Yelp Review: Good Ambiance, But Overpriced and Underwhelming…read more
I have years of experience in fine dining, so I'm not someone who looks for things to criticize just for the sake of criticizing. When I evaluate a restaurant at this price point, I look at three things: quality of ingredients, service, and ambiance. The price should reflect all three.
Blue Ribbon Sushi has the ambiance--it just needs some tweaking.
Seating: We were seated at the long bench with two-top tables. Unfortunately, the tables are squeezed so closely together that it's impossible not to hear the entire conversations happening on either side of you. Add music that was too loud, which caused everyone to speak even louder, and suddenly I'm involuntarily listening to the first-date questionnaire happening next to me. Not exactly the intimate sushi experience I was hoping for. It really killed the mood.
Now, the thing everyone talks about: the prices.
Do I think it's overpriced? Yes. But hear me out.
I don't expect Texas-sized portions at a sushi restaurant. I do, however, expect to understand what I'm paying for. When you're charging $18 for a single piece of sashimi, portion size matters. My advice: ask how many pieces come with an order before ordering, especially if you're planning to share. Otherwise, you may end up spending significantly more than expected.
I ordered the Chef's Choice Sushi for $60, along with the Kaki Fry. I hesitated because, in my experience, "chef's special" can sometimes mean a small portion dressed up with a fancy name. But having worked in fine dining, I also know what a chef's special should mean: an opportunity for the chef to have some creative freedom and show you what they think you should experience at their restaurant.
In fine dining, dishes are generally plated and presented intentionally and separately. Here, my Kaki Fry was not what I expected, it came as a roll and it was lumped onto the same board as the Chef's Choice Sushi.
At first, I actually thought, Okay, this is a pretty good amount for $60.
Then we asked where our Kaki Fry was.
We were told it was already on the board--mixed in with the Chef's Choice. Kaki fry tends to be. Graded oysters fried (look up pictures for reference). In this case, it came as a roll. It wasn't labeled as "kaki fry roll". The manager said "it was listed with the rolls" so what? It wasn't called the Kaki Fry roll!
That felt like a cheap shortcut to make the presentation look more substantial for the price. Maybe technically nothing was wrong with it, but as a diner, it felt like a bait-and-switch, and it completely killed the experience. They ultimately comped the Taki Fry, which I appreciated, but by then the moment had already been lost.
Service: We were seated promptly despite not having a reservation, which was great. I did wonder whether that was why we ended up with the particularly loud, cramped seats. The waitstaff was friendly, but there were a few things I think could be improved. Portion sizes should be communicated more clearly, particularly when something is only one piece or isn't realistically enough to share. There was also a noticeable push toward drinks, which felt a little aggressive given the already high menu prices.
Overall, as someone who lives in FiDi and has tried quite a few sushi restaurants in the area, I have to agree with other reviewers: Blue Ribbon Sushi is overpriced for what you get.
The restaurant has a beautiful atmosphere and clearly has the bones of a great dining experience. But at these prices, the details matter. Better spacing between tables, clearer communication about portions, and a more thoughtful approach to plating and service would go a long way.
There are simply better sushi options nearby for the money.