Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mystic Bar

    5.0 (1 review)
    Open 6:00 am - 2:30 AM (Next day)

    Mystic Bar Photos

    Recommended Reviews - Mystic Bar

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    6 years ago

    It more than lives up to its name. A very friendly and mysteriously tranquil place. Great place to relax and enjoy a refreshing drink.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Sheeley House Saloon - Brussels sprouts appetizer

    Sheeley House Saloon

    4.1(84 reviews)
    0.3 mi
    $$

    It's taken years since I left town to finally make it back here under the (not so) new ownership…read more I've heard such good things and so when we found ourselves with an open afternoon, we stopped by for dinner. The ambiance is casual with lots of fun things to examine on the walls - some historic, some new. We started with the Brussels sprouts, loaded with bacon and Gouda cheese. These were a huge hit and we cleared the entire plate. I ordered the Sheely burger with truffle fries and definitely ate beyond capacity. The Mr. ordered the ribeye special and it came out medium rare just as he likes. He ate every bite and when he saw that you could buy a round for the staff for $10, proceeded to do so. He appreciates a perfect steak. Can't wait to come back and try some other items! *NOTE: CASH ONLY*

    Really dig the ambience of the old building. They say it's haunted, you be the judge, I didn't see…read moreany ghosts. With great service. There was a new server training in. They were very attentive. The drinks were good. I had the Sheeley old-fashioned, made with Bulleit Rye, a fairly standard Wisconsin style old-fashioned. My ribeye was just a little overcooked and my wife smashed burger was just a little undercooked. The food overall was pretty good. I'll definitely go back. I can't believe I've never been there after all these years.

    Photos
    Sheeley House Saloon - Men's room wall

    Men's room wall

    Sheeley House Saloon - I believe this was a ribeye special with mashed potatoes and roasted veggies

    I believe this was a ribeye special with mashed potatoes and roasted veggies

    Sheeley House Saloon

    See all

    The Brass Lantern - patty melt

    The Brass Lantern

    4.0(4 reviews)
    1.3 mi

    This is a dive bar. Right next to the tracks. We had a family event here and the food was very…read moregood. Not much for tap beer but they have the usual stuff in bottles. Decent service. Touch tunes. Pool table. Darts.

    I know lots of "local dives" that have great food and service. Unfortunately this is not one of…read morethem. It's not much to look at from the outside. The inside is bright, with lots of typical bar items, including video poker games, pool table, jukebox, etc. Came here on a Monday afternoon, after the lunch crowd. The was one other patron at the bar. We were the only table eating food. There were several staff at the bar, including the owner/cook, chatting it up and having a good time, and we got off to a great start. Our server got our party of 5 settled in with a clean wiped table and waters. The menu has typical bar, with includes unique burgers that we took a big interest in. We got several different sandwiches and burgers. All of them were "okay", but nobody was raving about their orders. Specifically, the fries were warm, but not hot, the smashburgers had good char, but not much flavor, and the presentation was not appetizing (the Cream Cheese on the Olive Burger looked curdled). We did share a couple pieces of the homemade cheesecakes (which were the non-baked whipped versions), and that was nice finish to the mediocre meal. The server was friendly, but didn't bother to check up on us. While she was socializing with the bar people, we had to fetch napkins, ask for waters, and then the check. I love to see Bar serve great food, but this one has a ways to go.

    Photos
    The Brass Lantern - Bar

    Bar

    The Brass Lantern - Homemade cheesecake

    Homemade cheesecake

    The Brass Lantern - Ginge ale

    See all

    Ginge ale

    Mystic Bar - beerbar - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...