offered a delightful variety of sweets, from classic chocolates to unique handmade treats that…read morebrought back childhood memories. Lisa was friendly and the vibrant atmosphere made the whole experience even more enjoyable.Very talented Chocolatier and Sweets expert! We'll 100% be back

Stopped by today and tried pumpkin espresso and pumpkin pecan fudge. Oh my goodness. Lisa makes…read morethe most devine, creamy, perfectly flavor balanced fudge. There is no skimping on high quality ingredients.

Awesome this place was so much fun. I love the ice cream Staff was friendly and helpful. The…read more store had a lot of fun choices and was very cute.

Went here on a whim while in lake Geneva for a weekend , got there at 750 with an 8pm close the…read moreladies working couldn't of been nicer to all the people in line , got a great sundae and some candy , service alone you should stop by this place and the sundae was great. Will definitely stop by again when in town.

Had many flavors of popcorn to choose. Was still fresh tasting not stale. Would definitely buy…read morefrom here again on our next trip north.

WOW! We stopped in here after spending an hour or so at the Lake Geneva museum today. My 2 young…read morekids were indecisive like all kids are, so the young lady making the popcorn let us all try any flavor we wanted to help us decide. We had a lot of samples! In reading some earlier reviews about the cleanliness and professionalism of the staff. We were greeted very warmly the minute we stepped in and my 3-year old was a bit on the cranky side so she dealt with that well too! We had a completely different overall experience than the person wrote from earlier this year. The walls were perfectly in order, stocked with all bagged popcorn flavors and candy. Floors and counters were clean. They also had a beautiful display of gourmet candies to the side of the check-out counter, above it which listed also their ice cream offerings and prices. They had all their various tins with many patterns to choose from on the top shelves. My kids enjoyed watching fresh carmel corn being stirred up behind the counter. She even let us sample the fresh/warm popcorn. The lady was a great sales person, that is for sure. We walked in thinking we'd buy a small bag for the kids to share and we ended up walking out with a 2-pound tin tub, plus an extra bag of cheesy bacon pizza popcorn. We paid around $30, which really was a good price if you look at Garrett's prices! Plus, the lady told us that we could bring the empty tin back anytime (no expiration) and get it refilled with a discount - I think she said 15%. I liked that we were able to get 3 different flavors to fill up the tub. She filled it to the rim too. The tub seems to hold at least 7 of the large bags that were sold individually. My favorite was the 3-cheese that had white chedder, parmesan and I 'think' just regular cheddar. It melts in your mouth. So good! We were just there a couple of hours ago and I think I am half way through this third of the tin. We might need to refill the tin before heading home from Lake Geneva in a couple of days. My kids liked the carmel/cheese that was seedless (tastes like Cap N' Crunch cereal) and a white chocolate one. I might need to have some shipped to me during the year as this popcorn is seriously addicting! My mom is sitting in front of me as I am typing this and she is eating some of the popcorn, and she just said this stuff is so addicting. Agreed!

Wide selection of eclectic and imported candy items along with all of the usual staples. Staff…read moreworking here are all very kind and do a wonderful job keeping the store neat and organized. Items are priced reasonably. Actually had an issue where I misplaced and item during checkout, returned to store, and manager generously comped the item for me. They didn't need to do that but it was greatly appreciated.

Honestly, they have a good variety of stuff but their customer service sucks. No hi, no have a good…read moreday even when you say it to them. I tried to order and wasn't done and she was telling me the total and cutting me off and I said one more thing and she rolled her eyes at that time and also when I asked her for a drink carrier. I still said thank you and have a good day and girl just walked away.

I love chocolate, and this place was a wonderful surprise on my weekend trip to Wisconsin. There…read morewere so many great looking options, and I bought a few things. They had a jar with samples. It was nice to get to a free sample! I got some creams (strawberry, raspberry, orange, and lemon) and they were amazing. These might be my new favorites (Fannie May creams used to be my favorite chocolate but they have a weird taste now). I got chocolate covered pretzel rod pieces, and a couple of on sale Christmas chocolates: bear claw and chocolate covered oreo's. I didn't know what a bear claw was (or if I'm calling it the right thing), but they said it was like a bigger turtle. It was delicous. The chocolate pretzles and oreo's were great too.

Went on my way home. Had a chocolate banana it was so yummy. Something about how it's frozen makes…read moreits creamy with the chocolate and covered in nuts. I was going to eat it at home but sadly it did not make it. The staff was very friendly and helpful. It was a constant line. They were fast and efficient.

Amazing service so patient and friendly! Yummy food too! Such a great find and definitely will be…read morecoming back!

greatest ice cream and greatest owners. del carlson really loves people and has quality product. i…read morereally love the creampuffs, just like you get from the wisconsin state fair. whole family is great.

Decided to go to public market today in Milwaukee. I stopped at this candy shop. Excellent customer…read moreservice and amazing chocolate. The chocolate covered strawberry special was amazing! Would highly recommend. Can't wait to go back!

Good flavor and quick service. Very refreshing for a hot day. Place is pretty slow for a busy…read moreSaturday afternoon

What an adorably delicious place to get some sweet treats and gifts!…read more Got some Wisconsin Badger themed chocolates for a family graduate and quite of few chocolates for my own selfish consumption hehe! I'm also a salty/spicy queen and got some of their pretzels! As an Appleton local I made the day trip with my boyfriend to Oconomowoc and learned that the owners are also from Appleton! They'll be located at the Appleton Farmers Market so if you want to try them out I'd highly recommend wherever you're from! Thank you Shanay for all your help and kind support!

A sweet tooth dream come true! We stopped in to this slightly hidden gem in Oconomowoc and had the…read morechance to taste-test some of the best chocolates, nuts and more. You can taste the quality in each bite. It is clear why the treats here are repeated Wisconsin State Fair winners! There is a wide variety of small bites but also many gift packages to choose from. May I say that if you want to give the best to your sweetheart for Valentine's Day, please check Sweet P's out. With everything created on site, quality is assured. My personal favorites are the toffee bars and the candied pecans. But I love every other item I have been gifted.