Since moving to Lake in the Hills, my family has ventured out to pick up Nancy's Pizza many times. Besides generally having lackluster sides, their pizza is great, whether you choose thin or deep dish! They are on point with their pick up times and their prices are fair. Nancy's is carry out and delivery only-- no dining area. Parking is easy and it's easy to find, right on Randall! Regarding the sides, their Parm/Pesto Waffle fries were pretty tasty, so if you're looking for a side, I would try those. The garlic bread usually leaves me wanting more, so I'd pass on that! Nancy's is worth a ring when you're in the market for some really good pizza! read more

Nancy's Pizza - a tray of fries with guacamole - Pizza Near Me - Crystal Lake, Illinois

See all

We picked and the pizza wasn't ready because we asked for it well done. We waited in the car and the gentleman working the counter brought it out to us. Of course, the pizza was excellent as always!! read more

Picked up pizza. It was ready as promised. Checkout was a breeze. Decent price. Pizza had good flavor but tecture not so good. Too oily or soggy. Cardboard box was a little soaked. read more

Amazing pizza!! We usually get it delivered and they're on time and friendly! Give them a try!

Best deep dish pizza around. Perfectly buttery crust, extra cheesy and loaded with your toppings. Staff is super friendly and welcoming.

I used to love this place until I realized how ridiculously overpriced it is. We got a medium stuffed pizza, a salad, and cheese raviolis and it was $60 total (we did carry out). That is ridiculous to me. I really do love their pizza, but if I need a Nancy's fix, I will just get a small stuffed and make my own salad at home. The blueberry salad is TERRIBLE. It was basically just strait up lettuce with a few nuts and 5 pieces of feta. The dressing for the salad was very gross. I forgot to take a picture because it was so boring looking. I wayyyy rather prefer Lou Malnati's house salad. I will probably not go here again. Get Lou's or Giordano's. read more

Nancy's Pizza - Rocco's Party - Pizza Near Me - Crystal Lake, Illinois

See all

I've been enjoying Nancy's pizza since I was a young girl. Moved away to California for a few years and recently moved back to the Chicago area. I just love their pizza, my favorite and all of Chicago highly recommend. read more

Great pizza good service. Stuffed and thin crust are very good. The best around.the rest of there menu is very good also

Best gluten free pizza I found! I am so happy I tried it. Reasonably priced and 12". YAY finally found a pizza place my family loves and that has gluten free pizza for me!! read more

Growing up we went to Nancy's for years always a great place with great pizza. Not sure what changed but not so great. If I was honest probably below average. It's a shame but with so many pizza places in the area they really need to up their game to keep us read more

Do not overlook this gem! It's pretty hard to find a solid pizza place in an area that is so heavily saturated with the same thing. We were so happy when we found this place. And we are so close by which is even better! While the sizes aren't the largest, it is definitely very satisfying! We usually get some sort of combination of sausage, pepperoni, veggies etc. and a deep dish. It can be on the pricier side depending on what you get, but so Is everywhere else. You're paying for quality and Nancy's Pizza never disappoints. Their crust is flaky and buttery and has the perfect crumb that compliments their rich tangy sauces and gooey cheese. Everything is always hot and fresh. The deep dish is my go to and I would say that it's comparable if not better than the other "Chicago must-haves" highly recommend this to everyone! It's a place not to miss! read more

Oh my goodness, you can't go wrong with pizza from Nancy's. The thin crust is crispy, the toppings are generous and the cheese was perfectly toasty. But then that deep dish, with the buttery crust all stuffed with toppings, sooooo delicious! read more

Nancy's Pizza - Thin crust, half sausage, half pepperoni (hidden under all that cheese). - Pizza Near Me - Crystal Lake, Illinois

The best thin crust pizza place in the area - haven't tried the stuffed yet. They also have very good bone in wings.

Best deep Dish anywhere in America. Crust is truly unique. Sauce perfect balance sweet and savory. Great family run location .

I don't normally leave reviews, but after what I had delivered to my house yesterday, I had to do this. Their Stuffed Pizza was AMAZING! Hands down, the best pizza I've ever tasted. So much cheese, it's ridiculous. Pretty sure I'm gonna get diabetes from my meal last night, but it was worth it. I'm new to Crystal Lake, and I will definitely be going back to Nancy's for more. Love it! read more

Nancy's Pizza - a large deep dish pizza - Pizza Near Me - Crystal Lake, Illinois

Excellent gluten free pizza! I'm living in the area for awhile and wanted to find a regular pizza place. Nancy's was recommended by a local friend who hadn't tried the GF pizza. I don't believe there is ever bad pizza but when it comes to gluten free it takes something special - such that you wouldn't know it's gluten free - for me to rave about it and write a review. I highly recommend Nancy's if you or someone in your household eats gluten free! And be sure to tip the delivery people well. They are excellent at Nancy's too! read more

Best pizza on the planet. Consistency is superb, quality is amazing. If you haven't had you're missing the best of the best. I recommend!

I just paid $2.25 for 1/4 bag of fries and $7 for a cup of dry pasta. Never ordering from Nancy's Pizza in Crystal Lake again. What a rip off. read more

Nancy's Pizza - a plate of pasta and a can of yogurt - Pizza Near Me - Crystal Lake, Illinois

See all

Picked up pizza from Nancy's Pizza for the first time tonight. Got the BBQ CHICKEN and it was awesome!! The guy at the restaurant, Bill , was very pleasant too. I would definitely recommend it to friends and return for other tasty items. I'm not sure why some other people said some negative things about this place. I think they are doing a great job with excellent food and great customer service. Keep up the great work Nancy's Pizza !! read more

Recently discovered this place and I love their pizza. I'm a fan of the thin crust in particular. Definitely recommend.

My husband and I used to get Nancy's for date night when we dated so when we decided to get married we had to have them cater. Bill and his staff did such an amazing job. So professional and nice. Honestly it was easy working with Bill. The pizza was so great and really made the day special! I wish I could give them more than 5 stars. read more

We ordered many items. Pizza was amazing. The rest not so much. And how do you not have a combo, when you sell both? Cheese fries?¿?¿. The portions were that of a Costco sample. Again the stuffed pizza = amazing. The reason we ordered and remembered Nancy's from the city... Crystal Lake please step you're game up. read more

Did not receive hot food or marinara sauce with our order. First time here Most likely my last read more

Nancy's is awesome! They're polite, the food is consistently good, and delivery is always on time I appreciate that so much. Keep up the great work! read more

One of the best places I've had the joy of ordering pizza from. Not only is the pizza delicious, but the service is exceptional. I would highly recommend!!!Connot wait to go back!!! read more

Just tried Nancy's for the first time tonight and everything was excellent! Will definitely order from them again.Loved the rustic pizza crust. read more

Their pizza used to be really good . I ordered a take out of thin crust and pizza was super greasy . So much oil on top! It was a like a pool. And Idk what kinda cheese they used but it's chewy AF. I did more chewing than anything. So , No ones gonna talk about how chewy AF the cheese is besides me? Okay. They must like chewy cheese. I used to love their pizza but something change with the ingredients or brand. or whatever. It's not the same. The pizza was so greasy and oily that it soaked through the sauce and went on the bread. read more

Can we say YUMMY!? Perfect for a Wednesday night, Cubs baseball. Easy order and pay online. Picked it up 30-35 min later. Still hot getting home 5 min later. No hassle, friendly staff... lots of parking for pick up. read more

Best deep dish in Chicago. Ordered pick up and it took 20 minutes longer than what they estimated but the pizza was well worth it.

After a long awaited reopening, my wife and I ordered a stuffed crust. I must admit that I did not taste as good as we remembered. The sauce was bland but plentiful. The cheese was still as gooey as ever but also seemed to lack taste. The pepperoni was okay and not too overpowering. The buttery crust was just a little undercook. But compared to other places in the area it very good. The new location is right off of Randall road which makes pick ups even easier than the old place! We plan on waited a couple of months before trying again till they get back into the "groove". I would bet money that once the new staff gets comfortable Nancy's will be on top again in the area! read more

The pizza is really good. No issues with the food itself. Just WAY overpriced. You cannot order from this place without spending at least $30. So don't expect a cheap, easy dinner night. Again, really good pizza. Just extremely pricey. read more

Glad we finally gave Nancy's a try! Had seen it around for years but were in the habit of going to Lou Malnati's or Sal's for pizza. Nancy's didn't disappoint. Will definitely be including Nancy's in our rotation for pizza nights. As an afterthought, we also ordered some cannolis and were surprised at the quality: preferred Nancy's cannolis to those of Butera or even Konrads. An unexpected treat. We've only visited once but customer service was friendly and prompt. Thanks, Nancy's--we'll be back. read more

Love it when a restaurant reviews itself to get four stars I mean read these reviews the other reviews sounds so corny it's obvious the three reviews are from the people that own the place, earn your rating on the site yeah we believe it we all know the truth before you had to move try to get a new image and a new start the owners wife Kathy is an idiot she argues with customers over mistakes on their orders came outside to tell me not to park in the fire lane when they were very busy and wouldn't talk to me about my order said she was too busy but she wasn't too busy to tell a handicapped person with a handicap Placher it on their car was waiting for their order to be finished that cost $13 not to park in the fire lane in front of her store complete idiot she think she's a traffic cop she rubs her customers the wrong way moving from the old location to the new location won't change her abrasive personality when people call up and the pizzas are made wrong you don't argue with him that's why you lose customers I know that if I owned a business and I treated people like shit I would lose my customers husbands a decent guy but we know will pull the strings in this Business because I wouldn't put up with my wife chasing what few customers you have a way I love the Google review that says Bill with Nancy are such nice people that they had someone review their own restaurant the first three reviews on Google or so obviously fake you're trying to do damage control you want to fix your restaurant put a gag your wife she is ruining your business read more

We've been waiting for Nancy's to reopen! Missed this pizza so much. When the pizza came though our door everyone was so happy! tHE best pizza in the area. read more

Visiting family in Crystal Lake and someone recommended Nancys, Ordered a large vegie pizza. It was about the size of everyone elses medium. When I went to pick it up, I thought they were joking when they said it was $ 28.00. Was no better than a doctored $ 1.59 Totinos pizza. No wonder the sign out front said pizza maker wanted. read more

Best pizza around. DOWNSIDE is they can't handle the orders. Last time I ordered they made my pizza wrong AND had me waiting over 20 minutes past given pickup time. When I am waiting in there I hear all the unanswered phone calls. Tonight I had to call 3 times to get an answer. Now they say they quoted the wrong pickup time, they are backed up and not taking any more orders. And we'll be waiting another 30 minutes (who really knows) past our given pickup time. In exchange...a free fountain drink. Maybe instead of offering free 10" pizzas ONE DAY A YEAR and causing you this much chaos tonight for yourself and your customers, perhaps offer more coupons throughout the year. read more

I am so glade they are back in business. Love this pizza and I have had a lot of Chicago pizza and there's is just as good. Great pizza, fast delivery read more

I can't believe I haven't reviewed this place until now! Nancy's has been our go to pizza spot for years - we've tried others, but always prefer Nancy's over everyone else. We're big fans of the rustic crust pizza; it's perfectly crispy and light, not too thin. We've also done their thin crust and the deep dish, and have never been disappointed. We've ordered boneless wings, poppers, spinach salad, and other items - all delicious. The folks who answer the phone always acknowledge me by name, and always offer a customer loyalty coupon if available. The delivery timeframe is consistently about an hour and the pizza is a wee bit pricey, but totally worth it in my opinion. read more

Pretty good stuffed pizza but a little bit too sweet sauce at times. Don't go there very much anymore since the moved farther north on Randall Rd. as the traffic is a nightmare anywhere around dinner time. read more

Deep dish here is delicious. Recommend trying if you haven't yet. Like a lot of pizza places, the price is not exactly cheap. However if you want good deep dish then have to pay a bit more read more