Artisan ice cream done right. Expect to wait, expect things to run out and most importantly enjoy…read morethe fresh ice cream. Fridges stacked on freezers with ice cream pints to go, cakes and sandwiches. The swirls is a creamy surprise and the brown sugar cookie dough is a playful twist on a classic. the service is prompt for the volume and the value reminds you fresh ingredients cost more. Can't wait to return!

Delicious, fresh ice cream right on First Ave! Clean and spacious interior with super friendly and…read morehelpful staff! They kindly allowed us to try a few samples before picking our flavor. So far I've had the vanilla, bourbon chocolate and the mint chocolate chip, all of which were amazing! I can't wait to continue to support this ice cream shop in the summer

A nice family friendly ice cream location with a great selection of flavors and options for cones,…read moreshakes & special creations. Great customer service; very kind and welcoming.

We came here recently for ice cream on a relatively warm day. The place was empty but it's the off…read moreseason at the Jersey Shore. I really wanted italian ice or a gelati but even though it's listed on the menu - they dont carry it after Labor Day. I ended up getting the soft serve in a cup - which came out half melted honestly. My husband got the brownie sundae but the brownie was rock solid. Hard ice cream flavors were ok. Maybe it's different in season but this place wasn't too memorable.

This cute ice cream shop has delicious ice cream but leaves some room for improvement…read more I think the ice cream here is actually really good! I got the Elvis and midnight jersey and both were delicious mixed together! The service here was definitely lacking. Not sure if it was because it was midweek but the people working the counters didn't seem to really want to be there. Usually ice cream shops would at least offer one free sample but no such case here. Also, I had to come back up to get a bowl for my overly melted ice cream and they just kept looking at me and going away from the line to "help" others when other staff were already helping them. If you are okay with just getting ice cream and not caring about service, this is not a bad spot!

We wanted to treat the kids after a day at Sandy Hook beach and decided to go for a new spot. Glad…read morewe did! I went off the recommendation of other Yelpers and can confirm, yes the Elvis ice cream is incredible. My family members enjoyed all of their picks too. The line moved pretty quickly, so I am confident that I can come back anytime during the beach season for more.

Un YUMM! Lovely experience. We had a flight. The goat cheese one was exceptional. Kind of like a…read morecheesecake! Will be back! This is the spot all year long, expect a line button moves fast and really nice service

I just love this ice cream shop! Everything is freshly made and their flavors are so creative. I am…read morefrom Staten island and I wish there's a spot here. Everytime I visit my friend and her family in NJ, I try my best to stop by here everytime lol! A tip for you, plan an extra time for your schedule, the lines usually long but it's so worth it!

We all love stopping in Nicholas Creamery whenever we can. The staff is always super nice,…read moreattentive, and the flavors change often always fun to stop in and see what's new. We love you can get a pint too-and love that you taste a flavor or two to decide- Always fabulous highly recommend.

I came back here and ordered a flight this time. It came with four ice cream varieties and a…read morewaffle cone. The waffle cone was tasty and came out fresh while also having a nice crunch. Each flavor of ice cream was also divided where no touching of flavors was done, which was a great idea. The four flavors I had are below. Brown Sugar Cookie Dough - This was better than I remember, and I enjoyed the actual brown sugar ice cream better this time. Key Lime Pie - This was alright. The crumbs were too soft, and the actual lime ice cream overpowered that. Porta - This was a porta ricotta and virgin olive oil sweet cream ice cream. This was solid but could not really taste the olive oil and ricotta presence. It tasted ever so slightly, but the sweet cream flavor was good. Pistachio - This was my favorite flavor tried of the day. I liked the pistachio pieces and the actual cream, which was very fulfilling.

Vegan pineapple and strawberry soft serve and can do combo swirl!…read more Toasted vegan coconut ice cream. Good prices. Friendly service. Cash only. Great place to stop after Sandy Hook.

Best icecream place! Cheap, delicious, great sizes and flavors, Overall a 10/10. The banana coffee…read moresoft serve twist is amazing!

My kids and husband really liked the ice cream. They all said they all gave it 5 out 5 stars. They…read moreordered pistachio, Reese's, and blue raspberry. I couldn't order anything due to the overwhelming smell of cleaning products and milk mixed together. I just couldn't wait to get out of there. The staff were nice & they seemed to have a bunch of options. I wouldn't mind coming back one day. Maybe they could find a way to air out the place so the smell isn't so strong.

My favorite ice cream please by far. Not only was the ice cream exceptional but the service was…read moreunmatched. Very friendly and very patient. Love love love their coffee flavors and the creativity they have with the rest. They got a new long term customer!