I totally understand why Big Wally's is such a hit in Sayreville. I started visiting recently and I usually order the #9 club sub or the California chicken club -- both are very good. The bacon on their sandwiches is always crispy and they do a good job with the chicken cutlet. Their subs are HUGE and they pack on the meat. The menu also has a huge variety of options. Big Wally's easily beats out any chain for subs. This is a perfect spot for takeout since the inside is fairly small. Every time I've visited, my subs were ready within the time they stated over the phone. This is definitely my favorite sub shop. read more

Love this place. Best sandwiches. I always get the pork roll egg and cheese. Always the same quality and delicious. My husband tries different things each time. Always great ingredients and taste. This is an always must go when we are visiting in town. The only take cash Only do pick up read more

Want a sub? Make your way over to Big Wally's! Mom and pop shop with a variety of subs that are sure to please meat lovers and vegetarians alike. We usually order ahead, particularly on weekends when we know it will be busy, and go to pick it up in store. We recommend the #5 Italian half sub with the works (oil, vinegar, lettuce, tomato, onion) or the Massimo (veggie) sub! Note, cash only so make sure you come prepared! read more

Big Wally's Subs - #5 Italian - Sandwiches Near Me - Parlin, New Jersey

See all

Big sandwiches One of my favorite places Everything fresh and delicious you won't be disappointed read more

Still great after all these years. This is my favorite spot for sandwiches. I visit this spot whenever I visit home to get my fill of Italian subs. I usually get classic cold Italian sandwiches but I have also had their hot subs. They have a huge menu of subs with some very creative options. They only have one sit in counter. Since COVID, they pretty much converted it to a take out operation. This is cash only. They are kinda "soup-nazi" (from Seinfield) like when there is a long line; you better know what you want to keep the line moving. The guys are pretty nice otherwise. read more

I found this Gem of a Mom and Pop shop today while visiting my uncle. My family wanted to go somewhere else but I offered to pay so I won. Figuratively and literally. The owner's were friendly which is always a plus! I live in Los Angeles and drove up from Maryland and would do it again! Great food, great prices and great staff. THANKS GUYS read more

Excellent sandwiches. Our favorite go to! Fresh Bread and made to order. Oven Roasted turkey is my go to.

I love a good "fat" sandwich. My fiancé found this place after some googling/yelping and I knew we had to go. We had the superkick and birdman sanders. Both were so good. Huge portions for a great price. He ordered on the spot and it was less than a 20 minute wait. The menu is HUGE. There's something for everyone. I wish we lived closer because there so many sandwiches I want to try. One important note, this place is cash only. read more

Stopped by this place on the way down the Jersey shore. This sub shop offers a wide variety of sandwiches at a very good price point. The staff is friendly and service is quick. This place is cash only and there is no dining area. I highly recommend the lumberjack with pepper relish. So good! read more

Big Wally's Subs - Lumberjack - Sandwiches Near Me - Parlin, New Jersey

If you're in the area this is a must try sandwich shop! The Brahma Bull is very good as well as the macaroni salad, can get the sandwich's as a platter which is nice. No indoor seating so you're taking it to go! The people working are very friendly and will help with the big menu! CASH ONLY! read more

Awesome little sub shop! First time going here but it definitely seems like it's a staple in town! Small spot with a lot to choose from. There's no seating inside and it's cash only but the amount of special sandwich options they have are endless. You get a lot of food for a really good price too, I got a half of a linsanity which is a grilled chicken sub with bacon and a drink for $10. So much flavor in the chicken and great size sub. The lettuce, tomato & onion on it also seemed very fresh. Quick service too, I walked in and placed my order that was for a grilled chicken (not a deli meat sub you can pump out quick) and it was ready in a few minutes. They also have homemade noodle salad, potato salad and coleslaw as well as homemade desserts like brownies and banana bread. Super friendly employees, definitely would recommend stopping in for a sub or grabbing a bunch of food for a party or day at the beach. read more

See all

Subs are always delicious no matter which you order, the service is great. The time waiting is usually 20-25, on the longer side for 3+ sandwiches. Neatly packed. I don't really carry around cash that much but this place is so good its worth stopping by the bank before. I recommend calling ahead of time, its what most people do. I only docked for atmosphere because you cant eat inside realistically, its just 3-4 seats and its a very small area. Definitely a take out spot. read more

Easily the best sandwich shop in town. If you visit make sure to try either The King or The Buffalo Shemanheimer. Both are seriously delicious. Edit: I'm back, & this is also the best RUBEN in town. Like how they make theirs is ridiculously good. I always order mine with pickle & provolone & it's just ... read more

See all

I've lived in the area for many years and I've never heard of Big Wally's until I saw it featured as the #1 sandwich place in the country in an online article - I don't remember which one it was, but I knew I had to come check it out. My first experience lived up to the hype! Two things that stand out are the extremely extensive menu with every combination imaginable, and the fact that it's cash only. Bring cash, there is no ATM. The number of options on the menu is amazing, but it left me with choice paralysis! I wanted to try one of everything but eventually settled on the Birdman. Chicken cheesesteak, pork roll, pepperjack cheese, peppers, onions, and honey mustard. It was so, so good, lots of great flavors! Plenty of honey mustard but not too much so it didn't get soggy. It was busy on a Friday lunch hour but my food came out in ten minutes. The staff was friendly and had a certain old school Jersey charm. The price as very reasonable, too, 9 bucks even. I'll definitely be coming back to try more. read more

Big Wally's Subs - Birdman Sanders - Sandwiches Near Me - Parlin, New Jersey

This is a very old school sub shop. Seems like it's been around a long time. The sub was very good.

Wow wow wee wa(lly). This is good stuff. Picked up two wraps after Liquid Sayreville service which is right down the road. Cash only establishment and greeted by one of the employees stocking the fridges as I explored the massive menu. luckily I had just enough in my pocket for two wraps to take home. I forgot the names of the wraps, but I got one with beef and one with chicken and I was very happy with how saucy these wraps were! Overall, very filling, tasty and already craving the next time I can come back and try their actual sandwiches. I'm eyeing the Tombstone already. Give Wally's a visit if you're in the area, really nice people inside and amazing food. read more

Extensive menu with anything you can imagine on a sub. Fast service, but know what you want. Maybe do some research or have a specific craving before you come. Come with cash. read more

Big Wally's was an interesting experience. There are so many subs to choose from! My husband got the Buffalo Sheneineheimer and I got the Appetizer. We saw the great reviews so wanted to visit. The reason for the 3 stars is as follows: the bread is the type of cheap bread you get from an Italian take out place. When you use bad bread for sandwiches, it ruins the whole taste. In my sub, it was grilled chicken, prosciutto, Asiago cheese, and roasted peppers on garlic bread. After the great reviews, I was very excited for this sandwich. However, I was disappointed. The grilled chicken and prosciutto were chopped up and mixed together in the sandwich. I was expecting nice chicken cutlets and slices of prosciutto. Very disappointed. Also, you could barely taste the garlic bread. As for my husband's sub, he enjoyed it. But it did taste like cheap chicken meat in a saucy blue cheese. Probably skip this place next time. read more

Big Wally's Subs - Hot sub menu - Sandwiches Near Me - Parlin, New Jersey

Always fresh always full and glad they are located next to my cloths house. Will definitely be coming back. Even their Brenda's m breakfast sandwiches are good read more

See all

THE BEST HERO's! Overstuffed and delicious! Get them whenever I visit my son in Parlin, sometimes I lie and make the trip to Parlin just for BIG WALLY's. read more

Big Wally's subs.., beware they are humongous, incredibly delicious what a gem of a place. Cash only establishment so come prepared! Service could've been a little faster but everyone was hustle and bustling. read more

Because of Big Wallys I can never go to another sub shop. It's too good. I grew up in the neighborhood across from this family owned business and I never had a bad experience! During this time, they closed the inside of their store and are now bringing orders to your car so make sure you call your order ahead! My order took about 25 minutes. I've had quite a few subs from their menu, here are a few of my favs: - club sub (with provolone. Can't go wrong with a classic) - juicy lucy - poore boy - grilled chicken pesto (or prince pesto with eggplant) Try something different than your typical ham & cheese at this place. You won't regret it! Any sandwich is great with hot sauce. And the bread is always soft and fresh. They have plenty of unique add ons like .75 brownies, salads, chips or sodas to choose from. The options are displayed in their window. Enjoy! read more

Big Wally's Subs - To go order - Sandwiches Near Me - Parlin, New Jersey

See all

Why have I not tried this place earlier?! It's amazing, has the most delicious subs, good portions, and priced well. I'm addicted to their veggie subs and would not change anything about it. I can't wait to be back again. read more

Amazing sandwiches. So filling and big. Tasty. Will continue to come back. Cash only.

Great Sammy joint. Easy to order and quick pick up. The meats were fresh and thinly sliced to perfection. Had the Big Wally and it didn't disappoint. Would love to try something else next time. read more

Big Wally's Subs - The Big Wally, w/ hot & sweets and pickles - Sandwiches Near Me - Parlin, New Jersey

Always liked this place . 1st customer ahead of me asked about an ATM and almost got his head taken off by the brunette italian gatekeeper of this place. 2nd I ordered RB and fresh Mozz on RYE and got home and no cheese at all all WTF ? 3rd ordered 2 Soups and they ran out. Place is going down hill in my book besides the RB on rye was much lighter than the usual. Will give this place 1 more try then Dump them . read more

Great local sub shop. Delicious and unique subs to choose from. Plenty of quality meat & cheese sliced nice and thin. Call ahead to order and save time. Gets very busy at lunchtime and on weekends. Plenty of parking. read more

Big Wally's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Parlin, New Jersey

Looking for a sandwich shop in town and came up with Big Wally's... A friend who lives local highly recommended this place. It's a little awkward to say the least. Here's the deal. It's probably helpful if you're been to this sub shop before. But I haven't been living in town all that long. Anyways, you're not allowed in these days so just grab a menu , place your order and wait in your car. They'll bring it right over pretty quick ( less than 10 minutes) today. For takeout sammies ordered up two for lunch. They were MC Hammer for me, hot with London broil, mutz, pesto sauce on garlic bread on an 16 inch hero. So good, only could finish half . For the Mrs., a cold wrap called a Russian. This had roast beef, Munster cheese, cold slaw,lettuce, tomato, onion and thousand island dressing. Leftovers on her end, yet again. She mentioned that it was very good and looking forward to finishing it up tomorrow. That's rarely happens. She'll usually let me have a taste. Not this time. They are a cash only business and the parking lot was pretty crowded, so try to call first or have a menu handy. Glad to see this place thriving, even in these uncertain times. read more

See all

Absolutely delicious, good prices, huge portions, fast and friendly service. They have a parking lot, so it's easy to pull in and grab your order. read more

Big Wally's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Parlin, New Jersey

See all

Ordered wraps for parties twice, I'll be going back again! Tried the breakfast sandwich (pork roll egg and cheese) YUMMY

I love sandwiches so when my family said Big Wally's had some great subs and sandwiches, I was all in to try them out! I ordered a chicken cheesesteak and tried a veggie sub as well. Both were perfect! I wouldn't change a thing about either sandwich and I wish I lived closer so that I could be a frequent customer! read more

I Awesome food and service love this place just wish they took anything other than cash read more

They have good bread. Great service. Small place and even smaller after the covid setup. Bring cash. They have great combo sandwiches which I'm still trying to taste each one. This place closes after they sold out of bread. It's that good. read more

Ugh I was so disappointed in the cheesesteak today. Normally this place is 5 stars all day. Maybe they were having an off day. I'm sure they will redeem themselves. Everything else was amazing as always. read more

Big Wally's Subs - Cheesesteak was a miss today. - Sandwiches Near Me - Parlin, New Jersey

A great sub shop with a lot of varieties of combinations. This is a good example of what good New Jersey sub shop looks like.

A staple of Sayreville for as long as I can remember. The goat of subs. Consistency every time!

Another local sandwich place with a gigantic menu.sandwiches are good. People who own the place as well as the workers are nice. Give it a try,I think you will enjoy.only downside is cash only read more

The food here is always super fresh and never not made the way you want it. Due to the awesome customer service and small town feel. I will always go here when in the mood for a sub. read more

Great subs. We ordered a massive amount of food for a family of 12. I'm always afraid with such a large order something will undoubtedly go wrong. Not this time. All the subs include the pastrami reuben, italian, philly cheesesteak among others were made as ordered. We ordered take out via phone and the time they promised to pick up was precise. read more

Make great subs. Hours are a problem. Cash only not a BIG problem, but sometimes it can be..... No more booths. To go only. Store is clean though. read more