Nancy's has been an awesome neighborhood staple for years. Vicki and staff do an amazing job. If you have not stopped in and taken a peek at the new menu, you should! The meatballs are amazing !!! read more

Actually, the food was very good the first time I went, so I went back. The second time, the food was stale and undercooked. The brownie cake was hard. It was very good and moist the first time. My salmon was undercooked the second time. The waiter was sarcastic and neglectful the second time. Honestly, I think I was treated differently because he overheard my conversation with my partner-we were talking Trump and how we were scared for our country. After that, we got looked at strangely. Then "Vicky" I think was her name (owner? Not sure), came by the table to praise Trump-Really? This was not appropriate and she wouldn't stop. I think she could tell we were uncomfortable, but she held us there until closing singing his praises.That was just outright inappropriate. I told her so. I told her, you only hire mature waiters (white only) who are polite to customers for your restaurant, but you're ok with hiring this disgusting talking man (Trump) to run a country? He wouldn't have a shot to get a job here as a waiter. Her answer-Well, I don't know...he (Trump) can be bad that way, but I just LOVEEEE him! WTH? I left. Never went back. Don't want to support her business. "Vicky", how's business now? It's got to be worse under Trump. You get what you vote for and you've lost customers. read more

Had the most delicious and enjoyable lunch this afternoon. The owner Vicki was so sweet and the food was absolutely delicious and so fresh. Highly recommend read more

Nancy's Restaurant - French onion soup - New American Near Me - Floral Park, New York

See all

Food was good the service was amazing made you feel like you were from there the ambiance was homey vibe nice people if your in the neighborhood definitely stop in read more

Always welcoming Vicky! Sharing food next to the warm fireplace and taste of Winter lager, french onion soup, and perfectly grilled burger, Nancy's is truly a neighborhood gem. Prompt service and friendly staff complimented the memorable ambience. Cozy and shooshy shoosh. read more

Nancy's Restaurant - New American Near Me - Floral Park, New York

See all

Nice Irish Pub atmosphere, family owned since the 1940 s. The food was great big portions, we had their signature burger and fries ,for desert bread pudding everything was delicious . Victoria made us feel at home, it was cold outside and she had the fire place going so cozy Definitely will be back read more

I must have driven past Nancy's thousand's of times and never noticed it. What a charming oasis it is once you enter. Dark wood, beamed ceilings and even a fireplace makes you feel right at home. We started with the potato and bacon soup which was luscious and tasty. The Country Salad with crispy goat cheese fritter, mixed greens, tomatoes, carrots, bacon, candied walnuts, roasted garlic vinaigrette was outstanding and addictive. For entrees, the Grilled Hangar steak with Mexican street corn and French fries was cooked and seasoned perfectly and delicious. Also opt'd for one of the specials which was pork chop with spaetzle which was another great dish. Do not skip dessert! The homemade bread pudding served with caramel and ice cream was unreal. It was decadent, not too sweet and something we couldn't stop eating. It was exceptional. I would defintley fine again at Nancy's since now I know what I've been missing all these years. read more

See all

Wonderful experience at Nancy's. The owner was so helpful and open to our ideas for our baby shower in her restaurant (November 2024). The food was tasty and prompt. Would definitely go there again. Environment was calm yet classy. read more

See all

I just celebrate my baby's first birthday and Christening weeks ago. The owner of the restaurant Vicky is really helpful, she allowed us to come a bit earlier to decorate the place. It was my first time decorating and she gave us a couple of great suggestions. The staff were very warm and welcoming to all the guests. Food is really good. The place is great. I will definitely come back next year for any private events. read more

Nancy's Restaurant - New American Near Me - Floral Park, New York

See all

A cozy Irish Pub atmosphere, family owned business since 1941. The food was great nice portions we had their signature Hamburger with fries and bread pudding everything was delicious.Victoria made us feel like family, it was cold outside she had the fireplace going and was very cozy. I will definite be back read more

Unfortunately, I have to give a review on the food, which was horrible. I honestly hate giving two stars to a family owned restaurant. Maybe it can be looked into. The appetizers were better the main entrees, which is crazy. I had the burger, which had no flavor at all, the lettuce on the burger tasted unwashed, fries was excellent. The salmon my father had was too salty. My sister had the pulled pork risotto and had to give it back as it tasted like canned pork and the cheese from the risotto had a bad after taste. My mother had the veggie risotto but sent it back as well because it had a bad after taste. However, the service and wine were excellent. I'm not sure if the food is bad or the chef needs to put a little flavor in the food. My family was pretty displeased as it was my niece's birthday and wanted to try a different restaurant in my neighborhood. The restaurant has a cozy vibe which was nice! But I will not return for the food. read more

Nancy's Restaurant - Salmon - New American Near Me - Floral Park, New York

See all

Great family atmosphere. The food is delicious and reasonable. It's an amazing neighborhood restaurant.

Food was all very good. Reservation held and table ready. Talkative crowd but not loud enough to yell LOL. Older woman server was a pistol. Helpful and friendly. Buffalo shrimp has too much breading but tasted good. Warm spinach salad was tasty but not warm. Hangar steak on sizzling platter was good BUT because it keeps cooking the meat the medium rare went medium. Next time I'll say rare. Pan roasted crispy Chicken was delicious. Home maybe tagliatelle was super! Al dente thought it would be mushy but was not. Grilled pork chop was HUGE. We laughed at how big it was. Asked for medium but was slightly dry. Flavor and veggies were good though. Hot brownie was Amazing. Bread pudding not so much. Decaf espresso martini was great as was my Irish coffee. Would return. Don't be put off by the non- description exterior. And parking is lousy. But manageable. read more

See all

This place was absolutely amazing . The bread they give you on the table with the dipping oil was delicious right there we knew dinner was going to be amazing. The apps to dinner for Easter Sunday couldn't have been better. We all enjoyed our dinners. We don't live in the area but we will definitely be back. The service was excellent as well. read more

See all

Everything was delicious. Melt in your mouth chicken fingers and fish sticks. Burgers were fantastic and salad was fresh and tasty. Highly recommend! read more

I had my baby shower over at Nancy's over the weekend, and Vicky was amazing with helping us out and accommodating the venue to our needs, we had a total of 46 people so we ended up doing one long table of 32, and 2 tables of 6 but there was enough room for 3 tables of 6-8. The food was also amazing !! I received a bunch of messages from my family and friends after on how much they enjoyed the food, we got the whole restaurant to ourselves and she was very attentive and even offered to let us to come in early to decorate. Was an amazing four hours and super affordable especially compared to similar packages in the area couldn't beat it! Will definitely be recommending Nancy's for years to come :) read more

See all

I enjoyed the food here. We sat down right away and the waiter was great. We had the homemade mozzarella sticks which were really homemade. I ordered the hanger steak. It was good. The drinks were great. Staff was friendly and attentive. Will be back soon. read more

Nancy's Restaurant - Wine list - New American Near Me - Floral Park, New York

Nancy's, is my go to eatery when I'm in Floral Park. The food is always on point and the prices are reasonable. Vicky, the owner is very attentive and chef David never disappoints. read more

Nancy's Restaurant - New American Near Me - Floral Park, New York

See all

When you write a Yelp review, 2 stars literally means "Meh. I've experienced better." In this case, that would be an understatement... but I know that if I ordered something else, and if my waiter had perhaps been more experienced, I likely would have given this restaurant either 3 or maybe 4 stars. Here's the thing... parking is limited on the streets, but the place itself is nice looking. I believe it's adequately staffed, even for a Saturday night. Maybe they can use a "busboy," but if they're not filling the place up, I understand why they would cut that position. I definitely like the atmosphere there. The men's bathroom has more than one urinal and two lovely, large sinks. I found the place to be clean, and the wait staff have a uniform of sorts, and they all had a nice demeanor about them. Bread rolls are served cold. The menus are cute, but a bit confusing (there are 2 pages, one a regular menu, and the other for specials where some of the regular dishes are repeated with slight variations). The waiter starts with a drink order. I got a glass of Riesling, and I was surprised to find that they even had it there. When it came, I was disappointed, as the taste was bittersweet, unlike the typical Riesling... normally my favorite wine. I asked if I could return it... the waiter obliged with no problem, and actually brought me a small sample amount of "sweet wine", since that's what I like, but a different brand. I didn't like that one either, and just asked for a ginger ale. When we placed the order for food, I asked for a salad to share with my wife (and an extra plate, of course), and the "Risotto / Maine Lobster (with corn and baby arugula)" for 16.95. I thought this was a pretty decent deal for a lobster! Still though, it was listed under Appetizers, and I asked if it's really an appetizer. The waiter, a very young guy, said that if I wanted to, I could get it as a main course. Great! After he walked away, I remembered that I really love the tomalley (that disgusting green stuff that's inside the breast of a freshly cooked lobster), so I ran over to him to ask him to be sure that it's left inside, and not discarded. Salad came. It was really, really good. I highly recommend the Arugula Salad if you come here. And not only did they bring the extra plate that I asked for, but they actually split up the salad and the goat cheese for us. It looked fresh and beautiful, and was a very large portion (if it was for one person, it could serve as an entree) and tasted great. I was only saddened by the news from our waiter that the chef cleans out the lobsters first thing in the morning, so there wouldn't be any tomalley to serve me. Then my Risotto / Maine Lobster arrived. You can check out the photo. I was like "OMG, they gave me the appetizer as a mistake." I asked the waiter just to be sure. "Nope...that's the Entree portion." It was a decent-sized blob of risotto, topped with about a dozen small chunks of lobster, probably equating to an entire lobster claw cut into 6 pieces, and 6 or so other smallish chunks from an arm. I was blown away... not impressed. Mind you... at no time did we discuss how I wanted it cooked (steamed or boiled or broiled), nor did it say "Whole Lobster" anywhere on the menu, and the word "whole" never came up in conversation. I was wondering if the waiter had ever seen this served before, as "cleaned in the morning" doesn't usually mean that it comes served as some smallish chunks from a whole lobster. This means that it was actually COOKED in the morning, then cleaned and probably cut... in the morning. Or maybe it was frozen, and heated as it's requested. I don't know... but man, was I disappointed. The risotto was good... it's not something I was expecting to be my Entree. I eat Risotto on the side... never as a main dish. My wife's mussels were OK. My dad was really happy with his whole wheat pasta dish. My mom got her Grilled Steak. Having asked for it "Medium" but receiving it fairly burnt (some pieces burnt to a complete crisp), she asked to return it. FYI, anything "blackened" can contribute to causing cancer. F-that. (I tried the steak. It was a shame to throw away. It had a nice flavor.) She got the chicken instead, and wasn't really thrilled with it. We skipped dessert. The check still showed the wine I returned, and while the waiter told me that my risotto/lobster would cost "no more than $24.95", I was charged 26.95. He gave me a bit of trouble about taking my Riesling off the check, as I "drank some." I pressed on about it, and he removed it from the check, and reduced the lobster to 24.95... but wow, what a rip off. That's the rub. It's not really a bad place, but I ordered the wrong thing, perhaps on the wrong day, and neither the menu or waiter were helpful in communicating to me what I'd be receiving. I hope you have a better experience. read more

See all

I dined at Nancy's many times, many years ago. It was called Nancy's Fireside. It was good then and good now. I remembered she made a fantastic burger, and I was craving a good burger. So my husband and I went to Nancy's. We started out with risotto. It was creamy and the rice was al dente, perfectly cooked with a huge flavor. We shared the side dish. We both ordered cheeseburgers, and we were both totally satisfied. The burgers were cooked perfectly and they were moist and juicy. It came with fries. They were OK. The burger dinner was 14.00 and well worth it. Our waitress was wonderful. I don't remember her name. She was friendly and attentive. She also answered our menu questions. In the past, we have had their seafood and steak and were always very pleased. I would recommend this restaurant. read more

We had a lunch at Nancy's after a memorial service. It was fantastic from the process of setting it up to the service and the food. I really appreciated Vicki's thoughtfulness with our lunch. We got the 4 course meal and everyone loved everything they got in each course. The bread pudding was especially good! read more

Really glad we came here to celebrate our anniversary - Great place to come to with professional service! Had a great meal - Goat cheese salad with shrimp - shrimp tasted great and so did the goat cheese - I gave most of my salad to my husband though it was doused in vinegar wasn't too much of a fan of that part - risotto was delicious and cooked to perfection! We each had a Negroni cocktail and no complaints there - their French fries were cooked to perfection - crunchy on the outside and soft in the middle - chicken fingers were a bit dry but edible - buffalo shrimp cocktail was devoured by husband - you can't go wrong ordering the brownie for dessert it was delicious :) my daughter liked the Creme Brûlée - I am glad they offer a separate dessert menu - very professional! Instead of announcing what the desserts are - Friendly service all around. read more

See all

The food here was great. We started off with the fried calamari. The dipping sauce was great. I had the slow roasted chicken which was very juicy. It was fun going to such a renowned establishment. The servers were very friendly. read more

Nancy's Restaurant - New American Near Me - Floral Park, New York

Went here to celebrate my 3 year old son's birthday with family on a Sunday evening. Customer service was AMAZING!! I had guests cancel on me last minute & I was also running late for our reservation and they accommodated me. Everything was cooked really well just wish portion size for hangar steak was more & that the food had more seasoning. Hence why I took off a star. read more

This place is definitely a great spot to visit for next level pub fare and relax with a cocktail. The woman behind the bar seems like she's always working no matter what time you may pop in. There's a decent amount of tables but I always eat at the bar. Plenty of televisions in the place to watch a game and enjoy the atmosphere. Always friendly patrons and it really is a nice local hangout that's also very family friendly. Menu has a wide selection of dishes to accommodate even the finest of palates. Great steaks, burgers and salads. Whoever prepares the food is undoubtedly better than just a short order cook. Prices are reasonable and the drinks are always very good. read more

On the coldest day of the Fall (so far) we headed to Nancy's with good food in mind but found so much more. As we had been working outdoors for a while we were truly frozen right down to our toes. The hostess/waitress/possibly Nancy person lead us to a table right in front of their fireplace (after we answered her question, "How are you?" with our one word reply, "Frozen!") where we were able to defrost while enjoying our potato soup with bacon. OMG did that hit the spot and help us warm up something fierce. Did I mention it was a late lunch? It was about 2:45 PM and we were truly hungry. Next up we both opted for their delicious burger. I had mine with cheddar and bacon. It was yummy. But I knew that ahead of time because we have been to this lovely little gem of a restaurant previously Sorry, no photo of the burger because the hour was late and by the time I remembered, the burger was gone. Well half gone. The soup was so filling that I could only get half the burger down. Ironically while reading (originally I wrote eating the menu, lol!) the menu aloud to my Mom, I told her I wanted one of everything on the menu. That just goes to show you that the food choices are extremely attractive and my eyes are bigger than my stomach! I want to mention that Nancy's Restaurant has a lovely cozy vibe to it and makes one feel right at home with delicious food just an order away. In addition, the hostess/waitress/possibly Nancy person is simply delightful and makes it all even more pleasant. read more

Nancy's Restaurant - Potato soup with bacon. Perfect cold weather food. - New American Near Me - Floral Park, New York

I've been going to Nancy's for many years now Vicky, Liz, Frank and Brendan are great. The food is always terrific whether a burger or the fried chicken sandwich I just had with Cole slaw and pickles with a side of fries. A nice size portion as well. Great appetizers also. Always recommend. read more

The soups (onion; potato) are tasty and wonderful warmer-uppers on a cold day/night. The salmon is always tasty & plentiful and the burgers are large & juicy. There's a good choice of draft, as well as bottled, beers, with a diverse and reasonable wine list. Vicky is welcoming, warm, knowledgeable & helpful. There aren't many of these family owned & run restaurants remaining, so it always give us a good feel to go there. read more

The food was un edible,the food seemed to be microwaved and seasoned with a dash of salt and pepper at most.

Unbelievable food (12/10) and great music. Manhattan quality at Long Island prices. Best restaurant in Floral Park!

Classic comfort food at its Best! Never disappoints. Hanger steak to perfection. Service is spot on. Can't wait to go back read more

We've been here twice on Friday nights, and we love the live music they have. We sit in the bar area at the high tables, right near the fireplace and in sight of the musician- super cozy vibe. You can tell the bartender knows nearly everyone who walked in which shows theres a decent amount of regulars. We like the food, but both times I went somehow couldn't find much to choose from.. David's gnocchi was good but I wasn't crazy about the sauce/maybe not a big fan of pork shoulder- however, the next time we went I believe they had a special gnocchi and I preferred that taste. They have valet parking fyi! Wish they had a happy hour (their website isn't updated// don't see anything else on yelp so assuming they don't). read more

My first visit. Lovely place and hostess - warm and welcoming. Great food! Will go back again!

I just found this little gem of a bar restaurant. The menu wasn't the usual pub grub. Service was great especially the bar tender Dominique. I will be back! read more

Saturday night Bonnie G. and I trekked to Floral Park to finally try Nancy's Restaurant. We had scanned all the reviews and what photos there were and were expecting a bit more than we actually found there. It looks like a neighborhood bar and restaurant and once inside its confirmed...Big bar and moderate sized adjoining dining room with good activity. Noise level was over the top due to no wall coverings to absorb sound. Really hard to converse across table. We had seen photos of several dishes we were looking forward to trying, but we found that they change the menu at their whim. Not terrible but we did want to try the Pork Belly et. al....Also we saw photos of really tempting Turnovers but they discontinued them and subbed hard rolls. The food we ordered was good! Onion Soup was rich and cheesy..we enjoyed it! Quesadilla was actually 1/2 as it was one large shell filled with cheese and meat and folded in half. Needed more filling. Their Nancy's Special Salad with Burrata was fresh and delicious...particularily the ripe tomatoes and the Mozzarella!. For Mains BG ordered the Sizzling Hangar Steak and I had the Pork Chop. Presentation was good and meat was prepared perfectly but the entre's dont come with their fresh vegetables...they are all sides. We were surprised after seeing all the photos of farm fresh produce on their Yelp photos but aside from the salad none were apparent?? Service was very good and servers were cordial. After spending time at the venue we would not return with guests as its too loud and with the paper table cloths not to fancy. It really gives the impression of a local bar as previously stated but the food is really good. read more

See all

I had to give them another high five! How life has changed during Covid. We decided to support our locals places at least twice a week with "to go" before restaurants started coming back to normal again. Nancy's was on our list. A great place previously, but now in the new world we fell in love with our locals all over again. The food is great, the staff is amazing. Liz is amazing!!! Honestly can't wait to have a sit down meal here again! read more

Love Nancy's! Homemade everything family owned and great for groups or a stop at the bar!

Recently I stopped to Nancy's.I haven't been here in a while but I was a regular customer both at the bar and restaurant. The fireplace is still a landmark! Both me and my friend had the Potato Soup and their great Burger.The food is good.The server was helpful and she was been working here for a while.The bar is fine and they have TV's for the sports.They had a party going in the cozy restaurant. This place has been a staple in this town.I know that the owners have change but this is still a nice place.If you are going the only thing is that parking is mostly curbside.If you are in the area stop by at Nancy's. read more

Perfect neighborhood restaurant. The food is always great, impeccable service and nice ambience with the fireplace.

The food really is so good. I always get risotto and one of their salads with grilled shrimp. Portions are huge and everything still tastes great the next day. My husband loves their burger with sautéed onions and pepper jack cheese. We usually do takeout and we really appreciate how the food is packed up. Everything is always very neatly packed away and their French fries come in an open box that way they stay crispy and don't get soggy. I've never seen another restaurant actually care that much about takeout. Always keeps us coming back! Either Vicky or Liz usually answers the phone whenever we call and they are both so polite and always get the order correct. During Covid they'll even offer to bring the food out to your car for curbside! read more