Our experience in the shop itself was very positive, and we found the prices reasonable. The problems began when we were on the boat, specifically, with the divemaster/instructor. When I asked him his name, I thought he said "Pedro," but when I repeated it back, he said, "It's Pablo. Don't ever call me Pedro." And then laughed. This is not the problem. I'm just saying I'm not exactly sure what his name was. He was tall with closely shaved hair.
He was hard to understand. I speak Spanish fluently, but not everyone on the boat did (it was actually myself, my husband, and one woman from Puerto Rico), so he spoke in English. The problem was, his accent was so heavy that it was hard to understand him. So both I and the Puerto Rican woman kept trying to ask clarifying questions during his dive briefing. For example, he said something about what to do when we were low on air. I asked him "What PSI do you mean as low on air?" (Since this is always different, depending on conditions, distance from the boat, depth, etc.) He didn't like us asking questions and said "Can I please finish the briefing without you *attacking* me with questions?" I found that pretty negative, and we were definitely not attacking! The thing was, he had us pretty nervous, because he was telling us that the current was raging pretty hard and that it would be a tough dive. This was concerning, because my husband had only done 8 dives, had never done a drift dive, and had never dived in heavy current. BTW, we had told this to the dive shop. I don't know why he thought it was ok to take beginners on a dive like that. In fact, when I later spoke with the dive-shop owner (who was a very charming, open man), he said he never takes anyone to that site who has under 50 dives.
Anyway, since the current was so strong, it was hard for us to stay together. That's an issue. But the BIGGER issue was that both my regulator AND my husband's were leaking! Protocol in this case is to use your second stage (octo). But I couldn't see mine, because it was in an odd location (tucked into a little sleeve in the BCD). So I swam after him and he gave me his octo while he grabbed mine and gave it to me. Crisis averted. However, just about that time, I looked up, and my husband was at the surface! I motioned to the divemaster. I thought he should go after him. He shook his head. I motioned that I should go after him. He emphatically told me no, and that the captain would have him safely aboard. I worried the rest of the dive, but I also didn't want to ditch the other woman on the boat. Turns out that yes, the captain DID have my husband safely aboard, but my husband couldn't explain what had happened, because the captain spoke no English at all. When we got back on the boat, it turned out that my husband's regulator was ALSO leaking and that he panicked and swam to the surface. I was furious. I said "You've got three passengers aboard, and two out of three regulators are leaking?" He deflected by saying that we should be better divers and know what to do in these circumstances. Ok, maybe. But l'm a divemaster. I know what to do. I just could not see my octo because of where it was stowed. I told him he should have covered the location of the octo in his briefing. He was defensive. It got very heated. The fact remained--2/3 of the rental gear on the boat was defective, and there were no spares. And the instructor was not even apologetic.
My husband refused to go on the second dive. I was torn, because I also didn't trust the equipment (this should NEVER happen). But I didn't want the other passenger to go alone with this abrasive man, so I agreed to go IF I COULD DIVE WITH HIS REGULATOR. I knew THAT one would be working, right? Anyway, we switched, he dove with my second stage, and the dive proceeded uneventfully.
We did not tip well. Because we were PISSED. I mean, this is life-saving equipment. This is NOT ok. For a shop that busy, they should be maintaining their equipment and testing constantly.
I was so angry (and rattled, really, because this is dangerous!) that I called the owner, who was out of the country having a medical procedure. As mentioned, he was gracious and apologetic. He said he'd look into the equipment maintenance issue, and talk to the divemaster. The divemaster, he said, was a second-generation instructor; his father had worked at Mundaca, as well. He said he'd never have a complaint. Well, I found him to be arrogant, defensive, abrasive, difficult to understand, and RECKLESS. Why wasn't he on top of what was happening with my husband? Did he even look around to stop this before it happened? No.
I just want to add that I have over 150 dives under my belt and I am a divemaster (as I mentioned earlier). So I feel that I am pretty qualified to make these judgments. I've never seen anything so appalling in my life.
Net-net, I recommend you stay away from this shop. There are many others on Isla Mujeres--skip this one. read more