Had The last Pasta Fagoli soup and because my sis had cravings for "Neil's" chicken sub this where we wound up. The soup was very hot and a bit bland and needed more seasoning. Put lots of Parmesan cheese in it, but it was also sparse In beans and pasta. Understanding it was last serving , I would not have served it! The chicken cutlet with lettuce subs were made perfectly! The cutlets nice and crunchy on outside juicy inside. Had just enough Mayo and oil and vinegar ratio. Sis was right -good sub! read more

Neil's Pizzeria - Chicken Cutlet with Lettuce Tomato Mayo - Pizza Near Me - Clifton, New Jersey

The food is good, never had a problem and have been going there at least 30 years. Paul, one of the owners is absolutely wonderful. The young ladies who take your order are also wonderful very friendly and polite. However, his partner, the other owner, his brother. Geo is the rudest most nastiest individual around. I got an order delivered paid with a credit card. Something must have happened with the driver and the machine. Don't know what, but Geo called me the next day. And falsely accused me of not paying my entire bill. Had to speak with Paul to fix it. Now, every time I call there, if Geo answers the phone, he's always a nasty and route to me. And he tries to stop me from talking to anybody else. But him, that doesn't work with me. As far as service goes not sure what I would rate them only because of Geo. There wasn't for him. I'd give 5 stars for service. The food same thing. read more

Best Cheesesteak around !!! The Shrimp Scampi Pizza is my favorite but it's not on the menu you have to ask !!!

Delicious pizza, friendly staff, super clean shop. Loved it--definitely coming back! Got the cheese pizza and a cannoli. read more

Neil's Pizzeria - Pizza Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Clifton, New Jersey

The Best that own it and the people that work theonecirv4hecoizzerisxariubd this are re are all Amazing They around if the Best pizzeria in the neighborhood read more

I'm from Brooklyn. Bored and rise, been living in Jersey for over 10 years now. It's hard to find a pizza spot with the same Brooklyn feeling, and this spot HITS the spot. From their pizza to the sandwiches & the pasta 5 Stars read more

Neil's needs to sync their online ordering process. This evening I ordered a pizza online for delivery, including a tip for the driver. Later, they called and said it was ready for pickup. After arguing with the man on the phone who said I ordered for pickup, I insisted, per my verifiable online order, that it was indeed ordered for delivery. They finally delivered the pizza, as per my order. Lesson: If you order delivery from Neil's online, double-check all your info and be ready to defend it. read more

Pizza is always fresh salad cld be a lil better but it's passable mozzarella sticks are delish & so are the sandwiches Very fast with delivery,customer service over the phone cld be a lil better depending on who picks up read more

Neil's Pizzeria - Pizza is so good always fresh there salad can be a lil better but it's passable - Pizza Near Me - Clifton, New Jersey

I have ordered from Neils several times and yet need to be disappointed. White pizza, Pepperoni pretty much any is great. Pasta dishes are good like the Baked Ziti, Manicotti and their salads are good also. Solid place to go eat in or takeout. They have established themselves as a to go place especially for locals. read more

See all

Food as always great and service great but there prices have gotten out of hand I know we are in a recession but changing prices every other week is out of hand. I will always go there n order delivery and so on. read more

Everyone that grew up in New Jersey claims their local neighborhood pizzeria is the best and no where else compares. Well that's not what I am here to say about Neil's. Don't get me wrong, I love Neil's and I grew up on them but I have certainly have had better. If you grew up in Wayne NJ and was on the valley side, this was the place to be for pizza. Located in the shopping center across from my high school, this was the hangout spot whether it was during senior lunch or after school. They have all your favorites slices from plain to buffalo chicken to penne vodka. My favorite was the chicken bruschetta. All of the speciality pizzas gets super messy as the toppings falls apart fairly easily so I always end having to use a fork to finish. Pizza is also super oily but that's what you want in a good pizza so I am a-ok with that. I give it 3 stars for good pizza and another star just because it was my childhood pizza place and the memories it brings back for me. LOL, I wrote this for the wrong Neil's but whatever. read more

Neil's Pizzeria - Chicken Bruschatta - Pizza Near Me - Clifton, New Jersey

Just didn't like the fresh mozzarella margarita pizza but other than that is pretty good

No one working here wears a mask. They don't have any pizzas available that are on their menu ready to go.

If you like doughy pizza, Neil's is your place. I'm a thin crust gal myself but this place is all right. They don't skimp on toppings which is pretty cool but they don't put on enough sauce. Thicker crust pizzas need more sauce to complement the dough and I don't believe Neil's has nailed the sauce/crust combo yet. Their delivery is quick and on time. Their prices are reasonable. Good caesar salad. Buffalo chicken sandwich was huge and only $6.50 but it was a little dry. They give you a side of bleu cheese with it but it wasn't enough. read more

See all

More cheese is needed on the Sicilian. The crunch is good, but the sauce was a little light. The regular slice is ok. Not as crisp as I prefer but it had more cheese than the Sicilian. This is the only pizzeria I've tried in Clifton so far. The place is definitely busy during lunch. Seating is limited, best bet is to call in and take it back to the office if you have a group bigger than 4. There's a $10 minimum on all cards. A Sicilian, a regular, and a Snapple will run you $6 and some change. Not a bad lunch, but I'll see if there's better. That's what I do... read more

Neil's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Clifton, New Jersey

Lets just start with the following Im 26, and ive never felt the urge to give a sh*t about anything enough to wright a damn review on anything. Not a thing my generation does, more like the soccer mom karen who wants to speak to the manager.... BUT TODAY. That changed. So i ordered Chicken franches with Linguini... simple right? Aparently not. You know what i got? 2 slices of chicken floating in literally lemon sauce. (I LEGITIMATELY couldnt see the chicken through the merky lemon hell water) With the linguini sitting in another tin ...covered in marinara sauce. Someone explain to me how the actual f*uck you mess that up? Like what is going on in your kitchen that someone looked at that and went "YEAP, THATS ABOUT RIGHT". I get it, shit happens. But this was like HYPER easy to get right. (Yes i put this on google aswell. After looking their delivery/pickup is horrid cause they literally dont give a crap) read more

Neil's Pizzeria - Yeah... thats gonna go great in my lemon soup. - Pizza Near Me - Clifton, New Jersey

See all

been coming here now for almost a year. My friend told me about this we always order for tonight we came in and then the staff was great and the food was even better there. How do you like it? Nice atmosphere nice people definitely a comeback. Definitely recommend you trying it. read more

Called to place a order "1 large supreme pizza and wings", we repeated the order to make sure it was taken down correctly and they confirmed it. When we arrived to pick it up, my friend paid a large amount which was accurate for our order. When we arrived home they gave us a cheese pizza and wings. We called to inform them of the mix up and they said we never placed a supreme. I've never payed Soo much money for 1 large cheese pizza, the owner said that's the correct price and he even tried to play it off that we never ordered a supreme. I always double check my order when placing them just to make sure. The owner wouldn't even correct the order because it was too late, the cheese pizza was already made. He eventually slipped up and said "we don't even have the ingredients for your pizza so we couldn't make it in the first place". If that was the case why not just inform us instead of trying to sell us something else. This is the second time this passed year they messed up my order and were rude about their mistake. Never going back here again! read more

Unpleasantly surprised when I ordered dinner from this place tonight! A place I have ordered from way too many times to count but NEVER AGAIN!!! Price for buffalo wings n fries is OUTRAGEOUS! But the worst thing is I had to find out that they've outsourced delivery to Sling and they dont tell you unless there's an issue with your order which adds to your cost! The food isnt as good as it once was either. They wont get me again... read more

Every time I order they always cancel the order outright or I have to wait an hour to find out it's not coming. Their food is delicious but man can they just send me an order. read more

I love this neighborhood place, I go consistently every week for any of their sandwiches for lunch. They never disappoint!

I was first introduced to Neil's pizzeria almost 7 years ago!! I have tried other pizza places and by far this is still my favorite. Everything I have eaten has been absolutely delicious!! cooked to perfection and always fresh! I moved almost 25 minutes away, and once a month I make the drive for my pizza salad and sandwiches!! It's so worth it!! Tell them Pina sent you! Ciao! Note: just ordered last night a personal pizza & garden salad. Still A+!!! read more

See all

Went here one night. Ordered a no-cheese pizza with onions peppers and mushrooms, and some garlic knots. Highly disappointed. It was AWFUL!!!! No flavor. I could barely chew threw the dough including the garlic knots. The sauce for the garlic knots was nasty too. Plus there was a dude there, that may have been one of the owners because he left out of the back once we were in our car, staring at us like we didnt belong. And now that i think about it clifton is a very racist town.... read more

Ordered 3 pizzas this evening, mussels and mozzarella sticks. 90 bucks and it arrived 50 minutes later. Opened the pizzas and the bottom of all 3 were burned.... I called and spoke to the owner and he gave me a hard time. I texted him 3 photos of the bottoms. Called back and he was remaking them. 45 minutes later only 1 pizza arrived. I was so discussed I gave the driver the pizza back. And called I just want my money back, he complained to me that I wasted a pizza. Never again this is not how you do business. He claimed the toppings need to cook. Pepperoni and sausage are already cooked I'm not stupid. I can't believe how rude he was. I added the photos and note the phone flash made them lighter. read more

See all

Best chicken sandwich ever! Been ordering neils for 10+ years and always sooo good! :)

I ordered a plain simple cheesesteak wrap with provolone cheese I ended up getting it in a sandwich when I called back and asked for my correct order they couldn't serve me and told me they wouldn't be able to bring me my correct food only promised discount next time I come they shouldn't have even happened I used to come here all the time since I was young and the customer service now because the original owner left is TERRIBLE read more

This pizzeria never disappoints! The pizza is sooo good & so is their lasagna! Would recommend read more

Neil's Pizzeria - a piece of lasagna pie - Pizza Near Me - Clifton, New Jersey

Don't be fooled by the pictures especially if you're going there for pizza. Been here twice and the only taste the pizza has is whatever seasonings you add to the pizza. Gave it 2 Stars because the service was nice. read more

The food and pizza is A-OK. But yesterday, the kids ordered from the menu that Neil has posted on line. They carefully picked because they only had a limited amount of cash. When the delivery came it was more than they had figured and had to refuse the sodas. Today, I called the owner to see if there was a mistake. He said that the prices on line are different than the real prices and that the prices on line have to be changed. But he did not make me feel that that would happen any time soon or that it was a high priority. So, taking nothing away from their food or service, I would advise that if you order from their menu on line, ask them the price of each item to avoid sticker shock when the delivery arrives. read more

Used to be my favorite pizza place. I guess they have new owners. The pizza isn't the same sadly. It wasnt terrible but it used to be really amazing. read more

My family's business used to be two blocks from here, and we always ordered lunch from here. Even a few miles away, we still order just about once a week. Their pizza is classic and their marinara sauce is to die for. I eat it right out of the container like soup, no joke. Everything I've ever had from Neil's has been delicious, and they're friendly to boot! read more

I like my pizza very doughy and saucy, and Neil's has never failed to deliver! I'm not a fan of cardboard with can sauce on it. If I order pizza, I want PIZZA. Neil's has the best tasting pizza in the area, by far. They also have excellent subs and don't stinge you if you ask for any extra toppings. They aim to please which is a something a lot of companies are too cheap to honor anymore. read more

Im proud to say that I have grown up in north jersey (bergen and essex county) my whole life so I am spoiled when it comes to good pizza. Ive tried pizza all over the east coast and places like chicago and IMO nothing compares to north jersey pizza. Now that I work in clifton I was looking for a new pizza place around because I was slightly dissapointed with Villa Roma (i think it was). I saw Neils had a good review so i decided to give it a shot. I ordered the Mussels fra diavalo (i think it just says hot on menu) and of course a couple plain slices to go. At first it appeared like there was going to be just a little bit too much cheese on the slices for my liking. I was wrong as the plain slices are near perfect. The crust was not too crunchy or soft and had good flavor, the sauce and buffalo mozz were also right on point. The mussels were cooked just right and were not mushy like some restaurants. The fra diavalo sauce was delicious and had a nice little kick. All in all 9.5/10 and this is my new spot when at work. read more

First and only time ordering, got a pepporoni stromboli and a ham and cheese calzone, moz sticks, and french fries. 40 minutes was an hour. The boli and the calzone were pretty good, the sticks and fries were undercooked and soggy. Had to put them both in the toaster oven and even then, not impressive. They do take credit cards though which is a plus and the delivery guy was friendly. read more

By far the worst order I have gotten from a pizza place in the area . I even created a yelp just to tell this place how much they suck . You ask for potatoes in your cheesesteak and they say yea we got potatoes and they just put French fries in it . Doesn't taste the same at all . Mozzarella sticks were garbage . I even called back to tell them and they said " yea French fry is potato " so I said what if I ordered French fries would you give me an order of hash browns and say " hash brown like French fry , both potato ?" I wish I could give a -1 star read more

The Siclian Pizza at Neil's Pizza is tremendous..The staff are friendly and Polite

Very good anti-pasta salad and margarita pizza is to die for!! Very friendly staff and good prices. Everything is always fresh. Only spot in Clifton for good food!! Definitely would recommended this to anyone looking for some good food. read more

ZERO STARS!! Just spoke on the phone trying to make an order for delivery and the man on the phone all of the sudden changes his tone with me I quote "what do you want" horrible makes me think you guys spit on peoples pizza on rough days. read more

I'm so upset I never reviewed this place because my family has been bringing me here for 10 yrs now. We always order here their pizza is the best local spot, everyone is nice and it always hits the spot. This is my childhood pizzeria we love their salads, and foods as well. Good people, good food. read more

Neil's Pizzeria is so slamming! I love their pizza and calamari! You can't go wrong with those two