My daughter and son in law wanted to take me to their favorite pizza place and Italian eatery. Having lived on the east coast, now residing in California, it was a definite plus the owner is from Jersey! Westley was our server, and I cannot say enough kind words about this young gentleman. He was prompt and knowledgeable, and made sure our meal was delivered timely and in excellent order. It is a quiet tucked away osteria well lit and cozy. With Frank Sinatra softly crooning in the background, the staff were all well trained and so enjoyable. The meal was so delicious- we were all well satiated! We did get desserts to share and even ordered pizzas to take home for future meals(they live over an hour away). The pizza counter was packed with take away customers! What a treat! I will definitely make sure to hit this place up every time I visit! read more

See all

The service is incredible, the food is amazing!! Haven't had pizza this good since Europe!! We will definitely be back!

Donovan and Westly work extremely hard and always meet my needs and always kind. They're the best!

We came here for dinner. We went to the Fine Dining portion. It was very good. Our waitress was awesome. I will definitely be going back to check out the relaxed dining! So yummy!! read more

Super awesome Vegan - Sicilian veggie combo with vegan cheese (ask for it!) Equally delicious Vegan Eggplant Parmigiana Sandwich, and love they are eager to accommodate dietary needs of their customers. We have been enjoying their cooking since 2001. The owners are open to expanding their Vegan menu if there are customers interested in it. Pros: The best vegan pizza I've had anywhere., Welcoming and respectful of customers dietary need, Gluten-free options on request. read more

See all

Kind of a tucked away spot and not the easiest place to understand how to order or pay. However, the food was very good and the prices are fair. We did not have to wait, but I could tell others enjoyed the food and service as well. Our food came out quickly and the staff was friendly. read more

L'Osteria Mondello - White broccoli XL - Italian Near Me - Cheyenne, Wyoming

See all

If you're looking for a local and authentic restaurant, this is the place. From the pizza to the pasta, the food was delicioso. The staff was professional, and the ambiance felt relaxed and cozy. We were seated and served quickly with very little wait for a Friday night. Highly recommended. read more

The best Italian restaurant I have eaten at since I left New York! All dinners were wonderful. The service was really intense and caring. 5 STARS !!! Wonderful Italian atmosphere! read more

This is the best Italian food in Cheyenne I have had. Great delicious pizza in the front, best Italian top notch fine dining restaurant in the back. Local and delicious. I wish I could eat here everyday. Ryan was our server tonight he gave us the best service, prompt, funny, and our favorite. Thanks Modello you did it again. Grazie, tutto ottimo. read more

I've had lunch here twice. The first time I had a Stromboli. Not bad, but pretty wet. The second time was a few days before Christmas and the place was packed and our order took about 15 minutes. I had a calzone and it was ok. They only offer it with ham. They forgot one of our side orders so by the time I got it I asked for it to go. The staff was very friendly but I was disappointed to see some of the food being delivered to another customer fall off the plate onto the floor. There was no attempt to clean it up and it got stepped on repeatedly due to the high volume of customers. They were extremely busy but food on the floor in a restaurant is a "no go" for me. I hope to try their fine dining dinner in the future but won't go back for lunch. Ambiance... there is none in the lunch area. read more

Haven't been there for a while. Sunday around 11:30.. nice crowd but when I got my pizza slice it was cold in the top and burned on the bottom. I love a bit overdone but come on at least get the toppings hot. Doubt I'll go back read more

Perfect spot for a casual family meal!" Stopped in with my kids and we were all impressed. The kids each had a slice of pizza, and they devoured it. The crust was crispy, the cheese was melty, and the flavor was on point--classic New York style just like it should be. My partner and I split a Philly cheesesteak sandwich and were seriously impressed. The bread was soft but held together perfectly, and the meat was seasoned just right--not too salty, not too greasy. The peppers and onions were cooked just enough to still have a little bite, and the cheese pulled everything together. Super friendly staff and a chill, welcoming atmosphere. We'll definitely be back--and next time I might not share the sandwich! read more

Honestly, this is my FAVORITE food place in Cheyenne, period!! The pizza is so delicious and the SERVICE is the best!! The owner went out of his way to make us feel welcome and make sure we had everything we needed and more!! We will continue coming here forever!! P.s. We meant to take a picture of the full pie, but we were drooling and dug right in!! read more

L'Osteria Mondello - Garlic knots and marinara - Italian Near Me - Cheyenne, Wyoming

See all

Food is great and the people are awesome. We order pizza here almost every week. Best place in Cheyenne for pizza

We didn't get to dine in since they were booked up and we had our dog, but we were able to eat on the patio. It was super quick and convenient to get a few delicious slices! A slice of Joe's Favorite was my favorite, although I hear Joe actually prefers cheese XD read more

The food was very good. We each had something different and it was fresh and tasty. The meatballs were so good! The staff was very friendly always attentive and accommodating. It had indoor and outdoor seating and was nicely decorated and well priced. It was family friendly but not loud. The owner was attentive and came out several times to greet us and see how everything went. A must in Cheyenne and a staple for us now that we found it!! read more

I grew up in New Jersey eating great NY-style thin crust pizza my entire life. After living in places where peoples' ideas about Pizza involved Domino's and Little Caesars, I found myself living in Laramie, Wyoming and discovered Mondello's in Cheyenne. You can tell by my 5 star rating that Mondello's is the real thing: delicious, cheesy, crispy pizza available by the slice along with an authentic pizzeria menu. They know pizza; they even slice sausages (for pizza topping) the NY/NJ way. I think it's the best "fast food" you can get in Cheyenne. I put fast food in quotes because they make their pies thoughtfully and it's only fast because they can quickly heat up any of their premade pizza. In Jersey we rarely ordered slices with toppings. A slice and a coke meant a cheese slice. You can't eat a Poppa John's pizza (my least favorite McPizza chain) without toppings. Mondello's cheese slices stand on their own with my favorite local NJ pizza joints, and that's saying something. read more

The food is always delicious and hot! After you order the wait is minimal. Dave has done an excellent job of setting the example for his young staff, of what it means to be friendly and helpful. The atmosphere is always pleasant. My wife and I are customers for life! Keep up the great work, Dave and staff! read more

Excellent Italian food and excellent service! The restaurant is clean. Several workers checked up on us, not just our waitress. I will return when I'm back in town. read more

New ownership! Owners have shifted but pizza is the same delicious amazing pie it ever was. Service is fast and friendly. Don't miss out on this gem when in Cheyenne. A slice for lunch! Hometown pizzeria vibes, bistro in the back for romantic dinner. They have gorgeous sandwiches but I can't get past the pizza. I usually get slices but also take home a pie. It's tough not to eat it on the drive home! read more

L'Osteria Mondello - Meat squared - Italian Near Me - Cheyenne, Wyoming

See all

Hands down best pie in town, and excellent Italian fare in the evening! Joe's Favorite and a cheese pie is our go-to!

Wonderful people! Wonderful food! Nice atmosphere! My favorite place in town. Excellent service!

This is the best east coast style pizza I have found in WY- the quality ingredients are evident in the flavors of the sauce / crust / cheese - as far as pizza goes - you cannot miss by going here. I am going to try the restaurant next - I LOVE that they have Veal dishes (Saltimbocca !!!!) read more

Cena deliziosa. We were looking for a dinner spot open this evening and stumbled across this gem. The pizza in the front looked delicious, but we opted for the dining area and were so wonderfully surprised. We started with insalata caprese, which was a bit flat. For dinner, we had the lasagne, meatballs and gnocchi. All were molto bene. We'll definitely visit again. read more

We stopped in for lunch while visiting Cheyenne (from Aurora, Colorado). The pizza was the best... clearly all fresh ingredients and homemade taste. Service was fantastic! There were plenty of customers inside ordering and eating in. The place is bright and clean. The only negative for us is how far away from where we live. But we know where to come on our next trip. read more

The food that we ordered were good! I had a Fettuccine and my husband got a spaghetti with Meatballs. The service is fast too. After we ordered, we got our salad and soup right away. We sit in their outdoor. What I can recommend is they should put some music because all us and the other customers were whispering. Not to get in other people's business/gossips. read more

See all

If you want to impress a date or visiting in-laws take them here! Eat in the solarium with white linen tablecloths... Where to start....let's start with our server..Stephen. Stephen was a gem. Friendly, knowledgeable, attentive without being obsequious. Our party was 3 adults and 2 toddlers. Stephen anticipated our and our toddlers needs and thought to bring out their dinner while we waited for ours, keeping them happy and busy. Brilliant! 3 servers made sure we always had water, bread and dipping sauces without being intrusive. Now the stars of the show...the food...we had the eggplant rolotini to start and I could have happily made a meal of that. Just a little hint of the delicious meals to come. Each of our dinners was exactly what we hoped they would be and im drooling just remembering them....and espresso, limoncello, tiramsu and limoncello cake for dessert. I have not had a meal and service of that excellent quality in a very long time and I am looking forward going again! We also were gifted some red sauce and pizza dough to take home I leave my home, with an ocean view, on the amazing central coast of Oregon, to go to Cheyenne to visit my grandsons...now it's the grandkids and Mondello! (oh yeah...the pizza is also awesome ) Guess I could've saved alot of words and said: "Excellent! 5 stars Just go!" read more

My husband is a bit of a pizza snob and while I rated this restaurant higher than him, we both left satisfied and agreed we would visit again. Pizza can be ordered by the slice or you can get a small, medium, or large. The ingredients were fresh and the toppings were very generous. The crust was crisp but not overcooked and had a good flavor. The staff was incredibly kind and attentive. Pizza is only available at the front of the restaurant and the back is for "fine dining." You cannot order pizza in the fine dining side. The pizzeria side was bright and clean. Frank Sinatra was the soundtrack that added to the ambiance. Overall, we would recommend you give this restaurant a try if you are looking for a decent pie! read more

Fresh food, wonderful service, always good! New owners are ROCKIN' IT!! The pizza is great, and the ristorante is such a treat! Not a stuffy place! From the signature fresh baked individual bread loaves (Yum) to the entrees (linguine and clams!) to the wine selection, dessert options and the ambiance, it's just so much fun to have a meal there! We took a 4 and a 5 year old with us and they had a great time too. Fun to watch the greenway action. read more

Best pizza in cheyeene! Love it. Very clean. Good prices. Owner is very friendly service is fast. Menu variety is great.

"The food here is delicious! Every dish we tried was bursting with flavor and cooked to perfection. "Hands down, some of the best Italian food I've had recently! The service was amazing! The ambiance is super nice. My new favorite place! Thank you l'Osteria Mondello for a wonderful evening! I can't wait to come back! read more

Was never aware they had a "Fine Dining" section, so my wife and I went with my brother and his wife. We were seated quickly, bread was prom served along with a pesto type sauce, appetizer order taken and about 20 minutes later our dinner orders. We got our appetizers, stuffed mushrooms and artichoke dip, and shortly after we got our salad. That was the ending of our dining experience. The waiter had chosen to stop visiting our table, stop checking on our order, and simply ignore us. My wife was finally able to get his attention and he reluctantly came over. We asked if he had forgotten us? No! He claimed. He was held up by his boss he explained. We asked about the status of our order. "You haven't gotten your food?" He asked. Nope. Then he claimed a large group in a secluded room was causing a backup in the kitchen. We checked, it was 6 people In the group. We waited over an hour after we received our appetizers!! More than one hour waiting on our dinners. Needless to say, we wont be visiting again. read more

Have been eating this pizza since Joe in the 90's at the mall. The new Mondellos is still better than Pappa, domino's, Murphys. I don't think the new owner has kept the NY style. However its still better and more authentic than anywhere else. read more

I have only been to the lunch/pizzeria side. I plan on trying the dinner experience in the future. The main guy who I assume is the owner is so funny and loved by all. The pizza is amazing and the vibe is casual/relaxed. 10/10 recommend. read more

L'Osteria Mondello - Lunch menu - Italian Near Me - Cheyenne, Wyoming

Always delicious food, friendly atmosphere and great service! Highly recommend! The owners are fantastic. read more

Best place in town for pizza and fine dining! The new owner will go out of his way to make sure you leave satisfied and happy!!

Food is top tier and the owner is very nice/hospitable. Loved our experience here will definitely be back for more:)

New management and they haven't missed a beat from when Joe was running the place. Best pizza and pepperoni rolls around. We recently went and tried the newly re-opened restaurant in the rear or the building and the food was fantastic!! Glad they rebounded from that stupid pandemic! read more

Love this place. Always excellent friendly service. I really love the pizza! Very clean restaurant and outdoor seating. "Fine dining" is opening up soon. Great space for work and family gatherings when it does open up! Also has walk up window. read more

L'Osteria Mondello - Veggie Chicago style in the foreground. New York style cheese pizza in the background. - Italian Near Me - Cheyenne, Wyoming

This has become my Italian dining home. The menu is fantastic, the specials are out of this world I've made it my mission to have everything on their menu. The better part? Their staff is awesome (Steven is great), and Marie. Fairly new, does her absolute best, and is genuinely pleasant. She can be my server anytime. read more