I had a small cookies & cream in a cup, my standard ice cream order everywhere. This place is highly rated but for me it was average. The ice cream wasn't rich and creamy. And the cookies were ground into the ice cream instead of being chunks, my preference. The standout is the seating outdoor area. I came off-season but it's a covered space on the side of the shop. Ceiling fans blow a nice breeze and there are plenty of tables. The staff were efficient but nothing to write home about. read more

Day's Ice Cream - Cookies & Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Ocean Grove, New Jersey

This feels like an old school ice cream shop in the best way. The kind of place that feels like it hasn't changed much in decades, and they should probably spell it "shoppe" because I think that's how they did it back in the day. What do I mean by that? I'm not really sure. But the prices are right, they've got tons of flavors and options, you're served by some friendly teenagers, and there's an enormous outdoor seating area if you decide you don't want to walk the Asbury Park boardwalk with your cone (or cup or whatever). I love that they offer a small, medium, and large option for cups and cones, and that the large is only $7. There's also a "short shot" for $3.50, which is not just the size I want to give my kids so they don't overdose on sugar, but also the only size I want to eat myself as well. It's a single scoop of high quality ice cream, and it's perfect. I can also somehow get out of here with ice cream for my whole family for less than a single sundae in Brooklyn, and that's a beautiful thing. They've got dozens of flavors, but for me, it's all about the salted caramel pretzel. My wife is always trying to get me to split that and another flavor with her, but I don't need anything else. Keep your inferior chocolate whatever. Give me my short shot of salted caramel pretzel on a sunny summer day, and I'm a happy man. read more

See all

The old fashioned marketing...plane riding by on the beach with a banner is what got us to Days ice cream! The quaint historical town it's set in is lovely. I ordered the short shot of coffee mocha chip and it was full of chips which I loved since most of the time you're looking for the chips! The servers were friendly and quick so waiting in a line wasn't even an issue. Great place, will definitely be going back! read more

Day's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Ocean Grove, New Jersey

After spending the day at Ocean Grove beach, we stopped at this ice cream shop for a sweet treat. We were a little intimidated by the long line at first, but it moved quickly--and it was absolutely worth the wait! The ice cream is delicious, and the freshly made waffles are to die for. The shop itself is adorable, and the staff is warm and friendly. Highly recommend stopping by if you're in the area! read more

Day's Ice Cream - Yuuuuum - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Ocean Grove, New Jersey

Old school ice cream parlor serves flavor ice cream and nostalgia!! The graham was addictive! I'll be back!! There's a huge outdoor seating area, bathrooms, amazing staff and service, delicious flavors! read more

Love Days ice cream!! Staff is always friendly and prompt even when it gets busy. I've tried several flavors and they're all yummy especially the peanut butter craze and biscoff cookie butter. Prices are affordable and I can't wait to come back to try more items on the menu!!!!!!! read more

Day's ice cream is one of the best in New Jersey. On my last trip there, I had the butter pecan. It was delicious and very creamy. This time I tried a small spoon sample of the Oreo ice cream. It was so good that I decided to order a cup. My wife loves the butter pecan and that's what she ordered. We sat outside and enjoyed this heavenly, home made delicacy. read more

Our trips to Ocean Grove would not be complete without at least 2 visits to Day's for ice cream. Service is great, it's a bit pricey but the portions are very generous. A definite win/win. read more

This place is awesome. And great covered but open air seating area. Our family loves this place.

It's like stepping back In time! The line was long but moved quickly. Plenty of flavors to choose from. I ordered a brownie sundae, the thing was huge, the brownie was a chefs kiss!! Really enough for 2 people. I struggled to finish it. So good! read more

This summer the flavors and service have taken a nose dive. No Chocolate Sea Salt Caramel, the Chocoholic at the beginning of summer it was the original with chocolate cows.... the cows are gone, there's an awful after taste now! The line moves slower then ever for sub par flavors. The new cups have ice cream poring down the sides and it's not because of the heat. Should I mention I'm tired of seeing the Italian Ice Tea advertised on Instagram?! read more

The BEST ice cream I've ever had! I'm not really an ice cream person but we came here with the kids and it looked good. If you like creamy ice cream with smooth texture and with substance, not watery, not too sweet (but perfect) this is your place. I got the Nutella crunch flavor on a wafer cone and it was SO good, I'm still dreaming about it. I ate the whole thing. Because it's so creamy and has natural fats and sugars from the cream, they don't add too much sugar and it's just perfect. And it's not watery so it doesn't melt and run down your hand. They have so many delicious and unique flavors and their prices are reasonable. We had ice cream on the Asbury Park boardwalk a few nights prior and it was almost double the price for much less quantity and the quality was terrible. Definitely coming here from now on. Truly the best. read more

See all

Not allergy friendly at all. They advertise vegan/dairy free options but won't share ingredients with you. They have allergy sprinkles but they're just nut free so if you're dairy free this doesn't help. When my child started having an allergic reaction they didn't care and refused to make us a new ice cream. This is the second time they've been rude to us about allergies. Will never go here again. read more

the food was taste and the staff gave me and my family 3 extra scoops each. it is very expensive for ice cream but the 3 scoops made it better read more

Adorable neighborhood spot with great ice cream and fast service. Like walking into the past, but in a fun way. Highly suggested if you're in Ocean Grove. read more

Great ice cream, overpriced like everything else today! Service fine, place is very small.

While staying in Ocean Grove after dinner one night we decided to go get ice cream. We found this place while walking one day and exploring the town. It looks like it came out of a movie. It is so cute with the lights outside and the overhang area where you can sit outside and enjoy your ice cream. The place gets busy. It is small sides so the line is normally outside. They have a whole bunch of different ice cream flavors for you to pick from. I had the small salted caramel pretzel and it was more than enough for me. I like the chucks of pretzel in it. For two small and one medium the bill was about $15 which I thought was pretty reasonable. We sat outside in the area, which was really great for families or people who just wanted to relax for a little. This place definitely adds to the charm of the town and we enjoyed getting ice cream here. read more

See all

Stopped in to try my first egg cream since I'm visiting the area and had a delightful visit to Day's! I came in with a mission to try an egg cream and it was delicious. Their flavors of ice cream looked to be very unique. I will hopefully stop by again after dinner to try their ice cream. The employees were kind and helpful and the interior itself was colorful and filled with pictures and decor. read more

Day's Ice Cream - Chocolate Egg Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Ocean Grove, New Jersey

See all

The line was very long... but we were recommended to try this ice cream place as I am non dairy and my family are not. We made the line..... it was worth it. Very very nice friendly ambiance. They have many seating outside with over head. I recommend this 100!!!! read more

See all

Great breakfast. Lovely being able to sit outdoors. Fresh made food. Service was friendly and inviting. Prices and quality very good read more

Nice location. Went during labor day week. Its a seasonal place. Outside dining. Ice-cream parlor is small and lines can get long but the service is amazing and the lines go by fast. Ordered the waffle sandwich and i was able to pick two flavors. I chose chocolate chip mint and cookie dough - amazing. The waffle was fresh and fluffy . I am so glad i came here. The waffle sandwiches on the board walk don't even compare. read more

Day's Ice Cream - Chocolate chip mint and cookie dough - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Ocean Grove, New Jersey

We went on Fourth of July weekend. The line was pretty far out the door, but I don't think we waited more than 10 or 15 minutes. They kept it moving well maintaining a friendly atmosphere. Ice cream was delicious. Nobody was disciplined. We went back later in the week and there was no line. Highly recommend. read more

Ordered: Short Shot (~$3) on Sugar Cone: Cookies n Cream flavor Aya's take: Not the ice cream spot I wanted to try but the one I ended up at! Days has about 40 ice cream flavors to choose from, most of which are your typical flavors. I went with the Cookies n Cream which was pretty standard. It tasted good but nothing extraordinary. Nice outdoor seating area great for Summer time! read more

Day's Ice Cream - Short Shot (~$3) on Sugar Cone: Cookies n Cream flavor - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Ocean Grove, New Jersey

Very busy and great place. The line is out the door to order but they have plenty of seating inside: they have soft serve and hard ice cream with all the flavors. I had vanilla with hot fudge Sunday and we ordered strawberry and hot fudge Sunday with fresh strawberries. Service was fast and delicious. Definitely would be back! read more

Ooooh such good and creamy ice cream! I got the mocha chocolate crunch and a peanut butter - both were EXCELLENT. i also love how they can do two flavors in the kids cup. Classic old school ambiance, love the pride flags and the inclusivity. All the staff are wonderful. Great little post dinner spot. read more

Day's Ice Cream - front - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Ocean Grove, New Jersey

See all

Worth the wait (if there's a line)! So many flavors, including several sugar free and dairy free options. read more

Day's Ice Cream - Outside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Ocean Grove, New Jersey

Delicious and lots of flavors. At the shore for a couple of days and loves this little ice cream place.

The service was ok but in the sitting area there was curse words and political opinion it's literally an ice cream store. The ice cream is good though with a variety of flavors. read more

Delicious ice cream and plenty of outside seating on a charming covered porch. Nice variety of ice cream. Friendly service

First time here. Nice old timey classic homemade ice cream parlor. It's all outside, order at the window and pickup. Plenty of flavors to choose from, generous portions and plenty of outdoor seating (covered). Definitely a return visit is warranted. read more

See all

A decent wait to get ice cream on a nice summer night but definitely worth it! The waffle sundae was ridiculous. So much food and tasty! read more

See all

Best ice cream I have arguably ever had! We were looking for a place open after 9 and Days ice cream was one of the few open. They have a great vegan menu and creative normal ice cream too. The cherry chocolate chip was really goooooood and trash can was everything but trashy. The atmosphere is super cozy and brings you back in time. *10/10 totally recommend* read more

Day's Ice Cream - Cherry chocolate chip vegan ice cream (bottom left) trash can (top right) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Ocean Grove, New Jersey

my sea salt caramel truffle had neither sea salt nor caramel nor truffle. bad flavor. don't get this flavor. I want a new flavor read more

Day's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Ocean Grove, New Jersey

The ice cream was delicious. We ordered the raspberry chocolate chip and it was so fresh tasting! Would highly recommend!

We went to a festival in the area today and we stopped in to this ice cream and breakfast spot. The line was long so I knew it was going to be good. I ordered a waffle sundae which I thought was going to be a waffle cone/bowl, but it was an actual homemade waffle with ice cream on it. The ice cream was real good and the waffle was fresh and warm. Really big dessert, and it was $9, not bad. The only very minor constructive feedback is that the butterfinger topping on it was more like dust instead of small pieces. Otherwise it was yummy and I would definitely go back again. read more

Man o man.... This place is now my all time favorite ice cream spot because they have a flavor I have never seen before ... PEANUT BUTTER MOOSE TRACKS!!!!! Now Moose Tracks was my favorite ice cream flavor and it's not always available at most ice cream shops and if it is- sometimes it's not the best. But this place has moose tracks that is good and it has this PB moose tracks and that now trumps Moose tracks for me lol. I was brought here by a friend after a beach day at Asbury Park . We drove over to Ocean Grove . Parking can be hellish. But if you can find one- you are set! We walked in and there were a few people in front of us on line but by the time we left- the line was down the block !!! There is a patio / outside seating- that you can sit down and thoroughly enjoy your ice cream:) I'm not really a ice cream person but this place has me dreaming of when I can come back to have another dose lol :) read more

See all

Very quaint ice cream parlor in quaint OG. We stopped here following a friend's recommendation and it did not disappoint. There's a big porch with a decent amount of seating available. There's also a public restroom which was a huge plus. We all had different flavors and enjoyed every bit of it. Definitely recommend. Tip: don't enter on Olin. Enter on Pittman Ave. read more

See all

You're going to have to wait in a long line, no matter what time you show up. But the ice cream (in the end) is WORTH IT. There's also a large seating area, right after you finish purchasing delicious ice cream, where you can sit and enjoy all that goodness. read more

The ambience is adorable! If cream was very good. Staff super friendly. Definitely would go back!

Service: Our orders were taken quickly. The communication between customers and workers was pretty flawless. I know this place gets busy during the 'rush hours' after dinner so it's not surprising that there can be a bit of a wait at times but totally worth it. Cost: For ice cream, it is towards the expensive end but they are all very well made! If you want some good homemade ice cream, this is definitely the place to go. Environment: The store seems to be run almost like a family business. It is nice and cozy, the interior and exterior of the store gives off a feeling of familiarity. Food: Homemade ice cream- you definitely cannot beat that! The special flavored ones are on point with the ice cream to topping ratio. I personally ordered the coconut ice cream and it is one of the best ones that I have eaten! Uniqueness: There is a nice patio area to sit and eat outside. During the summer, when the weather is nice and warm/cool, I would highly recommend grabbing some of days delicious ice cream, claiming a spot outside, and enjoy the company and ice cream! read more

See all