Went here Sunday after 8 pm for dinner. Basically empty inside, so we decided to dine in since it seemed like we had a decent amount of time before they closed. Staff were friendly and helpful while ordering. Food took a good while to come out; by the time it did, we took a few bites then had to pack it up since they were now beginning to closing. To eat: I decided to try their baked ziti (7/10) I felt like the portion was a little small for them to be an Italian/pizza place and it could've been more seasoned. Also got a side salad (5/10) nothing special and even after repeating what I wanted in the salad while ordering, it still didn't come out correct. Also tried a slice of cheesecake. I was really looking forward to a good hot dinner; unfortunately, I wasn't impressed at all. My overall rate of experience : 5.5/10 read more

See all

Philly Cheesesteak is terrible, do not order here, one of the worst I have ever tasted, did eat half boxed the other half up, will see if the dog will eat it. I did have the spaghetti with meatballs last week, that meal was pretty good. Would try the Italian dishes again. Workers are friendly, some of the seating needs recovering. read more

I visited Mr. G's Pizza on April 7, 2026, and had an excellent experience, which is the ONLY reason I returned on April 8 around 11:30 AM. I am vegan, and on my first visit the staff was incredibly kind, patient, and accommodating. They took the time to make my salad exactly as requested (lettuce, black olives, green olives, cucumbers, and banana peppers only), ensured there was no cross-contamination, and even helped me choose a dressing I could safely have. I truly appreciated that level of care, especially since it can be difficult to find vegan-friendly options. That experience was a 5-star. Unfortunately, my experience the very next day was completely different. From the beginning, the service felt dismissive. I clearly explained my order multiple times and emphasized my dietary restrictions. Despite that, the food that was brought out was completely incorrect and included items I specifically said I could not eat, including cheese. When I calmly addressed the mistake, I was met with a rude and dismissive attitude. Instead of correcting the issue, the staff insisted I ordered something I did not. I have been vegan for over 20 years, so I am very clear and intentional about what I order. What made the situation worse was the lack of professionalism and transparency. I repeatedly asked to speak with a manager, but no one would clearly identify who the manager was. I was told the owner was "busy" and unavailable. It was later revealed that the person who had been speaking to me in a rude and unprofessional manner the entire time was actually the manager. Additionally, the owner never came out to address the situation, attempt to resolve the issue, or show any concern for how I was treated. That level of disregard for a customer experience is extremely disappointing. At that point, I no longer felt comfortable having my food remade and requested a refund, which was given. However, the experience itself was stressful, disrespectful, and completely inconsistent with the level of service I received the day before. It's unfortunate, because this location clearly has the ability to provide excellent service -- I experienced it firsthand. However, the behavior of management and lack of accountability made this a 1-star experience, and I would not return. The difference in treatment from one day to the next was shocking. Consistency and leadership matter, and unfortunately, that was missing here. read more

Service was good. Food so so. Salad was a bowl of lettuce with a plum tomato & 2 croutons. Garlic bread was a roll. Spaghetti had good flavor. Pizza was ok read more

We got the large deluxe, it was delicious and more than enough for 2 to 3 people. Large seating area and seems to have a steady flow of dine in and takeouts. The facilities them self could use updating. Probably would do the takeout option next time. read more

A pretty good Italian style restaurant in Demopolis was a unique find. You order at the counter and they call you back to the counter to get your food when it's ready. For the price, my meal was good and the next time I'm in the area I'll stop by again. read more

Mr G's Pizza - Lasagna, salad and garlic bread - Pizza Near Me - Demopolis, Alabama

The pizza we got was delicious and hit the spot. We tried this place while we were camping in Demopolis and I'm glad we did.

Service quick. Old favorites. Hot roast beef is good. Alfredo is as well.not much on ambience.

I love everything they cook. I have been going for years . Place is clean nice waitress

The spaghetti deal is really good and so is the key lime pie. Anxious to try the pizza.

Sadly a terrible terrible place to stop for food. Service wasn't polite at all and the food was a joke for 18$. Small portion and very poor quality food. I don't recommend the Ziti and my friend couldn't eat his turkey sandwich. read more

I went into the restaurant Saturday night December 7th and ordered food to go. I ordered food to go the white lady mgr/ owner waited on me. I ordered Lasagna with a salad which was extra and a Ham and Cheese sandwich with extra thousand island dressing. I let the lady read my text. When they called my to go order number I went to the counter to pick it up. I got back to my hotel room and pulled out the food that I had ordered. My wife in the text that the manager had read her thousand island dressing wasn't in the bag. I ordered a Lasagna with a salad. I didn't have a salad in my bag. Now the manager supposedly checked my bag. My wife's sandwich is good. Remember I had ordered a salad well my thousand island dressing was in the bag but I had no salad so I gave the salad dressing to my wife. The Lasagna was good. I just don't know why I should have to check the order when the manager was supposedly doing that. read more

I don't know why there's so many good reviews on this restaurant this restaurant is so bad the pizza legit looks like no one had no care for what they through out to the server and was like bon Appétit They get what they get I swear I ate a meat lovers pizza on a date with my girlfriend and this pizza is so gross looking im surprised I bit into it was like nothing but disappointment the most greases pizza I've ever ate got are order wrong and we only specified no ham on the pizza thats its not other changes not hard and put it on there extra heavy, the wings though quite nice not gonna lie but could've maybe marinated the wings with there sauce just a tad more maybe but other wise pretty good anyways won't be coming here again please the dough legit looks not even finished I know I'm servesafe certified please don't come gs cant even cook a pizza. Most of these high reviews have to be false and are previous owners of the building trying to boost the restaurant read more

Mr G's Pizza - Pretty dang good! - Pizza Near Me - Demopolis, Alabama

See all

Very good food I recommend was kind of quiet though. I got the Tuesday Special large portions great price

The place doesn't look like much. But it is a hidden gem. Stopped by for the first time tonight. The ziti was very good. And pizza was good as well. Will be coming back. read more

Mr G's Pizza - Baked ziti Was very good. Will be coming back for sure. - Pizza Near Me - Demopolis, Alabama

Great food I must say! We had the Lasagna lunch special and pleasantly surprised! Being from here and remembering the original Mr G's many years ago, both were/are great places to eat! Note Mr G's is now at a different location, as the original place is gone. But then I am talking 1974. My only complaint was the server when ordering. Perhaps be a little more friendly and customer oriented. One line statements like "help you" "your number is" or my favorite "got it" Maybe a HI and or "may I help you" or please let us know when you are ready Again, the food was great! but service not so much. We were there on Sunday! read more

This is going to be a very biased review. I live in Virginia currently, but I am originally from Demopolis. My Mom worked at Mr. G's when she was pregnant with me- so I've been eating Mr. G's since I was in the womb. My friend and I joke that, if something was ever to happen to G's, the city would get government funding to expedite the rebuilding process. Actually, when the original burned down- it took only a handful of months for them to rebuild on HWY 80. It's quick and greasy Italian, but this is clearly my favorite restaurant ever. True comfort Italian- Alabama style. The Po-Boy is great. The ham and cheese is better. My friends in Harrisonburg, VA swear the salads are the best they've ever had (turkey and cheese is my particular favorite). The holy grail of this place would have to be the lasagna (that comes with a small loaf of garlic bread and a salad.) My Mom would kill me if I didn't include the roast beef as one of the best items on the menu. The pizzas are good (BBQ tends to be a favorite), but they are the type of pizza that- if you take a bite, the cheese will slide off of the entire slice and slap you in the chin (which is all fine and good if you like cheese). If you go to Mr. G's, you might as well buy a case of their ranch dressing- it's the best you'll have. Growing up, we bought extra cups and would dip whatever we could find in it. Also, you have GOT to get the sweet tea. It's teeth-rotting comfort and is the pinnacle of true southern sweet tea. Don't miss it- it's cheap and there are no servers. I've loved Mr. G's since I was knee-high to a toad frog and still have cravings. read more

Mr G's Pizza - a plate of lasagna and a roll - Pizza Near Me - Demopolis, Alabama

Walked in @7:40 tonight. Sat right in front of waiter/waitress station. Listened to associates talk about going home for 15 minutes. Never acknowledged my presence. At 7:56 since home was topic of the night decided I'd go there myself....hungry. read more

It was ok for a quick lunch. Pizza here is good but the Bar-B-Que baked potato was not what I expected. I want to get or be able to get butter, sour cream, and sauce without a surcharge. People were very nice. read more

Mr G's Pizza - Got the Bar-B-Que baked potato. It doesn't come with sour cream but you can buy it from them for a little more than $.30 a small packet. - Pizza Near Me - Demopolis, Alabama

Love Mr. G's! My favorites are the Lasagna, Beef Cannelloni/Cheese Manicotti, and the Turkey Bacon Salad! YUMMY! Very polite cashiers and the restaurant is always clean. read more

Whenever I'm craving for a great salad I always stop by Mr. G's grilled chicken and bacon with cheese salad read more

Mr G's Pizza - a salad in a plastic container - Pizza Near Me - Demopolis, Alabama

OK guys how on earth has this been rated so high? We stopped in for dinner on a Sunday. I got the lasagna and my hubby the baked ziti. The lasagna was swimming in sauce and really over boiled. The noodles should be aldente ...and there was minimal if any ricotta. My husbands ziti....same thing with the pasta...really over boiled. The salad was good and the roll....was a sub bun. Now since I'm Italian, I tend to be a pasta snob but another thing that threw me off....there's no table service, you walk in order and pick up a cafeteria tray...and yes...they charge for ice water not much, but really!? read more

Mr G's Pizza - a plate of pasta, bread, salad, and salad dressing - Pizza Near Me - Demopolis, Alabama

We've eaten at Mr. G's twice. I wanted to give it the old college try before posting a review, just in case our first visit was just an off day for the staff. In both cases, the food was just okay and the service -- if you can call it that -- was delivered by angry and impolite people who evidently hated their jobs and despised the customers who provided their paychecks. Food-wise, the menu is broad and enticing. The flavors were okay -- we've tried Mr. G's spaghetti, Philly cheese steak, and reuben -- but while the spaghetti was plentiful, the sandwiches were skinny and underwhelming. The reuben was especially disappointing. The food genuinely rates two stars. On the other hand, the staff alone would make us not want to return to this place, even if they served five-star food. Simple courtesy -- e.g., the three magic words (please and thank you) -- and smiles go a long way in the restaurant business, yet neither were offered at Mr. G's. This could be fixed quickly by training, effective management, and if it comes to it, telling those employees who are obviously unhappy about working there to leave and not return until they change their negative attitudes. Bottom line: Mr. G's could be a great place, but it isn't. I don't recommend this restaurant. read more

In the culinary desert that is Demopolis, this is one if the restaurants in town that isn't a fried food chain and is opened for lunch. As good as it gets for this area, but would only be 3.5 to 4 stars in a city. It is clean, the staff are friendly, and the portion size is generous. Service was quick, but I came in just before the place started filling up for lunch. I ordered the lasagna special. The lasagna stood up and wasn't soupy. Pasta sauce was sweeter than I like, but not overly so. Sauce is not spicy, and I wish they had red pepper on the table to kick it up. Salad was fresh and crisp, mostly iceberg lettuce with some spinach mixed in. Lunch special with a drink cost $11.22. read more

A solid choice to eat at in Demopolis. My cousin took me here for lunch. We both ordered salads. He had the ham and cheese salad and I had the Italian salad. The prices are a little high, in my opinion (+7.00). However you do end up with a heaping amount of meat on top. I asked for the black olives to be removed and they did but they then put a large cup of very oily green olives on top_that coated the entire salad in the oil. I was not a fan. Maybe I missed the description of green olives but I didn't want olives. I would like more tomatoes. Next time I'll be sure to ask. I will absolutely try the restaurant again. read more

I am new the area and have been coming here for the past few Sundays. The food is good and fast to receive, however the 2 older ladies at the cash register could kill you with their daggers for daring to ask for anything such as a fork, God forbid a refill. I will be only partaking of this place for to go pizza for now on. Only because they are the only pizza game in town. read more

Absolutely terrible,how can you mess up a salad all lettuce store bought turkey sandwich meat

Very ok to good food for a small town. Like another reviewer, I too noticed that no one was eating Pizza. I heard it was good but the fact at a busy lunch no one had one at their table pizza told me not to order one even though I will be here a week, I may go back and try. I heard sandwiches are not that good and salads were filling and popular. I ordered a cheesevcannolloni with meat sauce. The meat sauce had very little meat but was still good tasting. Next time, if I don't try pizza I will get beef manicacotti (spelling????). I had it on a previous trip and thought it was great. read more

Great hot subs and yummy salads. More than enough food per serving. Quick service and plenty of seating.

People in this town surely don't know what classic Italian food tastes like. The food is simply bland and plain. Have they ever heard of fresh basil? It's bad, tastes frozen, no way it's fresh pastas. Ew. read more

I'm visiting the city for a week and decided to give this place a try. The menu is wide & varied for a pizza joint. Didn't look like pizza was their primary fare. Not a single soul was eating pizza. I selected the Tuesday special minus sauce. Chicken Italiano with salad & bread for about $8.50. The dish was diced grilled chicken on spaghetti covered with mozzarella cheese. It was good. Not great but better than expected for the price! Good homemade salad and the bread was delicious! I took home a slice of homemade pie to eat later. For the price, you just can't beat this place. Good hearty food. I think I'll give the pizza a go later in the week. read more

REALLY, Mr. G's? I ordered a "CHICKEN TENDER PLATTER." According to your menu, it includes tenders, cole slaw, fries, and a roll. What do I get? Three tiny tenders that are approximately three inches long and a handful of fries dumped into the bottom of a paper bag, because whoever bagged it couldn't even be bothered to put the package of fries upright in the bag, and no cole slaw and no rolls. Apparently, your cashiers have the inability to listen, because I was sitting next to my sister when she placed the order for me, and she said "chicken tender platter." PLATTER, not three-piece tiny tender and a small handful of fries. It isn't even enough to fill up a small paper plate. At least now I know where to not bother eating anymore. This is the last straw for me, Mr. G's. Your food's been going drastically downhill for a long time, your cashiers spend more time goofing off, playing around, and hollering at each other than they do serving the customers, they appear to be deaf, and none of them know what they're doing. In recent months, I've gotten repeated incorrect orders and terrible food, and I'm sick of it. I'm through. I won't be back, and I'll be encouraging my friends to do the same. read more

The last 5, yes, 5 times we have done takeout here the order has been wrong. Terrible service!

We visit this restaurant when at Univ of West Al. Worth the 25 mile one way drive. I have enjoyed every meal here. Great entrees, generous portions & very reasonably priced. read more

Not bad Italian for this small town! I had the Lasagna special today that came with a salad and bread. Healthy lunch portion and quite tasty. Also serve fried catfish, a must for this part of the country! read more

Great place... Local owned.. Pizza was good... Not quite "authentic" but a good deal and toppings were fresh .

Used to be good. Now, messy to-go and incorrect orders. Whoever's managing the kitchen and baggers needs to get their act together. It's a shame that their consistency has fallen off. Used to order take-out regularly. I won't be going back. read more

Recently ate here with my sister and we loved it. Pizza tasted homemade and the ranch is amazing! (doesn't taste like store bought ranch). Tiny little issue - the wings were extremely dry. However, the hot sauce we got on the side was delicious. We'll definitely be back! read more

Easter 2016 it was one of the worse places I have been since Jan 3' the gravy was so thick and the roast beef was not good, the girl that took my order was not friendly at all , I will never go back ,we are staying at the core park .in Demopolis read more

This review is hard for me because I grew up eating at Mr. G's and it has always represented good food and good memories. After visiting family today in Demopolis, my husband, daughter and I decided to have a late lunch at Mr. G's. We order a large pepperoni pizza and side salads. Mr. G's salads have always been good; simple and not fancy, but fresh veggies and home made ranch dressing. Ours today was simple and not fancy, but included brown iceburg lettuce, and what appeared to be a bagged salad mix with red cabbage and carrot slivers and a 1/2 slice of a cherry tomato. This however was not the worst. By all that is holy, people of Demopolis, when in the world did Mr. G's start using pre-made frozen pizza crust! When my husband brought our pizza back to the table, it "looked" delicious with lots of gooey mozzarella on top. After our first bite, the spongy soft barely cooked crust just stood out and not in a good way. I just looked at my husband and stated, "This is not Mr. G's pizza; I don't know what has happened." Seriously, and it kills me to say this, I have had better grocery store frozen pizzas. I wish I could say it was just the crust, but the pepperoni was sparse and the cheese seemed to be a cover up for that. I also agree with another review on the restaurant that it would not hurt the wait staff to offer greetings, smile and say thank you. My husband had to go back up to the counter a couple of times to get extra napkins, utensil set, etc., and seemed to be a "bother" to the counter ladies even though the restaurant was not that busy. Sigh, a very sad day for me. Does the same family own the restaurant? I am curious to know now because I cannot believe the original "Mr. G's" family would approve of what this Mr. G's is doing to a great reputation. read more