We have used the online ordering a few times and they always are ready on time. They had sent out a coupon awhile ago giving 30% off. We've used this many times and enjoy the savings. The staff there is always helpful and attentive. read more

We hadn't tried this place yet so have it a shot. Ordered online, easy, nice delivery person. Sadly pizza was rubbery and doughy. It wasn't fully cut and we could barely cut it with a pizza cutter. Everyone likes their pizza a little differently but this wasn't a fit for us. read more

So yummy! We call ahead to grab and go while traveling through. This will be a regular stop now.

Ordered a medium gluten free pizza last night. It cost $33 plus tip and was horrible. The crust was hard and chewy with hardly any toppings. I would have expected much more for that price. Have had wonderful GF pizza in the past. And the worst part is that it must have been bathed in flour because I feel horrible today. I've heard that the regular pizza here is pretty good but I give the GF one a FIRM pass. read more

They are the best pizza I found down here, and Wyoming, they use real bread though, and the vegetables are not killed. I am very picky on my food, so this gets a straight a from me. Will be getting them quite a bit. read more

I've found Mr. Jim's pizza to be better than say Papa John's or Pizza Hut, or most other places that sell pizza pies in Cheyenne. I like that I can order a triple pepperoni and they'll cover the pizza with pepperoni. When I eat a pizza I want to be able to taste the crust, the sauce, the cheese, and my pepperoni topping. Mr. Jims needs to be just a little more generous with the sauce as I can't taste it and usually can't see it either. You can't produce a 5 star pizza without the proper super high temperature oven. Most of these places have those ovens where you put the uncooked pie in one end and it spits out a cooked pizza at the other end. Those ovens don't produce great pizzas. If Mr. Jims wanted 5 stars he'd absolutely need to change out his dime a dozen ovens for some ovens that produce wonderful delicious pizzas. Service is quick, we always pick ours up and it's ready when it's supposed to be... actually a little earlier. Mr. Jims has two stores in town. One you can sit down and eat in, the other you can't. Mr. Jims serves some of the best pizza in this town, but it has a lot of room for improvement. read more

I can't believe I'm putting this negative review here but the last pie I got, from just today actually, was so disappointing. I made the order online so I could receive the special discount and set a pick up time for 5:30 since it wouldn't let me schedule it for an earlier time since I was driving thru Cheyenne. I was 45 minutes before Cheyenne and got to the store at 5:15 and they didn't even start on the two pizzas I ordered at 4:28. The young lady at the counter was confused and told me they'll start on it right away. I was annoyed because I wanted to just pick up my order and hit the road instead of waiting another 20 minutes. The sticky fingers looked terrible! Below par from what they usually looked like. The other pizza was just a medium sausage. I watched the young kid make my pizza and it seemed like he was frantically throwing on the toppings. I expected more from these guys since it is my favorite pizza joint to hit up here and when I'm paying $35 for it! read more

MrJims.Pizza - Mr. Jim's sticky fingers. - Pizza Near Me - Cheyenne, Wyoming

Mr. Jim's Pizza is my go-to place when I'm driving through Cheyenne. I call ahead from the road and the to-go pizza is ready in about 20 minutes. (Do your driving arithmetic to figure when to order; Exit 13 - North of Cheyenne.) The crust is really good and can stand-up to the toppings. Solid crust is important if you plan on multi-tasking / eating while you continue on your way along I-25. Note: It is carry-out / delivery only. read more

The service was very welcoming and on top of it and the best pizza I've had. cooked perfectly and amazing flavors. good prices and overall a good clean place(: read more

I ordered a pizza to be delivered. I told the person I talked to twice my address. After being 40 minutes late, I noticed a delivery fee. When I asked the driver how the fee was divided up and she told me that she got part of the fee as her tip from me. This I was told after I already asked if a three dollar tip would be good, and she told me yes. So she got my tip twice and gave me my greasy cold pizza. My wife and I both got diarrhea after eating the pizza. NEVER will l get anything from them again. They are dead to me. I would give them zero stars out of five even though I was forced to give a minimum of one. read more

passing through . Best pizza have has in a while and friendly staff. we recommend. You should give it a try

I'm not from the area and have never heard of MrJims but I'm glad I scrolled through Yelp and found this place! BlackJack Pizza has been my go to pizza place since I've got in town and it's pretty good but it's nothing compared to MrJims. It took a while for my three cheese pizza to be delivered but it is SO worth the wait! I will definitely be ordering from here again! read more

Placed an order online, once arrived to pickup it was incomplete, they then argued though the items were identified on receipt. However they were obviously overwhelmed which delayed the completion of our order. Walk-in customers were able to get pizza before us. Pizza was still good, just not as fresh as should be. read more

Got burned by another pizza place in town during my unexpected visit to Cheyenne and tried this one instead. I should have gone with Mr. Jim's right away. Got the Beddar Cheddar Burger for myself and my family with a few sides. The chicken didn't blow me away but I didn't even mind because I was all about this pizza. On a day when everything seemed to be messing up and going wrong I was so pleased that ordering from this place was not one of those things. They quoted me a high delivery time but got here faster than their quote by far, pizza was piping hot, and I didn't consider the price to be crazy. If you're looking for a balanced pizza with light crust, robust flavor, and doesn't sit in you like a brick when you're done... this is the place to be. read more

Wow. Mr. Jim has got ahold of something outstanding. I ordered the Sticky Fingers (supreme) and it was awesome. The crust is medium-thick, airy, and has a buttery crunch on the edges like a Pizza Hut pan pizza. The difference is Mr. Jim's is not drowning in grease. The pizza, for all its toppings and cheese was surprisingly light and refreshing. Fresh mushrooms were springy, green peppers still had snap. The sauce was great too, I think I'll ask for extra next time. It is in the tradition of sweet pizza sauces, but wasn't overly sweet and had a terrific lightness and zest. After a couple slices, the mellow spiciness of the sauce came out and it lingered nicely, perfectly balanced against the tomatoes and cheese. A large pizza cost about $12.50 after using an offer code from their website; great value. I didn't encounter any service issues on my visit, and found the order hot and ready to go when they said it would be. Counter staff were prompt and friendly. I'll definitely be back. read more

MrJims.Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cheyenne, Wyoming

See all

Tasted very odd like the meat wasn't washed and had chemicals on it. Also seemed like cheese must be the new eggs and was really rationed.

hi, I'll tell you where I am, I will tell you where I have been, but most importantly where I am now. I am 6'1 265 pounds and I am here to tell you pizza is my favorite meal, but get this to make a long story short I was evicted from my place, I had no money accept the rent money this asshole wouldn't reciece from me, move paid a hotel 500 a week, but tonight was different, Im extremely hungry, I have 7 dollars ish for cash but I was craving a pizza and not "pizza" ... Mr Jim's Pizza... I'm sure folks might their expensive, I did until I ordered one and it's awesome. so I'm homeless, Broke and hungry, I called in asking Sarah if I could charge a pizza for about a week and she apologized as they were unable to do that n she said gimme a second and she returned asking what did I want. I'm a 52 year old man who has copd and a few other things going on but short of inability, I'm never going to buy any pizza other than mr jims and I suggest you do the same !!! read more

Being from the East Coast and only recently relocated here, I am always on the hunt for authentic food, whether it's pizza, Chinese or Indian food; but Mr. Jim's hits the spot. The crust is delicious, I have to be careful I don't order this too often. I don't want to grow tired of it since there really aren't many GOOD pizza places in Cheyenne. I try to limit my orders to once a month. The variety of toppings is impressive, the calzones are HUGE and what great prices! The Vandehei store is my go to - very nice staff, friendly and always greet you with a smile. The food is always ready when promised, great portions, prices and the food is always hot. Treat yourself if you're looking for great pizza! read more

The pizza is great but I must have been wearing my invisible coat or something. I ordered ahead and had to go in and pay. So I walked in and stood at the front for a good 5 minutes before someone even spoke to me. There were three or four people working that were all at the front area discussing who was going to take out pizza's to the other's mom. Finally an older lady came around the corner and checked me out and gave me my pizza. She didn't apologize for the wait or anything just checked me out and walked away. I will go back for the pizza if I can order and pay for it ahead of time. read more

The topping choices are great and the crust is perfect. They didn't short me on the cheese either. I will most definitely return for more.

If this is your only option for pizza, bummer. You would be better off getting a frozen one at the grocery store and heating that up instead. Seriously, this was the worst pizza we have ever gotten for take-out. We got the Cheddar Fajita Chicken pizza - thinking wow! This sounds great! Not!!!! Crust was chewy cardboard and toppings were boring - not spicy - not yummy. We were so disappointed. read more

If you go thin crust, you will be very happy. The original stretched is good, but hooo-boy can it wallop you with some greasy goodness. I'm a fan of their Sticky Fingers pizza with jalapeños instead of black olives. They really load on the toppings, but not so much that it makes a soggy mess. For two-toppers, pepperoni and meatballs is a good combo. Don't go extra pepp though. I did mention the grease, right? The last one really worth mentioning is the Nacho Stix. It's great because it's not "Italian," so you can appease the person in the group who wanted Mexican over pizza. Then you can double-cross them and eat all the Nacho Stix before they get a second helping. It's that good. Their chicken wings are ok, but not super crispy. The skin slides off a bit. Ultimately I wish Mr. Jim's had a location on the East side of town; rumor has it that's going to happen. Be sure to order online as they have awesome deals. Mr. Jim's is our go to for thin crust pizza. read more

This is a hidden gem. I didn't know that you could dine in until yesterday. My little one and I had such a good time playing games and eating. Plus the staff are super friendly read more

Wow this Pizza is AMAZING! We decided to swing in on our way home from Colorado and I'm so glad we did! The pizza was hot and fresh and way better than the usual fast food pizza!! We bought the Sticky Finger pizza, as others on here advised was so good, and it was excellent! Their Jim Stix and garlic sauce were out of this world good too! Very good sizes-more than we could eat! Don't hesitate and give this place a try you won't regret it!! read more

MrJims.Pizza - Sticky Fingers Medium pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cheyenne, Wyoming

If you are needing crap service this this is your place! I called for a delivery last week. Was asked by three different people for directions where I was. After getting asked again where I was, I hung up and went with Chinese. Tonight, I got the order, missing 2 of the toppings I asked for. I'm done with this place! read more

This was a great stop coming in from a road trip off I-25 N. It was 49 minutes before they closed and is was quick and friendly service. We ate the Better cheddar burger pizza. Delish! We had to try the nacho stix are something to talk about too! The woman was very helpful with directions and even gave a coupon for free cin stix. Like we needed more delicious food, but a great treat! read more

MrJims.Pizza - Nacho Stix and Better Cheddar Hamburger pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Cheyenne, Wyoming

I'm a pretty picky pizza person (Say that 10X fast). In fact I have not been a fan of any pizza joints in Cheyenne - I would go to Fort Collins to Grimaldi's (shut down now). However I recently have given Mr Jim's a chance and I LOVE the sticky fingers and the pepperoni deluxe! The service is fast and amazing, I highly recommend this. It is a bit pricy of course compared to the fast food versions such as Pizza Hut, papa johns, etc but I highly say this is worth the money. read more

Driving through town and happened to find this place. I'm sure happy I did, though small, very nice service and quality. Though we didn't order ahead, they got right on our order and delivered in speedy fashion. Had a nice medium pizza with some lively toppings that made for a tasty meal. I would recommend, friendly people indeed :) read more

They changed the wings recipe. I used to love their wings but now they're really horrible. Nothing but a heavy flower coating. Pizza is still very good and I would definitely recommend. The crust is better than most other pizza places in town. read more

Stopped in Cheyenne on the way to NY with the family and jumped on yelp to find a place to eat. Mr. Jim's had the best reviews of the pizza places that opened late in the area. We were not disappointed, the sticky fingers or supreme pizza was by far the standout. Kids had cheese pizza and it too was very delicious. I recommend this place to anyone and everyone. The guys behind the counter were very nice and polite as well. read more

MrJims.Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cheyenne, Wyoming

I'm very picky when it comes to pizza but I have to say , AWSOME pizza . Ordered on line and delivery was with in time and the pizza is the best I ever had and yes even the ones in Chicago and New York . Thanks read more

Mr Jim's Sticky Fingers Pizza is the best pizza I've ever eaten. If I am asked to bring a snack food for game night, I know I can't miss by bringing a couple of extra large Sticky Fingers Pizza and bread sticks from Mr Jim's. Only problem is it is strictly take-out; no tables or chairs are available, but they do a great job of delivering hot pizza. read more

I love Mr. Jim's Pizza! I think it is the best around and there are many to choose from. Their combinations are unique and toppings are high quality. Their bread is tasty... Recommend the Cinni-sticks!! Thanks for being awesome! read more

I've never had Mr Jims pizza, so I thought I would give it a try, ordered a fajita chicken pizza and a toasted meatball sub, the medium pizza I received was on the smaller side compared to other pizza joints, but I figured maybe it made up for it in taste - opening the box I noticed that I got a pepperoni pizza instead, talked to the driver and he said to call the manager. I read a few other reviews that said they have a habit of getting orders wrong, welp yelpers I'm afraid its true... anyway I was so hungry that I decided to eat what I had, instead of waiting another 35 minutes to possible get another wrong pizza. The first thing I noticed is that the pizza was 30% crust ring, I like crust as much as the next guy, but come on now... Your pizza's are smaller than the competitors to begin with, but you have the nerve to scale back on the ingredients? Not being happy with the pizza, I decided to try the meatball sub, it was toasty as advertised, but I guess there was a shortage of marinara sauce because I sure didn't get any on my sandwich, and the meatballs were packed in the center, I guess it's too difficult to space them out to the ends of the bun... all in all, I would say my first time trying Mr. Jims pizza was not a good experience, I doubt I will ever buy another, just too many better options out there for the same price. read more

They make an excellent carry-out Gluten Free pizza -- arguably the best in town. It is not the cheapest, but I consider it a treat.

Finally a place that sells gluten free pizza! I was so stoked to see this place offered a gluten free option for the crust. So delicious and I can eat it without getting a massive migraine afterwards (always a plus!). It's a little pricey, but well worth it! NOTE: The GF crust is thin and only available in medium. read more

I've used Mr Jim's Pizza twice for large group lunches. They deliver fresh pizza on time. Tried "Sticky fingers" which is similar to the standard combo, Pepperoni, Veggie and cheese. They have a pretty good thin rust too. Would visit again. read more

Just ordered a roasted spinach and pepperoni white sauce pizza - definitely one of the best!!

Definitely the best pizza I've had in Cheyenne. The only negative I have is they left out all of the sauce I purchased and they also didn't put all of the ingredients on one of the pizzas. The crust was good. The sauce was good. All around a really good pizza! read more

So I've ordered two times from this place. The first time I got two large pizzas delivered and they arrived in about 50 minutes. They were mediocre at best and in fact, my pizza eating family had a couple of pieces each and left the rest for the dog. I decided to give them a second shot so we ordered two small pizzas and the fajita salad. The pizzas were not only burnt but the pepperoni has just a few ingredients on it. The cheese and ingredients dont even come all the way out to the crust. The salad was no different than any other salad I've ever bought and frankly was worth half of what I was charged for it. We wont order again.. read more