Finally stopped in here after passing it so many times. I've been trying to find a solid cheesesteak spot, so my partner and I ordered the El Niño and the Fat Jay and split both. El Niño was easily my favorite. There is a spice to it (as it described), good portion, and the bread held up really well. Everything just worked together. Fat Jay was completely different. Stuffed with tenders, mozz sticks, cheesesteak, a lot going on but still really good. Definitely heavier type sandwich. Had me stuffed. Overall both were solid. They gave me a BOGO card, so I'll definitely be back to try more. Service was quick. Kitchen is open spaced and seems clean. read more

See all

Stopped by with my teen son for a quick bite because he said the place was good. Nice and clean, clear menu, friendly workers, and most importantly, their sub was quite good. I had the Italian and enjoyed the meat-to-sandwich ratio. They had hot pepper relish too which is always a plus for a sub shop. They understood the assignment! Will be back again. read more

Mr Subs - #8 Italian - Sandwiches Near Me - East Brunswick, New Jersey

See all

Saved me a trip to Philly for a cheesesteak hero. Very good and local Clean fast I highly recommend trying

Came here today for the $3 8-inch sub deal from 11 am-2 pm and I definitely found my new go-to! The service was so fast, I was home before my work meeting, and the sandwich was fresh and so delicious! I ordered the honey turkey, "our way", with honey mustard and pickles and it was perfect! It's a small spot so I think it is just best to do takeout but it's the perfect sandwich shop and I'm so happy I stopped by! Great deal as well :). Thank you!! read more

Mr Subs - Hot 8in #7 Honey Turkey - Sandwiches Near Me - East Brunswick, New Jersey

See all

Get the white roll for hot sub (cheesesteaks) Get the seeded roll for cold subs 2 pepper relish is good read more

I can't say enough good things about Mr. Subs. My nephew used to work here, and when he recently passed away, they went above and beyond by generously donating food for his memorial service. Their kindness, generosity, and community spirit during such a difficult time meant the world to our family. Beyond having wonderful food, they truly care about their people and community. Thank you from the bottom of our hearts. A special thanks to manager Rich and Izza for authorizing and executing a delicious spread. read more

Amazing food ! Great location on the corner Nice setup Sandwich was perfect Made just how I wanted it Fries were crisp Yeddie read more

Their subs are bland and so plain as their staff, boring. I gave them a try and I was left with less money in my pocket and a real desire for a decent sandwich. read more

I just wasted 30 bucks bc I ordered a chicken cutlet(chicken fingers) sub and order of chicken fingers and to my surprise the cutlet sandwhich is the garbage fake ass chicken fingers that establishments pawn off bc they want to charge us more but sell us cheaper stuff so I didn't mind ur cheesesteaks and cold cuts but now I'm done with you. I'm tired of the customer always getting screwed and their are still some establishments that remember that. The chicken finger bandit signing off. read more

Cannot speak for the physical location but we have ordered delivery each time and the subs are always great. Always a good amount of meat and toppings, fresh breads and super thin shredded lettuce. read more

The picture on Yelp has normal meat portion. The one I received had 1-2 slice of meat. I won't be coming back to this location.

Delicious sandwiches in a world of basic lunch meat sandwiches from their bread to their meats delicious. The Chocolate chip cookies aint cheap but they're delicious after a nice cold sub. Eager to try one of the hot or fat sandwiches one day soon read more

it's fine - but i prefer riddle & martin, but they're fine. good location - but probably wouldn't go again unless there's bogo.

It was so refreshing to go into a shop that's clean and the staff is friendly and you know they appreciate your business. I have found in other sub shores that you need microscope to see the meat including the famous shop in Edison. Mr. sub is the exception! I could see and taste the meat Instead of lettuce and vinegar. Pricing is comparable to other sub shops. I'm so glad I can go to East Brunswick to get a good sub just like the ones I used to drive to Mr. Sub in Union for. You won't be disappointed! read more

From you guys Below are photos of my receipt, the sandwiches we got are like half the size of any other sub place I've ever been to in my life. read more

Mr Subs - Receipt - Sandwiches Near Me - East Brunswick, New Jersey

See all

Not really any better or different from any chain sandwich spot (which I normally stay away from), but it's close by and I figured I'd give it a shot...I got a "Super Sub" w the works, added hot relish and extra meat/cheese (additional charge of course), pretty good sandwich, bread is nothing special at all, the hot relish is outta this world and you really don't get much extra meat or cheese for the additional charge. My wife got an Italian sub wo extra meat/chs and there were maybe 2 slices of meat and 1 slice of cheese more on mine. That being said, it's still not a bad spot at all, VERY clean/organized inside and the guys who work there are nice. Probably wouldn't go back, but def not a bad choice if you want something quick and you're on 18 already. read more

Mr Subs - 1/2 Super Sub w the works, hot relish and "extra meat/cheese" - Sandwiches Near Me - East Brunswick, New Jersey

I went into the shop to ask about their buy one get one special that I saw a sign for last week. I figured that the sign was down because of the bad weather last night. Well, when I asked if the special was still going on, the man behind the counter told me to "get the f**k out his shop" Definitely my first and last time visiting Mr. Subs EB read more

Mr Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - East Brunswick, New Jersey

the buffalo chicken sub was so good! everyone was very friendly! loved the chipotle mayo! we will definitely be back

These were actually surprisingly good. The full sub is huge, turkey was fresh, mayo tasted good.. no complaints with that one. The oil and vin made the bread on the other sandwich mushy quick, so eat fast. I'd compared these to tastee. It's not an Italian salumeria with the best quality meat the world has to offer, but it's world's better than subway and jimmy johns. read more

The food is great. The service is excellent and friendly. The food was made perfectly. I recommend Mr. Subs.

Amazing sandwiches, clean,great service !!! Definitely will come back !!! The guys there are super family oriented!!! read more

Mr Subs - #16in #12 Ham Salami & Cheese... - Sandwiches Near Me - East Brunswick, New Jersey

Went to the store today after driving 30 minutes rushing to beat the 8PM closing time on Google and showed up at 7PM to a hand drawn sign out front saying: "Closing early at 6:30PM". Way to update it anywhere except the front door when I get there. read more

Good and fresh subs. Highly recommend you try it if you're on the fence about going here. Get the Italian with everything on it, mayo and oil vinegar. read more

Best sub in town for so many reasons. Bread is fresh, the subs are plentiful, but the best part is the service. Ii highly recommend the Italian sub. read more

Sad to downgrade this place, but the subs have gone downhill. The last 3 times we ordered there was Barely any meat and the thinnest, solitary piece of cheese on the sandwich... you can't even taste it. It's a shame because this shop was really good. It's like subway now. There are just too many good options in the area to keep coming here. 2 stars because our online orders are always correct and ready on time and the staff has always been nice. But I doubt we will be back read more

A negative review doesn't MEAN anything if you don't have supporting facts. One person wrote, "Meat is slimy" Now, how can the meat BE slimy if they slice it to serve. ??? It is quite apparent these negative .....people feel the need to spew ugly from their mouthes for reasons other then this sites intended purpose. I'm born and raised Jersey. We all have our favorites. This shop not only stands fine alone, but can run with the top sub shops. Freshly baked bread. A fine array of vegetables and accompaniments and the highest quality of very well know meats. Its located on the south side of Rt. 18 which is great for the commuters drive home. Welcome to the neighborhood!! read more

Great subs every time, and the staff are incredibly generous when you ask for more of a topping. They had the speaker on and it was just good vibes & good food! read more

Overpriced and small sandwiches I got a cheesesteak for $10 almost and it's the size of my palm that's insane and a hardcore ripoff read more

See all

If you can't make something, don't put it on the menu. This is a cheesesteak??? That resembles the nasty patty bro... I go in after making an online order and sit there confused af tryna make eye contact w someone working. Everyone avoided my eyes even the guy at register doing nothing. So confused af I had to yell CAN I PICK UP to get even noticed for existing lol. Seemed like their first day or something was really annoying and not gonna last like this. Didn't seem too busy. Guys: jersey mikes is already here and way better than this im so sorry to say.... But so is wawa.... read more

Mr Subs - The supposed cheesesteak - Sandwiches Near Me - East Brunswick, New Jersey

All the subs were fresh and sliced on the spot. A staff was freshly chopping onions when we walked in, so nothing was stale or sitting out too long. I loved the thinly sliced meats and the soft breads. I got the oven gold turkey and Italian and they were both awesome. The fries were better than boardwalk fries. It was perfectly fried and perfectly seasoned. The wings reminded me of my favorite childhood pizza joint wings, so of course I liked them. However I tasted the Buffalo sauce on its own - OMG! I could of drank it in a cup. So good. Service was amazing, everyone was friendly and helpful. The place is clean and organized. It's easy to miss when your driving by, hopefully they put up a more eye catching sign. Looking forward to going back to try out other items. Also the staff followed covid procedures and had they're masks on the whole time. No below the nose bs. Support small businesses in your local communities :) read more

See all

Great service. Best subs around. The bread is outstanding. The meats and salads are the best. Never disappoints.

Flew into Jersey to visit my son and friends. Customer service was great! Sandwiches were very fresh and filling for hungry college students. When in town I will eat here again and feed the family. read more

Had to take the time to rate this place since they took the time to do right by the customer!! I'm a repeat customer, and had a rather large sub order ($75/4 whole subs) this time. When I called the order in, I started it by stating that all 4 were to be on whole wheat, and scooped out (my usual rqst, which is not an issue). I pick up the subs and just figured I'd ask/confirm they were scooped out, and was told they weren't. Needless to say I was angry!! But still took my order home, as everyone was waiting and I didn't have time for them to remake it. Fast forward to today, the day after I was there......they actually called me, and offered to make right by comping my next visit!!! The reason for this post is simple.....everyone is quick to bash a small business for doing the wrong thing, so I had to take the time and highlight a small business for going above and beyond in customer service!! Kudos to mngt, as this simple gesture makes me a continued loyal customer!! read more

Very very tastey sub sandwiches. I got the 8 inch turkey with roast beef & provolone ..it was delicious! I also bought a pastrami on ríe and mannn yum! I would have taken a picture to add to the post but the food was gone before I even thought to write this review lol ..if youre in The area hit this place up and you won't be disappointed. read more

UPDATE: I was in today and the slicer was all clean with no issues there. They even gave me a free sub for my experience last time. I'll definitely be back next time I want a sub! read more

Subs were great as was service. Only problem is going in and out of parking lot. Place was very clean and order was ready. They also give credit points toward new orders! read more

Just happened to drive by and spotted this new opening. Decided to give it a try. It was clean and fresh look inside, not like a deli sandwich shop. Although the staff was still new, they were friendly and answer the best they could. I ordered the Italian and wifey had the Oven Turkey. We also ordered fries and had comp. wings. The sandwichs are on point, bread is like Tastee's and old school Blimpie, which I like more than other breads. The meats are sliced thin, probably their style. Probably would have liked more meat to get the taste more or maybe a little lesss veggies but overall, good sandwich, def better than "JM" a few minutes aways. The fries are banging!!!, maybe cuz I love salt but it was nicely salted broadwalk fries. The wings reminded us of Crown Fried Chicken wings, which is a good thing. We love our neighborhood wings. Would def go back since it's close to us as well. Park, manager/owner, was very nice to talk to, which gave it a better experience. read more

10/10 subs. better than jersey mikes, subway, any of them you name it. if you want quality and good tasting subs, come to mr subs.

My boss and I got a tuna sandwich as well as one of their classic Italians and it was delicious! Great quality ingredients and we were both surprised at how big the half sandwiches were. We will definitely be back and are happy it's within walking distance from where we work! read more

GOOD STUFF! Stopped by for the first time today for lunch. Got the super sub. Meat was sliced perfectly thin, as well as the lettuce. Shredded lettuce is so important. Bread was also perfect for an Italian sub. Glad to have a great new sub shop right by home. read more