Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Neumeister's Candy Shoppe

    4.0 (4 reviews)
    Closed 10:00 am - 5:00 pm

    Order Neumeister's Candy Shoppe Takeout or Delivery

    Neumeister's Candy Shoppe Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    More like Neumeister's Candy Shoppe

    Recommended Reviews - Neumeister's Candy Shoppe

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Neumeister's Candy Shoppe

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Coons Candy - Entrance

    Coons Candy

    4.0(27 reviews)
    6.3 mi
    $$

    Coons Candy - First Visit…read more Let's go ahead and name what some of us have probably thought: pulling up to a place called Coons Candy comes with hesitation -- especially as a Black customer. It's an unspoken (and sometimes spoken) moment of pause, wondering what kind of experience you're walking into. But curiosity -- and a soft spot for old-school sweets -- led us to check it out. To my surprise, the staff couldn't have been more welcoming. As soon as we walked in, we were greeted with friendly smiles and offered samples of fudge, toffee, and a few other homemade treats. That immediately softened the moment and brought on a bit of nostalgia -- felt like walking into one of those general stores my MawMaw would take me to, or a Cracker Barrel stop on a road trip. The store itself is exactly what you'd expect from a small-town candy shop: shelves packed with retro candies, novelty drinks, locally made honey and syrups, quirky gifts, and yes -- edible bugs. It's cozy and cluttered in a fun, old-school way. We left with: * Boba Vida popping pearls (dark cherry) * Sugar Daddy, Victory sticks, Stallion candy smokes, raspberry & green apple sticks * Locally made honey * A mix of glass-bottle sodas: * Sioux City Ginger Beer + Prickly Pear * Reading Draft Honey Cream * Drive-In Cherry Limeade * Nehi Peach * Ginger Strawberry tea * Hot & Spicy Ginger Beer This is definitely a place for folks who love that nostalgic candy-store vibe and don't mind digging through shelves of old favorites and funky surprises. ‍ Final take: It was a mixed bag. The selection was fun and the staff made us feel welcome. But the name? It sticks -- and not in a sweet way. That hesitation doesn't go away entirely, and I'd understand if someone else passed on the visit for that reason alone. I'm glad I saw it for myself. Would I go back? Maybe. Would I recommend it? Depends who's asking.

    We stopped by today & had to buy some of the delicious fudge! Utterly charming store. I will never…read moredrive past again. Wonderful chocolates, hard candies & so much cuteness! Plus, really sweet people. I'm so glad we stopped! If you have a problem with name, please get some professional help. You're ridiculous. It's their last name.

    Photos
    Coons Candy - Entrance

    Entrance

    Coons Candy
    Coons Candy - Beef jerky

    See all

    Beef jerky

    Maumee Valley Chocolate & Candy - Inside Maumee Valley Chocolate and Candy

    Maumee Valley Chocolate & Candy

    4.4(8 reviews)
    58.2 mi

    Maumee Valley Chocolate and Candy is wonderful…read more We were walking along the riverfront park and I saw a sign that said chocolate, so I walked over here to check it out. This store has so much candy! Lots of retro candy, plenty of foreign candy (multiple flavors of Kit Kats including flavors of chunky kit kats, hi chews and some other Asian candies (a bunch of options, but I can get all of them in Chicago's chinatown so I didn't pay attention), Aero bars, Terry's oranges, and other British candy. There were so many retro candy options, plus every kind of candy you've ever heard of. (I eat too much candy, and know a lot of types of candy and I was blown away by the options). They also had lots of types of pop, but I didn't pay much attention to them. I wanted my sugar in chocolate form. I am a chocoholic, and I was very happy to find this place. I got some creams from the case (dark chocolate raspberry cream, orange cream, strawberry cream, vanilla cream). They were delicious. These are better than my former favorite Fannie May (which sadly isn't as good as it used to be). I also got some chocolates in the bulk chocolate section. The chocolate covered cherries are amazing as is the chocolate covered orange peel (though jellier than I was expecting inside). The chocolate covered pecans are fine (but I don't usually get these so maybe chocolate covered pecans aren't my thing). The store is cute! It had a Lego Willy Wonka set! This place is in a good location. The staff were friendly and helpful.

    Maumee Valley Chocolate and Candy is Toledo's best retro candy store. Hell, I'll go so far as to…read moresay that it's the best candy store in town. Period. There was a time that title belonged to Boyd's, but Boyd's has been slipping for a while now. Walk in here and you'll find every kind of candy that you could want. The candy selection is flat-out unparalleled. Bun bars, Necco wafers, saucers, Zero bars, salt water taffy, the cheap-but-still-damn-good Willy Wonka stuff - you name it. If I ever saw it in a candy store as a kid, it's sitting on a shelf in this place. They've got the "finer" items, too: solid milk chocolate, actual truffles, bonbons, the works. Sugar free stuff? Yeah, that too. And the retro/craft pop ("soda," for those of you who never learned the proper word) is outstanding. Then, for a little depth, throw in a few kitschy tin signs and magnets, and few retro (think Scooby-Doo) lunchboxes. Oh yeah...they scoop their own ice cream too. Five stars, no regrets!

    Photos
    Maumee Valley Chocolate & Candy - Inside Maumee Valley Chocolate and Candy

    Inside Maumee Valley Chocolate and Candy

    Maumee Valley Chocolate & Candy - Candy shelves

    Candy shelves

    Maumee Valley Chocolate & Candy - Chocolate-Dipped Strawberry from Maumee Valley Chocolate and Candy

    See all

    Chocolate-Dipped Strawberry from Maumee Valley Chocolate and Candy

    Olde Thyme Pantry

    Olde Thyme Pantry

    3.5(2 reviews)
    47.7 mi

    I love having a place like this so close to where I live. They have a great selection of candy,…read moresauces, spices, cheese, deli meat, cookies, and so on. Most of the people who work there are some of the nicest people I've met. I usually stop in to grab the cheese pizza pretzels, the cereal marshmallows, and something from the chocolate aisle. My friend who usually goes with me loves their hot cheese cups and the sauces they have to offer. The dip mixes are great too and the baked goods on the rack towards the back are tasty! Sometimes the prices are a little higher on some things but it's a very clean store and just fun to visit.

    I had been wanting to go to Old Thyme Pantry since i moved to the area and i finally got my chance…read moreover a month ago. I love trying new foods and going to mom and pops as much as i can. I will tell you that one of the most impressive things about Old Thyme Pantry is that it has an extensive candy section... two aisles worth. Moreover, the candy isn't the factory made stuff... that said the candy can be a little hit or miss. My mother did not like the sugar wafers for instance and i disliked the sea salt fudge. Yet at the same time, the orange slices were very good and the chocolate covered raisins were to die for (def better than Raisinettes!). The store also sells soup mixes, local honey, jams, jelly's and fresh meat. They also have a Deli. I bought some Deli items and again hit or miss... some of the items i didn't like but their was this chicken one that was delish. Cool store, one that looks to be owned by mennonite/amish? Definitely would be willing to give it a second try in the future... and one you should try as well.

    Photos
    Olde Thyme Pantry
    Olde Thyme Pantry
    Olde Thyme Pantry

    See all

    Discount Drug Mart - Pharmacy and Deli hours may vary.  Please call ahead.

    Discount Drug Mart

    4.0(1 review)
    1.1 mi
    $

    Needing some sundries, this was the only drug store that popped up on Yelp in Upper Sandusky. They…read morehad what we needed, at reasonable prices. Plus tons of other stuff, food, household items, etc., in addition to health and beauty items. Friendly service. Convenient. Definitely would come back.

    From the owner: We opened our first store in Elyria, Ohio in 1969. Low prices, outstanding customer service, and…read morebroad based product lines are at the heart of Drug Mart’s growth and success. Equally important are our charitable, community and education related fund raising activities, and serving the health needs of the communities 7 days a week, 365 days a year. Our employee owned company slogan says it all: “Discount Drug Mart Saves You the Runaround…We Have Everything You Need.” From health and beauty aids to household merchandise; small appliances, paint, hardware and auto accessories; magazines, greeting cards, paper products, groceries, frozen foods, school & office supplies, seasonal merchandise, we have it all! You may pay utility bills send packages UPS or USPS, purchase postage stamps, play the lottery, and buy state dog or fishing licenses. Our pharmacies have the latest customized computer system and electronic prescription transfer, filling over 5.3 million prescriptions annually!

    Photos
    Discount Drug Mart
    Discount Drug Mart - Discount Drug Mart is your friendly neighborhood one stop shop!  From soup to nuts (and bolts!), we have it all!

    See all

    Discount Drug Mart is your friendly neighborhood one stop shop! From soup to nuts (and bolts!), we have it all!

    Neumeister's Candy Shoppe - candy - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...