking off the slimy, nasty CANNED MUSHROOMS (!!!) - even then, We, I, and the the pizza gods up in the sky, could not resurrect this sad sad thing called a New York Pizza. Bronx Pizza, where are you my love??? :'( read more

See all

What a great surprise as we tried this place for the 1st time...great NY Style Pizza....so flavorful! Also great lunchtime value offered....we will return!!! read more

Good food, atmosphere is OK, service is very good. Comes close to East coast pizza . Access can be a challenge

Went in for the lunch special and left full and happy! Amazing staff and food! Even grabbed a 22" pizza for the kiddos at home! For sure will be returning! I also like the set up and am so excited to see when they finish the improvements! read more

New York Pizza - Double Lunch Special - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

I found it by accident and went in they were just opening up; the arcade wasn't up yet. It was good pizza but no silverware only paper Plates and no bathrooms which is funny when a business sells beer. read more

Had lunch today. Meatball sub and a slice with 2 beers 23$. Guys are all so nice. Food is great sauce has a great taste. Clean environment. It's cool cause people been coming here for year. I've been coming 30+ years. New owners made some changes and I think it's great. $5.50 slice and soda everyday. read more

New York Pizza - Meatball sub - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

See all

Though this pizza joint has been here longer than I've been in Tucson (since the '70's), I only learned about it a few weeks ago from my son. I've been to New York City a few times, and, while I am no NY expert, this pizza joint closely resembles some of the places I have visited. Not a fancy restaurant by any stretch, but great service and great pizza. That's all you really need. Lots of toppings to choose from, great salads, and a nice beer selection. read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

See all

A real GEM for me for the last 40 years. Spent a majority of my HIGH SCHOOL years in this place instead of 4 period at Sahuaro. New owners keeping the tradition going and I still hit the LUNCH specials at least once a week. Keep On Keepin On!!! read more

The salad portion for the prise was nice, but the pizza itself didn't tasted more special than frozen pizza. The staff were very polite while playing my order on phone and when picking it up. The ambience was okay, nothing special about it. read more

New York Pizza - Caesar salad - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

See all

As the restaraunt improves the interrior, it keeps up its amazing pizzas and the staff is amazing. They are caring and hospitable to their guests, especially on those with food allergies. The new arcade they are putting together is cool and has all sorts of different games. read more

Service was friendly fast and efficient. Parking was a breeze but odd. A random fence separates the adjacent parking lot and stores. While the name and setup screams NY the pizza doesn't reflect authenticity. The crust is where it gets lost. Too thick and lacks flavor. Sauce and cheese were just ok. I've only had plain cheese pizza perhaps there's some better stuff in the menu. I get a sense this place is pretty good for groups. read more

New York Pizza - Small Cheese Pizza (takeout) - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

We decided to try New York Pizza again after new owners took it over. We ordered a sausage and pepperoni medium size. Please go somewhere else and give yourself a brake! It was the worst pizza I have ever had in my life. Horrible cardboard with hardly any cheese and the other crap they put on it was just terrible. Go anywhere else! read more

This is our third time eating here. Every time we come here I always wonder why we don't come more often because the pizza is SO good. We have a big family so we always get the family size pizza. The one that barely fits in your car. The pizza is SO good & it tastes just as good as the pizza you would buy at the train station in New York. The customer service is always amazing. We normally just pick the pizza up, but the restaurant is cute. They have arcades you can play and beer by the pitcher. Definitely check it out if you're in the area. read more

New York Pizza - Pepperoni & black olive pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

See all

Wanted to try a local pizza place and I was not disappointed. Ordered the Family Size (22") pizza. WOW! Mega pizza! This quaint pizza place has been a local pizzeria for over 40 years! Will be coming back soon! read more

New York Pizza - Family size Pepperoni Pizza with mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

See all

New owners. Pizza tastes completely different. Shrinkflation. After enjoying their pizza since I was a child, I can no longer recommend it. The owners did a great job, finally cleaning and remodeling. Why change anything else? read more

Pizza by the slice! Yummy! I was passing by and noticed this place so I decided to stop. Before 4pm they have lunch specials, pizza and a drink for $5. I had a pepperoni slice, lemonade and a side salad. The slices are huge! I ate inside and got my food hot and fresh. Staff was very friendly and they sell whole pizzas too. I'd definitely come back for a slice! read more

See all