Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Nataliano's

    3.8 (5 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 7:00 pm

    Order Nataliano's Takeout or Delivery

    Nataliano's Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Nataliano's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Zoe Q.
    2
    75
    11

    3 years ago

    Fresh great food! Stop by for friendly service and awesome tacos and empanadas. Great for people on the way to or from Bethel.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Rob R.
    0
    19
    0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Nataliano's

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Memito's Tacos and Deli

    Memito's Tacos and Deli

    5.0(13 reviews)
    7.5 mi
    Locally owned & operated
    Speaks Spanish

    What was I thinking giving this place 4 stars. Such great value, friendly service, and the food is…read moredelicious. Definitely worth a stop in Monticello. Had the cheese nachos this time as well as our faves from past visits. House-made flour tortilla chips blanketed in Mexican cheeses, black beans, guacamole, pickled jalapenos, tomatoes, lettuce and generous lashings of crema. Yes, the tomatoes were those pale imitation things and the lettuce is shredded iceberg, but it all worked, especially with the trio of house salsas. Was baby shark coming from a phone at the next booth over? Yes, but somehow it didn't matter, the food was so comforting. They bake Mexican pastries there too, and it seems like they've added pizza.

    This place is truly the best and has come through time and again as hungry travelers in need of…read morenourishment. Most visits we've done take out, but recently we dined in and the dishes and had a great experience too. The front of house and back of house service hustles hard here. The steak dishes have always been a stand out. The tortas are wonderful. Try anything with the handmade tortillas. They're out of this world. Aguas Frescas are delicious and not overly sugary or powdery. And most recently, we had a seafood soup special that was divine. And while you dine or wait for take out, admire the wonderful artisan designs on the furniture!

    Photos
    Memito's Tacos and Deli
    Memito's Tacos and Deli
    Memito's Tacos and Deli - Chairs at the counter

    See all

    Chairs at the counter

    El Sombrero Restaurant - Chips and salsa

    El Sombrero Restaurant

    4.3(113 reviews)
    13.6 mi
    $$

    Let me start by saying the owner is incredibly accommodating and genuinely generous. From the…read moremoment we sat down, he made us feel welcome. My brother-in-law ordered the combo with mixed meats and seafood for one, and it was absolutely amazing fresh, flavorful, and more than enough food. I ordered the fajitas; they were good, but next time I'd skip those and go straight for the nachos and the tostadas, which looked outstanding. Before we even finished scanning the menu, the owner brought out food for the baby on the house, which was such a thoughtful and appreciated gesture. The drinks were excellent as well made and refreshing. Overall, great food, great service, and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. We'll definitely be back for more of his amazing meals.

    We found this charming place on our way back to Westchester from Ithaca. We were getting closer to…read morehome and we were starving. This place popped up just off our route and I'm so glad it did. Being from Texas, it's hard to find good Tex-Mex and Mexican food. El Sombrero fit the bill. Inside, it looks like any place we might go for Tex-Mex in Texas. Our waiter, Elias, was absolutely amazing! The top shelf margarita was truly top shelf. It was seriously one of the best I've had. One thing that sets this place apart from so many restaurants... The guy who owns it is a butcher. They have the most amazing cuts of meat and they know how to prepare them. I got the mixed fajitas, while my husband got the steak. The cuts of meat were perfectly seasoned and perfectly cooked in both our meals. I asked Elias to bring me the hottest hot sauce they have and what he brought me was so good that I wished I had some for home. I mentioned this to him and when he brought us the check, he brought me some to take home! What a sweetheart! I really wish this place was closer to home, but it's good enough to take a drive for periodically. We'll be back.

    Photos
    El Sombrero Restaurant
    El Sombrero Restaurant - Shrimp fajitas

    Shrimp fajitas

    El Sombrero Restaurant - So good!

    See all

    So good!

    The Local Table and Tap - Cheese curds

    The Local Table and Tap

    3.4(196 reviews)
    0.8 mi
    $$

    I do not normally like to talk down on local businesses. I Like to see the good in people, even on…read moremy worst days. I really hope that someone (if it is just one person) in this building actually cares about food, customer service, helping people, or just spreading any sort of joy or kindness in general.....but I did not see a shred of evidence during my dinner here. Here's the shorthand for anyone who doesn't want to read my family's story: The water tastes like blood here. The service is abysmal and takes way too long. The vibe is very unwelcoming and unpleasant. The food is low effort and extremely overpriced. Here is my experience: We had a group of six, we left the little ones at home- my niece and her older cousin. The family was stoked to have a night to have some good drinks, laughs, and food on our airbnb vacation. This was pretty much the only restaurant in the area so we had to go here. Safe to say our night and our fun came to a screeching halt. Immediately drunk patrons at the bar were yelling slurs and the bartenders laughing with them all buddy-buddy. Dirty looks from the hostess and bartenders. We are from NJ, so maybe we are just lucky and have cleaner tap water, but all our our tap waters tastes like blood to us. Straight up mercury. Same with the soda from the tap. Awful. Our extremely unhappy (from the start) waitress rolled her eyes when we told her this and asked for other water. We were brought bottled water about 20 minutes later by a different angry waiter. The service was abysmal. Everyone in there, including the bartenders, seemed like they wanted us dead. Angry furrowed brows all around. Our entire excruciating experience was almost two hours long, and this is even with us rushing to eat and drink quickly because the vibes were so awful in there. The "pizza" we ordered was a piece of thin hard bread with about an ounce of tomato sauce drizzled on it for $40. The food was overpriced and not very good. The mashed potatoes were a liquid. My sister ordered a burger excluding vegetables that she was allergic to yet it was brought out with everything she requested to be taken off right there on the burger. Careless. No one there cares. At all. Right from the start they seemed annoyed that we showed up. I understand that working sucks- I get that, I really get that. I fucking hate my job, serious I do. But if you work at a restaurant where people come to laugh and relax and have a night out, I really think you at least should be pleasant. I have worked plenty service jobs where I hated being there, but for the sake of kindness and humanity I would treat customers like people with feelings. I wouldn't treat them like a burden or like I hated them. I would never recommend this restaurant to anyone, and I pray for the miserable souls that work here and emanate mean and unpleasant energy. There is a future full of joy and love, we just need to start by spreading it to our neighbor.

    Was up here for the weekend and trying to find a great burger ... food choices in the area is…read morechallenging... the place is on the lake great view and service and the burger and fries were delicious also had the Caesar salad with great dressing .... Very satisfying

    Photos
    The Local Table and Tap
    The Local Table and Tap
    The Local Table and Tap - View, and back deck

    See all

    View, and back deck

    Nataliano's - tacos - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...